15 Match Star Ratings For AEW All Out 2022

The MOTY, more than one dud, and extraordinary backstage drama: this was AEW in 2022 defined.

Jon Moxley CM Punk
AEW

AEW rode into Chicago amid much controversy and uncertainty.

The morale of a roster in crisis. A "new", Triple H-led WWE generating hugely impressive ratings as their own stagnated. The anniversary of last year's potentially transformative All Out PPV hanging over this year's, like a greying cloud, as something more of an opportunity wasted than a landmark occasion to celebrate.

On television, some of AEW's output was almost as intriguing as the sensational reports of onscreen burials, locker room blood feuds and panicked escapes into bathroom stalls. CM Punk and Jon Moxley told a bold, experimental story that was nothing if not fascinating. The Trios Title tournament was a deft blend of compelling storytelling and jaw-dropping action. On Wednesdays, anyway; Rampage continues to the least interesting thing in the company, which is saying something, since it tries to do a million things at once.

The usual complaints echoed across the week, which is worrying, since AEW is meant to listen to them. 15 matches is far too many. The women received barely any attention in the build. All of this shooting, while entertaining, simply can't be good.

Quite clearly, very little was resolved...

15. Zero Hour: Sammy Guevara & Tay Melo Vs. Ortiz & Ruby Soho

Ruby Soho Sammy Guevara
AEW

The plight of Ruby Soho underscores the year AEW has had with its ridiculously overstuffed roster.

At All Out 2021, she was one of the new faces leading every division to a golden age. At All Out 2022, almost a nonentity, she worked a match that very few people needed to see. The announcement of a second match in the least compelling chapter of the JAS Vs. BCC saga on Rampage was mystifying enough. Did this warrant a trilogy? Did the rubber match warrant being added to what was already a 14 match card?!

If Tony Khan is accommodating too many matches on his PPVs in fear of upsetting his roster, it might be a better idea to simply not nod along as CM Punk's aims a f*cking flamethrower in their direction.

This match is even harder to care about now than it was at the time, but as easy as it was to resent - 15 matches man - it was just as easy to pop for its empty, excessive calories. Sammy Guevara assisted a Tay Conti Canadian destroyer on Ortiz at one point in a very fun if inessential get-your-sh*t-in affair. It was a mad spot in a match that the talent did give a sh*t about.

God bless Ortiz, but that look needs to be abandoned. There's trying to stand out more, and there's...whatever that is.

Star Rating: ★★¾


14. Zero Hour: HOOK Vs. Angelo Parker

HOOK All Out
AEW

Not to go on and on - the highest of praise is imminent - but HOOK is yet another character in AEW's expanding universe that has stagnated. He's in no better position than he was when he debuted, and it's disappointing; he's so over and talented that if there were a clearer path to true stardom, he'd likely have travelled it.

This was fun - the build and the match itself was amusing and cathartic undercard fare - but wasn't it better when HOOK was a real killer?

There's an incredible amount of time for him to develop, but still. It feels like a wasted opportunity to really strap the rocket to somebody who deserved it in rapid order. HOOK was so striking because his act was thrillingly new and unique. It is very familiar now.

Angelo screaming "Where's the bad man?" before getting blasted with a headbutt was great, but this followed another familiar routine: prelim comedy heel chats sh*t then gets banged to diminishing returns.

Star Rating: ★★¾


13. Zero Hour: PAC Vs. Kip Sabian

PAC Kip Sabian
AEW

There's a twinge of guilt here, because the man has put a lot of effort into it, but this new Kip Sabian character isn't terribly convincing.

Aspects of this reinvention from d*ckweed heart-throb to unhinged comic book villain almost work. He stomped the sh*t out of PAC in the corner early. That was good. And then he did this strange bit where he invited the audience to cheer, and boo, then cheer, then boo, like some "conductor of chaos". He tried (probably) to convey that he didn't care what they thought - underrated/over it - but it was powerfully lame. It was so obviously a man trying to play a character, and he isn't remotely helped by the fact that AEW in general feels all too real at this point.

