12 Things We Learned From Jim Ross: Under The Black Hat

We take a closer look at what is undeniably one of the greatest wrestling books of all time.

Jim Ross Under the Black Hat
Tiller Press

Few people in the history of the professional wrestling business have as unique a viewpoint as the legendary Jim Ross.

In a career that began in 1974, that has taken in all of the biggest companies of the day, that has involved some of the very best in-ring and executive talent in the history of the business, and that continues on to this very day, J.R. has been there and seen it all.

Not only does Jim have a unique vantage point across the history of the business, but he's a master storyteller, too. And so, upon him sitting down to pen the first part of his tale with 2017's Slobberknocker: My Life in Wrestling, fans were chomping at the bit to read about the life and times of this iconic figure.

Fast forward to the here and now, and J.R.'s follow-up book, Under the Black Hat: My Life in the WWE and Beyond, has now arrived.

If Slobberknocker was fantastic, Under the Black Hat is up there as one of the truly all-time best 'wrestling books' that we've seen.

Brimming with emotion, truths, humour, and poignancy, here are just 12 takeaways from what really is a must-read for anyone with even a passing interest in the world of professional wrestling.

12. He Was The Shoulder To Lean On After The Loss Of Owen Hart

Owen Hart King Of The Ring 1994
WWE Network

The loss of Owen Hart at 1999's Over the Edge PPV is one of the saddest, most tragic days in the history of professional wrestling.

While Jim Ross was handed the thankless, heartbreaking responsibility of having to break the news of Owen's death to the millions of people watching at home - including Owen's family - many wrestling fans won't be aware of Jim's role behind the scenes on that tragic night.

As J.R. explains in Under the Hat, he effectively had to serve as a counsellor to the WWE locker room once his announcing duties concluded. Some were crying, some were angry, some were in disbelief - but Jim Ross was there for them all, as he provided a shoulder to cry on and a presence to vent at.

Rather than allowing his own emotions to overcome him on that tragic night, Jim first and foremost put others before himself.

Under the Black Hat reads, "After the show ended, I sat on my own for a couple of minutes. Backstage veered from quiet confusion to anger, from sadness to tears. I cried for my friend. I cried for his family. And then I felt like I had to wipe my eyes and offer counsel to anyone who needed it. Just an ear, someone to listen.

This was a tough, tough night for the family, friends, and fans of Owen Hart, and Jim Ross was a rock that so many others turned to in their moments of shock and grief.


11. He Was Pivotal To WWE Signing Chris Jericho

Chris Jericho Vince Mcmahon Disappointed
WWE

Chris Jericho has always been a phenomenal in-ring worker, a phenomenal promo, and a phenomenal wrestling mind. And in recent years, the inaugural AEW World Champion has only further cemented his status as one of the genuine all-time greats.

Back before he signed for the then-World Wrestling Federation though, Vince McMahon and various other company higher-ups were against signing the man who would go on to become a multiple-time World Champion for the company across the next 19 years.

As has so often been the case with management, size was the issue working against Jericho back in 1999. Despite him clearly ticking so many of the right boxes, Jericho wasn't even on McMahon's radar due to his height. But that thankfully changed, due to the intervention of Jim Ross.

It was J.R. who pushed for Vince to take a look at the Winnipeg native, and it was J.R. who had a highlight package put together so that he could further sell McMahon on the WCW star. Catching McMahon at the right time on the right day, Jim's sales pitch worked and he was given the green light to reach out to the Ayatollah of Rock and Rollah.

Ross got Vince on board by discussing how versatile a performer Jericho was both in the ring and from a character standpoint, how the Canadian had travelled the world, and how there was no locker room baggage associated with Jericho.

Going even further, J.R. pitched Chris Jericho as a top level player who could be a main event attraction for the company. And boy, if Jim Ross wasn't proved correct on that front.


10. The Car-Crash Debut Of SmackDown

WWF SmackDown Logo
WWE

For wrestling fans, the debut of WWF SmackDown was absolutely fantastic. When the company opted to launch a second batch of major weekly television, the fresh look and feel of SmackDown instantly grabbed fans' attention.

