3 Ups & 6 Downs From AEW Dark (Dec 10)

Seek Dark's awesome Big Swole interview out immediately.

AEW

AEW Dark isn't a show that warrants any kind of in-depth analysis and none of the show's flaws are ever worth losing one's mind over, though this week's offering brought a number of issues to the forefront.

This episode leaned heavily on recaps, with last week's Dynamite picked apart thoroughly. Tony Schiavone, Dasha Gonzalez, and Lexy Nair spent significant time on every major development with Cody and MJF, the Inner Circle, and, pleasantly, the still under-represented women's division. These were mostly fine and served as useful reminders of what's going on ahead of tonight's Dynamite, though some of Dark's segments raised questions about how AEW divide content between the A and B-shows.

As far as original stuff goes, we got a tremendous Big Swole interview/video package, Kenny Omega wrestling up-and-comer Kip Sabian in the main event, and two supporting matches in Jurassic Express' Luchasaurus and Marko Stunt vs. Alex Reynolds and John Silver, and Scorpio Sky vs. Jimmy Havoc vs. Peter Avalon.

A light, breezy watch as ever, though Dark's "essential" moments are starting to feel fewer and farther between. Yes, its key purpose is to supplement the flagship, but it could definitely use more some hooks of its own...


Downs...

6. Competition In Dominance's Place

Luchasaurus jobbers
AEW

Marko Stunt and Luchasaurus vs. John Silver and Alex Reynolds was a well-worked bout and it's always great to see the big man spotlighted (and Silver on AEW TV!), with Stunt mostly ineffective as the heels worked him over for the bulk of the match, leading to the Luchasaurus hot tag for the win.

Those parts of it were fine. The problem is that a tandem who have previously been booked as total jobbers looked too competitive against a team containing the beastly Luchasaurus, who should have ran through Silver and Reynolds in just a couple of minutes, with Stunt getting swatted early on.

If putting Luchasaurus over was the goal, then they may as well have accomplished this in the strongest possible manner, right?


5. Where Was This On Dynamite?

lexy nair
AEW

It was great to see AEW's new backstage correspondent Lexy Nair giving the women's division some serious shine on Dark last night, but why isn't this stuff going down on Dynamite as well? Why are AEW restricting it to a web series watched by a fraction of the A-show's audience?

Cody, in a recent interview with Dallas News, claimed that "to follow AEW, you've got to watch Dynamite. Dynamite's our only show. Everything else that exists outside of that is shoulder content."

So recapping and developing the women's division is "shoulder content"? Really?

Granted, viewers don't need Dynamite to become Recap Central, but what use is dedicating Dark time to building the women's division when they could be doing it on a more visible platform? One of the scene's biggest issues is a lack of character development. Something like Dark's tremendous Big Swole vignette would go a long way to addressing that, but it isn't deemed important enough to go down on TNT.


4. Where Was This On Dynamite? (Part 2)

MJF promo
AEW

Originally released as social media/YouTube content after last week's Dynamite, the promo in which MJF revealed that he hired The Butcher, The Blade, and The Bunny to attack Cody then named QT Marshall as his tag partner for the upcoming bout was replayed on last night's Dark.

We shan't waste time breaking down week-old content, but it's important to ask the same question as the previous slide: why wasn't this on Dynamite?

These were big, important storyline developments surrounding two of the roster's boldest personalities who are embroiled in a feud that could come to define AEW over the coming weeks, months, and years. It answered several questions and contextualised recent Cody-related developments, yet it's seen as internet-only content. A real shame.


3. To Push, Or Not To Push?

Kip Sabian Penelope ford
AEW

Not everyone can be pushed at once and AEW wrestlers will be made to wait their turn before their moment in the sun comes around, so it's understandable that the company aren't really doing a whole lot with Kip Sabian and Penelope Ford. Regardless, it's puzzling that AEW went out of their way to establish the real-life couple as A Thing, with Sabian taking Ford on as his manager, only to immediately take their foot off the gas.

A listless appearance in the Dynamite Dozen Battle Royal (for which the duo made their entrance during the commercial break) was the first we saw of them after their coming together. Then, on last night's Dark, Sabian faced Kenny Omega in a losing effort. There's no shame in that on paper, but shouldn't 'Superbad' be racking up a few wins, establishing his alliance with Ford, and building some momentum before he's going toe-to-toe with one of AEW's biggest stars?

This feels as stop/start as the average midcard WWE push.


2. Protect The Referees

Aubrey Edwards
AEW

Aubrey Edwards is a well-respected referee and a great performer, yet one that's frequently made to look dumb in where she should be assertive and authoritative.

We saw this with Kip Sabian vs. Kenny Omega last night. Penelope Ford interfered in the match multiple times, going as far as putting her hands on 'The Best Bout Machine,' with several incidents going down before Edwards' very eyes. What did the official do? Next to nothing. She pointed her finger and let the shenanigans continue under her watch, stretching the concept of "referee's discretion" to its limit.

