19 Ups & 4 Downs From NJPW G1 Climax 2019

Kota Ibushi is going to Wrestle Kingdom; KENTA and Shibata shock the world.

Kota Ibushi G1
NJPW

The 29th G1 Climax tournament is finally over.

After 19 shows spread forgivingly over 37 days, New Japan Pro Wrestling's signature heavyweight tournament concluded with Kota Ibushi punching his Wrestle Kingdom 14 main event ticket, having felled IWGP Heavyweight Champion Kazuchika Okada to take A Block, then 'Switchblade' Jay White in the finals. A stunning victory, and one that will yield an awesome Tokyo Dome headliner should he and the 'Rainmaker' make it to 4/5 January unscathed.

The competition yielded countless highlights. Brought in by Katsuyori Shibara before the G1, KENTA blew NJPW apart with an awesome angle on finals night, having accumulated a modest eight tournament points. Jon Moxley emerged as a violent, unhinged, credible threat to anyone in the company. Entering as junior heavyweights, Shingo Takagi and Will Ospreay toiled but grew throughout. Lance Archer is suddenly the best big man in wrestling. Tomohiro Ishii once again reminded everyone that is, at minimum, one of the three best wrestlers in the world. Tetsuya Naito, still NJPW's hottest star, was ultimately undone by a disastrous 0-2 start. The list goes on.

Unpacking such a monolithic tournament is tricky. Within, you'll find day-by-day breakdowns as well as every big-picture talking point from a G1 Climax that yielded over 60 hours of wrestling.

Let's do this...


Downs...

4. A Man Out Of Place

Bad Luck Fale
NJPW

The G1 Climax is no place for Bad Luck Fale anymore.

He has never been anything other than a basic wrestler, but Bullet Club's 'Rogue General' could always be helped to a decent bout by a super worker like Kazuchika Okada or Hiroshi Tanahashi. Not anymore. At 37 years old the New Zealander is more limited than ever before and no longer carryable. Increasingly reliant on interference from Jado and other stablemates, his 2019 performances didn't hit the mark. Size doesn't matter when you can't keep up.

Moreover, Fale has been made redundant by the surging Lance Archer. Taller, scarier, more athletic, hungrier, and consistent, he, not the former 'Underboss,' should be installed as the G1 big man who can best any top-tier talent on his day. His night three trouncing of Fale should go down as a torch-passing match in that regard.


3. Is That You, Hideo? (Night 9)

Kazuchika Okada KENTA
NJPW

Night nine peaked with its first match. A great execution of the David vs. Goliath format, it saw swaggering monster Lance Archer but the absolute p*ss out of opponent Kota Ibushi, who sold, and sold, and sold, finding out the hardy way that little of his own impactful offence was any use against the former Killer Elite Squad man. This helped inform one of the tournament's most badass moments as Archer absorbed Ibushi's first Kamigoye. That move is supposed to be a silver bullet; that it took two to put the main mountain away ensured he looked incredible in defeat.

The show's biggest issues came during a sssslooooowwww three-match closing stretch, with EVIL besting Zack Sabre Jr., SANADA continuing to be a lot less interesting than he should be against Hiroshi Tanahashi, and a main event that took 15 minutes to come to life.

It wasn't KENTA wrestling Kazuchika Okada in those opening stages, but Hideo Itami. The NOAH legend looked pedestrian despite bludgeoning 'The Rainmaker' with impossibly stiff kicks. While he showed a few flurries of adrenaline and looked domineering, the lack of fire was evident. Busting out a few Katsuyori Shibata spots isn't enough.

The third act brought considerable improvement as KENTA heated up and Okada switched into his usual match-ending gear, though it was a struggle to get there.


2. This Ain't It, Jeff (Night 8)

Jay White Jeff Cobb
NJPW

Jeff Cobb performs like a wrestler hell-bent on being nothing more than the least interesting version of himself.