Unfortunately, what we fans weren't aware of, was the chaos that surrounded that SmackDown premiere.

From Jim Ross, the creation of SmackDown was something that so many people were largely in the dark about. As Ross puts it, "Most people in the company hadn’t even known we were in talks for a new show, but out of nowhere we were live on the air."

The deal for SmackDown was rushed through by UPN and WWF brass, yet the rapid nature of putting this agreement together meant that there was plentiful uncertainty going in to this new TV show. In particular for Jim, Vince hadn't even suggested to J.R. that he wanted something different from him in terms of commentary style - yet he proceeded to spend a large chunk of that initial broadcast bellowing such instructions to Ross.

As written in Under the Black Hat, "'This is a whole new audience, J.R., goddamnit,' Vince shouted. 'Talk to them, tell them who we are.'”

By the time that first SmackDown was even half-way through, Jim Ross knew that he was going to be relieved of his SmackDown announce duties.

That would indeed come to pass, with McMahon giving Ross the news later that night on Vince's private jet - and this was something Jim was more than happy with, given how he was also being tasked with announcing Raw and heading up Talent Relations, while not receiving any additional pay or benefits for his SmackDown gig.


9. Vince McMahon Uses Cutlery To Eat Sandwiches

Vince McMahon
WWE.com

While Luke Harper's Exalted One persona has been taking subtle shots at Vince McMahon on AEW Dynamite in recent weeks, the wrestling world has heard so many stories about Vince's, well, Vince-isms over the years.

Many a wrestling fan have heard a former talent or executive talk about McMahon's hatred of sneezes, his daily meal of steak, or the fact that you don't have a snowball in hell's chance of getting an idea approved should Vince be hungry. But in Under the Black Hat, Jim Ross goes on to detail how one such Vince-ism involves him using a knife and fork to eat sandwiches.

To anybody else, that notion sounds utterly insane, yet McMahon and his germaphobia means that the WWE Chairman is completely against using his hands for such breaded delight. In fact, Ross goes on to make mention of Vinny Mac's unique way of eating a pizza.

Imagine the scene. It's been a long day at Titan Towers. Vince McMahon likely hasn't slept for three days, yet he's still managed to cram in six workouts and hired and fired Bruce Prichard two times over. At such times, Vince occasionally will have a pizza delivered.

As Jim writes, "Vince would fold a slice and eat it up to where he touched it, then bin the rest. It was my daily challenge at WWE to ignore this while sitting across from him."

And that, ladies and gentlemen, most certainly sounds like quite the unique daily challenge.


8. His XFL Experience Was In Memory Of His Father

XFL Jim Ross Jesse Ventura
WWE.com

The first iteration of the XFL - with the current incarnation seemingly following suit right now - ended up being a bust for Vince McMahon. But McMahon wanted a football league, dammit, so McMahon got a football league.

For anybody with even a passing interest in the life and career of Jim Ross, they know that J.R. is a huge football fan. And so for Jim, the launch of the XFL offered him the chance to indulge in one of his other true passions.

To Jim, it was actually football that sprouted the seed for his career in pro wrestling commentary. Most specifically, it was gathering all of the various stats and then sitting down with his father to discuss the game of the day back when he was growing up.

Ross explains, "My true beginning as a commentator came from watching all those football games with my dad and breaking down the pertinent information for his attention. I’d prep and get all the info ready before the game, and then when the action started, I’d give my father the stats and previous scores; I’d tell him what to look out for, including rivalries between players."

In J.R.'s eyes, regardless of the failure of the XFL, it gave this legendary wrestling figure a way to reconnect with his deceased father - and as Jim put it, "that made every second of it a joy."


7. Vince McMahon Was Against The Stone Cold Heel Turn

Steve Austin, Vince McMahon, WrestleMania 17
WWE.com

Even Steve Austin himself has said that, in hindsight, his heel turn at WrestleMania X-Seven was a mistake.

