12 WWE Survivor Series 2017 Impulse Reactions

It's good, but it's not The One

Triple H Shane McMahon
WWE

The 31st edition of the November tradition had the makings of being one of the best ever WWE pay-per-views after an explosive month. Especially when an even more explosive McMahon dropped bombs on original plans.

When Roman Reigns and Bray Wyatt were replaced by Kurt Angle and AJ Styles respectively just 48 hours before October's Tables, Ladders and Chairs pay-per-view, the seismic adjustments had a once-in-a-generation feel to them. As it turned out, WWE would pattern their next four week's worth of television on the shock and awe.

Initially announcing Champion Vs Champion matches to feed into the broader Raw Vs SmackDown Live! arc, the company then switched all bar one of them through frantic title changes. Elsewhere, red and blue men and women's elimination teams were assembled for five-on-five wars. Then retooled and reshaped in the final week before the show.

It was disorder unlike any build-up in recent memory, and it manifested itself in the company generating rare unmissable air it so often craves. The actual quality of the show would quickly determine if WWE could keep said momentum over the notoriously difficult festive period though.

Already running short on goodwill with audiences after their announcement that Raw will go live on Christmas Day, the company must provide the type of television that will make fans want to slip away from family festivities to indulge in some Monday Night madness. Their own Thanksgiving spectacular suggested they might have just enough of the winning formula to do so.

12. Red Vs. Blue

Finn Balor Shinsuke Nakamura
WWE.com

There was much to criticise about the way WWE went about kicking off inter-brand hostilities on the post-Tables, Ladders and Chairs edition of Monday Night Raw. It was bad enough that '#UnderSiege' seemed as much about selling a slogan you could shove on a purple t-shirt if you couldn't decide between Red and Blue, but SmackDown Live!'s raid of the Raw locker-room overspilled in sizzle without so much as a sliver of steak.

Though no motivation was ever established for why exactly Shane McMahon's sapphire squad were so willing to die for such a legless cause, it at least promised a ruby Tuesday for 'The Boy Wonder's brand when Kurt Angle eventually elected to return fire.

With the title matches already locked in based on whomever happened to be holding the belts at the time, the Red/Blue chasm was resultantly strong enough to build the show around from the off. With a ludicrous five-man commentary booth, vibrant contest graphics that looked like trading cards and a post-match scoreboard, WWE went all out to preserve the thin veneer of brand warfare for the night.

Wrestlers themselves got in on the act too, with some outstanding and outlandish gear choices to put over their position for the night. Special praise must be afforded to Shinsuke Nakamura and Finn Bálor for their luxurious blue and red variants that were right out of a PlayStation 2 game's alternative attire menu. It was a slight shame not everybody got the memo...


11. Star Bursts

John Cena Triple H Kurt Angle
WWE.com

Triple H and John Cena, compu-global hyper-megastars that they are, couldn't give less of a sh*t about Raw Vs SmackDown Live!

One one hand, this makes them sane heads. Kevin Owens, Sami Zayn and Daniel Bryan have been cast as heel and babyface voices of reason over on the 'Land Of Opportunity' for refusing to buy into the November narrative. However, if anybody should be willing to stare into the abyss of 'Brand Supremacy' it should have been these two.

John Cena agreed to join Team Blue by virtue of retweeting Shane McMahon's announcement of the news. If his performance on the show was anything to go by, it might be how the deal actually happened. 'Big Match John' was a passenger in one of the year's biggest main events, and a fly-by-night to proceedings in general. He also picked the worst evening to flog brand new bright green clobber, and disregarded the one job every other star had that night by high-fiving Raw announcer Booker T as he went to the ring. Where were the A4 printouts by the Gorilla position reminding talents to 'KEEP ON BRAND'?!

Triple H was a similar offender. The topliner eventually became all about him, despite his involvement only confirmed on the go-home show via a turn-of-the-century midcarder Pedigree. He was at it again, here too, but his biggest crime was his red t-shirt/black trunks combo. Presumably the script on his latest sh*tty merch was Latin for 'not on the same team as these absolute mugs'.


10. Rip It Up

Dean Ambrose Xavier Woods
WWE.com

The Shield and The New Day had perhaps more pressure on them than anybody else on the card. In a company not famed for too many glorious trios, these triumvirates can comfortably be considered the two finest. Like limp-wristed political campaigns, they are better together - evidenced alone by the roars of support for Roman Reigns' superman punches and spears when he's a 'Hound Of Justice' rather than a 'Big Dog'.

