13 WWE Title Contenders Who Never Stood A Chance

The unlikely grapplers who tried - and failed - to take titles off far superior, far more over, or just more appropriate champions.

There comes a point, for every fan of pro-wrestling, where you look through the match card of an upcoming pay-per-view event and frustratingly come to the conclusion you can pretty much guess the outcome of every bout. More often than not, the most predictable match is the one contested for the most prestigious title in the WWE €“ now the WWE World Heavyweight Championship, but formerly either the WWE or World Heavyweight Championship. Considering this match is usually the one that headlines the show, the predictability of a pay-per-view€™s major title match is what can make or break the show. Thinking back to that unforgettable Money In The Bank pay-per-view of 2011, what made the main event so captivating was that genuine sense of not knowing who would leave Chicago with the WWE Championship. In this event, CM Punk was booked as a genuine threat to John Cena. This article however, will take a look at those superstars who weren€™t viewed as favourably as Punk and had lost their championship match before even stepping in the squared circle.

13. R-Truth Against John Cena - Capitol Punishment 2011

Truth was one of many superstars in this article who suffered from being thrown into the title picture when the champion at the time was in a transitional phase. In this instance, the champion was, of course, John Cena and this won€™t be the last example of superman defeating one of our failed contenders. At the time Cena was about to engage in his summer programme with CM Punk, which would begin at Money In The Bank in 2011. His main event bout with Truth took place at the pay-per-view just before €“ Capitol Punishment. Truth was simply required to give Cena something to do prior to his feud with Punk. It wasn€™t just the timing of the match which doomed Truth, but the fact that until this point in his career he had only ever been booked at mid-card level.

12. Kane Against Daniel Bryan - Extreme Rules 2014

Although Kane has reached the peak of the profession and held major championships in the WWE on various occasions, he was very recently booked in a match that he never really had a chance of winning. Obviously it would be great if every title match was unpredictable, but the WWE also has a responsibility to safeguard the prestige of its major championships. To achieve this, the champion needs to go on a winning streak to add value to the title. When Daniel Bryan defeated Batista and Randy Orton to win the WWE World Heavyweight Championship at Wrestlemania, WWE€™s first aim was to solidify his status as champion. Kane was the superstar chosen to be Bryan€™s first victim at Extreme Rules a couple of months ago. Despite a well contested and quite entertaining match, Bryan unsurprisingly achieved his first title defence on pay-per-view.

11. John Morrison Against The Miz - Falls Count Anywhere Match (Jan 2011 RAW)

Former WWE superstar John Morrison has been inserted in and around the WWE Championship picture on a few occasions, but have we ever thought he could actually ever win it? In perhaps one of the most forgettable championship matches in the history of the WWE, Morrison took on, recently crowned champion, The Miz in a falls count anywhere match. There were many reasons why Morrison claiming the title simply wasn€™t going to happen. Firstly, The Miz had only recently won the championship and this match took place in the middle of a serious feud with Randy Orton. The match took place on Raw €“ where title changes are few and far between and the bout kicked off the show, making a Morrison win all the more unlikely. And those in the know would have realised that with Morrison awaiting surgery, him winning the title on this night was practically impossible.

10. Dolph Ziggler Against Sheamus - No Way Out 2012

If you ever need a superstar to throw into a major championship match when you don€™t know what to do €“ Dolph Ziggler is your man. Despite being a two-time World Heavyweight Champion, Ziggler has experienced many setbacks as a contender, often thrown into the title picture in a short-term programme to give the champion something to do. WWE were forced to do this in the least subtle way possible at No Way Out in 2012 when Ziggler was brought in to replace an injured Alberto Del Rio to face the World Heavyweight Champion Sheamus. The fact that Del Rio and Sheamus€™ feud was almost certain to continue once the Mexican aristocrat had recovered, meant that a Ziggler win was extremely unlikely. Not wanting to miss an opportunity to put the World Heavyweight Championship on the line, the WWE threw Ziggler into the match and gave Sheamus an unsurprising victory.

9. Bobby Lashley Against John Cena - Great American Bash 2007

Former WWE superstar Bobby Lashley was another superstar who fell victim to John Cena as champion. The leader of the Cenation was once again in the middle of a WWE Championship run and was scheduled to enter a summer programme with Randy Orton. So unfortunately for Lashley, he was thrown into the title picture at just the wrong time. Lashley was without doubt a superb athlete, who more than matched Cena physically. The WWE decided to put over how hard Lashley was to beat by having Cena FU him from the second rope during the match finish of their title match at The Great American Bash in 2007. He had also enjoyed a successful run as ECW Champion, prior to his draft to Raw, but perhaps lacked the charisma to be WWE Champion at that particular time. If not for his injury shortly after this pay-per-view, we perhaps may have seen him as champion at some stage.