At this best, the Hawaiian's superhuman strength and athleticism combine to create a dynamic, bombastic performer closer to something from the Marvel Cinematic Universe than a conventional wrestling big man. Cobb, in full flight, is a sight to behold. His myriad impressive throws, slams, and suplexes belie his affable exterior, and he can be a force of nature when he chooses to be.

The trouble is that he doesn't do it enough. Cobb is too willing to coast through a rudimentary execution of the NJPW style, showing only flashes of the superhero within. There's little to Jeff Cobb, Half-Hearted Grappler: he's plodding rather than methodical, exhibitionary instead of urgent, and night eight's stodge-fest versus Jay White best encapsulates that. The half-speed 37-year-old's meanderings combined with Jay White's heel shtick to create one of the G1's least engrossing matches.

Tetsuya Naito vs. Tomohiro Ishii and Jon Moxley vs. Shingo Takagi raised the bar before and after, but Taichi vs. Hirooki Goto was equally dull.


1. As Dry As Prohibition (Night 4)

Juice Robinson Hirooki Goto
NJPW

The G1's fourth night was, by most promotion's standards, a decent little show, but "decent little shows" aren't enough when it comes to wrestling's biggest tournament and long, long portions weren't exactly riveting viewing.

Shingo Takagi vs. Toru Yano was every Yano match you've ever seen, so your mileage will have varied depending on whether or not you enjoy CHAOS' DVD-flogging banter merchant. Hirooki Goto and Juice Robinson got hot towards the end but the bout's first two acts dragged. Elsewhere, we got a fun clash of styles in Jeff Cobb vs Jon Moxley (though it was too short to really get going), Taichi's tedious gubbins in the main event, and an awesome sh*tbird heel vs. grizzled, fired-up babyface slugger pitting Jay White against Tomohiro Ishii, which almost single-handled dragged night four towards the Ups. Almost.

Shows of this calibre are part of what can make the G1 such a grind. They're fine, but there's too much great wrestling out there to make the time investment worthwhile.


Ups...

19. Old Friends Collide (Night 11)

Zack Sabre Jr Will Ospreay
NJPW

Will Ospreay and Zack Sabre Jr. could probably do this in their sleep, so strong is their chemistry. Though ZSJ is more experienced than his rival, their careers have effectively run parallel over the last few years and, after facing each other loads of times throughout the past decade, it took them to this year's G1 Climax, where they entered one of their finest singles bouts yet.

Sabre's formula is so impeccable that you could probably book him against Kevin Kelly and it'd yield at least a ***1/2 match at this point. Here, he cranked, yanked, and twisted Ospreay's dodgy neck as if it were an unruly weed stuck between two paving slabs in his garden. Will was tremendous, too, eschewing the melodrama that still occasionally blights his work for a more realistic defensive performance, ultimately falling in 20 minutes.

Unlikely tournament standout Lance Archer looked awesome against Kazuchika Okada afterwards, while Hiroshi Tanahashi and EVIL over-delivered in the main event. The rest of the card didn't hit. Footage of KENTA vs. SANADA may be prescribed as an insomnia remedy going forward.


18. Best In The World? (Night 12)

Tomohiro Ishii Hirooki Goto
NJPW

Tomohiro Ishii should always be involved in the "Best in the World" conversation, particularly at this time of year. Hidden in undercard tags for much of the calendar, he comes alive in the G1 Climax, delivering standout match after standout match every single night, even when working with the promotion's jesters. His fighting spirit and selling are incomparable, he's an underdog par excellence, and while he'll probably never be IWGP Heavyweight Champion, few wrestlers are more reliable in a big spot.

On night 12, Big Match Tommy continued his hot streak with a firecracker against the underwhelming Hirooki Goto. While not quite on the same level as last year's violent classic, it was another no-bullsh*t chest-slapper rife with stiff strikes, hard-nosed attitude, and complete and utter disrespect.

Toru Yano and Jon Moxley's boy-popper ended with Mox taking his first tournament loss when Yano taped him to Shota Umino on the outside, preventing him from answering the 20-count. Jay White vs. Taichi was a wet fart and Tetsuya Naito vs. Juice Robinson underwhelmed, but another lead-taking Shingo Takagi performance elevated the card, as 'The Dragon' helped Jeff Cobb to one of his better matches.