Going on first, the six looked as though they needed to warm up the crowd as well as themselves in an opening stretch that felt more laboured than lively, but the action eventually came as thick as Big E and as fast as Seth Rollins in a closing set of near-falls hugely dramatic for a contest that was one of the most predictable on the card.

The Shield weren't losing their first pay-per-view clash back, not least with Roman still on duty to dethrone Brock Lesnar at WrestleMania. It would be overstating things to call the contest a resounding success, but it's a testament to the quality of contests the combatants have had this year that some left disappointed with the fray. Later in the card, and this possibly would have fared better. Robbed of genuine stakes (outside of the cathartic moment E disposed of Dean Ambrose' hideous half-and-half shirt), it did fall just a tiny bit short.


9. Flawed Genius

Asuka Carmella
WWE.com

The five-on-five Women's Survivor Series match looked on paper to be one of the night's biggest disappointments, not least as fans continue to nervously anticipate the company's mishandling of Asuka. Even including her in the match raised eyebrows from those that rightfully believed that the 'Empress Of Tomorrow' shouldn't be anywhere near Raw's horribly booked rank-and-file. And as it turned out, she wasn't.

Imperfectly perfect, the teams raised their games to tell a Survivor Series story Dads (including this one) could be proud of.

The match wasn't without botches. Alicia Fox and Naomi mangled...something that clouded their eliminations, and Nia Jax still isn't good at everything she should be, but the rest of the field were excellent in the small doses they were afforded. Spunky captain Becky Lynch was toppled early by her old mucker Bayley. 'The Hugger' herself faced an early bath, drawing shock (and possible frustration?) from bessie mate Sasha Banks. Normally duck-egg wallpaper on SmackDown Live!, Tamina was taking no sh*t as a one-night killer there to be eventually killed by Raw's deadliest weapon. These were brilliant character-based moments the Survivor Series used to be such a good vehicle for before agents got lazy with the gimmick.

And most importantly, the doubters were silenced for a night. Asuka looked awesome in victory, the best in class, exactly as she should. The whole spectacle was a resounding success.


8. Sins Of The Father

Jason Jordan
WWE

Showing sartorial solidarity if not his usual sunny smile, Jason Jordan wasn't homophonically foreshadowing a latter appearance on the card when he claimed to be 'fully healed' from the knee injury that convinced Kurt Angle to rule him out of the five-on-five blockbuster main event.

The former American Alpha man was none-too-pleased with Triple H though, and rightfully f**king so. 'The Game' Pedigreed him all the way out of the pay-per-view on Monday, whilst Daddy dearest stood there doing absolutely bot all about it. He didn't even look that peeved as the two stood side by side in the main event either. It can't have pleased Jordan to see Hunter and Kurt playing nicey nicey in early exchanges, but he can at least play Captain Hindsight on this week's Raw after Hunter's needless betrayal of the Olympian.

That Jordan's promo even occurred (to the soundtrack of vociferous boos from the capacity crowd) at least highlighted that the company finally seem to have picked a direction for the absurd Angle angle. Game-midcarder-who-happens-to-be-the-gaffer's-biological-son was working about as well as Jason's green and yellow colour scheme. In wrestling terms, those shades represent inexperienced and cowardly, respectively. Hardly the makings of a new top face, but certainly the palette of the audience's latest figure of bilious derision.


7. Best Of The Best

Alexa Bliss Paul Heyman
WWE

Alexa Bliss has had a blinding year or so on pay-per-view, even if her ascension has occasionally resulted in the total collapse of a division underneath her.

Comprehensive victories in matches and feuds over Becky Lynch, Sasha Banks and Bayley allowed Bliss to highlight a fabulous point never once alluded to by announce teams before the match - she's Four Horsewomen kryptonite. More than winning both red and blue Women's Titles as her opponent had, Bliss was afforded confidence that she could slay the 'Queen' because she'd done just to that to her superlative super-friends.

On this night, it wasn't to be, but there'll be wars again between the two that will highlight why they're currently booked as the best in class. Alexa's jaw-jacking was typically on point, whilst Charlotte has unexpected shone as a sympathetic babyface despite how domineering her character was as a heel.

The pair's match risked fading into the background of a loaded card, but an excellent stretch of offence for Bliss late on added fabulous drama to the clash. In hindsight, it was a shame the battle only gave the winner a point on the board instead of an inflated position on the card. This had all the makings of a big-time WrestleMania title match. Hopefully one day they'll get to do it.


6. Ring Sting

Bayley Kay Jewellers
WWE

In many ways, 1999 feels more like a hundred years ago than 18, but few could forget Stone Cold Steve Austin's incredible turn in a mid-show advertisement for the latest brand the organisation had gotten in bed with.

Wait, you don't remember?

