13 Classic Matches That Should Have Happened At WrestleMania

These matches should and could have happened at WrestleMania, but didn't.

Every year during WrestleMania season, fans take to the internet to speculate on which matches will make the final card for WWE€™s biggest event. More often than not, people are able to read between the lines and guess a handful of high profile contests, but sometimes, a few logical ideas never came to fruition for various reasons. As recently as two weeks ago, rumours swirled that Daniel Bryan and Sheamus would meet one-on-one in San Francisco. Last year, fans threw around the main event of The Rock vs. Brock Lesnar to headline WrestleMania 30. Heading into WrestleMania 29, all anyone would talk about was the possibility of CM Punk vs. €œStone Cold€ Steve Austin. And yet, none of that happened. Over the last 30 years, several big matches should justifiably have happened at WrestleMania, but for circumstances unknown they never made it to the bill. In some cases the two competitors met prior to €˜Mania; in others, the WWE brass just didn€™t see the value in a particular match. And in others still, matches were booked that were subsequently dropped because of injury or other changes. Either way, fans were deprived of witnessing potential dream matches in the perfect setting. While fans inevitably like to think up €œDream Match€ scenarios that are impossible to book, these are the few that could have actually happened had it not been for a wrench or two thrown into the equation.


13. Matt Hardy vs. MVP €“ United States Championship €“ WrestleMania 24

On a July 2007 episode of Smackdown, Matt Hardy kicked off a bitter rivalry with United States Champion MVP when he pinned him in a non-title match. In a fun series of competitions, MVP declared he was €œbetter than Matt Hardy at everything.€ The two traded wins in various feats of athletic skill until MVP was diagnosed with a heart condition that kept him out of action. To throw fans a curveball, after MVP was cleared to compete, he and Hardy won the WWE Tag Team Championship as the unlikeliest of teams. When they dropped the titles, the feud jumped to another level with MVP putting Hardy on the shelf with a vicious attack. Shortly thereafter, Hardy legitimately suffered a burst appendix, keeping him out of action from November until March 1st. Hardy was cleared to return to wrestling, but WWE kept him off TV until he interfered in the Money in the Bank Ladder Match at WrestleMania 24 to attack MVP. So if Hardy was cleared a month before the biggest show of the year, why didn€™t they pull the trigger and give fans the match they had been working toward for over eight months?

12. €œMacho Man€ Randy Savage vs. Ricky €œThe Dragon€ Steamboat 2 €“ WrestleMania 4

It€™s kind of hard to get in the ring and top a performance that is widely considered one of the greatest matches of all-time, but if any two professional wrestlers could do it, it€™s Randy Savage and Ricky Steamboat. After losing his Intercontinental Championship to Steamboat in their classic at WrestleMania 3, Savage soon became a fan favorite. Heading into WrestleMania 4, he was chosen by Vince McMahon to win the tournament for the vacant WWF Championship. Savage€™s path to championship glory saw him win four matches against opponents Butch Reed, Greg €œThe Hammer€ Valentine, One Man Gang, and €œThe Million Dollar Man€ Ted DiBiase. So why not a rematch with Steamboat? If you look at the bracket, Steamboat and Savage could have met in the second round to give fans a second helping of off-the-wall competition. A babyface vs. babyface showdown between Mach€™ and the guy who pinned him for the Intercontinental title the year before would have been outstanding. Throw in a sportsmanlike handshake after and you've got yourself another WrestleMania Moment. Instead, Greg €œThe Hammer€ Valentine pinned Steamboat clean in the middle of the ring.

11. John Cena vs. Randy Orton €“ WWE Championship €“ WrestleMania 24

Early in their careers, Cena and Orton were handpicked by the right people to lead the charge for the next decade. By 2007, the two had been multi-time World Champions and barely touched in the ring. In fact, they never had a one-on-one match in that time-frame. Having the two meet for the first time at WrestleMania should have been a logical conclusion. Instead, WWE couldn€™t help but jump the gun in an attempt to push SummerSlam as the second biggest show of the year. Their first pay-per-view singles match happened in front of 17,000 fans in New Jersey and lasted all but thirteen minutes with Cena retaining the WWE Championship. After an injury sidelined Cena until his surprise return at the 2008 Royal Rumble (which he won), the Doctor of Thuganomics took his title shot early, challenging WWE Champion Orton to a match at No Way Out. Orton got himself disqualified to retain the title, Triple H got involved in the title picture, and Cena obviously deserved a rematch. The Triple Threat Match between the three was set for WrestleMania 24. So yes, John Cena and Randy Orton technically wrestled one another at WrestleMania. But how much bigger would that match have been if Cena and Orton locked horns for the first time that night? By this point, fans were tired of seeing the two in the ring together. Had they waited to cash in, who knows what kind of money it could have drawn?

