15 Worst Undertaker WWE PPV Matches Of All Time

The Dead Man has had some absolutely terrible matches over the years.

There's no denying the Undertaker's legacy. Mark Callaway has done everything asked of him in his twenty-five years in the WWE. The consummate pro, he has had to endure some pretty shabby treatment at the hands of the writing team and been given the task of wrestling some of the worst wrestlers to ever step in a WWE ring. That he did so willingly and without protest is a credit to The Undertaker's professionalism. There are many men of his stature who would have balked at having to not only wrestle, but also convincingly put over the likes of Giant Gonzalez, The Great Khali, Vladimir Kozlov and Mabel. Those matches are, invariably, not very good. Although 'Taker had had some bona fide classics over the years, he's also had some certifiable disasters. A lot of times it wasn't his fault: it was down to his lacklustre opponent, the restrictive nature of his gimmick or a silly stipulation. Sometimes, however, Undertaker is as much to blame for a match either not producing or completely falling apart as anyone else. Whether it's because he's injured, uninterested or simply not on his game, The Undertaker is not, despite his legendary status, the perfect wrestler. Even a superstar with the respect level of The Undertaker can have a shocker. Here are his 15 worst, seen by millions across the world on PPV.

15. Vs. Mark Henry - Unforgiven 2007

The Undertaker was on an incredible role in 2007, winning the Royal Rumble and having some exceptional matches with Batista. Unfortunately for 'Taker, he suffered a torn bicep tendon in May which necessitated surgery and a few months on the bench. In order to write Undertaker (who was World Heavyweight Champion) out of the storylines, he was attacked by Mark Henry after his narrow steel cage match victory over Batista on the May 7th Smackdown, allowing Money in the Bank holder Edge to cash in and become the new champ. The Dead Man was fit to return to action by the September Unforgiven PPV. Naturally, he was pitted agains the man who 'took him out' months prior. The whole PPV was built around The Undertaker's return and grudge match against Henry. When the highlight of the match is the entrance, you know you're in trouble. Despite receiving the lion's share of the hype, the bout was the worst on the show and one of 'Taker's worst PPV offerings ever. To be fair to him, he was just coming back off major surgery, but if he or WWE had any doubts about his ability to perform, it should never have hyped up his return and placed him in the last spot on the car. Slow, boring and plodding. A classic this was not.

14. Vs. Luther Reigns - No Way Out 2005

Yes, somebody in WWE thought it would be a good idea to give Luther Reigns a PPV match with The Undetaker. Considering how clueless the jacked-up former Horshu was, it should come as no surprise that this is one of 'Taker's worst PPV matches ever. WWE were at least semi-serious about pushing Reigns in late 2004/early 2005, pairing him up with Kurt Angle and having him wrestle in high-profile tag matches on Smackdown. He was also tested against Eddie Guerrero in the opener of No Mercy 2004 (although, by having to wrestle the bland Reigns in the PPV opener, it was really Guerrero's nerves being tested). But a PPV match against 'Taker? That's a real test. If you can hang with the locker room leader in a PPV setting, you earn a great deal of respect. It was a test that Reigns clearly failed, as he was out of his depth and 'Taker was clearly apathetic. It was such an obvious case of 'we don't have anything better for Undertaker, stick him with Reigns and see what happens'. 'Taker allowed Reigns to look competitive before putting him out of his (and the audience's) misery with a Tombstone. This was Reigns' last PPV appearance before he was released in May.

13. Vs. Big Show & A-Train - WrestleMania XIX

As much as WWE hype up The Undertaker's WrestleMania winning streak, it's worth mentioning that a sizeable portion of those matches (particularly his earlier ones) were just awful. Most of that was down to the limitations of the zombie-like original Undertaker gimmick. At WrestleMania XIX, he had no excuse. Without the restrictive character, 'Taker had managed to have thoroughly entertaining matches with Triple H at WrestleMania X-Seven and Ric Flair at X8. There would be no threepeat at XIX, however, as 'Taker had a God-awful match with the gruesome twosome of Big Show and A-Train. The match was originally supposed to be a tag match, or course, with The American Badass teaming with Nathan Jones. When management realised just how utterly inept (and legitimately dangerous) Jones was, they removed him from the match on the day of the show and had 'Taker go it alone. It was the worst match on the card, and by some distance. It just dragged on and on, its ten minute length being at least three too long. 'Taker was clearly having more fun during his Limp Bizkit entrance.