17. A Gentler Schedule

Jay White Hirooki Goto
NJPW

The G1 Climax's grind can be brutal.

While no other tournament provides such a high volume of outstanding matches, that's part of the problem. Watching 5+ shows of breathless action a week is exhausting. Its excess often necessitates a wrestling vacation once it's done, no matter how great the highs.

This year's schedule was met with great relief. NJPW stretched the tournament out, going seven days between the first show in the United States and second in Japan, before settling into a groove that rarely exceeded 3-4 weekly shows. Tired fans were regularly granted two days to ready themselves for the next event. Burnout was alleviated.

From the performer's standpoint, the increased rest time meant less wear and tear, allowing them to work harder far deeper into the tournament. Yes, most of them were almost certainly working hurt by the end, but this is a tough sport and a tough competition. Anything done to ease that should be celebrated.


16. Dragonslayer (Night 14)

Tetsuya Naito Shingo Takagi
NJPW

Tetsuya Naito will not taste a more hard-fought victory than that which he won against stablemate Shingo Takagi on night 14.

Bouts like this are why the G1 is so revered. More than a mere exhibition match, it played on the duo's years of history, stretching all the way back to their time training together in Animal Hamaguchi's gym back in 2004/2005. Positioned as a spoiler ready to end the Los Ingobernables de Japon's tournament prospects and a man running out of opportunities to prove he could make it as a heavyweight, Shingo, at his pal's behest, brought more thunder than he had in any other match up to that point, and though he lost, LIJ's 'Dragon' came out looking like a million dolllars.

Tomohiro Ishii vs. Toru Yano aside (strong style Yano is back, baby), the rest of the show wasn't up to scratch. Hirooki Goto vs. Jeff Cobb fit perfectly on both men's line of best fit for the tournament and Taichi vs. Juice Robinson was very Taichi. Jay White vs. Jon Moxley was fine, and Mox was protected in defeat, but not quite the compelling character battle it could have been.


15. In Which Jon Moxley Proves He's The Best (Night 2)

Taichi Jon Moxley
NJPW

You wanna know why Jon Moxley is the king of wrestling? He had a great match with Taichi.

The Suzuki-gun jester can be carried when he plays it relatively straight and keeps the Sports Entertainment-style shenanigans to a minimum. That's what happened here, with the 'Holy Emperor' attacking Mox as he made his entrance through the crowd. Cracking the former Dean Ambrose's back with a steel chair provided a smart, simple story to build the work around, p*ssing Mox off and bringing out his hard-brawling best as he put the potential banana skin in just under eight minutes.

Moxley vs. Taichi wasn't match of the night, though: that honour goes to Tomohiro Ishii and Jeff Cobb, whose hard-hitting beef-slapper hit all the right notes. This is the time of year when everybody suddenly sits up and realises that the former is one of the best in the world, and while it felt like the duo still had another gear to reach, this was by design.

The opener saw Shingo Takagi learn that this heavyweight business is a lot harder than bullying juniors around as Juice Robinson bested him in a bruiser encounter. Later, Toru Yano bantered Tetsuya Naito into oblivion by pulling his t-shirt over his head for a shock pin, while Hirooki Goto brought his A-game in a vicious humbling of Jay White in the main event.


Channel Manager
Channel Manager

Andy has been with WhatCulture for 10 years and is currently WhatCulture's Wrestling Channel Manager. A writer, presenter, and editor with 10+ years of experience in online media, he has been a sponge for all wrestling knowledge since playing an old Royal Rumble 1992 VHS to ruin in his childhood. Having previously worked for Bleacher Report, Andy specialises in short and long-form writing, video presenting, voiceover acting, and editing, all characterised by expert wrestling knowledge and commentary. Andy is as much a fan of 1985 Jim Crockett Promotions as he is present-day AEW and WWE - just don't make him choose between the two.