13 Ups & 4 Downs From AEW Fyter Fest 2019

Janela vs. Moxley, The Elite vs. Lucha Bros/Laredo Kid, and more!

Jon Moxley
AEW/CEO/Tomas Tischio

No matter what caliber of show AEW Fyter Fest turned out to be, the critical response was always going to be interesting.

Double Or Nothing was an out-of-the-park home run of an event that built great hope for the nascent promotion while lumbering All Elite with boatloads of excessive hype. This meant that whatever happened next almost had to hit the same level, or those who weren't as invested in AEW's maiden PPV voyage as most critics would've been made ever warier of the company's long-term prospects.

Understandable, but troublesome, as Fyter Fest was never designed to hit Double Or Nothing's lofty heights. This was, from day one, marketed as a B-tier show; a Backlash or Stomping Grounds, not a SummerSlam or Survivor Series. Expectations should have fallen somewhere between "good" and "great," not "great" and "best of the year," despite the abundance of fun-looking matches on this loose Fyre Festival parody show.

Regardless, Fyter Fest was a success. Highlighted, as expected, by Jon Moxley vs. Joey Janela and The Elite vs. Laredo Kid and the Lucha Brothers, it was another night of deep varied action from wrestling's cool new promotion. More than that: it was another step in the right direction, despite a handful of Buy In pre-show concerns.

Let's dive into it.


Downs...

4. Skip To Kip

Kip Sabian
AEW

England's Kip Sabian was on commentary for Hangman Page's victory over MJF, Jimmy Havoc and Jungle Boy, and in the night's weirdest booking move, it looks like Page's win has "qualified" him for a match with Sabian - presumably about Fight For The Fallen.

Sabian effectively revealed the match from the booth, claiming he'd take a massive step forward if he could defeat Page before his big World Title shot. He's right, but where on Earth did this come from?

Kip is a fine wrestler, but his AEW resume amounts to no more than a Buy In win over Sammy Guevara so far, while Page triumphed in the inaugural Casino Battle Royale and just bested Havoc. Somehow, though, we're supposed to take Sabian as being on the same level or even above Hangman?

Odd. Super odd.


3. The Dark Order Underwhelm... Again

The Dark Order
AEW

The Best Friends of Chuckie T. and Trent Beretta were cutoff by Stu Grayson and Evil Uno - AKA the Dark Order - moments after their win over Private Party and SCU. The duo appeared in black and white on the video screen, claiming they had a "long list of deceivers we need to correct," and that they'd chosen Best Friends as their first.

Cue: the lights cutting, just like at Double Or Nothing, with the duo's army of masked goobers appearing at ringside.

Then, another cut. DON had conditioned us to expect Grayson and Uno at this point, but no: the goobs were gone when the lights returned.

This didn't come off well. While not having the Order destroy Best Friends was a nice twist on the already-established format, the crowd was as unenthused as they were for the Order's misplaced debut, and it's impossible to classify anything that fails to get over so spectacularly as anything other than a Down. Here's hoping AEW figure out a way to make this corny-looking gimmick work going forward.


2. Allie Can't Carry Leva Bates

Allie AEW
AEW/CEO/Li Hoang

The Librarians and their shhhhh'ing session were eventually interrupted by former Impact Wrestling standout Allie, who was playing an extension of her old babyface character from that promotion. She looked genuinely delighted to be involved in this, though she'd raised Leva Bates and Peter Avalon's ire.

Unfortunately, the bout barely exceeded the corny segment. While Allie moved, fought, and generally looked good between the ropes, she and Bates struggled to put anything compelling together. This was particularly apparent when the former 'Blue Pants' was in control. Her shtick parts were noticeably smoother than her actual wrestling and there were some textbook heel spots with her de facto valet, Avalon, but the execution was the opposite of crisp and she never settled into a good rhythm.

A shame, as the Buy In could have done with another banger to maintain its momentum after the three-way tag. Still, we have to call this for what it was: a failure. Matches like this can't blight AEW pay-per-views going forward.

'Pretty' Peter did a grand job on the outside, at least.