At that point in time, Stone Cold was the hottest star in the industry and was still bringing in huge numbers for Vince McMahon's company. But Austin being Austin, he was weary of audiences potentially tiring on his bird-flipping, beer-swilling shtick, and thus he wanted to stay ahead of the curve and turn into a nefarious villain.

Upon Stone Cold proposing the heel turn to McMahon, Vince thought it wasn't a good idea. Likewise, Jim Ross thought it was an outright stupid idea.

The thing is, Vince trusted Steve Austin's instincts to the fullest. In the years prior, Austin's ideas for promos, for merchandise, for storylines and rivalries - they'd all paid off.

Jim writes, "The dilemma for Vince was whether to bet on Austin’s gut one more time. 'Have you tried talking him out of it?' I asked. 'It means a lot to Steve, so we’re going to try it,' Vince replied. If Steve was adamant—and he was—the chairman wanted to back him. 'Steve deserves the opportunity to see if we can make this work,' Vince said."

After starting his transition from The Ringmaster to Stone Cold in 1996, Austin and his instincts were rarely wrong. Unfortunately for all involved, though, the majority of wrestling fans - let alone those in attendance at Houston's Astrodome - were far from ready to start booing Austin upon that 2001 turn.


6. Austin Was Due To Lose At WrestleMania X8

Steve Austin Scott Hall WrestleMania X-8
WWE.com

WrestleMania X8 is largely remembered for the goosebumps-inducing match-up of The Rock vs. 'Hollywood' Hulk Hogan. But while The Great One and The Hulkster stole the show in one of the greatest WrestleMania matches, Steve Austin found himself in the middle of the card against Hogan's nWo running buddy, Scott Hall.

Many have always suggested that 'Mania X8 was initially meant to be Austin vs. Hogan. Not only was that never the case, but Stone Cold was actually due to do the honours for Hall at the Showcase of the Immortals.

Given how Hulk was to do the J-O-B to The Rock later in the show, Vince didn't want the nWo losing two matches on the same night. As such, the original plan was that Scott Hall would come out victorious against The Bionic Redneck.

Ever the professional, Steve Austin had no problem with Scott Hall and was happy to put him over at WrestleMania. Austin's gripe, however, was that he didn't see any money in this match, and his frustration was only further compounded when rumblings suggested that Hall had fallen off the wagon once more.

The decision to have Austin get the W at the Granddaddy of Them All was only made in the day leading up to WrestleMania - McMahon changing the finish after learning of Hall's drinking and drug use - although nobody had remembered to inform a pissed off Texas Rattlesnake of this change by the time Stone Cold arrived at Toronto's SkyDome.

Come WrestleMania day, and Austin was annoyed, creatively disappointed, and questioning just what WWE saw in his future - to the extent that he went home at the following night's Raw event.


5. The Cruelty Of Vince McMahon

Vince McMahon Jim Ross
WWE

To get this out on front street from the get-go, there are times in Under the Black Hat where you can see that Vince McMahon isn't forever the devil that some make him out to be. Jim Ross himself even states at several points that the two are still friends to this day, that he has a lot to be thankful to McMahon for, and that Ross truly cherishes his over 25-year relationship with Vince.

That said, Under the Black Hat also highlights just how downright cruel Vince McMahon has been to J.R. over the decades.

Jim suggests that his decision to move back 'home' to Norman, Oklahoma hurt McMahon more than he ever let on - with Kevin Dunn pointing out how, despite the macho bravado, Vince doesn't like to be left by anyone - but that doesn't excuse any of the treatment that followed.

One example of this is Vince deciding on a "different direction" at the drop of a hat and getting J.R. to tell the locker room how he was being replaced in Talent Relations by John Laurinaitis. Another, more shocking example of McMahon's disgusting behaviour was when he informed Jim during a Waco, Texas Raw taping that tonight was to be his last night at the commentary desk.

That time, again it was pegged as a "different direction" for the company. But what really irks, is that McMahon refused Ross' wish to at least say goodbye on air to those who he'd for so long been the voice of wrestling to.