12. Vs. JBL - SummerSlam 2004

Whenever JBL is commentating on an Undertaker match, he usually mentions something about their past 'wars' and how the two used to beat the tar out of each other 'back in the day'. The way the 'Wrestling God' talks about these matches, you'd think they were bona fide classics. In reality, nothing could be further from the truth. JBL and The Demon from Death Valley had a summer/autumn series in 2004, during JBL's notoriously long WWE Title reign. The majority of their matches were unbelievably boring affairs, the worst of which was their first PPV clash at SummerSlam. The match went down like a led balloon in front of the 'Bizarro World' (according to the announcers) Canadian crowd. Completely bored by the non-action that (wasn't) unfolding before them, they amused themselves with chants and a prolonged Mexican wave. Making matters worse, after their near twenty-minute snooze fest, the match ended with a cheap DQ. Things could have been even worse: an overzealous fan jumped on top of JBL's limo, almost collapsing a gimmicked portion of the roof, which would have completely ruined the post-match angle ('Taker chokeslammed JBL through the roof of the limo). Their 'Last Ride' rematch at No Mercy was another deathly dull encounter.

11. Vs. Sid - WrestleMania 13

Bret Hart versus Shawn Michaels was supposed to headline WrestleMania 13, but then HBK lost his smile and this was booked instead (thankfully Michaels was able to work through the pain of losing his smile and commentate on this monstrosity of a match). This was essentially fifteen minutes of rest holds, no-selling and not a lot else. It was certainly not worthy of main eventing the biggest show of the year but, then again, no match involving Sid would be. After some shenanigans with Bret Hart at ringside, Undertaker was able to get the win and mercifully end the match and become WWE Champion. The most interesting thing about this match is that Sid (allegedly) pooped himself during the finish. As if the match wasn't crap enough...

10. Vs. Kane - Buried Alive Match, Bragging Rights 2010

By the time 'Taker and Kane clashed in the autumn of 2010, their long-standing feud was about six years out-of-date. Did anyone want to see these two veterans have yet another series, after their programmes in 1998, 2000 and 2004? Was the star power really so lacking on Smackdown that WWE could present nothing better? The two men had three consecutive PPV matches in 2010. Their first, a No Holds Barred match at Night of Champions was bad but at least Kane's win provided a shocking moment. Their Hell in a Cell match, at one time a sort of dream match, was pitiful. Their Buried Alive match was quite possibly the worst of the year. The Buried Alive stip was as anachronistic as their feud and did nothing to help either man. 'Taker was really banged up at this point and shouldn't have been out there, even in a gimmick environment. The brawling was weak and the finish was another silly one: the Nexus got involved and helped bury The Undertaker (who sought no revenge upon his return). Was this really the same Undertaker who had one of the best matches of the year against Shawn Michaels at WrestleMania XXVI? In name, maybe, but not in spirit.

9. Vs. Yokozuna - Casket Match, Royal Rumble & Survivor Series 1994

The Undertaker has had the dubious honour of wrestling nearly every super heavyweight that has walked through WWE's doors since he debuted in 1991. A company man through and through, 'Taker has never complained about this and has always done his damnedest to make the best of a bad situation. Sometimes his best isn't good enough and he can only do so much. Such was the case during his awful programme with Yokozuna in 1994. They had two casket matches on major PPVs that year, neither one of which was any good. The first, at the Royal Rumble, had one of the most insulting WWE match finishes ever. After five minutes of a one-on-one match, a grand total of TEN heels came out to try and take Undertaker out. It took them another ten minutes to finally get him in the casket. Once inside, 'Taker cut a gibberish promo and then 'levitated' (actually Marty Jannetty attached to some clearly visible wires) to heaven. Seriously. Vince sold the whole thing like it was one of the deepest, most spiritual experiences he has ever had on commentary while the crowd looked on, completely dumbfounded. When 'Taker returned from the afterlife, he had to settle the score and beat Yoko in another casket match at Survivor Series, thanks to a little help from Chuck Norris. Seriously. WWE in 1994, everyone.