1. Shhhhhh!

Leva Bates Peter Avalon Librarian
AEW

This 'Librarian' shtick? It's not good. Not good at all.

Leva Bates and 'Pretty' Peter Avalon made their respective presences felt on the Buy In, with Bates emerging first. She shhhh'd the crowd before her cohort came out to do the same, and while Avalon got heat for dumping a tent in the paddling pool then decapitating a mannequin, the pre-match segment came off as poorly as their backstage bit at Double Or Nothing.

Was Bates criticizing comics and instructing the fans to "read books with words" supposed to draw heel heat? It didn't. This is goofy, nonsense comedy, and it isn't hitting the mark.

Here's hoping AEW find a way to make these characters work before the TV deal kicks in. At the moment, the Librarians are an affront to AEW's supposed "sport-like" goals. They don't fit at all, and while this stuff works on Being the Elite, its presence on mainline shows messes with everything the promotion are trying to accomplish.


Ups...

13. An Acceptable Car Crash

Alex Jebailey Michael Nakazawa
AEW/CEO/Thomas Tischio

God bless Michael Nakazawa. God bless that man for not only carrying Alex Jebailey, the non-wrestling CEO head honcho, to an acceptable hardcore mess, but also making it so much fun in the process.

Yes, there were moments that look like sh*t. Jebailey isn't a wrestler. He collaborated with AEW to put this show together, and that's primarily why he was on the card. While he deserves commendation for the hard work he put forth in training for the Nakazawa match, he looked really rough at points, but if anyone's to be criticized for that, it's AEW themselves for putting him on the show.

A weird, weird match here, and if you told your writer that you thought it was complete garbage, he wouldn't necessarily argue with you. Still, Nakazawa rules. He's a grade A comedy wrestler whose oiled-up shortcuts get over, and he and referee Bryce Remsburg successfully navigated Jebailey's glaring weaknesses to craft a bout that won't win any awards for technicality, but still had enough to finish as a net positive.

Jebailey's best moments came with plunder. He battered Nakazawa with a CEO-branded joystick and tried to drown him in the paddling pool, before Michael bludgeoned him with an inflatable Flamengo. A kendo stick, table, and more gaming accessories were used as we headed back towards the ring, with Nakazawa spearing his opponent through said table, before the Japanese comedy act reversed a pin for the 1-2-3. As a leave-your-brain-at-the-door trainwreck, this was fine.


12. Goldenboy>Alex Marvez

Double Or Nothing's janky announce team was one of the biggest complaints thrown at AEW's maiden pay-per-view voyage, with the outstanding Excalibur forced to hold it together all night long as Jim Ross hit a few rough patches early on (before recovering the point where he actually sounded great by the end), and ex-NFL man Alex Marvez clearly in over his head.

There was an adjustment last night, with Esports announce Goldenboy replacing Marvez in the booth. This was a step in the right direction. While Marvez wasn't as awful as his biggest critics made out, his inflections and delivery were all wrong for pro-wrestling, while Goldenboy fit like a glove. Sure, he wasn't able to offer the same level of insight as his partners, but that wasn't his job. He was there to supplement the action with the right lines at the right moments and he did that admirably.

Whether or not Goldenboy was only here through the CEO partnership remains to be seen, but he'd make a solid addition going forward, particularly if AEW are to persist with the three-man booth.


11. The Mad Bumper

Darby Allin is an enigmatic performer. At first glance, he looks like every "troubled" goth kid you knew growing up. He dresses all in black, covers half his face with corpse paint, and wears a moody facial expression constantly. On top of this, his backstory begins with tragedy (he was involved in a road traffic accident in which his drunk uncle passed away when Darby was just five years old) and he has "lost his faith in humanity," which, if you're a cynic, sounds corny and may present Allin as a caricature.

Here's the thing about Darby, though: he's fantastic in the ring. His crisp, impactful offence, maniac bumping, and do-or-die attitude blow every preconception away as soon as he gets rolling, and while it took him a while to work through the gearbox versus Cody's more methodical style, he got there by the end.

