4 Ups And 6 Downs From WWE Clash Of Champions 2017

Lackluster wrestling, overbooked "drama" drag down last PPV of the year.

AJ Styles Clash Of Champions
WWE.com

If you ever needed the poster child for a totally skippable WWE PPV, we got it Sunday with Clash of Champions to close out 2017.

The PPV, where every title was on the line (along with Sami Zayn and Kevin Owens’ WWE careers), had the potential to be entertaining, a diamond in the rough so to speak. But overbooking hampered this PPV from early on, and it never settled in. We were left with a disjointed event that didn’t produce a seriously memorable (in a good way) match.

WWE put all its eggs in one basket, the drama between Shane McMahon and Zayn & Owens. And the result was turning a surefire memorable match into a snoozer. But hey, we got to see special refs who also are SmackDown authority figures arguing. If that’s the kind of thing that gets up fired up, then Clash of Champions was for you.

It wasn’t all bad though. Jinder Mahal looks to be out of the main event – and world title picture – for now, which is a positive development. And regardless of what you think of the storyline itself, giving Daniel Bryan something to do other than make matches is at least something.

With that said, let’s find out what rose to the occasion and what came toppling back to Earth. Let’s get to it…


Downs...

6. A Confusing Setup

tag match usos
WWE.com

New match stipulations pop up all the time as WWE tries to make its product fresh and interesting. Some of them work, and some of them bomb and are never heard from again.

But a fatal four-way tag match has a generally accepted format: two competitors are legal in the ring at any time, and they can tag out to anyone (except their opponent’s partner). However, WWE unveiled a new format Sunday, with one member of each team legal, and they could only tag out to their partner.

With four people legal in the ring, we got a very weird dynamic early on, with Rusev and Aiden English beating up one of the Usos, and Shelton Benjamin and Chad Gable beating down Kofi Kingston. And they almost never interacted unless one went for a pinfall. It was a boring segment that seemed to confuse fans because it just dragged on with little real action. You’d think with four guys legal, it would be all action from bell to bell.

By the last third of the match, they were firing better, but it was really touch-and-go for a while. Regardless, they should never do that stipulation again.


5. Crocodile Tears

natayla promo
WWE.com

Did Natalya just retire from WWE? Or was she pulling a Bret Hart by “turning [her] back” on all of the fans?

Either way, it was a strange promo after losing to Charlotte Flair. Nattie complained about carrying the women’s division on her back for a decade and getting no love, and talking about turning away from the fans (which is weird when you consider she’s been a heel for much of the past couple years).

And then she started to cry.

All in all, it was a strange promo, especially if it was a retirement speech, and even more so if it simply goes nowhere. It just didn’t feel like it was well thought out.


4. Not For Wrestling Fans

breezango bludgeon brothers
WWE.com

A PPV with Kevin Owens, Sami Zayn, the Usos, Charlotte Flair, AJ Styles, Shinsuke Nakamura, New Day, Bobby Roode and Chad Gable on the card sounds like it should produce a few really good matches, but you’d be wrong.

Aside from the triple threat United States Championship match, much of the PPV was dominated by mediocre or subpar wrestling. In a couple cases, match stipulations or rules dragged the action down. One of only two straight wrestling matches on the main card was a 90-second squash, and the other involved Jinder Mahal.

If you’re the type of person who wants to be up on you WWE PPVs for the year, then you’ll be happy to know this clocked in at about two-and-a-half hours. Otherwise, you would have been in for a long night.


3. A Hot Mess

hot mess
WWE.com

Lumberjack matches are definitely a mixed bag when it comes to match quality. And it’s even more of a tossup whether the presence of other wrestlers advances the storyline or is just a convenient distraction.

Unfortunately, it was the worst of all worlds Sunday night during the SmackDown Women’s Championship match between Charlotte Flair and Natalya. The women’s roster (sans Becky Lynch) surrounded the ring, which meant six heels (including the Riott Squad) and one face (Naomi). That by itself presented a bit of a problem.

And while Nattie had a sound strategy of tossing Charlotte out to the heels multiple times, it just looked awkward, with the Riott Squad alternately brawling with and then helping Lana, Tamina and Carmella beat up Flair.

Then the lumberjacks entered the ring, exited it, got moonsaulted and were taken out en masse and were never heard from again. Just a really clunky way to get all the women involved.


2. Did Corbin Insult Another Veteran?

triple 3
WWE.com

WWE is either truly conflicted about what to do about Baron Corbin, or they think these start-and-stop efforts are a real direction for his character.

Corbin lost his United States Championship, just two months after winning it, to Dolph Ziggler in a triple threat match. Ziggler, who has been all but directionless for much of 2017, won a match with a hot ending – and fans popped for the title change – but why stop Corbin’s reign now?

Backstage, it was pointed out that Corbin also failed in his Money in the Bank cash-in, and he was asked if he is squandering his opportunities. This prompted an outburst from Baron before he stormed off.

