4 Ups And 4 Downs From Last Night's WWE SmackDown (Feb 21)

If you're looking for a number one contender, you won't find one here...

luke harper aj styles
WWE.com

One week removed from what was probably SmackDown's strongest show since the 2016 draft, team blue provided a topsy-turvy offering last night. It wasn't bad by any means, but a number of dips in quality made it feel like the average episode of Raw, albeit without the colossal volume of filler typically found on Monday nights.

The number one contender's battle royal consumed much of the show and surprise, surprise, it produced an inconclusive result. AJ Styles and Luke Harper just couldn't be separated at the end, and while blighted by a poorly-executed finish, the match did an excellent job in furthering multiple stories at the same time.

While WWE Champion Bray Wyatt left SmackDown cackling, Naomi probably departed the building in a state of depression. Injury forced her into relinquishing her newly-won Women's Championship at the top of the show, and Alexa Bliss and Becky Lynch fought to crown a new champion in the aftermath. Elsewhere, Nikki Bella and Natalya looked to settle their beef in a chaotic Falls Count Anywhere match, but Nikki's problems are far from over, and neither are her partner, John Cena's.

A clear step down from last week's fantastic show, but SmackDown still provided a number of major talking points on the road to WrestleMania. How do they stack up? Let's take a look.


Downs...

4. Alexa vs. Becky Falls Flat

Alexa Bliss Becky Lynch
WWE.com

As solid as the set-up segment was, there was nothing special about Alexa Bliss vs. Becky Lynch. Running less than 10 minutes, their SmackDown Women's Title match was incredibly underwhelming given the stakes, and nowhere near close to the standards we've come to expect from Lynch in particular.

The match was cannibalised by an ill-timed commercial break, but that doesn't excuse the lack of excitement throughout. Bliss eventually won with a shot to the throat and a roll-up with a handful of tights, but the finish came with little build and caught the audience off-guard.

For all her strengths as a character, it is increasingly clear that Bliss still has a lot of work to do in the ring. Her main roster transition has been seamless in a lot of ways, but she's still struggling to put on good matches, even with Becky - the division's best wrestler. Their rivalry just hasn't produced the goods between the ropes, and Alexa is far from the finished article.

Bliss has only been wrestling for just over three years, so her deficiencies are understandable. Still, her and Becky were put in a great spot to shine on SmackDown, but set the night off to a disappointing start.


3. The Slump Continues

Breezango Jason Jordan
WWE.com

After successfully overcoming The Ascension (a team that haven't won in well over a year) last week, SmackDown Tag Team Champions American Alpha were served another mighty "challenge" this week. Tyler Breeze and Fandango stepped-up to the plate for a non-title match, and were routed by Jason Jordan & Chad Gable in less than three minutes.

The Usos arrived to cut a brief promo on Alpha in the aftermath, keeping their individual rivalry going but rounding-off another listless night for SmackDown's struggling tag division. The two segments took-up little more than five minutes in total, and for the second week in a row, Alpha were forced to wrestle a subpar team with little credibility. This is a direct result of the lack of care and attention that WWE have put into this division since the draft, and even Alpha themselves feel lost at the moment.

As over as they were in NXT, main roster fans just don't care about Gable & Jordan. WWE have completely failed to give the audience a reason to invest in them, and while competing against pointless enhancement teams doesn't help, it's not the only problem.

Their coming together in NXT was an incredibly well told story, but they've been given next to nothing on the main roster. You can't expect a crowd to root for an act if they're never given a chance to get to know them, and while the ongoing Usos feud should benefit both teams, it's about time SmackDown started taking tag team wrestling as seriously as their other divisions.


2. The Setup That Nobody Wants

The Miz John Cena
WWE.com

WWE took two big steps to setting-up John Cena & Nikki Bella vs. The Miz & Maryse for WrestleMania last night. The match has been rumoured for weeks, and after Maryse became inadvertently embroiled in the Natalya/Nikki Bella brawl at Elimination Chamber, the escalation was inevitable. Maryse cost Nikki her match (and feud) with Natalya last night, while Miz eliminated Cena from the battle royal, which puts all the pieces in-place for a match few people want to see.

The tag bout still feels like a huge waste of Cena and Miz. Nikki is a fine wrestler herself, but Maryse has never been particularly good in the ring, and intergender tag bouts are often disjointed and clunky. It's disappointing that this is the best thing WWE could come up with for Cena, their most important wrestler, and a singles match between him and Miz would almost certainly fare better.

The way WWE handled the set-up was strange, too. Miz's elimination of Cena was sneaky and underhand, but there are no disqualifications in a battle royal. Cena should probably understand this by now, but no: it took four referees to eventually convince him to quash his diva strop and leave the ringside area following his elimination. His sense of entitlement seems to grow by the week, and if he continues at this rate, it'll be hard to root for him at WrestleMania.


1. A Clumsy Conclusion

Luke Harper AJ Styles
WWE.com

SmackDown's main event was a fun 10-man battle royal that generally did a good job of showcasing everybody involved. Even deadwood like Mojo Rawley and Apollo Crews felt like they were there for a reason, and it never seemed like their only purpose was to pad the numbers out. It ultimately failed to produce a number one contender, but while this isn't necessarily a bad thing, the execution was very sloppy.

Luke Harper and AJ Styles made the final two, and WWE tried to pull a double elimination spot. Harper pulled Styles out of the ring and to the floor, but eliminated himself in the process, and WWE played-off the idea that both of their feet hit the deck at the same time. The referees called it a draw, and Daniel Bryan booked an official number one contender's bout between the duo for next week.

It's a solid enough booking decision, but the spot wasn't well-executed at all. Styles' feet clearly hit the ground before Harper's, and it was very telling that WWE didn't show a single replay in the aftermath. Even the live crowd noticed it, and after chanting Harper's name during the referees' deliberation period, they booed the eventual decision loudly.