10. Brock Lesnar vs. Daniel Bryan €“ WWE World Heavyweight Championship €“ WrestleMania 31

The fact that this match isn€™t happening this Sunday has a lot of wrestling fans perturbed. When Daniel Bryan returned from what many thought was a career-ending neck injury, the WWE Universe clamored for him to rise to the WrestleMania main event for a second time. Fans were so caught up in the Yes Movement 2.0 that they were left speechless when Bryan was unceremoniously eliminated from the 2015 Royal Rumble. The tease continued at Fastlane when Bryan was granted an opportunity to win Roman Reigns€™ WrestleMania spot in a one-on-one match. Again, Bryan came up short. Now he is in the Intercontinental Championship Ladder Match this Sunday instead of challenging Brock Lesnar for the WWE World Heavyweight Championship. Bryan vs. Brock could have been an epic underdog story, with Bryan overcoming the odds again. Some believe that Daniel Bryan beating Brock Lesnar seems impossible, but they also said the same thing about him having to beat Evolution over the course of two matches in the same night. What a comeback story it could have been.

9. The Rock vs. Triple H €“ WWF Championship €“ WrestleMania 2000

In one of the most head-scratching decisions in WrestleMania history, red hot WWF Champion Triple H defeated the even hotter People€™s Champion The Rock in a Four Way Elimination Match involving Mick Foley and The Big Show at WrestleMania 2000. You see, The Rock won the 2000 Royal Rumble in controversial fashion €“ his feet touched the floor €“ when he last eliminated The Big Show and Triple H was still involved in a bitter rivalry with Mick Foley. At No Way Out, Triple H forced Foley into retirement with a Hell in a Cell victory. The Rock lost to The Big Show after interference from Shane McMahon that same night. So instead of giving fans a one-on-one contest between two guys in their prime who make up one of the greatest rivalries in the history of the business, they wedged in The Big Show and Mick Foley €“ with a McMahon in every corner. Rearrange a few things and BOOM, you have The Rock vs. Triple H one-on-one at WrestleMania 2000. Instead, fans were given an overbooked main event where the bad guy retained the WWF Championship.The following month at Backlash, The Rock defeated Triple H in a singles match for the WWF Championship.

8. Hulk Hogan vs. €œThe Million Dollar Man€ Ted DiBiase €“ WWF Championship €“ WrestleMania 4

Was there ever a more logical WrestleMania match to be made when you consider the circumstances leading up to it? Good Lord. For the first time in company history, the WWF Championship had been declared vacant. Why? Because €œThe Million Dollar Man€ Ted DiBiase paid a referee to undergo plastic surgery to look like Dave Hebner and count Hulk Hogan€™s shoulders to the mat during his WrestleMania 3 rematch with Andre the Giant so Hogan would lose the WWF Championship and Andre could sell it to him. That actually happened. The plan went off without a hitch until the real Dave Hebner showed up to blow the lid off the ruse. WWF President Jack Tunney declared the title vacant and booked a tournament for WrestleMania 4. Hogan and Andre were scheduled to meet in the second round €“ both were given a first round bye. Instead of Hogan picking up a second victory over Andre to meet DiBiase in the finals to get revenge, Vince McMahon and Pat Patterson made the call to put DiBiase in the next bracket position, have Hogan and Andre wrestle to a double disqualification, and award DiBiase a third round bye to the finals. The Million Dollar Man lost to €œMacho Man€ Randy Savage in the finals and the rest is history. Hogan eventually got his hands on DiBiase at WrestleMania, but it was alongside Brutus "The Barber" Beefcake in a losing effort to DiBiase and IRS at WrestleMania 9.