Insofar as the action goes, this was strong. It was a PAC match, for starters, and Sabian is a fine athlete who knows his way around the modern hybrid style. This master manipulator character work however is just not "it". PAC looked more like an idiot for running into a low bridge than Sabian appeared intelligent.

If he's a sort of Batman baddie composite, it's closer to Leto than Ledger.

Star Rating: ★★¾


12. Zero Hour: Eddie Kingston Vs. Tomohiro Ishii

Eddie Kingston
AEW

This is more f*cking like it.

A guaranteed great match, this was a guaranteed great match. They subverted the collar-and-elbow tie-up in such a cool, characterful way. It was almost timid, like their hearts weren't in it. They weren't there to determine the better wrestler; they were there to determine who could best withstand the fight.

They articulated this via chop battle, using their marvellous faces to convey the agony and defiance alike. The rhythm was intoxicating and commanded a standing ovation. At first, they took it in turns, allowing a pause. Then Ishii started to respond immediately. Then Kingston revved his up to generate more power. Ishii still returned immediately to establish that he wouldn't even absorb the hardest shot. Kingston looked despondent, but would not bend. Still Ishii cracked him right back, denying the spirit now. He was relentless, indefatigable - until with an almighty roar, Kingston chopped him off his feet. They told a tremendous story with literally one move: the spirit is always stronger than the body.

After an awesome series of bombs, Ishii simply stopped selling. His spirit was burning. The finish was outstanding; after a signature incredible no-sell spot - Ishii absorbed the Uriken and replied with an immediate headbutt - Kingston paid tribute to Genichiro Tenryu by pinning Ishii with the Northen Lights bomb.

The series is tied 1-1, and since Eddie didn't win with his own finish - it was bantered off, in fact - there's scope for a rubber match now.

Star Rating: ★★★★¼


11. Casino Ladder Match

The Devil MJF
AEW

The Casino Ladder match is a fundamentally flawed concept, and this should be the last we see of it.

There is no drama whatsoever before the Joker arrives. The match will never end before that moment. Not to be the worst kind of old school wrestling head grifter, but f*cking hell: if you're going to encourage talent to take outrageously risky bumps, make it make sense. The action, while it lasted, was electrifying - in that modern turn-taking way that requires rather a lot of generosity from the audience. Dante Martin was on unbelievable form spring-boarding from the top rope to climb for the opportunity. Claudio Castagnoli displayed his supernatural strength. Andrade took a sickening (awesome) Canadian destroyer bump on a suspended ladder.

Very little of this mattered in the end because the big angle, while intriguing, made no sense. In this context, anyway.

At one early point in the match, Andrade and Rush had a clear run at the poker chip. They had almost a full minute - with their opponents either incapacitated or waiting in the wings - to just...climb the ladder. What if they did?

Wouldn't MJF et al. have looked like a right group of morons backstage?

Thinking about it - and AEW is ordinarily great because it encourages you to think - the big reveal angle literally only worked because wrestling is fake.

Star Rating: ★★½


10. The Elite Vs. Dark Order - Trios Title Match

Hangman Page Matt Jackson
AEW

This was the pro wrestling match of the year.

Quick reminder: this version of the star rating system, in an attempt to appreciate wrestling in all of its diverse forms and get away from the idea that the maximum score should be reserved for lengthy main event epics, measures matches against the standards of their respective genre. This was one of the greatest trios matches of all time.

20 minutes of relentless, blistering, exhilarating, non-stop action, the level of drama was absolutely intoxicating. The sheer stamina, positioning, timing, athleticism and creativity required to pull it off was astonishing. The momentum didn't so much ping-pong; the back-and-forth was so competitive and well thought-out that it felt more like a vibration. The amount of drama wasn't just driven by a layout so expert that even the Bucks outdid themselves; by rarely speaking to the press and only providing updates indicating that he was irreparably broken, Kenny Omega spent a good nine months building the euphoria of his coming back 100%.

