12 Ups & 13 Downs For WWE In 2019 (So Far)
4. Failed Call-Ups
That WWE will eventually ruin most wrestlers called up from NXT isn't even a cynical take any more: it's a seemingly unbreakable pattern.
Of 2019's call-ups, Ricochet is the current United States Champion and it's too early into Aleister Black's reinvention as Angry Man in Darkened Room to pass judgement. Those guys are fine. The rest? Not so much.
Johnny Gargano and Tommaso Ciampa's years-long NXT storyline was disregarded so that they could be hot-shotted into a DIY reunion on Raw, before the latter's neck injury prompted his fremeny's return to developmental. We've already spoken about Lars Sullivan's failings. An early win over Dean Ambrose suggested WWE were going to do something with EC3, but it has amounted to nothing. Linking with Asuka should've been a good move for Kairi Sane but LOL at the women's tag division. Lacey Evans isn't ready for her spotlight Remember The Viking Experience? The list goes on.
NXT has never been as stacked as it was while these call-ups were going on, but the main roster hit rate has never been so low. The positive news is that none of the aforementioned names are too buried to be salvaged, despite the complete balls-up WWE have made of them so far, so there's hope yet.
3. Poisoning The Locker Room
WWE cannot be absolved of blame for their role in what's currently going on with the likes of Lio Rush and Luke Harper.
2019's walkouts and protests were inspired by what the performers involved perceive to be mistreatment, but that's just the start of it. Only those involved know exactly what went down with their respective cases. That isn't why this Down exists: it's because of the way WWE have handled the mini-revolt.
The company responded to Harper's polite, respectful release request by refusing to use him and adding six months to his contract. The Revival will now depart the promotion two months apart from each other when Dash Wilder was dealt with similar treatment, and we can't forget their 'Ucey Hot' burial either. Lio Rush has been banished. Sasha Banks, meanwhile, hasn't been used since WrestleMania 35, and there's currently no word on when (if ever) she'll come back.
Doling out punishments like this sounds like a great way to destroy what little morale remains in the locker-room, with WWE seemingly going out of their way to make the promotion as unattractive a proposition to free agents as possible. At the moment, the company sounds like a horrible, horrible place to work, and it's their own doing.
2. The Wild Card Rule
Here's hoping that Eric Bischoff and Paul Heyman's arrival as Executive Directors does away with the Wild Card rule, because Vince McMahon's lame attempt at saving his TV ratings has been wholly destructive.
We should have seen this coming when the Chairman changed his mind on how many wrestlers can invade a brand at once on the night it was introduced. WWE have broken the limit on almost every show since then, and while the rule has proven fruitful for big names like Roman Reigns, it was left WWE's undermined midcard with even fewer opportunities to get onto television.
Buddy Murphy can't buy a TV appearance. Remember the Kabuki Warriors? They still exist, apparently. Aleister Black has done nothing but cut cheesy promos from a darkened room since April. The list goes on.
If the brand split is to continue, the Wild Card Rule has to go. It has done nothing but dilute Raw and SmackDown and widen the gap between WWE's haves and have-nots.
1. Super Show-Down
Cue: mass eye-rolls from certain sections of the commentariat, but Super Show-Down 2019 was a huge flop of a pay-per-view even when removed from the political concerns regarding WWE's deal with Saudi Arabia.
An incomplete list of the show's failings:-
1. The Usos and Revival being made to wrestle a condensed version of the banger they'd have on any other pay-per-view because the agents only gave them seven minutes.
2. Finn Balor and Andrade busting their backsides for a crowd that couldn't care less.
3. The crowd in general. They came alive only a handful of times, with most of the show playing out to silence.
4. Shane McMahon literally dominating 75-80% of his match with company golden boy and supposed badass Roman Reigns.
5. Lars Sullivan defeating the Lucha House Party by DQ, an outcome that helped nobody.
6. Lars Sullivan beating the Lucha House Party down to cricket chirps.
7. Randy Orton vs. Triple H: a 25-minute match that felt like double its runtime.
8. That mess of a Battle Royal. Devoid of highlights, the ring was too crowded for anyone to do anything notable.
9. Goldberg vs. The Undertaker, obviously. A messy botch-fest that both men were lucky to escape from without serious injury. A shame, as it was actually pretty good until Goldy's head met the ring post.
Not everything was awful and Mansoor's Battle Royal win was a fun, crowd-popping moment, but much of Super Show-Down was a heatless mess. It wouldn't be hyperbole to call this one of the decade's worst pay-per-views.
Ups...
12. Andrade Vs. Rey Mysterio
While the storyline didn't get the pay-per-view blow-off its stellar ring-work warranted, Rey Mysterio vs. Andrade was a delightful feud to kick SmackDown's year of programming off.
Both of their big TV matches ruled. A revitalised Rey performed like a man 10 years his junior, pulling off all manner of risky spots against the younger, healthier Andrade. There were big dives, Powerbombs on the floor, sliding splashes with chairs, and Mysterio sending Andrade bombing into the barricade. Two glorious displays of in-ring oneupsmanship, they remain among the best matches WWE have put on all year.