8. Ryback Against CM Punk - Hell In A Cell 2012

Ryback€™s clash with CM Punk at Hell In A Cell in 2012 is one that many believe ended the wrecking ball€™s run in the WWE before it had properly begun. The WWE booked themselves into a corner in this match, making both superstars come off as weak. Ryback was selected to replace an injured John Cena to face Punk for the WWE Championship inside Hell in a Cell. The problem was €“ Punk was never going to lose the match because he was almost certain to face The Rock at the Royal Rumble in a couple of months€™ time and WWE didn€™t want to have Ryback defeated clean. So the creative team decided to have the referee screw Ryback and give Punk the cheap win. This was a flaw of Punk€™s run as champion in late 2012. With a clash with The Rock in January 2013 approaching, it was almost certain he would retain his title until that point.

7. The Great Khali Against Triple H - Summerslam 2008

After The Great Khali€™s highly unpopular run as World Heavyweight Champion in 2007, whenever he was once again inserted into the title picture it was always pretty obvious that he wouldn€™t be walking out with the gold. Perhaps the most obvious of these insertions was when he clashed with Triple H at Summerslam in 2008. With The Game in the middle of what was clearly going to be a lengthy run as WWE Champion, there was no way Khali would prove any obstacle. Of course, WWE did their best to convince fans that Khali could win the match with an early finisher and allowing him to control the majority of the match. But in a way this made it even clearer that Triple H would eventually launch a comeback, in a typical David and Goliath contest.

6. Cody Rhodes Against Randy Orton - RAW 2009

Cody Rhodes has always seemed to be on the cusp of something great, but he is still yet to capture WWE€™s top prize. Up until now, he hasn€™t been involved in the main event picture since his time with Randy Orton and Ted DiBiase as part of the group Legacy a few years ago. Around this time, his mentor Randy Orton was engaged in a feud with John Cena over the WWE Championship. As part of the storyline, Rhodes€™ father Dusty granted Cody a championship match against Orton, exercising his powers as Raw€™s guest host. With John Cena appointed as special guest referee for the bout, it was always obvious that the match would break down into chaos. Within minutes of the bell ringing, Rhodes and Orton abandoned the match to assault John Cena, causing a no-contest.

5. Ric Flair Against Edge - TLC Match - Raw 2006

I bet you€™re thinking €“ why on Earth are you including arguably the biggest superstar in the history of wrestling in a list of failed contenders? Well back in early 2006, Flair took on Edge for the WWE Championship in a tables, ladders and chairs match and despite WWE teasing that Flair might win when his fingertips brushed the title belt, it was never to be for the 16-time world champion. Once again, it is always advisable to be sceptical when a title defence occurs on Raw and with Edge set to defend his title against John Cena at the Royal Rumble, it was never going to be likely that Flair would defeat Edge so close to the pay-per-view.

4. Zack Ryder Against Sheamus - Night Of Champions 2010

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=QtP4bbql1BA It is very easily forgettable, but Zack Ryder was once involved in a WWE Championship match. In 2010, Sheamus was attempting to loophole around the policy of only having to defend his title every 30 days so he wouldn€™t have to compete in a championship match at Night Of Champions. To achieve this, he hand-picked Zack Ryder in the knowledge that he would be no physical match for him. The match was over within 11 seconds, after a single brogue kick. Ryder was simply placed in the match to advance Sheamus€™ character of being a champion who would keep hold of his title by any means necessary and a superstar who would bend any rules to succeed.

3. Wade Barrett Against John Cena - Bragging Rights 2010

In late 2010, Wade Barrett entered a short WWE Championship programme with Randy Orton. The feud was designed to advance Barrett€™s rivalry with John Cena, so claiming the title was extremely unlikely. Also, Barrett at the time had only just arrived on the scene as leader of Nexus and a world title reign was never on the cards. What made matters even more predictable was the fact that Cena had been appointed as special guest referee for their title match, making the likelihood of a chaotic match finish all the more likely. As it happened, the title match at Bragging Rights did finish controversially as Cena attacked Barrett to cause a disqualification.

2. Brian Kendrick - Championship Scramble - Unforgiven 2008

Despite never being involved in a one-on-one match for the WWE Championship, Brian Kendrick was entered into the title picture by being one of the five men in the championship scramble match which took place at Unforgiven in 2008. Maybe the WWE hoped that by putting €˜The€™ in front of his name fans would be convinced that the new Kendrick could actually win the WWE Championship. As expected though, it turned out that Kendrick was no more than someone to fill a space in the match Triple H successfully defended the title. Kendrick was briefly an interim champion during the match, but soon became the whipping boy that Triple H and Jeff Hardy would take turns pinning.

1. Jerry Lawler Against The Miz - Elimination Chamber 2011

In what still seems such a ludicrous decision looking back, Jerry Lawler was involved in a short programme with The Miz for the WWE Championship. A title which is supposed to be contested between the best superstars in the industry, was being fought over by a former reality TV host and a retired wrestler. Their feud culminated in a match at Elimination Chamber in 2011, where the winner would walk into Wrestlemania as WWE Champion. The Miz unsurprisingly came out on top but imagine if Lawler had been booked to win? The King headlining Wrestlemania in a title defence against John Cena. As hilarious as that would have been, it was never going to happen.

Contributor

Having recently graduated from university, I have joined WhatCulture as a contributor to cover sport, WWE, TV and film. Formerly published nationally in the Guardian and Independent.