Recapping it is pointless: this was a breakneck 20 minute exchange of awesome moves so intoxicating that it led to two of the most convincing, heart-stopping near-falls in recent memory. Hell, of all-time; John Silver's small package One-Winged Angel reversal and Page's BTE trigger kick-out were so unreal that they managed to locate the sweetest possible spot: that magic nanosecond before the crowd thought the referee must've f*cked it.

Also: the leg-clutch spot was subverted in another incredible thread of the saga (pictured).

At the finish, continuing the glorious Elite saga, Omega quickly covered Silver after Page inadvertently struck him with the Buckshot - a tell that Page will ultimately emerge from the story the better man with the more powerful finish.

Star Rating: ★★★★★


9. Jade Cargill Vs. Athena - TBS Title Match

Jade Cargill
AEW

A good version of an attraction that has ran its course, Jade Cargill's streak is such a non-concern at this point. As is Athena, Jesus Christ and what a shame. The result was something of a giveaway.

Why did Tony even sign her to a deal?

When she debuted, she did so in a convoluted, over-thought angle in opposition to Jade and Stokely Hathaway. By the time the blow-off happened a quarter of a year later, she had wrestled just four TV matches, didn't appear on the go-home Dynamite, and Stokely was on his second stable.

In a match reeking of obligation, Athena proved she was worth so much more; she worked brilliantly around Cargill, using her poise and agility to slip out of a counter attempt and launch herself seamlessly into a pop-up fallaway slam. Showing fire, she kipped back up before eating a spear. She trimmed the fat of the typical Jade match - a spectacle that too often gets lost in itself - and did much to get Jade over as unbeatable killer without undermining her own aura.

It's a miracle and a credit to her that she still just about has one.

Star Rating: ★★¾


8. FTR & Wardlow Vs. Jay Lethal & Motor City Machine Guns

Wardlow Jay Lethal
AEW

This was very good, but the Elite are so phenomenal at what they do that an exhausted crowd only received about an hour of what followed politely.

The exchanges between the Motor City Machine Guns and FTR were incredible, but also a little bit sad. They worked so hard and so well together, but the vibe was more "They should just do a tag at a different time" than "This is awesome". Cash Wheeler, one of the most acclaimed wrestlers of the year, still wrestled with something to prove. He doesn't receive the same plaudits nor opportunities as Dax Harwood, so it was rewarding to watch him form the emotional crux of the match. He toiled mostly in vain.

At least one match is always going to be affected on a card as stacked as this. The fans, knowing this was an excuse to get FTR on the card in a match devoid of stakes, chose this one for a rest.

Remember All Petite Wrestling? Wardlow killing both Sabin and Shelley at once was a cool reminder that this company just gets the hoss destroyer role, but ultimately, this was as good as it was unnecessary: a ****1/2 TV match on a Wednesday, a slight imposition on a weekend.

Star Rating: ★★★½


7. Ricky Starks Vs. Powerhouse Hobbs

Powerhouse Hobbs Ricky Starks
AEW

When there are two very long-running grudge programmes on a premium quarterly PPV - and both Must Continue - this indicates a problem, yet again, with the mammoth and unworkable roster Tony Khan has assembled.

With so much to get through, it's possible that Khan sensed the big babyface triumphs couldn't resonate, and didn't go through with either. Bryan Alvarez tends to know an injury when he sees one, as a former/part-time wrestler. He called Becky Lynch facing months on the shelf before anyone, and suspected that Christian Cage had suffered a bicep injury. So there is that - but if you can't blow-off one of two blood feuds when fans have paid money, that's a problem.

This match was very good for what it was, and aimed to tell the story that Ricky Starks was too vengeful and heroic to take the match when he was truly ready. There simply wasn't enough time to adequately tell the story.

Powerhouse Hobbs got his beautiful Spinebuster over as a shocking kill-shot, so there's that, but this was an angle on pay-per-view elevated by the gruesome viciousness of Hobbs' work.

Star Rating: ★★★


6. Swerve In Our Glory Vs. The Acclaimed - Tag Team Title Match

Anthony Bowens
AEW

This will scan as eye-rolling mark-out sh*t, but Tony Khan actually deserves more credit than he does when operating at the peak of his powers. The most critically acclaimed North American promoter of the century is capable of outdoing himself.