AEW must start doing more to protect the referees and their credibility. They have very little authority when heels are allowed to get away with such blatant f*ckery, undermining their rules and the role they play in preserving them. Definitely something for the promotion to start working on immediately, because they hung Edwards out to dry here.


1. Real Sport(s Entertainment) Feel

Kenny Omega Kip Sabian
AEW

Kenny Omega vs. Kip Sabian was Dark's best match from a workrate perspective, with 'Superbad' good in his role as a decent, athletic heel, and his opponent as strong as one would expect, despite barely breaking out of third gear.

Fundamentally, it was sound, but like Jurassic Express vs. Alex Reynolds and John Silver, the layout was problematic.

This was a full-on Sports Entertainment interference-fest. Penelope Ford was all over the bout, imposing herself on it time and time again, and it got tiresome towards the end. There were far too many shortcuts and it didn't feel like they were generating sufficient heat to justify their frequency, leaving this viewer feeling hollow by the time Kenny secured the pin.

Cheating was always going to be Sabian's easiest avenue to victory, but there needs to be some restraint. Bouts like this don't feel right for this promotion. The "real sport feel" needs to be put over, even on the B-show, as this was way too overbooked to fit the remit.


Ups...

3. Friends Reunited

Excalibur Chuck Taylor Orange Cassidy
AEW

AEW continued the recent theme of having wrestlers step in for guest announcing slots on last night's Dark, with Excalibur reuniting with PWG buddy Chuck Taylor and Orange Cassidy for the opener.

This went well. Taylor was funny, calling Jimmy Havoc a "pervert" for stapling him in the crotch the other week, while Cassidy's role was perfect for his character. 'Freshly Squeezed' didn't utter a single word. The man's so lazy, in fact, that he didn't even bother to put his headset on, because why the hell would he?

Britt Baker came in for the Jurassic Express match and immediately felt a lot more comfortable than she did in her last guest commentary stint. She was positive, had decent energy, and played a complementary role by offering constructive criticism, putting the action over, and offering several snippets of Luchasaurus lore. A good job from her.


2. Sky Shines In Showcase

Scorpio Sky Peter Avalon
AEW

Scorpio Sky was very, very over as he faced off with Jimmy Havoc and Peter Avalon in the night's opener, which turned out to be the night's most effective match by getting everything it needed to over.

The SoCal Uncensored Man was looking for a rebound after losing to AEW World Champion Chris Jericho. Havoc and Avalon approached this the right way, teaming up to take Sky down early on, before 'The Librarian' double-crossed the Brit in an attempt at taking control. This ultimately backfired, because it's Peter Avalon, but while he brought a book into play and Havoc tried to introduce his signature staplegun, Sky ended up taking the victory after a TKO on 'Pretty Peter.'

Fun stuff all-round, with Sky showcasing plenty of personality and athleticism throughout. AEW still have something in him, even if his World Title-chasing days are over, and while this match would've looked well out of place on Dynamite, it was perfect for Dark.


1. Life Or Death

Big Swole
AEW

Comfortably the best thing on the entire show was the Big Swole feature, with the new signee getting over huge as a result of this extremely well-produced video package.

Engaging, charismatic, and infectious, she brought her "big personality and Swole mentality" early, before diving into her life's most traumatic phase. Her heart stopped beating in April 2008. She was brought back, but told she'd been diagnosed with Crohn's Disease and had just 30 minutes (!) to live, necessitating emergency surgery during which two feet of her intestines were removed.

Swole survived, obviously, but was told she'd never have kids or never be active again. She was broken down. This situation sent her "spiralling out of control," but she rebounded, got pregnant, gave birth to a daughter, and found her place in wrestling - highlighted by the heartwarming clip of Kenny Omega offering her a full AEW contract.

Words like "can't" shouldn't be in anyone's vocabulary, she said. It's hard to think of a more effective summary than that.

Bits like this show that there are personalities hiding within AEW's women's division: they just need an opportunity to stand out. Here's hoping that unlike the recent Shanna package, this one gets the full Dynamite treatment - her upcoming bout with Emi Sakura could use some extra juice.


Channel Manager
Channel Manager

Andy has been with WhatCulture for 10 years and is currently WhatCulture's Wrestling Channel Manager. A writer, presenter, and editor with 10+ years of experience in online media, he has been a sponge for all wrestling knowledge since playing an old Royal Rumble 1992 VHS to ruin in his childhood. Having previously worked for Bleacher Report, Andy specialises in short and long-form writing, video presenting, voiceover acting, and editing, all characterised by expert wrestling knowledge and commentary. Andy is as much a fan of 1985 Jim Crockett Promotions as he is present-day AEW and WWE - just don't make him choose between the two.