7. The Legion of Doom vs. Demolition €“ WrestleMania 7

When The Road Warriors signed with the World Wrestling Federation in 1990, the thought of seeing them take on Demolition was on the minds of wrestling fans everywhere. Having allegedly been created as a knockoff of Hawk and Animal, Ax and Smash were built as the most dominant tag team in WWF history. The feud made sense. Vince McMahon renamed the former NWA World Tag Team Champions "The Legion of Doom" and immediately threw them into a rivalry with Demolition. But instead of waiting until WrestleMania, the teams met on non-televised events with new Demolition member Crush thrown into the mix. What had happened was Demolition Ax was experiencing health problems after an allergic reaction to shellfish on a tour of Japan - at the time they thought it was a life-changing heart problem. The decision to add Crush to the crew was met with the agreement that Ax would transition into a backstage role. It didn€™t work out and Ax was gone from the WWF by Survivor Series 1990. Ax eventually recovered from the medical issues. In fact, he was perfectly healthy by WrestleMania 7. Instead, they rushed into the feud and made drastic decisions because of a bad meal.

6. Shawn Michaels vs. Bret €œThe Hitman€ Hart II €“ WWF Championship €“ WrestleMania 13

A lot of wrestling fans know the story behind this one, but let€™s tell it anyway. Part of Bret Hart€™s agreement to drop the WWF Championship to Shawn Michaels at WrestleMania 12 involved a promised rematch at WrestleMania 13. The Heartbreak Kid embarked on a tremendous run as WWF Champion while Bret€™s popularity came into question due to a changing climate in what fans wanted out of their professional wrestling. After regaining the WWF Championship from Sid at the 1997 Royal Rumble, HBK suffered a knee injury that required surgery. Shawn vacated the WWF Championship on Raw and told fans that he had €œlost his smile.€ Due to the timing of the injury and recovery time involved, Shawn would have to miss WrestleMania 13 as an in-ring competitor. He still showed up to join the commentary team for the main event between The Undertaker and Sid, but could not compete. Bret Hart has gone on record as saying that Shawn Michaels faked the injury because he did not want to lose the title to him at WrestleMania. HBK stands by the injury claim. When Shawn finally returned, the two feuded until Bret€™s unceremonious departure at the hands of Shawn at Survivor Series €™97.

5. The Undertaker vs. John Cena €“ WrestleMania 30

Undertaker Cena Wm3 WrestleMania 30 will forever be remembered as the night The Streak ended. Heading into the night at 21-0, The Undertaker was dominated by Brock Lesnar, putting The Dead Man€™s future into question. After all, now that he is 21-1, what would be the point of coming back? This was especially frustrating to anyone who wanted to see The Undertaker put The Streak on the line against the biggest name of the past 12 years in John Cena. Every year since The Streak€™s acknowledgement at WrestleMania 17, various WWE Superstars sought to end it with fans wondering whether or not that particular Superstar could. Could it have ever been in more question than if Taker was in there with Cena? Last year, very few fans actually believed Brock Lesnar would end The Streak. That€™s why it was so shocking when it happened. Now imagine if he was in there with John Cena? Completely different dynamic. I mean, he is €œSuper Cena€ after all. Right, Internet Wrestling Community? That match had money written all over it and WWE missed the boat. The Undertaker vs. John Cena could still happen at WrestleMania 32 in Dallas, Texas, but the aura just won€™t be the same without The Streak intact.

4. The Undertaker vs. Sting €“ WrestleMania 31

Let€™s be honest, The Undertaker vs. Sting is the match fans wanted to see this year. Sure, Triple H vs. Sting will be good because everything Triple H has touched over the past few years has turned to gold, but it€™s not even close to the dream match that€™s been talked about for over a decade. Streak or not, The Undertaker vs. Sting should have been booked for this year€™s show. If Sting has a bad showing with Triple H or doesn€™t have it in him to do another WrestleMania, the hope of seeing Taker/Stinger is gone forever. Let€™s not forget that The Phenom€™s health has been brought into question heading into the last three WrestleMania€™s. Timing is everything. Maybe WWE is banking on that time being next year at AT&T Stadium, but between now and then there are a lot of variables that can throw off that timing.

