2 Ups & 5 Downs From AEW Dark (Jan 14)
Shawn Spears cops an eyeful of Billy's Gunn on this dud episode of Dark.
That the cover image for this week's AEW Dark review is a gif of Shawn Spears staring at Billy Gunn's whapper tells you all you need to know about the show. Sure, it was a fun spot, but one fun spot should never be the most newsworthy thing to emerge from a wrestling show.
Last night's card promised Austin and Billy Gun vs. Spears and Peter Avalon, a continuation of Shanna's feud with Nyla Rose as they met one-on-one, Darby Allin warming up for PAC in a bout with Brandon Cutler, plus AEW's Tribute to Legends of Memphis Wrestling, with the Rock 'N' Roll Express, Lawlers, Gilberts, and many, many more all represented. Not exactly the most stacked lineup, but one that suggested a better show than what was served.
Overanalysing Dark is pointless because it is becoming increasingly obvious that this is a filmed house show, despite being presented as a vital platform for midcard talents when launched. Much of it isn't to be taken seriously, particularly on episodes with no marquee matches (a la Kenny Omega vs. Joey Janela) and no Undesirable to Undeniable feature, but that doesn't mean it shouldn't be criticised. AEW is putting these shows out on their YouTube channel, after all.
Let's break it down...
Downs...
5. Stodgy Brawl Undermines A Solid Story
Whoever booked this week's Dark came up with a solid idea by having Shanna attack Nyla Rose on the ramp, preventing their match from actually happening. It added a nice slice of variety to the show and Shanna had a bone to pick, having been driven through a table by the 'Native Beast' before Christmas, establishing their feud.
The execution wasn't up to scratch, though. Perhaps it went over better in person, but the live crowd didn't sound into it, reacting to Nyla's vertebrae-rattling Spinebuster on the outside with a slight "ooh!" when it warranted a guttural "aaaaarRGHGGHgghwhatthehellareyoundoing?!". Worse was the Big E spot, with Shanna attempting to spear Rose through the ropes with a table on the outside. Again, a great idea, but Nyla held onto the top rope for a second too long, making for a clunky viewing experience.
The brawl continued backstage and while it's great to see AEW telling a non-title story in their women's division, this stuff just didn't feel convincing. Wrestling isn't much fun when you can see how the sausage gets made.
4. Boring Shhhhhhhhhh*t
It's been a while since Peter Avalon and Leva Bates have taken residence in this column's Downs section, such is their usage rate at the moment, though the tiresome duo were back in full effect last night, working the same, boring shhhhh shtick as before.
Yes, this gimmick is bad by design, but it's tedious to watch. So-bad-it's-good doesn't work without charm, and there's nothing charming about 'Pretty Peter' rattling off the same series of "this town" barbs before Leva grabs the stick and apologies for her partner - a character tick that, up to this point, has gone absolutely nowhere.
Maybe it'd be more palatable if this act drew significant heat, but alas. This writer would be hitting the mute button whenever the Librarians appeared if not for this column.
3. Gunn Club Cruise Past Spears & Avalon
Billy and Austin Gunn vs. Shawn Spears and Peter Avalon was an attempted banter match that suffered from pedestrian pacing, including the half-minute Spears spent staring at Billy's penis. Gunn didn't even connect when he attempted to biff 'The Chairman' with his appendage for the payoff, man. Poor show.
That Avalon and Spears lasted so long as another problem. Sure, Shawn was once a pushed commodity, but 'The Librarian' is a comedy jobber who should maybe get one or two of his heel spots in before dying. They went 11 minutes here. It should have been half that.
On a more positive note, Austin is an interesting prospect and a much better wrestler than his experience should allow (this was his 21st match). He moves around the ring like his father, has some charisma, and projects a believable cocksure attitude, and while he has rough edges, these will be ironed out with time. It'll be interesting to see how he fares in a proper bout.
2. Demolish This Act
It's time to rip everything about Shawn Spears and Tully Blanchard up and find something else for both to do, because their current situation is wretched.
Going down the undercard comedy route with Spears is fine, given how badly his 'Chairman' act flopped after the Cody bout, but not with Tully by his side. Blanchard needs to split. Why would Tully, a master strategist, put up with this sh*t in character? Why would he let his charge sit and get entranced by Billy's willy? Why would he allow Spears to slip into comedy geekdom in the first place? The guy's supposed to be a wrestling genius, yet he currently looks about as effective as a chocolate coffee pot.
Get Tully out of there and find something else for him to do. He was excellent in the build to the Cody match and still has boatloads to offer as a performer, so let's use him while he's still up for it. As for Spears, maybe there's something else in his locker... but we need to start seeing it.
1. Cutler Stumbles To Defeat
Brandon Cutler's AEW presentation is very, very weird. His entrance music is bad*ss and imposing, suggesting an absolute beast is about to stride out from the back whenever it hits, yet he's one of the skinniest guys on the roster. Then, he walks out with Kratos-adjacent facepaint and an awesome-looking dragon robe, suggesting he's a big deal, before he inevitably jobs out in a few minutes. It's a jarring disconnect between aesthetic and athlete.
Cutler partook in a disappointing opening clash against Darby Allin. "Disappointing" not because it came with high expectations, but because Darby's propulsive underdog performances have made him an early AEW highlight, yielding great bouts with the likes of Chris Jericho, Cody, and Jon Moxley. Here, the former EVOLVE standout wasn't permitted to show any of the skills that have seen him catch on with the crowd. It was a slow, unengaging plodder with only a few bursts of Darby's energy to light it up, and didn't come alive until Allin hit the Coffin Drop for the three-count.
It was also marred by a couple of awkward spots, with Cutler almost landing on his head off a poorly-aimed Moonsault Press minutes before hitting the sloppiest enzuigiri you'll see all year. Not good, unfortunately.
Ups...
2. Like Butter
Get your AEW Dark Ups & Downs bingo cards out and put an "X" beside "Murray Praises the Guest Commentator," brothers and sisters, because here we go.
An extension of Dark's Memphis tribute, Dave Brown and his butter-smooth voice joined Excalibur in the booth and was tremendous. Not only does the 73-year-old still sound like a million dollars but he put real effort into putting the action, characters, and storylines over when it would've been easy for him to coast. He put over the stakes of winning and losing more than most who've occupied the chair since AEW started rotating the commentators too, and even threw out a little Flex Kavana reference early on. Shout-outs to Dwayne.
Warm, welcoming, and bringing a totally difference cadence and energy to AEW's other announcers, Brown was a winner. Listening to him calling matches for an hour was a nostalgic joy.
1. A Fitting Tribute
Dark's Tribute to Legends of Memphis Wrestling was genuinely lovely stuff - and Dark was precisely the right spot for it. Put nostalgic tributes on your A-show and you risk backlash for taking TV time away from full-time wrestlers and their ongoing storylines. That's not so important on the B-show, especially on weeks like this, and AEW did a great job across the board.
Particularly heartening was Justin Roberts' running through who each person was and what they'd accomplished in the wrestling business, putting everything into context for younger viewers. It was a heartwarming trip through memory lane, the crowd were totally into it, and it's something that connects AEW to wider wrestling history. Here's hoping they do more of these when they pass through other territories.
Jimmy Valiant looks like he's still about that 'Boogie Woogie Man' life, the Rock 'N' Roll Express are still going strong in 2020, the Lance Russell shout-out was poignant, and it was lovely seeing Kevin Lawler representing his late brother, Brian Christopher. Only a heartless individual could take umbrage with what went down here.