Well, of course you don't, because it didn't f***ing happen.

Two years earlier, 'The Rattlesnake' had made himself a star in one of the company's greatest ever matches against Bret Hart. Since then, the world had gradually become his. The sound of glass smashing in sold out arenas could have been confused with a cocoon breaking as the stoic technician became one of the industry's most influential performers. The legendary WrestleMania contest was everything to him, and the company he helped restore to former glory.

Bayley had her own Austin moment in 2015. Listen to her appearance on his podcast for proof. The pair watch the match together, with Stone Cold as absorbed in her TakeOver: Brooklyn war with Sasha Banks as she probably was in the Bret match. It's a gut feeling. All the Michael Cole WrestleMania cliches are briefly actual truisms. Stars are born, legacies are made. The lot.

The last cliché is the saddest - things aren't what they used to be. Bayley, that iconic underdog come good is a conduit for awkward romance in a saccharine jewellery commercial. A break from the action then to celebrate Steven and Valerie's love is one thing. Divorcing Bayley further from the fanbase she carefully cultivated is quite another.


5. The Hit Man

Brock Lesnar AJ Styles
WWE

There were thankfully few echoes of the 1997 Survivor Series as WWE toasted 20 years since the Montreal Screwjob. It was nice to see the story left alone at a time the company may have felt ripe for reference, but even the briefest mention would have at least reminded younger fans that there was once a performer with the emotional and technical dexterity of Bret Hart.

To a generation of fans, 'The Hitman' was the glue that held their world together as a fan of a declining WWE. The mid-1990s were starved of believability, but not when the bell rang for Bret. No matter the story, he'd tell it with painstakingly accurate heft, carefully employing his broad skillset to leave both himself and his opponent better off regardless of the result.

The industry looked to have passed him by, but nonetheless left a vacancy for his modern equivalent that looked never to be filled until AJ Styles arrived in WWE. Not that 'The Phenomenal One' wasn't already the finished article in New Japan Pro Wrestling or his later days in TNA. But as WWE Champion, he may very well be the new 'Best There Is, Best There Was, and Best There Ever Will Be'.

The Pele kick to the back of Brock's head was a study in skilful desperation. The calf-killer near-tap and face-flattening escape may be the best spot of the entire year. Excellence of execution was certainly in supply, with Styles' immaculate selling of Lesnar's early assault finally making his auto-pilot effort seem worthy.

He couldn't slay the beast, and we all knew it, but AJ refused to let anybody believe it until the F5 was fatally landed.


4. Raising The Bar

The Bar The Usos
WWE

The words 'Superkick Party' were uttered in a WWE match for perhaps the first time as The Usos lowered the boom on The Bar after yet another breathless exchange. Ignoring a potential cease and desist document that may have to travel in the opposite direction, it was one of the only ever allusions to a dynamic Young Bucks match happening in a McMahon ring. With respect to Matt and Nick Jackson, this was even better.

In the opener, The Shield and The New Day were perhaps missing the opponents they'd had their finest moments of the year with as they struggled slightly to lift the match into legendary territory. Keen to prove they were more than the spare parts, Jimmy, Jey, Sheamus and Cesaro outperformed their doubles rivals in a blinding battle that wouldn't be remiss if revisited for WrestleMania.

When Sheamus and Cesaro ended The New Day's record-breaking tag team title run last December, they did so with a breathtaking false tag finish that fooled fans and foes alike. This conclusion may have been even better. Jimmy simultaneously scoring with a mid-air tag and a plancha to 'The Swiss Superman' to unlock Jey for the match-winning splash was the type of beautiful spot construction virtually non-existent on the weekly show. As a supercard shut-down, it'll deservedly live longer in the memory.


3. Getting Over

Kalisto Survivor Series
WWE

In 100% correct predictions piece previewing this show, it was posited that Enzo Amore was a substantially superior star than Kalisto merely because he was actually over. As if to plainly illustrate the gap between himself at the 'Smacktalker Skywalker', the former Lucha Dragon couldn't even literally interpret the criticism in their kickoff Cruiserweight title clash.

Nobody will speak of the match, because nobody should. There was nothing to talk about, write home about, or lament. But, feasting on the misery of others as we're sometimes wont to do, let's just share once more in the calamitous Kalisto entrance.

The mask has been a cursed artifice since WWE cynically attempted to replace Rey Mysterio's merch-shifting mechanism without giving remote thought to the performer under the hood. Mysterio was a rare breed in his ability to emote with children and adults alike. Like most truly exceptional performers, his moves were second place. Like Sin Cara before him, Kalisto is unable to establish the emotional connection from underneath his colourful garb. When flips are elsewhere on the card, more is required to form that bond.