8. Vs. Kane - Judgment Day, 1998

The Kane/Undertaker conflict was played-out by 2010, but it was already wearing thin by late 1998. The two had been fighting one another for the best part of a year, having a seemingly never-ending series of matches. You'd think that after working with each other so many times, they'd be able to produce something at least moderately entertaining. You'd be wrong. Kane and 'Taker squared off in the main event of Judgment Day, with Steve Austin serving as the special guest referee. Austin was the best thing in the match by a mile, providing at least some entertainment when the storyline brothers couldn't. After liberal amounts of punches, chokes, chokes, rest holds and stalling, the usually lively Attitude Era crowd began growing restless. It was hard to blame them. After Austin and Paul Bearer inevitably got involved (it was predictable but at least provided some excitement), Austin wiped out both men and declared himself the winner. Only in the Attitude Era.

7. Vs. Big Boss Man - Hell In A Cell, WrestleMania XV

Seeing The Undertaker and Hell in a Cell next to each other, you'd think that the match would be at least half decent. After all, 'Taker has worked thrillers with the likes of Shawn Michaels, Mick Foley and Brock Lesnar inside Devil's Playground. At WrestleMania XV, Undertaker had one of his worst ever encounters inside the Cell. A lot of people are quick to talk about how glorious the Attitude Era was and, while there was a lot of good stuff from that period, there was a lot of dross, too. The Boss Man was a perfectly adequate lower-to-mid-card worker by spring 1999 but placing him in such a high-profile match against The Undertaker was a mistake. The match was so bad that they WWE even bother including it on the three-disc Hell in a Cell compilation DVD. Nobody would miss it. Equally as bad as (if not worse than) the completely naff 'action' was the post-match angle in which the Ministry 'hanged' Boss Man from the ceiling of the arena. The worst HIAC match ever, this one deserved all the 'boring' chants it received on the night and more.

6. Brothers Of Destruction Vs. KroniK - Unforgiven 2001

The Undertaker apparently spent a good portion of the Invasion storyline declaring to anyone who would listen that the guys coming over from ECW and WCW 'didn't know how to work'. His damning appraisal essentially ended the WWE careers of guys like DDP and Mike Awesome before they even got started. Two guys Undertaker did want to work with were his friends from back in the day, Brian Adams and Bryan Clarke, known in WCW as KroniK. Unfortunately for the Dead Man (and his partner Kane), he would soon find out that those two were about fifty times worse than a Mike Awesome or a DDP ever could be. The Brothers of Destruction and KroniK had a legendarily bad match at Unforgiven 2001. American Badass 'Taker was all pumped up in his pre-match interview and looked like he was really ready to go out and put on the performance of his lifetime. Sadly, the match completely fell apart, despite the WWE duo's best efforts to keep it together. There were so many botched or otherwise awkward moments and moves in this match. 'Taker was noticeably furious afterwards and reportedly chewed out the WCW men for their poor performance backstage. After KroniK were told they were being shipped to developmental, Clarke quit the company in protest. Adams only lasted a couple of months before being sent packing. Nobody, least of all 'Taker, were sad to see them go.

5. Vs. The Dudley Boys - Concrete Crypt Match, Great American Bash 2004

The 2004 Great American Bash was one of the worst PPVs in WWE history. Full of bizarre booking decisions and house show calibre matches, it was crying out for a great main event to save it. With the handicap Concrete Crypt match headlining, that had no chance of happening. The Concrete Crypt match was a one-time deal. Primarily used as a way to write Paul Bearer out of the storylines, it had no business closing the show. Bearer was placed in a box at the top of the entrance way. If Undertaker lost the match, Bearer the casing would be filled with cement. Undertaker won, yet still pulled the lever and buried his manager in concrete after a mysterious lightning bolt struck the cement truck. Dumb, dumb, dumb. WWE did make a point to let viewers know that nobody was actually murdered during the PPV (they used a mixture of pre-recorded footage and a stunt double for the live event). What a relief. As well as being one of the stupidest matches ever, the action also wasn't very good. Undertaker defeated the then-Tag Team Champions far too easily and, although Bubba was game, the match lacked energy.

