5 Biggest WWE Winners & Losers In 2021

Who's had a year to remember and who's had a year to forget?

Bianca Belair
WWE.com

2021 has been another dramatic year for WWE.

They’ve returned triumphantly(ish) to shows in front of crowds, crowned new champions, and put on some great and occasionally groundbreaking matches. Simultaneously, they’ve seen their competition grow exponentially and come under fire for baffling booking and callous staff cuts.

So that’s how the company has fared, but what of the wrestlers in its employ? Wrestling is, in kayfabe and otherwise, a hierarchy of sorts, and at any given time, not everyone can be a top star. Some performers have grabbed 2021 by the scruff of the neck and taken their careers to new heights, being embraced by the fans or put to good use by the office.

Others, meanwhile, have endured a slog of a year, losing match after match, being asked to do nonsensical things, or simply falling off the radar altogether.

The fickle nature of WWE, its management, and sometimes its fans, means that the wheel of fortune may spin around for any of these 10 come January 1st, but for the time being, here are the superstars who’ve had, for good or for ill, the most eventful of 2021s...

10. Winner: Riddle

Riddle WWE
WWE.com

Riddle may have lost his forename in moving to the main roster, but he’s gained a whole lot more. The former MMA star has all the tools he needs to succeed, and his outspoken manner and comedy stylings seem to have won him fans in the office.

He started the year winning the US Championship from the dominant Bobby Lashley, and while it wasn’t a particularly eventful reign, it culminated in a terrific match on WrestleMania night two, during which he and Sheamus put on a stiff clinic and Riddle’s scooter-mounted entrance gained one of the biggest pops of the event.

He then started teaming with the reluctant Randy Orton, who couldn’t help be charmed by his goofy manner. RK-Bro was one of the lone highlights of Raw for much of this year. The two clearly have a blast bouncing off each other, and like fellow hybrid athlete Kurt Angle before him, Riddle has an uncanny ability to turn from class clown to killer as soon as he steps in the ring.

The ace up his sleeve is the future break up of the tag team. Provided the booking isn’t bungled, Riddle has a heated angle with a future hall of famer to look forward to, and from there, the sky’s the limit.


9. Loser: Cesaro

Cesaro WWE
WWE.com

Truly, 2021 has been a year of two halves for the Swiss superstar. In February he began a rise from the midcard, beating Daniel Bryan and entering into a great feud with Seth Rollins that peaked with a clean win in his first WrestleMania singles match (and one of the card’s best).

He followed that with an excellent WrestleMania Backlash match against Roman Reigns, in which he took the dominant champ to the limit and looked right at home in the main event.

Then, as per, it all slid back downhill. He burned off his angle with Rollins, who ultimately won, didn’t get past the first round of the King Of The Ring tournament, and is now half-heartedly sparring with Sheamus (and the Irishman’s odd little pal). There’s no doubt these two can put on exceptional matches together, but we’ve seen them do it many, many times before.

It’s better to have loved and lost, and the ‘Mania match is a memory for the ages, but the latter end of 2021 has been miserable for the prodigiously talented Cesaro. It’s made all the worse by the fact we’ve seen for sure he can hang with the big boys. If not now, then when?


8. Winner: Bobby Lashley

Bobby Lashley
WWE.com

For many years, Bobby Lashley seemed like a whole lot of potential unrealised. Obviously he’s got the physique, as well as the strength and credentials, but in his first WWE run there was something missing - not charisma, necessarily, but pizzaz.

When he came back to WWE, early signs were equally worrying - he was thrust into bizarre comedy spots with Sami Zayn and floundering in the midcard. Since allying with MVP, though, the sky’s the limit for the almighty. In March of this year he won his first WWE Championship. We thought he’d be fed to Drew McIntyre at WrestleMania - instead, he triumphed in the excellent opening match, and to no small ovation.

His ring work has come on leaps and bounds, his intensity a sight to behold, his conditioning as impressive as ever. Unlike other career midcarders making the jump to the top, Lashley with the big gold didn’t feel incongruous - it felt totally natural.

He has since dropped the title, but seems to be hovering around the title scene all the same. So long as he’s given the right opponents (i.e not Goldberg), he should be a big deal for the rest of his career, and deservedly so.


7. Loser: Elias

Elias WWE
WWE

No one’s ever really watched Elias for his work between the ropes, but for a while, his persona, catchphrase, and musical act was properly over. Fans looked forward to his derogatory, cheap heat-gaining songs, he performed with real charisma, and even had a little recurring feud with John Cena going on.

Now, though, he’s nowhere to be seen. He was involved for a while with Shane McMahon during Shane’s interminable feud with Braun Strowman, enjoying a brief run out in one of ‘Mania 37’s absolute lowlights.

After getting creamed by the monster among men a few times, he teamed with Jackson Ryker and got battered by Omos instead. The two split up their team to little reaction; Elias then put on basically the same match with Ryker for several weeks on the trot, before vanishing.

We were treated to some vignettes in which Elias burned his guitar, “killing” the drifter character, but he’s yet to emerge in his new persona. Rumours abound that a rebirth in a new colourful guise was kiboshed at the death, with McMahon feeling it was too similar in look to Randy Savage. What Elias will do next remains to be seen; hopefully he’ll be able to put his gifts to good use soon enough.


6. Winner: Damian Priest

Damian Priest
WWE.com

The road from NXT to main roster has been a rocky one, with many seemingly surefire superstars since falling by the wayside. On the strength of his work and presentation so far, though, you’d bet on Damian Priest bucking the trend.

He couldn’t have asked for much better a start, appearing in the Royal Rumble and nabbing a respectable four eliminations before being tied to Bad Bunny for the next few months. The Puerto Rican rapper astounded wrestling fans worldwide with his WrestleMania match, and Priest got a healthy dose of the rub as his tag partner.