3. The Rock vs. Shawn Michaels €“ WrestleMania 19 Or 20

The dream match that will never happen could have taken place not once, but TWICE had everyone simply been nice to each other. The greatest in-ring performer in WWE history should have shared the ring with the greatest Superstar in WWE history at WrestleMania just once. After a five-year hiatus from WrestleMania, Shawn Michaels squared off against Chris Jericho at WrestleMania 19 in an unbelievable match toward the beginning of a seven-year run that was as Hall of Fame-worthy as the first half of HBK€™s career. That same night, The Rock put €œStone Cold€ Steve Austin out to pasture in the epic conclusion to their memorable WrestleMania trilogy. Would fans have traded their matches that night to see a returning Shawn Michaels and super-mega-heel Rock go head-to-head? The following year at WrestleMania 20, Shawn found himself involved in a Triple Threat Match for the World Heavyweight Championship against Triple H and Chris Benoit while The Rock reunited with Mick Foley as The Rock €˜N Sock Connection to take on Evolution (Ric Flair, Batista, and Randy Orton) in a handicap match. It was The Rock€™s last match in a WWE ring for almost eight years. Would fans have traded their matches that night to see a top-form Shawn Michaels and "about to leave for a long time" Rock go head-to-head at Madison Square Garden? Unfortunately for the fans that would make these trades, The Showstopper was pretty brutal to The Great One in the locker room when The Rock was still a youngster and Shawn was in the main event. That alone left a bitter taste in The People€™s Mouth and fans were deprived of what could have been an incredible show. Today they seem pretty friendly, but it would have been great if it had been sooner.

2. Hulk Hogan vs. €œStone Cold€ Steve Austin €“ WrestleMania 19

Stone Cold Vs Hulk Hogan The pieces were also in place at WrestleMania 19 for Hulk Hogan to have the fantasy match of a lifetime with €œStone Cold€ Steve Austin. While it was originally proposed for WrestleMania 18 and shot down by Austin, they could have gotten their act together to give fans that battle in Seattle. Instead, Austin wrestled The Rock in a classic that turned out to be the last match of Stone Cold€™s career. Hogan wrestled Vince McMahon in what turned out to be the last WrestleMania match of The Hulkster€™s career. Both were outstanding performances. It€™s just a shame to know that this was the night the window closed on Hogan vs. Austin. Reasons as to why the match didn€™t materialize remain dubious. Austin himself has said that he didn€™t think it would be that good based on where they were physically. Hogan proved that wrong in his matches against The Rock and Mr. McMahon. If it came down to an argument as to who would win, then it would be terrible to know fans never got to see it over something that wouldn€™t have hurt either guy.

1. Hulk Hogan vs. €œThe Nature Boy€ Ric Flair €“ WWF Championship €“ WrestleMania 8

This one is probably the most frustrating because it was actually announced at a press conference. When Ric Flair jumped from WCW to the WWF in 1991, the dream of seeing him square off against Hulk Hogan at WrestleMania was becoming a reality. Hogan and Flair had been arguably the two biggest stars in all of wrestling throughout the 1980€™s, carrying rival promotions on their shoulders. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=yfQPKSxsBuc In a shocker, Flair brought the NWA World Heavyweight Championship with him to the WWF, calling himself the "Real World's Champion." After some shenanigans involving The Undertaker, a steel chair, and ashes from the urn, the WWF Championship was vacated and decided at the 1992 Royal Rumble. Flair emerged victorious to unify the NWA and WWF Championships. When Jack Tunney named Hulk Hogan the number one contender, WrestleMania 8 looked to the biggest €˜Mania yet. Then something weird happened: Flair focused on €œMacho Man€ Randy Savage while Hogan was thrust into a feud with Sid Justice. But why? Hogan and Flair had been wrestling on house shows across the country with Flair pinning Hogan after an illegal shot with brass knuckles. The idea was for Hogan to beat Flair at WrestleMania and go on another lengthy run to rekindle HulkaMania. Instead, Hogan was burned out and wanting to spend time with his kids. His plans for retirement derailed the main event of WrestleMania 8. Ric Flair and Hulk Hogan would face each other on television two years later, but that was for the WCW World Heavyweight Championship at Bash at the Beach. It just wasn€™t the same. Which other classic ties do you wish had happened at WrestleMania? Share your thoughts below in the comments thread.

Contributor
Contributor

Eric Delgado has been writing about professional wrestling for five years and has been involved in the professional wrestling business as a performer for ten. He is also the former host of Steel Cage Radio and has an irrational love for The Ryback.