20 DUMB WWE Gimmick Changes (That We Didn't Want To Admit Were GENIUS)
These sudden WWE gimmick changes were ridiculously stupid. Or...were they?
Changing a wrestler's gimmick is always risky.
Classic examples of rip-roaring success include Steve Austin going from largely mute 'Ringmaster' to hell-raising 'Stone Cold' and Becky Lynch spurning happy-go-lucky vibes to become 'The Man'. Both of those switches led to massive career upturns, but it isn't always as simple to see the genius behind such change.
If wrestling fans are being honest, we're a fickle and impatient bunch. That often makes it difficult to stomach changes, or appreciate why WWE has decided to try them on in the first place. Such experimentation is something everyone should be grateful for though, because it has created some serious pro wrestling gold that wasn't fully-valued until later on.
Hindsight is a wonderful thing, eh? It filters out knee-jerk reactions (like the kind you'd see on social media) and enables one to see that sometimes WWE's creative types know best. Many of the gimmicks here were met with raised eyebrows and scoffing from fans, but they all had merit.
One stands out as unique too, because it caused a butterfly effect that created competition whilst bolstering the wrestler in question's resolve.
Dumb? Nah, genius!
20. The Boogeyman Comes To Get You (Forever!)
Imagine this: Someone pulls you aside in the summer of 2005 and says, 'Psst! The Boogeyman will be one of WWE's most enduring characters!'. You'd have laughed right in their stupid face. How could Marty Wright's cartoonish horror nonsense endure? Well, it has.
That imaginary person from '05 was bang on.
Nobody could've predicted that such an overtly silly character as this would become one of WWE's go to cameo bookings for a generation. Boogey hasn't appeared for a few years now, granted, but we're coming up to the 20 year mark since he debuted his worm-eating ploy to bag a company contract.
That's remarkable for something so one-note. It's almost impossible to name a handful of Boogeyman matches, and yet he'll likely show up again here or there in the future whenever creative needs something easy to get a nostalgia pop. Who the hell saw this wrestlecrap-worthy gimmick hanging around so long?!
19. R-Truth Is A Friendly Idiot
In 2011, R-Truth started yakking on about a mysterious imaginary pal of his own: "Little Jimmy". No, Jim didn't say anything about The Boogeyman's legacy, but he did become an invisible tool Truth could use to power his promos. The whole thing was so curiously entertaining that the guy even bagged a main event match with John Cena.
Fast forward to 2024 and R-Truth has cranked up the 'resident idiot' dial to charm fans with some legitimately funny backstage skits. His work opposite Judgment Day, for example, almost caused Damian Priest and Finn Bálor to corpse on multiple occasions, and the laughter coming from crowds was genuine.
This is the funniest Truth has ever been, which is almost certainly something nobody saw coming for the guy a full decade (at least) after his prime. Ron Killings just works as a friendly, well-meaning moron, and the fact he even survived the dreary 24/7 Title days says it all.
In Truth we trust.
18. Sad Baron Corbin Is Sad
There is a section of the wrestling fanbase that will never like Baron Corbin. Fair enough, but even the man's harshest critics must admit that he put his all into that 'King' Corbin to "Bum Ass" Corbin (Pat McAfee's words) change in 2021. Almost overnight, Corbs went from annoying royal stalwart to someone down on his luck.
Baron lost his crown and spiralled into a funk. It should've sucked hard, but Corbin dedicated himself to the role and made it work by living the gimmick. He wore the same shirt over and over again, stopped shaving his head and even grew an unkempt beard. The dude got some fun out of his switch, at least.
Sure, Happy Corbin on the other end was lame, but the sad era was gold looking back. The experiment even threatened to turn Baron into a sympathetic babyface before WWE went full-blown villain with the Happy run instead.
Dumb? Sure. Genius way to move on from the 'King' gimmick? You bet.
17. “Hi, I’m Dolph Ziggler!”
Current TNA man Nic(k) Nemeth's face must've been a picture when WWE's writers laid out their latest plan for him in 2008. 'So, you've been a golf caddy for a racist gimmick and a cheerleader who was humiliated. Now, you'll be someone who shakes hands backstage and introduces himself!'.
MONEY.
Seriously, even the name Dolph Ziggler was ridiculed on various internet forums at the time. It sounded so silly, and the way Dolph tried getting friendly with various workers behind the curtain was tiresome after just a handful of promos. Then, something special happened.
Ziggler volleyed the paper-thin handshaking gimmick into orbit and showed what he was capable of in-ring. Comparisons were made to everyone from Curt Hennig to Shawn Michaels, and Dolph went on to enjoy a WWE run that lasted right up until 2023. In hindsight, as stupid as it seemed, going from Nicky of The Spirit Squad to slicked-back rookie Ziggler gave him a platform to show off his skills.
