4 Ups & 3 Downs From Last Night's WWE SmackDown (Aug 22)

Debuts, returns, title defences: last night had them all.

WWE.com

With the dust from the second biggest show of the year still settling, WWE delivered a hectic episode of SmackDown last night. Only one match stretched longer than 8 minutes, almost all of the brand's major names featured, and the show bounced from one quickfire segment to another without ever coming up for air, but was it an effective SummerSlam follow-up?

Yes and no.

It wasn't a bad episode, and definitely a clear step forward from last week's shambles. The highs outnumbered the lows, but this certainly wasn't must-see television, though there were plenty of talking points.

Former NXT Champion Bobby Roode finally showed up on SmackDown, while Shelton Benjamin returned and seemingly formed a new tag team. Shinsuke Nakamura's feud with Jinder Mahal continued, as did Natalya's with Carmella, and, disappointingly, Kevin Owens' with Shane McMahon. Elsewhere, The Usos stamped their authority on the tag division, Lana vowed to make Tamina a champion, and some guy named Dolph Ziggler showed up.

A routine episode of SmackDown, but we'll take that any day of the week, given the brand's recent struggles. Lets look at what drove it forward, and what dragged it down...


Downs…

3. Inglorious Booking

Bobby Roode Aiden English
WWE.com

As good as it was to see Bobby Roode finally appear on the main roster, WWE totally botched his debut match with Aiden English. The former NXT got a great reception, and the fans were hyped up throughout, but he needlessly went 50/50 with one of the most useless performers on the roster, and that’s an issue.

English is an enhancement guy, while Roode is somebody who WWE presumably see as a future main eventer. Logic dictates that ‘The Glorious One’ should crush his opponent in such a scenario, but no. He was made to absorb an unnecessary amount of offence from the lowly 'Drama King,' whose pointless heat segment ultimately harmed Roode, made him feel like less of a star, and diminished would should've been his big moment.

The producers also went for the screen-in-screen approach, relegating the match to the bottom corner while the footage headed elsewhere, which further harmed the power of Roode’s debut. He won, which is the main thing, and he got a shred of microphone time afterwards, but one of modern day WWE’s biggest failings has been their inability to effectively debut new wrestlers, and it continued with Bobby last night.


2. Ziggler's Uninspiring Return

“Awesome! Dolph Ziggler’s back,” said absolutely nobody last night.

‘The Show-Off’ returned to SmackDown following a lengthy absence from television. Interviewed by Dasha Fuentes, he feigned excitement at being back, then derided the company for having him return via backstage segment.

Things got a little meta from there. Ziggler sarcastically said he knew what it took to be a star, and that perhaps he’ll start singing and playing guitar, dancing around like an idiot, or get a “woman who glows in the dark” to accompany him to ringside. He then signed off, promising to deliver all this next week.

Dolph’s delivery was fine, but the content was not. The meta references to other WWE characters were clumsy, and rather than doing something new with Ziggler for his return, WWE are going with the same “I’m really overlooked, you guys,” angle he’s been running for years, albeit with a slightly different slant. Unfortunately, this did nothing to build excitement for his comeback, and it’s hard to imagine an effective follow-up.

Just send this guy to NXT already...


1. The Styles vs. Owens (Vs. Shane) Saga

Shane McMahon Kevin Owens
WWE.com

Kevin Owens vs. AJ Styles dominated last night’s SmackDown. It started in the ring, with ‘The Phenomenal One’ celebrating his successful United States Championship defence at SummerSlam, then announcing that he was bringing the US Title open challenge back. This drew out Owens, then Shane McMahon (Sunday’s incompetent official), and the match was made, with Owens allowed to choose the referee.

A series of short backstage segments followed. Sami Zayn was the first person KO appealed to, but he declined. The Fashion Police reached out and were promptly shut down. Baron Corbin finally showed up, the deal was made, and ‘The Lone Wolf’ became the referee.

What followed was another deeply disappointing AJ vs. KO match that wasn’t about Styles or the US Title, but putting the forthcoming Owens vs. McMahon feud over. Corbin abandoned his refereeing duties before the end, prompting Shane to take control, counting the three on KO, which gives Kevin fuel to continue his rivalry with the Commissioner.

The show-opening in-ringer was tiresome, the backstage segments felt scatterbrained, and the match was bang average. The storyline started promisingly, but ultimately ended in disappointment, proving that sometimes, even the company's strongest performers can't overcome WWE's shoddy booking. There was no need to extend this feud beyond SummerSlam, and in doing so, WWE only succeeded in clogging a half decent episode of SmackDown.