That 'more' is yet to show itself, but not for the first time, Kalisto has shown himself up. If 'good lucha things' won't cut it, bad ones clearly won't help either.


2. Last Man Standing

Samoa Joe Shane McMahon
WWE.com

Earlier in the night, The Miz and Baron Corbin had what was predictably the dullest match on the card. However, it still a credit to both. Still trying to improve, Corbin sold a bad wheel convincingly, and Miz remained the most important full-timer on the roster with yet another selfless display. His willingness to let Baron cut a post-match promo over top his prone frame was a fine callback to his rampant abuse of interviewer Renee Young and an enormous further lift to 'The Lone Wolf's credibility.

Shane McMahon could learn a thing or two from the 'A-Lister'.

What's in the f***ing kool-aid at arenas worldwide that continue to ensure fans greet this man with cheers loud enough to convince his father to continue pushing him as the toughest man in the world?

Reptilian and robotic in his propensity for swallowing up the skills of others, 'The Money' tonight gobbled up the resilience of his entire roster to survive ludicrous levels of offence.

The five-on-five main event was problematic in places (more on that later), but utterly infuriating in the bold-faced protection of the Commissioner against onslaught of Raw and SmackDown Live! talent alike. How long did he cling on in Kurt Angle's anklelock that should have finished the match? How quickly did he return from the murderous hesitation dropkick from Finn Bálor. How easily did he fend off Kevin Owens and Sami Zayn's Chuckle Brothers' act in comfortably the worst point of the whole show.

If a teased dissent with Daniel Bryan comes to fruition in the aftermath of all this, here's hoping he copies the 'Yes Man' and sustains an injury so brutal he also has to retire. It's gotten way beyond ridiculous.


1. Last Monster Standing

Braun Strowman Triple H
WWE.com

Despite how befuddling the ending of the pay-per-view may have felt, WWE did at least protect one of their literal biggest weapons to come from the as-yet-unproven Performance Centre star factory.

In darker days gone by, all your favourite dreamboats would have eaten Pedigrees, but Shinsuke Nakamura and Bobby Roode were at least slammed to death by Braun Strowman en route to surviving the match with the treacherous Triple H. 'The Game' still had to embody all his cerebralist assassinist clout in the closing stretch of course. God forbid he look remotely troubled by the majority of the fellas in the battle - in the last week he's set up enough WrestleMania matches to work more on the 'Show Of Shows' than the time Vince McMahon made him wrestle five times on an edition of SmackDown.

There was much to criticise about the booking of the contest's closing stretch, not least because of just because of how much of it revolved around the 'King Of Kings'. He only put himself in the match last Monday, what on earth had they got planned before then?!

Thankfully, Braun putting him down and (just about) out to close the show left a window open for him to do it again next Spring if he's not busy claiming one of the World Titles. The company may not push all your favourites, but they can't be accused of not getting firmly behind this valuable starlet.


Contributor
Contributor

Michael is a writer, editor, podcaster and presenter for WhatCulture Wrestling, and has been with the organisation for 10 years. Alongside the production of daily written, audio and video content covering WWE and AEW, he also provides knowledge and insights on all aspects of the wrestling industry thanks to a passion for it dating back over 35 years. As one third of "The Dadley Boyz" Michael has contributed to the huge rise in popularity of the WhatCulture Wrestling Podcast and its accompanying YouTube channel, earning it top spot on the UK's wrestling podcast charts with over 10,000 episodes and 70,000,000 total downloads. He also co-hosts Benno & Hamflett, In Your House!, Podcast Horseman: The BoJack Horseman Podcast, and has guested on long-running Sunderland AFC podcast Wise Men Say. With WhatCulture, he has provided in-person coverage of some of the biggest pay-per-views and Premium Live Events in wrestling history, including WrestleMania, Survivor Series, All In & Double Or Nothing in destinations such as New York, New Jersey, Chicago, Dallas, Las Vegas, Philadelphia, London and Cardiff. He has also been featured as a wrestling analyst for the Tampa Bay Times, Fightful, POST Wrestling, GRAPPL, GCP, Poisonrana, 411Mania and Sports Guys Talking Wrestling. Michael's background in media stretches beyond wrestling coverage, with a degree in Journalism from the University Of Sunderland (2:1) and a series of published articles in music and culture magazines The Crack, Pilot as well as Sunderland AFC's premiere fanzine A Love Supreme. When not offering his voice up for daily wrestling podcasts, he can be found losing it every other Saturday at the Stadium Of Light, and at Cribs gigs nationwide.