This match was at its least interesting with Cody in control. As great a performer as he has become, the 'American Nightmare' isn't always the most exciting wrestler when booked as some kind of ring general. Fortunately, Allin's bumping prevented any major lulls. He flopped straight through the ropes and to the outside on a whip to the corner, then took an insane bump later on, landing back-first on the apron after soaring from the top. Lord knows what kind of damage this stuff is doing to this body, but it sure is exciting.

The time limit expiring before Cody could score the decisive pinfall was a nice touch that puts Darby over as a difficult guy to beat, too. Allin made a mark, though it would've been nice to see him show more of the cool sh*t he can do, but such was the layout.


10. That Stage, Though...

AEW Fyter Fest Stage
AEW

Aesthetics are important, and Fyter Fest's set design deserves a little shout-out.

This thing looked tremendous. All Elite did a fine job of making the pay-per-view look and feel different, and the Fyre Festival gimmick was strong. These guys had bikini-clad models, a paddling pool, palm trees, and actual tents from the failed festival around the stage. These things, coupled with the TNA-style entrance tunnels, left the show looking unlike anything WWE will produce all year, and that's critical.

AEW needs to the alternative to the sterile "A-league," and they're already doing a fine job of presenting themselves as such. Sure, this was a themed pay-per-view, but it looked great. Here's hoping similar shows employ similar methods going forward.


9. Skull Stuff

Cody Chair Shot
AEW

Shawn Spears' unprotected chairshot on Cody was grim, hard to watch, and undeniably stupid, particularly with concussions so prevalent these days.

But holy sh*t, was it impactful.

Stuff like this isn't for everyone, but if the announcers are to put a chairshot over as concussive, it has to be done like this. Anything less wouldn't be believable. That thing hit like a hammer blow and your writer isn't in the business of telling grown professional adults what they can and can't do with their own bodies. For that reason and because it got over, this is an Up.

Impact is impact, whether ghoulish or not.


8. CIMA Edges Daniels In Veteran Battle

Fyter Fest kicked off with one of its most anticipated singles matches, with former Dragon Gate standout CIMA facing off against SoCal Uncensored's Christopher Daniels, mirroring Double Or Nothing where their respective factions faced off in the same spot.

25 May's opener ruled, as CIMA, El Lindaman, and T-Hawk found their footing as stars to watch against the established gang of bell-ends. This opener? A delightful veteran scrap between two old pros who know what the f*ck they're doing, and executed their plan well.

They spaced out and built to their biggest bombs well. An Arabian Moonsault off the ropes highlighted Daniels' early shine, before CIMA hit him with a top rope Backstabber minutes later. The Strong Hearts man tried taking control from there, but it didn't quite play out that way, as damage to his lower back prevented him from taking full advantage. Daniels' countered his way out of what looked like a Fisherman Driver and hit the Angel's Wings. It wasn't enough, though. CIMA eventually got that Fisherman Driver, then kept the pressure, heading north for a Meteora and the 1-2-3, setting him up nicely for next month's bout with Kenny Omega.

The relatively short runtime is our only real complaint here, but perhaps the 49-year-old Daniels isn't capable of working longer singles contests. Regardless, this hit the mark and he sacrificed no credibility in losing the fall.


7. Because He's Better Than You...

How do you put MJF on your wrestler show and not have him cut a promo? You don't, and the biggest d*ckhead in AEW tore everyone to pieces prior to his four-way bout.

The crowd were already booing Friedman out of the building by the time he grabbed the microphone. He shot hard on a crowd largely comprised of gamer, dropping untoward comments about the "basement-dwellers" and their mothers, before turning his crosshairs on his opponents. MJF calling Page (who is a "f*cking horse," of course) 'Seabiscuit' will never not be great. From there, he went back to Daytona Beach, saying that if he was them, he'd be watching reruns of their episodes of "My 600lb Life," and that he "loved video games... until I lost my virginity."

While not as scathing as his DON rant (where he had a tremendous target to aim for in Hart), MJF came off like a fabulous bastard here. He's the next big heel in professional wrestling and will therefore be a vital piece for AEW going forward.