Is that really the angle here? Corbin loses his title and he’s labeled a choke artist? Is that really how he’s being painted? If so, that’s just a dumb idea. And it’s doubtful they’re suddenly doing something clever with Ziggler (they haven’t followed through on anything with him for years), so you’ve got to wonder what they were smoking.


1. Stipulation Drags Down Action

randy orton kevin owens shinsuke nakamura
WWE.com

On paper, several of the matches looked like they would be tremendous contests. But when you start adding stipulations to most of those bouts, you’re bound to lose something.

By all accounts, Randy Orton, Shinsuke Nakamura, Sami Zayn and Kevin Owens should have been able to put together a hell of a tag team match. But the dual referee showdown became the entire focus of the match, and it served to completely detract from the contest itself.

It got to the point where fans sounded deathly quiet for most of the offense, because they were waiting for one of the refs to screw a team over. And then when that started to happen, the crowd came alive for the “real action.” Everything else to that point was just a prelude.

And look, the actual shenanigans were done decently enough, but when the focus of the match – for the wrestlers and the fans – is on drama between two special referees, you have to wonder what’s going on around here.

The only saving grace was the fact that Bryan quick-counting the fall for Zayn got a huge face reaction. Otherwise, this was awful.


Ups...

4. Anything’s Better…

mojo rawley zack ryder
WWE.com

An easy critique you could make about the breakup of the Hype Bros is, “So what?” It’s not like Zack Ryder and Mojo Rawley were some beloved tag team that had connected with fans for years. And it’s not like Mojo punching Zack from behind was on the level of Shawn throwing Marty through the Barbershop window.

But if the breakup gives us a new, aggressive direction for Rawley, then so be it. He (and the tag team) wasn’t going anywhere, and the persona of an aloof goof certainly wasn’t going to win championships. Ryder is always a guy fans seems to rally around, making him a perfect fall guy to help get Mojo over.

And the new Mojo, yelling at Zack, “Show me your killer instinct!” was way more interesting than the hyper goof. Sure, it might not lead anywhere regardless, but it’s worth trying.


3. Strong In Defeat

Rusev Big E
WWE.com

Funky format aside, the SmackDown Tag Team Championship fatal four-way match provided some good action in the latter half of the bout. And the two less-decorated teams got some opportunities to shine.

Rusev and Aiden English, who seemed like a throwaway duo a couple months ago, looked sharp with Rusev kicking everything in sight and slapping the Accolade on multiple wrestlers. And Gable got to show off some raw strength by German suplexing half of his opponents.

And while they lost, it’s hard to consider losing to what has to be the best tag team going in WWE right now – the Usos – a huge downer. Jimmy and Jey have been resurgent during the past year, and they have become a complete team.

If nothing else, casual fans got to see the two teams not named New Day (another top-flight tag team) hang in there and look pretty decent for most of the match. And sometimes that’s the best you’re gonna get.


2. Let The Speculation Begin

Daniel Bryan Refs
WWE.com

“He took a bump!”

Someone, somewhere saw Daniel Bryan fall backward, knocked over by Kevin Owens onto Shane McMahon, and was instantly convinced that this meant that Bryan was going to come back as an active wrestler.

There is next-to-no chance that Bryan comes back as an active wrestler in WWE again.

“But he took a bump in the ring!”

Set that aside for a second, and set aside the match-long drama between D-Bry and Shane-O-Mac. The real drama is in whether Bryan is going to side with longtime fellow indy wrestler compatriots Sami Zayn and Kevin Owens against a McMahon. Sure, there are plenty of people who will despise an authority figure power struggle (and the irony that Bryan would be one of those figures).

But that’s the real issue here, not whether Bryan is going to wrestle again. Regardless, we’ll give an “up” to putting Bryan – an extremely popular figure regardless of what he’s doing in the ring – right smack in the middle of things instead of just being a matchmaker and cheerleader for Shane.


1. AJ Continues As Champ

AJ Styles WWE
WWE.com

We knew that Jinder Mahal was not going to have a classic title match against AJ Styles at Clash of Champions, so we had to modify our hopes: a watchable match where Styles retained the WWE Championship.

Thankfully, that’s exactly what we got. Mahal got his offense in, was saved at one point by the Singh brothers, and hit the Khallas for a very close two count. But he was not to emerge victorious Sunday, with Styles locking in the Calf Crusher for a submission win.

The big “up” here is that this hopefully spells the end for Jinder in the world title scene. While he’s come a long way and would be a perfectly serviceable heel in the midcard, it’s safe to call the experiment with him as champion a flop and move on. AJ has become one of the most reliable wrestlers on the roster, and it would be great if he continues as champ for a while.


Contributor
Contributor

Scott is a former journalist and longtime wrestling fan who was smart enough to abandon WCW during the Monday Night Wars the same time as the Radicalz. He fondly remembers watching WrestleMania III, IV, V and VI and Saturday Night's Main Event, came back to wrestling during the Attitude Era, and has been a consumer of sports entertainment since then. He's written for WhatCulture since 2014, establishing the Ups and Downs articles for WWE Raw and WWE PPVs/PLEs and composing pieces on a variety of topics.