16. Al Snow Gives The World "Head"
Many gimmicks from the vaunted 'Attitude Era' seemed like they'd been crafted by a teenage boy playing WWE 2K24's Universe Mode. Take Al Snow; he was a walking punchline who carried a mannequin head that was named after a certain sexual act. Yep, that was it. That was the entire purpose of the "Head" gimmick.
It got over huge. Everybody wanted "Head".
In fairness, Al started this journey in ECW, but that demotion (and it was considered a demotion at the time) proved to be a blessing for the ex-Leif Cassidy. He'd been going nowhere on the WWF main roster, so jetting off to Paul Heyman land for a while worked wonders for his own self-confidence and enabled Snow to get creative.
Al Snow and "Head" was the perfect blend of goofy, sophomoric fun and 'Attitude' raunch people expected back in the late-1990s. Few back then cared to acknowledge it was a genius move from Al to 'learn another hold' outside the WWF bubble, but it definitely was.
15. 'Dirty' Dominik Mysterio Goes To Jail
Poor little Dom Dom gets hacked to bits on social media.
Fire up your favourite timeline, punch in his name and you're sure to see comments criticising WWE for nepotism and/or Dominik Mysterio himself for daring to have a legendary father. Those cries intensified when Dom and Rey formed a tag-team on TV - people were really rough on Mysterio Jr Jr.
Then, WWE handed Dominik a reprieve. He turned heel on dad, and broke out of Rey's shadow by pretending to be a jailbird who lived the life of a hardened (albeit falsely imprisoned) criminal behind bars. Immediately, Dom had something to hang his hat on in promos, but creative wasn't done yet.
'Dirty' Dominik assumed a significant role in the revamped post-Edge version of Judgment Day, and hasn't looked back since. Yes, the jail time stuff might've been hokey and unbelievable, but it did turn Dom into more than just Rey's gangly kid.
14. Right To Censor Trashes Raunchy Gimmicks
The wrestling community hasn't been kind to RTC since it vanished from screens. A lot of that hate seems to be aimed at the knowingly-dreadful entrance theme they used, but...it was supposed to be annoying. Then, there are those p*ssed off that the WWF curtailed popular gimmicks like The Godfather or Val Venis.
Again, that was done on purpose. You were supposed to be angry that the pimp and porn star characters vanished in favour of hoity toity buttoned up types who were more likely to preach against past transgressions than revel in them.
Right To Censor was a quite excellent send up of the real-life Parents Television Council putting heat on the company for risqué content. It even gave going-nowhere midcarders like Stevie Richards, Bull Buchanan and Ivory some purpose they badly needed if they were going to survive on the roster.
This writer will gladly die on the 'RTC doesn't get enough love for how brutally heel it was' hill.
13. Happy Rusev Day
Say hello to a silly catchphrase that was likely meant to last for a few weeks at most.
After beating Randy Orton in 2017, Rusev declared every day "Rusev Day" and began aggressively barking that at fans. This routine heel move played before gentle boos for a while, but then people started enjoying the Bulgarian's OTT presentation. It was something totally fresh for him, and that mattered to fans.
WWE cut the legs off the idea instead of running with it. Being more specific, Vince McMahon didn't like that "Rusev Day" was playing before cheers and trashed the gimmick rather than continuing to make cold hard cash aplenty from merch for as long as possible. That was dumber than Rusev, Lana and Aiden English going overboard by inventing fake holidays could ever hope to be.
Attend any WWE show between 2017-2018 and you'd likely see a "Rusev Day" t-shirt in the crowd. The catchphrase was over as heck for a year or so before McMahon buried it. It's wild that something so silly clicked then got binned because it was never meant to gain traction.
12. Heath Slater “Got Kids”!
What a trip 2016 was.
WWE brought the brand split back, and Heath Slater teamed with Rhyno to become the least-likely tag-team success in years. Their entire act revolved around Slater moaning that he had to win to feed his kids back home. Oh, Rhyno also adored squeezy cheese from a tube too, for some reason.
Heath would passionately put forward his babyface case in promos as the ex-ECW original munched cheese on crackers and stared down the lens. It was so odd, but people gobbled the twin everyman gimmick up and turned the Slater/Rhyno combo into oddball SmackDown Tag Champs.
The genius here was that Slater, in particular, had been struggling since the Nexus days. 3MB, The Social Outcasts and more weighed him down rather than lifting him up. Who could've known that something so simple as providing for his off-screen children and taking a kicking from Brock Lesnar for trying to do so would get him so over?
11. Chad Gable Wants You To “Shoosh”
'Shorty G' was an abomination of an idea that shouldn't have left WWE creative meetings. Ripping the p*ss out of Chad Gable for being eh...roughly the same height as most workers poking fun at his size was a frankly rubbish concept. People were glad to see the back of it.