Going even further, there's the time that J.R. had a large chunk of his colon removed. Vince had rang the recovering Ross, informing him to tune in to Raw that night as they looked to acknowledge this trauma. This, of course, would be when McMahon did a skit depicting all manner of objects being pulled from the ass of a Jim Ross dummy.

That last one was enough to bring Jim's strong, ever-supportive wife Jan to tears. All so that Vince could get his damn licks in on J.R. once again.


4. The Insecurities Of Donald Trump

Donald Trump WWE
WWE.com

As a long-time buddy of Vince McMahon, Donald Trump has not only been involved with WWE TV and WrestleMania several times over the years, but Trump is also an inductee of the WWE Hall of Fame.

Make of that what you will.

Regardless of the US President's cocksure demeanour, blind arrogance, and him often outright denying the most obvious of truths, Under the Black Hat gives a glimpse into a more insecure side of Donald Trump.

This ties back to WrestleMania 23, which was where Trump backed Bobby Lashley vs. Vince McMahon's Umaga in a match with Donald and Vince's famed hair on the line. As Jim Ross explains, though, Trump was conscious of his own body, was worried of stepping into the ring, and had a leering eye for the female talent of the day.

Ross puts it, "Donald Trump was body conscious, to say the least. He arrived at our TV taping almost as fixated on the guys’ bodies as on the women’s. Almost. After a few minutes of walking around among the tightest, most ripped, tanned bodies on planet Earth, The Donald was suddenly wearing a large, heavy overcoat, even though he was clearly too hot."

Jim goes on, "Backstage, Trump’s eyes were wandering, and because of WWE’s new policy of hiring Playboy-type models for the women’s division, there were plenty of places for The Donald’s eyes to wander."

Discussing Trump's fear of getting physical, J.R. adds, "I had seldom seen a WWE guest who was as nervous about getting physical as Donald was. 'You’re going to look after me? You sure now, Vince?' Trump asked. 'I’ll bring you through it,' Vince replied. ''Cause I don’t want to look like a loser.'"


3. The Highs And Lows (And Highs) Of WrestleMania XXVI

Undertaker, Shawn Michaels, WrestleMania XXVI
WWE.com

By 2010, after years of ups and downs, Jim Ross was as open as he'd ever been to the possibility of leaving WWE. But just as quickly as one can be down on the company, one could just as suddenly see a carrot of light dangling at the end of the tunnel.

For J.R., that carrot was the prospect of making his announcing return to call a match at WrestleMania XXVI. And not just any match, but The Undertaker vs. Shawn Michaels in a contest that would prove to be the swansong of The Heartbreak Kid.

Kevin Dunn made the call to Jim, informing him to "bring your tux" to the Showcase of the Immortals. 'Taker and Shawn had gone to bat for J.R. and asked that he commentate on their upcoming epic encounter.

The sheer joy that Ross conveys at this moment in Under the Black Hat is undeniable, with this phone call coming at a particularly difficult time for the Oklahoma native - Ross having recently had another Bell's palsy attack, and had to deal with the deaths of friends Steve 'Dr. Death' Williams, Jack Brisco, and Skandor Akbar.

To Jim Ross, this was the perfect pick-me-up and something that once more put some pep in his step. And so, WrestleMania weekend rolled around, a beaming J.R. got to once more be amongst the boys, and calling one of the all-time great matches was looming large on the horizon.

Only Jim never got to call that match.

The day before WrestleMania XXVI, Kevin Dunn informed Jim that they wouldn't be using him for the show. J.R. was angry. The Undertaker was angry. Shawn Michaels was angry.

In a book full of gut-punches, this is one of the most emotional moments to read about. But the positive to come out of this, is that 'Taker and Michaels opted out of the annual WrestleMania afterparty, and instead invited Jim Ross to join them in a fire-lit parking lot to drink some beers and tell some stories into the early hours. And that is as good a WrestleMania moment as you can get.


2. The Sincere Goodbye

Jim Ross Vince McMahon
WWE.com

As mentioned earlier, the relationship between Jim Ross and Vince McMahon was far from an entirely negative one. Sure, when it was bad, it was horrid, but there were plenty of positive moments shared between the two. And one such moment, was J.R.'s farewell from WWE in 2013.