He did here.

The storyline that built this match was poor, just to undermine that statement, but nobody thought this was going to be much of anything.

A fun showcase filler defence to stuff more names on the card to appease the roster.

An uninspiring and inessential replacement for FTR Vs. Young Bucks III.

Khan had the utmost faith in one of his favourite homegrown acts, and allocated them 22 minutes to grab their career-making moment. They did that to a frankly extraordinary extent.

A quick word on the defending champions: while the match was clearly laid out with advance knowledge that the Acclaimed are the more over act - and they played situational heel accordingly - there was still an excellent improvisational quality to their selfless performance. Anthony Bowens was the heart of what was the most improbably great match in AEW history. He terrified fans by selling what is a legit suspect knee in a masterful performance. Before his incredible comeback, he looked shoot hurt - and Swerve Strickland drop-kicked the sh*t out of it to drive the drama. Max Caster, known as the mouthpiece, performed a sensational, holy sh*t FU on Keith Lee. It was incredible, as was the entire match, which was nothing short of a career-making masterpiece. Dramatic, deafening, as modern as it was classical, the result was the only bum note.

Did anybody watching not beg for an audible?

Star Rating: ★★★★¾


5. Four-Way Women's Match For The Interim Women's Title

Britt Baker Shida
AEW

Lacking in crowd heat, the work was to a solid to very good standard.

The opening blitz of pinning combinations made for instant drama in a match helped by how unpredictable it was. In the end, strapping up Toni Storm was the correct choice. Tony Khan badly needed to back a new star in the division; when the likes of Ruby Soho, Kris Statlander and Athena faded into the background or were barely used, it was difficult to take the entire division seriously, much less anybody in it. Without being blow-away great, this was a brisk, action-heavy match that told the correct story twice over. Finally going in the Britt Baker Vs. Jamie Hayter direction allows Khan to add more focus to the scene, but where have we heard that?

It's time for Khan to actually do something now. This was good, and needed, but it can't be considered promising until Khan proves himself worthy of earning trust.

The sad part is that the work earned a reaction that was never forthcoming. The stigma is too powerful now.

Star Rating: ★★★


4. Jack Perry Vs. Christian Cage

Jungle Boy
Twitter, @boy_myth_legend

Another match-cum-angle, almost identical to Starks Vs. Hobbs only with the twist that was the full-blown Luchasaurus heel turn, it was performed well enough.

Jungle Boy took a wicked bump that convincingly wrote him out of the match, where Cage was on typically despicable heel form blowing a kiss at Jungle Boy's family as he executed the match-winning Killswitch, but come on. If he isn't injured, this thing has rumbled on since Double Or Nothing 2021. Moreover, the feud has lost much of its intrigue in recent weeks. The time to do it was now.

But there isn't anywhere near enough time for Tony Khan to do everything he wants to do.

Star Rating: ★★


3. Chris Jericho Vs. Bryan Danielson

Chris Jericho All Out
AEW

This was weird in a way that, using the flawed metric that is live reactions on Twitter, everybody struggled to articulate.

The live crowd struggled to really click with it too, despite a smattering of very cool ideas. Again, it's weird. The story was simple enough to follow: Chris Jericho was insistent on simply wrestling, realised late in the game that he was inferior, and ultimately gave in to his dark carny heart with a low-blow. And yet, this suffered from a lack of cohesion somehow.

One such cool idea saw Danielson brush off a series of thudding Jericho chops as if one drop of perspiration had appeared on his chest. Jericho's Liontamer reversal from a top-rope Frankensteiner is always impressive. Danielson finding new ways to lock in the LeBell was another thread that just...missed.

So what was wrong with an otherwise good effort? Was the pacing too methodical deep into a long night? Were the submission transitions at times so sloppy that they were all but telegraphed? Did it feel more attritional in a real sense as opposed to fictional?

Sometimes, matches simply don't click. This just happened to be one of them, despite a few cracking individual moments.