WWE's next ploy for Chad was to have him head up the heelish Alpha Academy and form a tag-team with Otis. The pair were played for laughs initially - Gable obnoxiously yelled "SHOOSH PLEASE!" at everyone. Folks figured this would burn out and fade away after a few months of on/off TV time.
Not quite.
The "SHOOSH!" thing randomly caught on, and the Academy has grown to add members like Maxxine and Akira Tozawa. Incredibly, Chad also went from going nowhere in a hurry heel to gritty underdog babyface who some would prefer to see wrestle GUNTHER at WrestleMania 40 over Sami Zayn. That's a staggering upturn for Gable's career, all things considered.
10. The Hurricane Is Coming Through
This shouldn't have worked, especially mid-Invasion angle.
Talented Cruiserweight and WCW man Shane Helms turned into a bogus superhero called The Hurricane in 2001. Keep in mind this happened whilst the WCW/ECW Alliance storyline was still the WWF's focus, so Hurricane should've Hurri-tanked in a flash. He didn't though. Not even close.
This writer recalls wrestling magazines chastising the company for slapping a green light on Helms' switch at the time. The Hurricane was lumped in with dire WCW > WWF transformations like DDP becoming a stalker. Somehow, Helms was so damn good at the role that he turned it into a niche instead of a noose.
The Hurricane was one of the most-loved midcarders on the entire roster by 2002. Shane's creativity and energetic 'all or nothing' approach to the gimmick manifested memorable moments vs. The Rock and other top liners. Few, if anyone, had that on their predictions list when he was teaming with Lance Storm in the Alliance.
9. Too Cool Defy The Odds
Vince Russo's original idea for Too Cool was to create an anti-Hardy Boys act that'd be totally uncool. The then-WWF writer enlisted Scott Taylor and Brian Christopher, tweaked their pre-existing Too Much name and BOOM! Scotty 2 Hotty and Grandmaster Sexay were thrust into the world kicking and screaming.
Look at those names! Hotty and Sexay should've been booed out of the building, but fans loved the bucket hats, goofy goggles and ridiculous dance moves. People were even more into Too Cool when the thong-wearing Rikishi was added to the lineup. Together, Too Cool enjoyed their 15 minutes of fame as a red hot babyface gimmick through much of 2000.
That was an accidental byproduct of Russo's change up. Nobody was complaining. Too Cool seemed destined for the 'X Horrible WWE Gimmick Changes' list treatment for decades to come, but no - it's fondly recalled as one of the best gimmicks of the time.
Also, the group had not one but two banging themes.
8. Sami Zayn Is A Conspiracy Theorist
Cherished workhorse Sami Zayn laid foundations for his 2021 conspiracy theorist gimmick long before WWE pulled the trigger on it. He brought up the company's treatment of him when managing Shinsuke Nakamura and Cesaro in 2019, but didn't go full-blown conspiracy nut until he was on his own again.
Collectively, fans wondered if the character had legs, but Zayn knew he could make it work. Amazingly, and to his credit, he did. In fact, Sami showed off the kind of charisma that'd stand him in good stead years later when joining The Bloodline and eventually spinning out into an unlikely babyface singles run.
Droning on about how he was being held back by management helped sow seeds for that moment. Zayn's promos were so passionately produced that it was hard to take your eyes off of him, and he steadily built a groundswell of support on the midcard before skyrocketing up the card towards main events.
There was hidden genius to all that conspiracy stuff, y'know.
7. Stardust Changes Cody Rhodes
OK, so this one stands out as unique and some won't agree. That's fine, because it wasn’t genius in a deliberate sense. Playing the Stardust character for so long soured Cody Rhodes on WWE life, so much so that he requested his release in 2016 and went out into the big, bad world of wrestling solo.
A critically-acclaimed indy run followed, and AEW was born from that yearning for more. Cody has since returned to become a genuine WWE megastar. What a happy accident Stardust was looking back! That's what makes his story so standalone on the list; Rhodes agreed that playing a costumed riff on his brother's Goldust gimmick sucked long-term.
However, it was accidentally genius because it pushed him to become more.
Would Cody have become the confident main-eventer he is in 2024 without those unwanted trials and tribulations? It's up for debate. He seemed destined to be a career midcarder before Stardust pushed him to seek change. Accidental genius is still genius.
6. JBL Ditches The Beer-Drinking
In 2004, yours truly thought he was clever by telling friends that new SmackDown heel JBL was a "Million Dollar Bore" instead of a 'Million Dollar Man' like Ted DiBiase. Yeah, that's one of those smart-arsed moments every fan knows all too well. Sometimes, it's fun to look back and realise you were wrong.
JBL was a sensational upgrade for Bradshaw.
It was unwanted at the time though, chiefly because his APA tag with Faarooq had been so over with live crowds. You knew what you were getting with the beer-drinking, card-playing guns for hire, which made it difficult to accept that the ride was over. WWE put its full might behind JBL's DiBiase-meets-J.R Ewing from Dallas character.