A tricky spot to execute, but the clumsy finish closed SmackDown on a disappointingly sour note. On the bright side, Harper vs. Styles should be a tremendous singles bout.


Ups...

4. Sucks To Be You, Naomi

Naomi Vacates Title
WWE.com

Last night's SmackDown began on the sourest note imaginable for Naomi. Nine days after winning her first piece of WWE gold, the former Funkadactyl was forced to relinquish her title through injury. Having legitimately hurt her knee while wrestling Alexa Bliss at Elimination Chamber, Naomi was given no choice but to hand the SmackDown Women's Title back to Daniel Bryan, as she supposedly wouldn't have been able to defend it within the required 30-day window.

WWE obviously can't have injured wrestlers carrying championships around, but the justification felt a little odd, particularly as Becky Lynch went 30+ days without defending the belt last autumn. The fans were behind Naomi 100%, however, and she gained a great deal of sympathy through this unfortunate situation, which will only help her get over as a babyface.

Suddenly without a Women's Champion, Bryan reignited the Becky Lynch/Alexa Bliss feud by throwing them together with the title on the line. Bliss cut a typically smarmy and condescending promo on Naomi to ensure their bad blood survives through the now former champion's time away from television, rounding-off a practical segment that keeps the women's division rolling in the wake of Naomi's injury.


3. Natalya Wins Big, Courtesy Of Maryse

Natalya SmackDown
WWE.com

Last night's Natalya vs. Nikki Bella match was a big improvement on their Elimination Chamber bout, and a fitting end to their feud. The Falls Count Anywhere stipulation prevented another inconclusive double count-out, and after spending the past couple of months tearing into each other all around the building, it felt entirely appropriate.

The warring women made the most of it, too. The brawled in the crowd and struck each other with kendo sticks, and Nikki hit Nattie with a nasty-looking Alabama Slam onto the announce table at the halfway point. The fight spilled backstage, and after running into Maryse again, the finish was set. Natalya pushed Bella into Maryse backstage, and when the fight return to the arena proper, The Miz's other half struck Nikki with a pipe to ensure Nattie's victory.

The crowd were into the match throughout, and the wrestlers' intensity shone through. The duo felt like they were going through the motions at Elimination Chamber, but there was no such problems here, and the fight really felt like a bitter, feud-ending war.

We all know what awaits Nikki next, but what of Natalya? This was her biggest win in a long time, and while it's unlikely she'll get a title shot while another heel is champion, she can't be too far away from contention at the moment, particularly after winning this feud.


2. No True Winner, But Plenty Of Storylines

Dolph Ziggler Kalisto
WWE.com

The best thing about last night's main event was the way WWE used it to further multiple stories. Sure, the finish wasn't perfect, but it kept Luke Harper and AJ Styles looking strong, and it gave the company a good excuse to book next week's main event in advance. Similarly, WWE's handling of John Cena was odd, but his interactions with The Miz at least give the A-Lister something to brag about in their forthcoming promo battles.

These weren't the only stories that WWE advanced in the battle royal, however. The ongoing Dolph Ziggler vs. Kalisto/Apollo Crews feud continued when Ziggler superkicked Kalisto out of the ring, but was quickly dumped-out by Crews. A hacked-off Ziggler retaliated by attacking Kalisto with a chair in the aftermath, but Crews chased him off, and their rivalry must continue.

Finally, there was the ongoing Dean Ambrose/Baron Corbin situation. Having pinned Corbin at Elimination Chamber and eliminated him from last night's match, Ambrose has now scored two major victories over The Lone Wolf. Corbin, however, utterly destroyed Dean following his PPV roll-up, and did the same on last week's SmackDown. They're neck-and-neck at the moment, and that's likely how things will continue ahead of their expected Intercontinental Title bout.

Aside from Mojo Rawley, everybody left this match with a sense of purpose. Nice job, WWE.


1. The Build Continues

luke harper smackdown
WWE.com

WWE Champion Bray Wyatt didn't get a lot of airtime last night, but he didn't need it. He cut a brief promo ahead of the battle royal, then looked pleased when a concrete winner couldn't be found. SmackDown closed with a shot of him and Randy Orton on the big screen, and while Bray was consumed by laughter, The Viper couldn't help but glance at the championship belt on his shoulder.

It was a smart piece of foreshadowing from a company not usually known for their subtlety. The Orton/Wyatt saga continues to impress, and while last week saw Orton insist he won't face his "master" at WrestleMania, everybody knows what's coming. WWE are building towards a predictable outcome, but the set-up has been immaculate, particularly over the past few weeks, and Orton's eventual betrayal is going to go over huge.

Wyatt has shown no signs of vulnerability as champion thus far. He was allowed to pin both AJ Styles and John Cena at Elimination Chamber, and followed-up with another fall on Cena two nights later. It has been years since he has been booked this strongly, and he has an excellent foil in Orton, who remains one of the sport's biggest stars. While Goldberg vs. Brock Lesnar will probably close WrestleMania, Wyatt and Orton more than deserve the spot, particularly if their story continues unravelling this strongly.


Channel Manager
Channel Manager

Andy has been with WhatCulture for 10 years and is currently WhatCulture's Wrestling Channel Manager. A writer, presenter, and editor with 10+ years of experience in online media, he has been a sponge for all wrestling knowledge since playing an old Royal Rumble 1992 VHS to ruin in his childhood. Having previously worked for Bleacher Report, Andy specialises in short and long-form writing, video presenting, voiceover acting, and editing, all characterised by expert wrestling knowledge and commentary. Andy is as much a fan of 1985 Jim Crockett Promotions as he is present-day AEW and WWE - just don't make him choose between the two.