25 WWE Champions Who Never Got Their Rematch
5. The Rock
Title Lost: WWE World Heavyweight Championship
Lost Title To: John Cena
It seemed pretty obvious regardless of injury that The Rock was not going to invoke his rematch clause after losing the WWE Championship at WrestleMania XXIX. With his loss to John Cena, Rocky’s two-and-a-half-month reign ended with two title defenses, only one successful.
The almost-comical part of this was Booker T coming out on Raw the night after Mania and telling the crowd that The Rock was still the #1 contender and entitled to a rematch against Cena, but he tore abdominal muscles and would not be able to compete. The crowd reacted as if this was a storyline excuse to write off The Rock since he wasn’t contractually obligated to appear.
It’s unclear whether Rock will lace up the boots again, but it’s highly doubtful that we’ll see him vie for the WWE World Heavyweight Championship again.
4. Hulk Hogan
Title Lost: WWF Championship
Lost Title To: Andre the Giant
This of course would be the classic The Main Event title switch that came with the help of an evil twin referee. Hulk Hogan’s four-year title reign would come to an end at the hands of Andre the Giant under those dubious circumstances. Andre in turn would only hold the title for a matter of minutes, as he would surrender the world title to Ted DiBiase.
The Million Dollar Man would actually “defend” the title at a few house shows before WWF President Jack Tunney stripped DiBiase of the belt and ruled that Andre could not forfeit the title and hand it over to another wrestler. But since the Giant had surrendered the title, he was no longer champ either.
This set up the infamous (and godawful) 14-man tournament at WrestleMania IV, which “Macho Man” Randy Savage won to launch his yearlong reign, which ended at the hands of – wait for it – Hulk Hogan. So while Hogan never got his rematch against Andre, he did get the championship back a year later.
3. Bret Hart
Title Lost: WWF Championship
Lost Title To: Shawn Michaels
Ah, the Montreal Screwjob. The backstory, match and aftermath is well-known to any fan who even remotely follows wrestling. Shawn, Earl and Vince screwed Bret out of the WWE title and sent him on his way to WCW in 1997.
Bret never wrestled for WWE again (the “matches” he competed in when he returned in 2010 simply shouldn’t and can’t count – he threw a few punches and kicks and slapped on a couple Sharpshooters), while Michaels would have his own unceremonious “end” to his WWE career (more of a long hiatus) just a few months later.
In hindsight, it’s a little surprising that Hart (and WCW) didn’t try to make hay out of the Screwjob and the fact Hart never got a title rematch. They could have pushed him as still the champ from “up north,” given him a belt and let him state his claim over and over. It would have been far better than the crappy angles we got for the next three years.
2. Shawn Michaels
Title Lost: WWF Championship
Lost Title To: Steve Austin
“Stone Cold! Stone Cold!... The Austin Era has begun!” Jim Ross was not using hyperbole when he yelled those words at the conclusion of WrestleMania XIV. Steve Austin had just beaten Shawn Michaels (who five months earlier had helped send Bret Hart packing without the WWF Championship), silencing Degeneration X and ending HBK’s in-ring career for more than four years.
In truth, Michaels had suffered a serious back injury two months earlier, which necessitated his retirement and forced him to forgo a rematch. Had that injury not taken place, the two probably would have feuded throughout 1998, with DX desperately trying to get Michaels’ title back and the Rattlesnake flipping them off at every turn.
By the time Michaels returned in 2002, Austin was on his way out, winding down his career. They both were on the card at WrestleMania XIX, but that was the closest they ever came to rekindling their rivalry from five years earlier.
1. Hulk Hogan
Title Lost: WWF Championship Lost Title To: Ultimate Warrior
This has to be one of the all-time head-scratchers in terms of leaving money on the table. Hulk Hogan vs. Ultimate Warrior at WrestleMania VI was one of the biggest matches of that era. The match pitted two of the most popular superstars in WWE at the time against each other, and their Mania bout was about as even as possible – Warrior only won by capitalizing on a mistake by Hogan. This could have easily headlined SummerSlam or drawn huge numbers for a Main Event program.
Instead, Warrior went on to feud with “Ravishing” Rick Rude and Mr. Perfect, while Hogan engaged in a battle with Earthquake. Keeping these two apart and not letting Hogan invoke a rematch, even months down the road, left fans asking “What if?” and WWE with a lost opportunity.
Sadly, fans had to wait eight years to get that rematch, and by that point, the magic was long gone and the feud had degenerated into two past-their-prime stars seemingly trying to out-crazy the other with promos. And let’s not even get into the match. It was a sad sequel to something so memorable.