Bradshaw wasn't a popular choice to become one of SmackDown's focal points in 2004, but it was the right call in retrospect. He was perfect for the role, and successfully transitioned from midcard to main events without pause.
5. Damien Mizdow
Playing a hammy stunt double defo would've tanked in the wrong hands, but Damian Sandow needed something light and fun following his failure as the ‘Intellectual Saviour Of The Masses’. Rather than get the petted lip and bemoan his Money In The Bank flop, Sandow embraced the chance to become The Miz's stand in.
How he and Miz kept a straight face is beyond everyone, because Damian was superb here. He'd wear toy replicas of Miz's titles, take bumps at ringside when his leading man was working matches, and generally did everything in his power to get fans onside and show WWE he was a team player.
It ruled, but it seemed like a naff concept when Mizdow first popped up. That name alone sounded crap and didn't make much sense. Shouldn't he have been called The Miz too? Nope. Damian Mizdow played on the old Sandow name well, and the dude turned the gimmick into something more than it deserved to be.
What a guy.
4. The Undertaker Is A...Biker?!
It's easy to roll with the punches and downplay what risks The Undertaker was taking in 2000 when he morphed from satanic undead overlord into a tobacco-chewing biker in 2000. That was a risk 'The Deadman' was willing to take, 'cause he realised change was needed even if everyone else was blind to that necessity.
'Taker has since lifted the lid on this monumental switch by telling fans on YouTube that countless people behind the scenes told him he should scrap plans and revert to type backstage at Judgment Day 2000. Becoming the 'American Badass' would humanise his character too much, everyone reasoned.
He was having none of it and ploughed ahead anyway.
Humanising The Undertaker actually helped prolong his run, especially during an era that was less-reliant on supernatural shenanigans or cartoonish flair. 'Taker also knew he could always return to his roots eventually, which was a Mensa-level bit of foresight from someone willing to take the plunge most wouldn't.
3. ‘King’ Bookah!
The buffoonish ‘King’ gimmick has been a creative noose for so many workers not-named Jerry Lawler or Randy Savage, but Booker T stands proudly as someone who made it click. Think about the failures here. There's some great talent: Harley Race, Haku, Sheamus and Wade Barrett all come to mind.
'King' Bookah and his beautiful 'Queen' Sharmell were different. They hurled themselves into a delusional royal world and delivered performances so over-the-top it was impossible to cast your gaze elsewhere. The way Booker went from respected worker to despotic royal ruler after winning the 2006 King Of The Ring tournament was stunning.
Not just any old worker could've pulled that off the way he did.
Becoming 'King' breathed new life into Booker's WWE career because he was willing to clown himself at the right times. Like only the best workers can, Book also knew when to dial down the silliness and get intense mid-match. He remains one of the best to ever adopt a typically-unwanted gimmick.
2. John Cena = Vanilla Ice/Eminem
As legend has it, people heard John Cena rapping on a WWE tour and were impressed by how good he was. Then, one cosplay as Vanilla Ice during a SmackDown Halloween party later and Cena's destiny was locked in. He'd become pro wrestling's answer to bad boy rappers like Eminem.
Being honest, John's approach had a splash of Fred Durst in there too. He was a phoney hard man at times, but it saved Cena from the WWE chopping block (he apparently thought he was in line to be released) and let the guy show some actual potential. Overnight, he became more than a generic babyface in boots and tights.
Still, no-one realistically thought Cena had a chance of turning the rap game into something above midcard. It's astonishing then that JC went on to become WWE's poster boy for around a decade pre-Roman Reigns. Of course, he had to tone down the rap stuff to get there, but yes - that counts as an essential part of his growth.
Curious party trick to bonafide WWE headliner. What a rise.
1. Mick Foley Is Dude Love
Speaking of huge risks.
Few in WWE history took a bigger one than Mick Foley in 1997. He'd found fame as Cactus Jack elsewhere and Mankind after signing with the promotion, but Mick loved the thought of bringing his goofy teenage creation to flagship programming like Raw Is War. Thus, Dude Love was born.
Looking back now, this was quite the gamble. It could've backfired too, and theoretically killed off his more established Mankind character. How could fans ever accept Mankind again if the Dude bombed spectacularly? Foley didn't need to worry about that, because everyone accepted Mr. Love with open arms.
It was dumber than dumb in '97, but playing Dude Love actually let Mick showcase more of his naturally likeable personality behind the mask he'd been wearing on TV. That, in turn, evolved the Mankind gimmick into more than it arguably had any right to be.
Genius.
What other WWE gimmick changes were genius in retrospect? For more wrestling, check out WWE 2K24: 15 CAWs You Must Download Immediately and HORRIBLE Matches WWE Forced On Fans!