Star Rating: ★★★¼


2. The House Of Black Vs. Sting, Darby Allin And Miro

Sting Malakai Black
AEW

Elements of the semi-main were fantastic, but it was slightly anticlimactic and a notch below both the trios standard and the Sting party match.

Miro refusing to tag in Darby and Sting, and instead electing to take on the entire heel unit alone, was a great storytelling choice. It was faithful to the continuity of his association with Darby and framed him as a complete badass. The interactions between Darby and Buddy Matthews were excellent, and while Sting shouldn't be expected to perform a crazy aerial in every PPV match, that expectation has been established. The match didn't do quite enough elsewhere to get around a development that, sadly, is necessary.

He's still so great at the spaces between that his body language generated the loudest reaction of the match. He ate several strikes and continued to cinch in the scorpion death lock before Darby's unbeatable lopé allowed him to mist Malakai Black.

The visual wasn't enormously impressive, truthfully, and what scanned as Malakai Black's goodbye meant this was not remotely the Sting party jolt of electricity that worked to such awesome effect at Double Or Nothing.

Star Rating: ★★★¼


1. Jon Moxley Vs. CM Punk - AEW World Title Match

Moxley CM Punk
AEW

The first three minutes of this match were scintillating.

CM Punk, high on the rush of an adoring hometown crowd, took the fight to Jon Moxley and subverted the unification squash match by drilling him with the GTS. The execution was perfect, which informed the heart-stopping near-fall perfectly. What a false finish this was.

Mox during the subsequent heat sequence literally drank Punk's blood, because he's the best. It really feels as though, had this match taken place literally anywhere else, Punk would have been booed out of the building.

The tone both men created in the spaces between moves was exquisite. In one small masterful detail in a thoughtful war, a claret-drenched Punk, on his knees, slapped Mox in defiance when he was told to bring it. He couldn't even stand back up, he was pissing that much plasma, but he was never not in the fight. His selling was immense throughout, and Mox pulled off, yet again, the most difficult job in wrestling by performing as the hardest and most daunting player in the game.

In a theme that continued long into the night, in shocking fashion, Punk's defiance was threaded throughout the match. Trapped in the figure-four leg lock, he flipped the bird directly in Mox's face. He also gouged his eye out in a spot intended to put Mox over. He wasn't above cheating; he had to cheat to stand a chance. In a glorious spot, Mox reversed Punk's elbow drop and seamlessly countered with the bulldog choke in just one of several fantastic, suspenseful submission sequences.

Bonus point: Mox deprived us of Punk's sh*tty elbow drop.

The atmosphere was incredible: proper main event stuff in a company that has failed to engineer it during the last match on a marathon PPV half the time. That is an enormous credit to both men.

The duelling chants gave way to an insistent swell of "CM Punk!" chants. The noise was rabid, not remotely performative. The people who wanted Punk to win - and amazingly, in Chicago, it was far from everyone - really wanted him to get it done.

And he did, following an incredible Death Rider near-fall, with a double GTS shot. In the aftermath, MJF returned, and despite putting in a near-unparalleled level of work to get his heat, Punk extinguished it in about 20 minutes during an incendiary press conference.

A bit empty-headed, no?

Star Rating: ★★★★½


 
Posted On: 
Contributor
Contributor

Michael Sidgwick (Creative Writing BA Hons) is an editor, writer and podcaster for WhatCulture Wrestling. With over a decade of experience in wrestling analysis, Michael was published in the influential UK institution that was Power Slam magazine, and specialises in providing insights into All Elite Wrestling - so much so that he wrote a book about the subject. You can order Becoming All Elite: The Rise Of AEW on Amazon. Possessing a deep knowledge also of WWE, WCW, ECW and New Japan Pro Wrestling, Michael’s work has been publicly praised by AEW World Champions Kenny Omega and MJF, and Undisputed WWE Champion Cody Rhodes. When he isn’t putting your finger on why things are the way they are in the endlessly fascinating world of professional wrestling, Michael wraps his own around a hand grinder to explore the world of specialty coffee. Follow Michael on X (formerly known as Twitter) @MSidgwick for more!