From there, it has been a steady climb for the archer of infamy. He made easy work of The Miz and John Morrison, took the US championship from Sheamus at SummerSlam, and has kept in the picture with an invitational challenge ever since. It’s simple, effective booking, and Priest has the presence and skill to make it work.

At 39 years old, if Priest’s going to take a stab at the main event he needs to do it sooner rather than later, but the measured pace of his rise has made acclimatising from NXT look easy.


5. Loser: Asuka

Asuka WWE
WWE

Frittering away anyone’s career seems a shame: wasting the time of a talent like Asuka is downright criminal. Perhaps the most consistent star on the roster since around her debut, through stagnation and bad booking, Asuka has lost a decent chunk of her aura by the close of 2021.

She started the year as Raw Women’s Champion, but bafflingly the focus had been put on her erstwhile partnership with Charlotte Flair. The two nabbed the tag team belts for no real reason, then killed a few weeks with some “can they co-exist?” storytelling that’s always just death.

Asuka had a good spot at WrestleMania and a fine opponent in Rhea Ripley, but sadly their match never quite caught fire. This was partly down to the build - or rather, the complete and utter lack of one. Ripley turned up on Raw, said she wanted a match, and that was your lot.

Asuka has been a background player at best since then, possibly rehabbing an injury. On her return, there’s plenty she could be getting on with - surely even this booking committee couldn’t mess up Asuka.


4. Winner: Bianca Belair

Bianca Belair
WWE.com

It has been a ridiculously good year for Bianca Belair. The EST has been in the business for a scant half-decade, and yet her glittering CV and rocket-fueled ascent doesn’t feel the least bit inorganic - she’s just that good.

Belair’s first eight months on the main roster saw her working in a comedy angle with The Street Profits, but when she was allowed to go alone, things exploded. In January she won the Royal Rumble, going nigh on coast to coast and besting runner-up Rhea Ripley in a changing of the guard moment.

Next came a brilliant feud with Sasha Banks, culminating in a WrestleMania main event. The history making match saw two black women headline for the first time, and they did not disappoint, lacing their bout with pathos and memorable moments. A brief but quality run with Bayley followed, leading up to SummerSlam.

There, she lost her title in 26 seconds to Becky Lynch. But while this seemed idiotic at the time (and still does, really), it has only made Belair a better and more beloved babyface. Few have grabbed the proverbial brass ring like Bianca in recent memory, and there’s no way she’s letting go.


3. Loser: Otis

Otis WWE SmackDown
WWE

If we’re being kind, we could say Otis hasn’t yet found his level. As popular as he was, becoming Mr Money In The Bank was probably a mistake, and The Miz getting squashed to put the belt on Lashley was preferable to Otis getting this treatment.

Now, though, the poor guy just feels adrift. As part of Alpha Academy, he has a tag team partner in Chad Gable with whom he could do something special if let off the leash. Thus far, there’s little indication that’s ever going to happen. Even in the hinterland of WWE tag teams, Alpha Academy feel like an afterthought.

Otis will get a quick TV match from time to time or indulge in a little comedy mugging for the camera, but all this amounts to is air time to be filled. He was thrust into the MITB scene without any kind of plan, that much is clear, and now WWE have panicked and gone in the other direction, pushing an extremely talented and once hugely popular performer right to the periphery.

With all that being said, in topsy turvy WWE land he’ll probably beat Reigns for the belt at ‘Mania 38.


2. Winner: Big E

Big E
WWE.com

One of the true feel-good stories of WWE’s 2021 has been Big E’s progress as a singles star. Last Christmas, they gave him the Intercontinental Title, and the very next year he became WWE Champion for the first time.

Anyone who has followed E’s career will have known that he had the total package for a long time, and at long last, he’s been given the chance to prove it. Nabbing the briefcase at Money In The Bank was a major moment; wrenching the belt from Bobby Lashley’s vice-like grip on Raw was even better.

It’s a sign of WWE’s faith in the big man that they had him announce his intentions on Twitter prior to the broadcast in order to pop the rating. It worked: the WWE universe loves this man, and wants to see him succeed.

Just where he’ll be able to take the belt remains to be seen, but few have had as impactful a year as the New Day man. From a hard-hitting (if short) WrestleMania midcard match to clean wins over Drew McIntyre and Kevin Owens, Big E is, in this moment, the guy.


1. Loser: Bayley

Bayley WWE
WWE.com

For the first six months of the pandemic, Bayley was indisputably the MVP. The first to figure out the need to fill the silence, her matches were more watchable than anyone’s due to her insistence on berating all around her, she could cut a consistently brilliant promo, and in her slow-burning feud with Sasha Banks, she had the best story in the company.

When WrestleMania returned in front of a live crowd, Bayley’s big reward was to be sidelined in favour of the unpopular Hulk Hogan, the sleepwalking NWO, and the not-Becky-Lynch-so–not-interested Bella Twins. She did the best with the material she was given, but was essentially sent out there to play the fool in front of legacy acts.

Her subsequent feud with Bianca Belair had moments of greatness, though it was stymied by the fact no one ever believed Bayley would come out on top. Before it could be blown off, she was on the injury bench, out for nine months with a torn ACL.

While injuries do of course happen, the usage of Bayley in 2021 beggars belief. Her 2020 title run was one of the finest in the division’s history: after that, it’s like the office forgot she even existed.


Watch Next


Contributor
Contributor

Yorkshire-based writer of screenplays, essays, and fiction. Big fan of having a laugh. Read more of my stuff @ www.twotownsover.com (if you want!)