The most refreshing thing about Andrade vs. Mysterio was that it was a pure wrestling feud. These guys weren't warring because 'El Idolo' had upset Dominick or trashed Rey's car, but because these guys wanted to prove they were the better man between the ropes, and WWE let them do their thing with few restrictions when the time came.
11. The Right Road To WrestleMania
WWE dropped the ball spectacularly when it came to booking last year's Royal Rumble winners. Shinsuke Nakamura and Asuka partook in crowd-popping victories at the 2018 event and it looked very much like Vince McMahon had finally conquered his inability to book Japanese wrestlers well, but each flopped within months of their career's greatest triumph. For Nakamura, it was losing to AJ Styles and the never-ending feud that followed, and for Asuka, it was the end of her awesome undefeated streak by Charlotte Flair's hand.
Fortunately, WWE knocked it out of the park in 2019. Seth Rollins and Becky Lynch were the right winners, and their respective pathways to WrestleMania saw them arrive at the year's biggest show just as their momentum was peaking, with both wrestlers partaking in compelling feuds.
Were their programmes perfect? Of course not, but they largely hit the right notes, and their success culminating in the night's two biggest pops after Kofi Kingston's emotional WWE Title triumph. Battered and bludgeoned, Rollins rose to slay Brock Lesnar in the opener, while Lynch's triumph in the first-ever women's main event transcended the sloppy finish to her bout with Ronda Rousey and Flair.
10. A Fitting Farewell
If 2019 was the last we'll see of Ronda Rousey in WWE ring, at least the company made the most of her services before she and Travis Browne sailed off on that #ImpregnationVacation.
It began with the awesome Sasha Banks feud. Was 'The Boss' a filler opponent? Absolutely, but their Royal Rumble throwdown was a nasty, gritty fight, and one of the year's best so far. From there, 'The Baddest Woman on the Planet' murdered Ruby Riott in an appropriately dominant Elimination Chamber squash, having defeated Bayley in-between, then let her bad side out on the road to WrestleMania, turning heel for her programme with Charlotte Flair and Becky Lynch.
Many had been waiting for this moment since Rousey walked through Titan Towers' doors, and Rousey shone as a heel. It was the right move, too, as she was never going to be cheered while warring with 'The Man,' and it ended up bringing out some of the best character work of Ronda's run.
A star from beginning to end, Rousey's rookie year deserves to be slotted in just beneath Kurt Angle's.
9. The Clusterf*cks Deliver
2019 has largely been a solid year of WWE pay-per-views, with only Super Show-Down's horrors and Stomping Grounds' abject second half sticking out as anything close to failures.
Elimination Chamber and Money In The Bank - shows built around signature clusterf*ck matches - stand out amongst the finest offerings. This is largely on the strength of their titular matches. Sure, MITB had the superfluous Seth Rollins vs. AJ Styles clash, but both pay-per-views succeeded largely because the gimmick bouts were so much fun.
At Elimination Chamber, Bayley and Sasha Banks became the inaugural Women's Tag Team Champions in a sharp, well-agented bout that saw each performer utilised perfectly (even Nia Jax and Tamina), culminating in a cathartic vitory. The men's Chamber, meanwhile, was one of 2019's most spectacular so far, with the stunning Kofi Kingston vs. Daniel Bryan closing stretch taking the burgeoning KofiMania movement to a new level.
Elsewhere, Money In The Bank's women's bout was an absolute hoot, and say what you will about the finish, but the action preceding Brock Lesnar's main event victory was everything you'd want from the ladder stipulation.
8. R-Truth & The 24/7 Championship
God bless R-Truth, because what started with one of the year's most cringe-worthy segment (Mick Foley's unveiling the gross green belt) has turned into WWE's most enjoyable midcard oddity, with the 24/7 Championship continually providing a welcome reprieve from the contrivances found elsewhere on the card.
These segments are delightful. From Truth losing the belt on an airport runway then regaining it mid-flight to the former K-Kwik ruining Drake Maverick's wedding and referring to the 205 Live General Manager exclusively as "Hornswoggle," they're always a hoot, and much of this should be appropriated to the division's ace. Always an endearing entertainer, R-Truth and his cohorts have apparently been given a creative license to do whatever they want with the division, and it shows, with the 24/7 Title doing the impossible - delivering WWE comedy that's actually funny.
There'll come a time when they need to freshen the formula up, but the current format isn't close to running out of steam yet. Long may it continue.
7. Batista's Return
While his WrestleMania 35 clash with Triple H was divisive, the events that brought Batista back onto WWE television were incredible.
The seeds were sown back in October 2018's Evolution reunion at SmackDown 1000, where 'The Animal' got frosty not only with 'The Game,' but Randy Orton as well. Four months later, Big Dave came through with 2019's most startling Raw segment. The feed cut backstage moments before Ric Flair's 70th birthday celebration. There, the Guardians of the Galaxy star was seen literally dragging a cameraman to 'The Nature Boy's' locker-room where he battered the 70-year-old, took him out, and stared down the lens.
"Hey Hunter," he said. "Do I have your attention now?"
A stunning reintroduction, and his "give me what I want!" promo ended up birthing one of 2019's best wrestling memes a few weeks later.