12 Ups & 12 Downs For WWE In 2019
Weirdest pro wrestling on the planet. Period.
How else can one assess 12 months of WWE television without doing as they do and going entirely 50/50? This is not a month-by-month breakdown in which the company rather organically arranges one good and one bad thing every thirty days - but the product would probably be a little more straightforward if that was the case.
An extreme elevation of the chaos that's gradually grown into the norm over the past couple of years, 2019 was at times magical and at others miserable. The lows were amongst some of the worst in company history, but the highs made history that will stand proudly for generations to come.
This list won't include anything from NXT by the way, lest all 12 positives be from the black-and-gold brand. Finding hope for the hopeless on Raw and SmackDown is like trying to find a clean finish on either of those broadcasts - near-impossible, but immensely more satisfying when it happens.
No, from Dog Food to Graveyard Dogs, this'll only be from WWE, and only from the "genius" mind of Vince McMahon. And speaking of that...
Downs...
12. The 2-Out-Of-3 Falls Era
A vintage Vince McMahon ratings paranoia edict brought forth to a 2019 in which he was panicked enough to hire both of his business rivals at the same time to run his two biggest shows, the Chairman's sudden belief that matches shouldn't happen during commercials resulted in one of the strangest periods in Raw history.
Each week, writers weren't tasked with coming up with storylines for wrestlers, but excuses for why matches suddenly came to a stop or reset point right before commercials. For the first time since Michael Cole started smashing us to pieces with it a decade earlier, Raw actually stopped "rolling on".
The lifting of the ban actually made Raw better, presumably so McMahon could lie and say it was the plan all along.
11. Hey Good Looking, What You Got Cucking?
A truly bizarre obsession with heaping sympathy on men because of those bloody women in 2019 came after WWE hadn't ever been so empowering - was this little more than a petty response to the rise of 'The Man' and the inarguable brilliance of women's wrestling elsewhere?
In Mandy Rose, Maria and Lana, the fanbase were give three females to despise based entirely on their sensationalised and sexualised relationships (or lack thereof) with male superstars.
Rose was sent to seduce Jimmy Uso under Naomi's nose, Maria abused her husband and questioned if he was even the father of their unborn child whilst Lana...well, you watch Raw in spite of yourself too, Lana's a f*cking b*tch isn't she lads? Eh? Isn't she?
10. Ucey Hot
A modern era phenomenon, this.
Once a year, there's a comedy segment on either Raw or SmackDown so impossibly awful that it becomes that year's shorthand for hideous wrestling hilarity. 2019's was one of the worst yet.
Barely moving forward from an a*s cream bit from nearly 20 years ago - and that couldn't be carried by Christian and Chris Jericho, so The Revival had no chance - The Usos meddled with some Icey Hot that got Dash and Dawson's backs right up. Or their a*ses.
Once the best tag team in North America, the pair were now dragging themselves across the canvas in pain instead of decorating it with pleasure.
9. The WrestleMania Main Event Build
WWE did the right thing positioning Ronda Rousey, Charlotte Flair and Becky Lynch at the top of the WrestleMania tree (and more on that later), but f*cking hell did they make a shift of it on the way.
The inherent problem presented itself when Lynch and Rousey's rivalry peaked the night after the Royal Rumble. "I choose you" was the line 'The Man' uttered in the face of the undefeated 'Baddest Woman On The Planet' to set up the dream match they'd lost months earlier, but the build entered nightmare territory before settling down with about a week to go.
In between there and Becky lifting both belts above her head, she was forced to apologise to the McMahon family for being hard as f*ck, then taken out of the match completely, and then reinserted. WWE had all that time but rather than simply trying to use it, nearly conspired to lose it.
8. The Wild Card Rule
P*ssed off with all the decline happening around him, Vince McMahon appeared on a May edition of to confirm that superstars could take advantage of a "Wild Card" rule every week, allowing them to flit between brands if the mood struck them.
It muddied the waters of a roster split that was already struggling - so much so that an October draft lacked the usual punch due to ardent viewers genuinely being unclear where a Superstar even resided. The rules and ramifications (and even the amount of people permitted each week) were never fleshed out as the company tried and failed to spread the likes of Roman Reigns and AJ Styles thinner than usual for the good of the cause.
McMahon had the temerity to call himself a "genius" the very night he launched it. In contrast, the @WWEonFox Twitter account immediately mocked it upon the network taking control of the blue brand's future. Not that they wouldn't face some of that themselves in the weeks that followed...
7. The Normalisation Of The Billion Dollar Show
SmackDown - the show that barely feels different from SmackDown Live other than the fact less people talk about it on Saturdays than used to on Wednesdays - is worth a billion dollars.
It's a figure that has to be brought up as often as it is, because it's unprecedented for a wrestling company to be earning so much for their output. It reflects, more than any TV rights deal in wrestling history how well Vince McMahon read the room when he cannibalised his pay-per-view game in 2014 for the good of his Networks and his flagships. Conversely, it highlights how far gone his once-dynamic creative mind is - Roman Reigns getting covered in dog food will not f*cking do, no matter how much you could practically hear the Chairman's cackles through Michael Cole's headset.
Raw is better than SmackDown. Three hour jesus-f*cking-christ-why-do-I-do-this-to-myself Monday Night Raw. Something has to change.
6. The Rise And Immediate Fall Of The Women's Tag Team Championships
When Sasha Banks and Bayley became Women's Tag Team Champions in February, they promised to build the prestige of the new belts my taking them anywhere a challenge was available. With three thriving women's divisions, the possibilities appeared endless and two immensely talented performers had finally found their place.
As of writing, the belts still haven't been made special four changes later.
A WrestleMania loss to The IIconics was delivered for shock at the expense of the belts' entire summer. Comedy characters, the Aussie pair weren't booked to defend them because they clearly couldn't, and a token reign for Alexa Bliss and Nikki Cross hadn't yet done the heavy lifting before The Kabuki Warriors finally took some ownership.
Things have looked up ever since, but they'll remain token gestures should WWE treat them as such again.
5. "The Viking Experience"
Indicative of WWE's repeated failure to perfect the NXT-to-main roster process, The War Raider were victims of the method hitting rock bottom shortly after WrestleMania 35.
Weeks earlier, Triple H had mournfully delivered the news that Tommaso Ciampa, Johnny Gargano, Ricochet and Aleister Black were all to debut on Raw before injury to his Champion Ciampa resulted in him claiming back Gargano in the nick of time. A few months later, he'd be permitted to hold on to his entire crew thanks to NXT's move to USA Network. "The Viking Experience" was a sign that it couldn't come soon enough.
Rowe and Hanson were now Erik and Ivar, with a collective label so utterly pathetic that it went viral for all the wrong reasons. Even WWE understood the scale of parody they'd created and scaled it back, but the name surviving as the tandem's finisher ensures the memories won't be left alone.
4. Brock Squashes Kofi
As of writing, Kofi Kingston hasn't gone absolutely f*cking spare and battered Brock Lesnar in a revenge attack for the humiliation he suffered on the first edition of SmackDown on Fox.
The New Day man had audiences weeping for his win at WrestleMania earlier that year, and whilst some of his decidedly midcard title matches left fans bored to tears in the months that followed, he deserved far better than the seven second squash he was made to endure when he lost it.
WWE appears to revel in the disappointment of its audience sometimes - this was one of the most recent completely criminal examples.