Ups…

4. Hooray For New Guys

Bobby Roode Renee Young
WWE.com

While Bobby Roode’s debut match was poorly executed, it’d be remiss not to mention what a strong addition to the roster he could turn out to be. Though far from the most exciting wrestler in the world, the former NXT Champion plays his character to perfection, and is more than ready for a big main roster spot, regardless of card position. Let him do his thing, and he’ll shine.

Roode was immediately over in Brooklyn. The fans adored him, and while he’ll probably go full heel in the next week or two, his character work and bombastic entrance music (which is still as fantastic as the day we first heard it) means he’ll always be popular. The match stunk, but his appearance was a definite highlight.

Shelton Benjamin also returned on the show, and while re-introducing him via backstage segment felt a little cold, it’s great to have him back. ‘The Gold Standard’ remains a tremendous wrestler, and whether placing him with Chad Gable results in a new tag team or a fresh singles rivalry (as Shelton’s reaction suggested), he should be a nice addition to the roster.


3. The Women Tell Us A Story

Natalya Carmella
WWE.com

There was absolutely nothing special about the work on display in Naomi and Becky Lynch vs. Natalya and Carmella. It was a totally run of the mill SmackDown women’s division match, with little in the way of major thrills and spills, but it did tell a good story throughout, and that’s why it’s an up.

It was preceded by an in-ring segment with Nattie getting all emotional about her overdue title win, and a snotty Carmella teasing a Money In The Bank cash-in. From there, ‘The Princess Of Staten Island’ flat out refused to tag her partner during the match. Carmella tagged out almost as soon as the bell rung, then spent most of the match on the apron, continuing to tease a cash-in as the bout unfolded, though she didn’t go for it in the end.

The finish saw Nattie eventually tag her partner against her wishes, then chase her into the ring, leading to the finish. Lynch took Ms. MITB out with an Xploder Suplex while she was screaming at Nattie, Naomi hit the split-legged Moonsault, and that was that.

Unspectacular from a work standpoint, this bout delivered a strong, cohesive narrative, and helped further the ongoing Natalya vs. Carmella feud.


2. The King Vs. The Singhs

Shinsuke Nakamura Singh Brothers
WWE.com

Predictably, Shinsuke Nakamura vs. Jinder Mahal must continue. ‘The King Of Strong Style’ fell at SummerSlam, but it was thanks to interference from the Singh Brothers. Daniel Bryan’s response was to book Nakamura against both of Jinder’s henchmen last night, and it accomplished everything it needed to.

This was the Singhs’ first televised match since taking Jinder’s side, and they showed up to wrestle in their usual dress shirts and smart trousers. They were dominated: Nakamura completely worked them over, just as he should have, until Mahal pulled the distraction. Still, this wasn’t enough for the duo to take control, and they were defeated in less than three minutes.

The Singh Bros have been awesome sidekicks, and this was the right way to use them. There’s absolutely no way they should be in control of a wrestler like Nakamura for any more than a couple of seconds, and they weren't. They were squashed, and Shinsuke can now look forward to another big title fight, for which the company will presumably find a wacky stipulation that’ll (fail to) keep the Singhs from ringside.


1. It's Not Paranoia, It's The Best Team In The Company

The Usos
WWE.com

Let’s just take a moment to appreciate how good The Usos are these days.

One year ago, Jimmy and Jey were one of WWE’s stalest acts. Their dancing babyface gimmick had long since run its course, and while they were still delivering in the ring, The Usos had lost their groove. They were Roman Reigns' cousins and part-time allies, and while this occasionally gave them a decent rub, they weren't over.

Now, they’re one of the best things on SmackDown. Turning heel has transformed them into a menacing set of thugs, and they’ve done a great job not only with their characters, but in transforming their wrestling style. They delivered a great match at SummerSlam, and they followed up by smashing The Hype Bros last night, putting the lowly duo away in just over three minutes.

The match was short, fun, and energetic, and SmackDown Tag Team Champions put the division on notice with a quick post-bout promo delivered in their uniquely manic style. An abbreviated night for them, but one that was completely effective. They feel like the most exciting tag team in the company at the moment. Not every match needs to hit 10-15 minutes, and not every promo has to ramble on until tumbleweed starts drifting around the arena. This was absolutely spot on.


Channel Manager
Channel Manager

Andy has been with WhatCulture for 10 years and is currently WhatCulture's Wrestling Channel Manager. A writer, presenter, and editor with 10+ years of experience in online media, he has been a sponge for all wrestling knowledge since playing an old Royal Rumble 1992 VHS to ruin in his childhood. Having previously worked for Bleacher Report, Andy specialises in short and long-form writing, video presenting, voiceover acting, and editing, all characterised by expert wrestling knowledge and commentary. Andy is as much a fan of 1985 Jim Crockett Promotions as he is present-day AEW and WWE - just don't make him choose between the two.