6. Page Wins All-Action Scramble

Put together in hilarious fashion on Being the Elite, MJF vs. Jimmy Havoc vs. Hangman Page vs. Jungle Boy was an extension of Double Or Nothing, where MJF interrupted Page during Bret Hart's AEW World Title unveiling before the babyfaces joined forces to run him off. MJF cut a marvelous pre-match promo, Jungle Boy rode to the ring on Luchasaurus' shoulders, Havoc looked like a mad goth, and Page got a tremendous pop. A solid start.

A fast, fluid, action-packed scrap followed. MJF brought the heat by faking out of dives and getting it right up the audience throughout. Blessed with an inherent ability to get over through exciting ring work, Jungle Boy unleashed torrents of flippity-do-das and quick athletic explosions, out-pacing everyone else in the match. Havoc, meanwhile, came through with the reckless that brought him to the dance, particularly with his senton dive to the outside, and as for Hangman? The guy's a star in the making and he filled that ring like a 20-year veteran, the audience in the palm of his hand whenever he was in the ascendancy.

Though Page was the favourite heading in, MJF would have made an acceptable spoiler. They went toe-to-toe as the bout approached its third act with Jim Ross putting them over as "two of the biggest players in AEW going forward." He's right, but this one belonged to Page, with the prospect nailing Havoc with his Deadeye finisher to score the win.


5. Best Friends Win Highlights The Buy In

Fyter Fest's Buy In pre-show kicked off with a three-way tag scramble between Private Party, SCU's Scorpio Sky and Frankie Kazarian, and Best Friends, with a daft stipulation meaning the winners would earn the opportunity to wrestle for a first-round bye in the upcoming tag tournament at All Out (nonsense, as they'd therefore need to wrestle one more match than anyone else to reach round two).

That notable contrivance aside, the bout was lots of fun. Exploratory opening exchanges offered flashes of the excitement to come, and the three teams meshed well together, with Party Private providing the most flurries of athleticism (getting themselves over in the process), the popular SCU douching it up, and Best Friends sitting somewhere in the middle. It had a rough edge or two (one saw Chuckie T. fling Isiah Kasidy into a Trent cutter - but he didn't get all of it), but it was sharp, exciting, entertaining, and full of character. A solid way to introduce Private Party and take the other two teams forward from Double Or Nothing.

The finish came following a signature move shoot-out, with big kickouts escalating the drama before Best Friends finally nailed Kasidy with the Strong Zero for the victory. A hoot of a match, particularly late on, and a great way to get started.


4. 'The Native Beast' Rises

Riho Nyla Rose
AEW

Fyter Fest's second women's bout saw Riho, Yuka Sakazaki, and Nyla Rose collide in a three-way dance, with the winner gaining the opportunity to establish themselves as an early frontrunner in the nascent division.

How Rose would fare was the biggest question heading in. While Awesome Kong's Double Or Nothing appearance was a great surprise, it undermined the 'Native Beast.' She's supposed to be being set up as the monster heel, after all, and it was tough for her to get any shine while competing against one of the strongest female archetypes of that character. Here, she'd have every opportunity to flex her might against the smaller joshi wrestlers, and she started fast, tossing both women into the corner before countering their early team-up with the kind of power one would expect.

While it's clear that she's still growing into her role as a performer, Rose is an intriguing prospect and building much of the bout around her dominance was a smart idea. Credit to Sakazaki and Riho, too: they sold and bumped well, and bridging out of Nyla's early double-pin attempt got the crowd going.

Sakazaki, 'The Magical Girl,' came alive with a dive to the outside. Shine shifted from the monster to the underdogs from there, with an explosive Riho/Sakazaki sequence erupting when Rose re-entered the fray, and while there were a couple of moderately sloppy moments, they nailed the layout and got over. That's what was most important.

Riho's win on Rose is a brave booking choice, too, but a more interesting one than Nyla just running through the smaller women. Let's see where she goes next.


3. An All-Star Spotfest

Cocaine.

That's what Laredo Kid and The Lucha Brothers vs. The Elite was, but who would've anticipated anything different?