4. Vs. The Big Show - Punjabi Prison Match, Great American Bash 2006

WWE originally advertised The Undertaker versus The Great Khali in a Punjabi Prison match, which makes sense since it was apparently Khali's 'speciality' and the two were engaged in a feud. When medical tests showed that Khali had 'elevated liver enzymes' and would not be able to compete, they drafted in ECW's Big Show as a replacement. Did the swap make the match quality any better? Of course not. The novelty of the Punjabi Prison gimmick soon wore off when it became readily apparent that neither Show nor Undertaker had any idea what to do with it. This was twenty minutes of two big guys just wandering around, occasionally hitting each other and then wandering around some more. It didn't help that Show was completely knackered at this point and badly needed a vacation. The match did have one highlight, though: 'Taker delivered a massive superplex on Show, eliciting a 'holy s***' chant from an audience that were starving for some real action.

3. Vs. Mabel - King Of The Ring 1995

One a list of 'worst WWE PPVs ever', King of the Ring 1995 must rank pretty high. The matches were universally awful and the booking unfathomable. This was the King of the Ring that WWE actually booked Mabel to win. On his way to the final, he rolled through The Undertaker in a rotten match. The Dead Man probably wasn't too thrilled about having to work with the future Viscera again at In Your House: Season's Beatings, since the big man shattered his orbital bone due to being reckless and sloppy in the ring. This necessitated 'Taker's wearing a Phantom of the Opera style mask during matches upon his return. Mabel would, of course, become a member of Undertaker's Ministry of Darkness in 1999. Hey, better to work with him than against him!

2. Vs. Giant Gonzalez - WrestleMania IX & SummerSlam 1993

The Undertaker's had to deal with a lot of stiffs in his time, guys he's essentially had to work around, but out of all of them, Giant Gonzalez is the absolute worst. If you think the Great Khali is/was bad, go back and watch some Gonzalez matches. He makes the Punjabi Playboy look like Bret Hart by comparison. What can you say about Gonzalez and The Undertaker's WrestleMania match? Out of The Phenom's 23 'Mania outings, it is the worst. Gonzalez just wasn't cut out for wrestling and looked ridiculous in that airbrushed body suit. WWE clearly didn't learn from their mistakes and booked the match again for SummerSlam. The SummerSlam match was a 'Rest in Peace match' (essentially a No DQ match) which really didn't require the stips. 'Taker got beat up a lot (it's not like they could do high spots out there) while Gonzalez wandered around and looked like he generally didn't know what he was doing before Paul Bearer transferred the power of the urn (honestly) to The Undertaker, who made a superhuman comeback and sent the giant packing.

1. Vs. Fake Undertaker - SummerSlam 1994

As stupid as the Concrete Crypt and Punjabi Prison matches were, they pale in comparison to The Undertaker wrestling, erm, himself at SummerSlam 1994. After the Royal Rumble 1994 shambles, Ted DiBiaise introduced a fake Undertaker (Brian Lee), who wrestled for the Million Dollar Man's money. Paul Bearer got involved and said that he had made contact with the real Undertaker, leading to a battle of the Undertaker's match at SummerSlam. The two men were distinguished by their different coloured gloves and the fact they didn't really look that similar to each other. The whole angle was stupid and the match was a washout. It could have been a cool spectacle, but Lee was not a good enough worker to carry his end of the workload. The two men moved in slow-motion and no-sold each other's offense, making the whole thing rather pointless (why even have the match if you're not going to sell anything?). The real Undertaker naturally won the match and then placed the imposter in the casket to end this silly charade.

Contributor
Contributor

Student of film. Former professional wrestler. Supporter of Newcastle United. Don't cry for me, I'm already dead...