That final goodbye famously came as a result of the WWE 2K14 Symposium.

Said 2K public event saw Jim head-up a panel of wrestling stars of today and yesteryear. And while it was an event that brought in a large online audience and proved to be entertaining, it was one for which J.R. was punished.

Several variables came together to make this a wild roller coaster of a ride, with a grieving, alcohol-fuelled Ric Flair pushing the envelope a little too far, and the image of Jim Ross on stage with a cocktail in his hand one that the WWE Chairman was not impressed by.

When Vince summoned J.R. to his office, Ross knew what was coming. But rather than a bitter, aggressive firing, this proved to be a sincere and heartfelt parting of the ways between two long-standing friends.

As Jim pens in Under the Black Hat, "We hugged and, again, it felt different than it had in the past. It wasn’t a back-slapping, manly affair. It was genuine. 'You could have done this over the phone,' I said in our embrace. 'I respect you too much not to do it face-to-face,' he replied. We separated; both of us had tears in our eyes. My bridge with Vince and WWE was charred but not burned down completely. 'So long, J.R.,' he said. I tipped my hat and left."

Jim Ross would eventually make it back to WWE, with him returning to the fold for WrestleMania 33.


1. The Importance Of Jan Ross

Jim Ross Jan Ross
Jim Ross

Of course, many wrestling fans know just how pivotal a role his wife Jan played in the life and career of Jim Ross. And Jan's tragic passing in 2017 is a heartbreaking moment that clearly will affect anyone. But what Under the Black Hat does, is this book really highlights just how important a person Jan was to Jim and to so many others.

It feels almost redundant to say that a man's wife was a vital part of his life, but with Under the Black Hat we see how Jan was there at every turn, at every twist, and at every moment of need. In a business that's notoriously tough on the partners of those involved in pro wrestling, Jan was the rock who was forever there for Jim to lean on.

Even Vince McMahon himself has labelled Jim Ross as the hardest working man in the business, and there were times when he was having to spin so many plates - from Talent Relations, to the Raw commentary booth, to PPVs, to being holed up in WWE's Stamford HQ for days on end, to the constant travel - yet in this book we see how Jan was always understanding of her husband's plight.

Under the Black Hat not only serves as an all-time great read that highlights the latter half of J.R.'s life and career, it more importantly serves as a love letter to his wife.

There have been wrestling books filled with emotional moments over the years, yet Under the Black Hat is arguably the most emotional, poignant read that we've seen to date from the world of professional wrestling.

Jim Ross: Under The Black Hat is available now from Amazon and other book retailers.


In this post: 
Jim Ross
 
First Posted On: 
Senior Writer
Senior Writer

Once described as the Swiss Army Knife of WhatCulture, Andrew can usually be found writing, editing, or presenting on a wide range of topics. As a lifelong wrestling fan, horror obsessive, and comic book nerd, he's been covering those topics professionally as far back as 2010. In addition to his current WhatCulture role of Senior Content Producer and Presenter, Andrew previously spent nearly a decade as Online Editor and Lead Writer for the world's longest-running genre publication, Starburst Magazine, and his work has also been featured on BBC, TechRadar, Tom's Guide, WhatToWatch, Sportkskeeda, and various other outlets, in addition to being a Rotten Tomatoes-approved film critic. Between his main day job, his role as lead panel host of Wales Comic Con, and his gig as a pre-match host for Wrexham AFC games, Andrew has also carried out a hugely varied amount of interviews, from the likes of Robert Englund and Eli Roth to Kevin Smith and the Russo Brothers, to Kevin Conroy and Frank Miller, to Bret Hart and Sting, to Mickey Thomas, Joey Jones, Phil Parkinson, and Brian Flynn, to many, many more. Where his beloved Wrexham AFC is concerned, Andrew is a long-standing season ticket holder and an FSA Award-winner for his time co-hosting the Fearless in Devotion podcast.