This was six of the most cutting-edge wrestlers in the world operating at the state of the high-flying art, with risks, giffable moments, and high spots aplenty. That's all it ever needed to be. While there were storyline considerations with the Young Bucks and Lucha Bros still feuding over the AAA Tag Team Championships, a slow-burning psychological epic wouldn't have fit the bill at all, though the supreme level of choreography and cohesion meant the contest was anything but mindless.

It was great seeing Kenny Omega and the Bucks doing their thing again after such a low absence, and Laredo Kid looked like a million dollars too. His highlight spots left the bout feeling like ALL IN's breathtaking main event, with Kid playing the Bandido role, walking out a much, much bigger name than when he was announced as Fenix and Pentagon's mystery partner. If AEW sign Laredo Kid, they'll make a star of him. Guaranteed.

A thrilling climax concluded with Omega nailing the One Winged Angel on Kid, not long after Fenix had taken everyone else out of the match with a big dive to the outside. The biggest star in the match beat the smallest. Textbook booking, and the Spanish Flies, Superkick Parties, and double-team fluidity were, at times, astounding.


2. Moxley & Janela Bring The Pain

Fyter Fest's top two matches promised varying degrees of madness, and in Jon Moxley vs. Joey Janela, fans were treated to the barbaric, chaotic plunder brawl they'd expect from the 'Death Rider' and indie wrestling's foremost modern daredevil.

This was batsh*t.

While those who don't like hardcore wrestling probably got nothing from this bout, it was an outstanding execution of the stipulation. It was sick, violent, and felt like a real fight. Janela and Moxley justified the "non-sanctioned" stipulation after AEW had set the table by cutting the lights, signifying the "official end of the show," before bringing them back up for the violence party. Such stipulations don't always make sense (if the promotion don't want anything to do with it, why are they providing the arena and production?), but that was a nice touch regardless.

Moxley emerged to AEW's best entrance track: a slamming, stomping groove metal number that fits his character to a tee. He then fought like the song sounded. Tossing Janela into the crowd within minutes, he, like JR pointed out, "had a little bit of Terry Funk in him." As he walked-and-brawled, unleashed plunder, and lobbed the 'Bad Boy' through a barbed wire board, he felt like a man who'd rediscovered his truest form, and Janela was just as tremendous, more than living up to his reputation in this dangerous, dangerous battle.

Barbed wrire chairshots were exchanged. A Russian Leg Sweep from the apron drove both men through a table. Janela got dropped on some thumb tacks. Joey hit an elbow drop from a ladder, over the top rope, to the outside, and through a table. At one point, Moxley speared his opponent through another table at full propulsion. It was carnage, and it took a Paradigm Shift onto the tacks to finish it, setting us up for the closing angle...


1. Kenny Omega's Revenge

This had to happen, and it ruled. Kenny Omega and Jon Moxley's show-closing brawl absolutely ruled.

It began with the 'Best Bout Machine' setting upon Mox after his win over Joey Janela, much like the former Dean Ambrose had done at Double Or Nothing. The 'Death Rider' ate a piledriver through the table. With Daytona Beach at its loudest, Moxley took a double stomp with a chair atop him then got dragged up the ramp. Kenny set about him with the drumkit and guitar props, and while the referees tried to take Jon away, he ended up tossing them from the stage.

The man wanted a fight, and he took a beating for it. Omega struck with trashcan slots. Finally, poetically, he drilled him with his own Paradigm Shift finisher onto the plunder, pouring gallons of heat on their already molten All Out clash.

Moxley's response to this bludgeoning? A big, fat smile.

God bless that man, god bless AEW, and god bless pro-wrestling.


Watch Next


Channel Manager
Channel Manager

Andy has been with WhatCulture for 10 years and is currently WhatCulture's Wrestling Channel Manager. A writer, presenter, and editor with 10+ years of experience in online media, he has been a sponge for all wrestling knowledge since playing an old Royal Rumble 1992 VHS to ruin in his childhood. Having previously worked for Bleacher Report, Andy specialises in short and long-form writing, video presenting, voiceover acting, and editing, all characterised by expert wrestling knowledge and commentary. Andy is as much a fan of 1985 Jim Crockett Promotions as he is present-day AEW and WWE - just don't make him choose between the two.