22 Injured AEW Stars (And When They're Set To Return)
Assessing the timelines for Killswitch, Adam Copeland, and the other suffering All Eliters.
All Elite Wrestling operates a schedule less mentally and physically gruelling than WWE, lacks the abundance of programming to accommodate sufficient television time for everyone from Jon Moxley to Ariya Daivari, and employs a roster chock-full of hungry athletes, many of which rely solely on AEW for their bookings, forgoing seeking external work even when Tony Khan has nothing for them.
So, why the extensive hospital bill?
Style.
Or, rather, lack thereof. AEW, as an authentic alternative to WWE's bold, brash, and boring sports entertainment slapstick, entertains the super-indierific work-rate style that caused the boom period on the North American independents. Collar-and-elbow lockups, body slams, and rest holds are replaced with Canadian Destroyers, grisly table bumps, and the odd unprotected folding steel chair to the cranium; naturally, this takes a toll on the body of those at the mercy of such spots.
Discharge the following exclusions before checking in AEW's wounded warriors. Samoa Joe, described during 2024's Blood and Guts Dynamite special as being out of action indefinitely, is injured in storyline so as to allow him to film Twisted Metal. Then, there's Ruby Soho and Tay Melo, both of whom are on either end of the maternity leave spectrum.
Expect Tay back soon - as well as...
22. Bandido
"Ready to go".
Those are the words, per WrestlePurists' Ibou, that exited Bandido's mouth while the uniquely masked grappler was backstage during the 23 October Dynamite. The ex-ROH World Champion hasn't wrestled since facing Konosuke Takeshita on 16 June, 2023, with a broken wrist that required two surgeries keeping him high on AEW's hospital waiting room list. Expect him back soon.
Returning: Imminently.
21. Leyla Hirsch
"Banged up, bruised, and battered."
That was how Leyla Hirsch described her condition following a remorseless Texas Death Match vs. Diamante at ROH's Death Before Dishonor. The bout was an eclectic modernistic take on the iconic stipulation, though 'Legit' Leyla was left looking like a Red Dead Redemption II character following a fisticuff in the local tavern post-match. A recent ROH on HonorClub broadcast saw Hirsch state that "everything was good" following her dislocated shoulder injury, so expect her back imminently.
Returning: Soon, hopefully.
20. Kiera Hogan
There's currently no word on the recovery of Kiera Hogan, AEW's 'Hottest Flame' having been pulled from an independent wrestling card with an unspecified shoulder injury. The Georgian, who was primarily a fixture on the AEW-owned Ring of Honor, last wrestled Ashley D'Amboise in a match aired 9 May.
Returning: Nobody knows.
19. Anthony Henry
Anthony Henry's case is an awkward one. The Workhorsemen's blue chipper was unceremoniously let go from AEW as part of the sudden 1 April batch of cuts while recuperating from a broken jaw, was said by Tony Khan not three days later that he'd be welcomed back, and resumed normal AEW/ROH duties when he was good to go.
Eh?
He's now sidelined with a torn bicep, and has been since the start of October. Per the ex-205 Live mainstay, Henry has recovered superhumanly, and should be good to go by year's end.
Returning: By 31 December.
18. Dalton Castle
AEW's 'Party Peacock' suffered what he described as a "freak accident" in a bout pre-recorded for transmission on the 13 July Collision, tearing his bicep in a loss to Roderick Strong. The incident, allegedly, wasn't Strong's fault, but, allegedly, the Backbreaker fetishist either failed to realise the gravitas of the situation or, simply, didn't care.
Castle, through his own projections, is nearing the end of his recovery timeline, so expect him back in action (and battering Roddy Strong) in due course.
Returning: In the next two to three months.
17. Ortiz
The behind-the-scenes dissolution of he and Mike Santana's friendship unofficially spelled the end for Ortiz's AEW career, who has wrestled just one match for the promotion in 2024.
Per the former Inner Circle man, he suffered a torn pectoral tendon in that match - which pitted he and Eddie Kingston against Bryan Danielson and Claudio Castagnoli - from throwing a simple Clothesline. He noted in April that he would be inactive for roughly four months and followed up in August, four months later, by saying he was at the finishing line recovery-wise. He's yet to resurface, though.
Returning: Unknown, but unlikely in AEW.
16. Skye Blue
Skye Blue, an AEW regular since April 2021, was enjoying a swift push pre-injury, the Chicagoan's brooding partnership with Julia Hart seeing her darker persona twice challenge for the TBS Championship in one calendar month.
A broken ankle was the diagnosis given to Blue following a 20 July Collision match vs. Hikaru Shida being called off. She's undergone surgery and seemed in good spirits when she was wheeled out for a hometown pop at All Out, so all signs point towards a speedy recovery. Thus...
Returning: Early 2025.
15. Julia Hart
2023 treated Julia Hart exponentially well, as a 20-match-plus winning streak propelled Hart to challenge for - and win - the TBS Championship, while, away from the sacred mat, she and long-time partner Lee Johnson tied the knot.
2024, though, has been less kind to House of Black's solitary female comrade. She's been sidelined with an undisclosed injury since dropping the aforementioned TBS title to Willow Nightingale at April's Dynasty, but she's fit and healthy. Her return lies solely at the feet of Tony Khan.
Returning: Whenever Tony Khan remembers she's employed.
14. Nick Comoroto
The resiliency of Nick Comoroto cannot be denied; 'Mr Freakbeast', an honest nickname, revealed that he underwent a hip resurfacing procedure in August because he was, quote, "wrestling on one leg for nearly two years".
...
He expects to return to competing on both legs by 2025, though an exact window wasn't provided.
Returning: 2025.
13. Matt Sydal
Matt Sydal, then under WWE employment as Evan Bourne, famously mangled his foot in a March 2012 motorcycle accident, breaking his foot in four places and dislocating it in a further five areas. Despite having performed regularly since then, the ex-WWE Tag Team Champion has been wrestling on borrowed time for twelve years, having finally undergone treatment in June to fix the damage.
Given the extent of the operation - Sydal's surgeon had to break three bones and fuse them back together in what sounds like a grisly procedure - there is no accurate timeline for when Matt Sydal will return.
Returning: Unknown.