5 Most Infamous Illegitimate Son Wrestling Storylines
Congratulations - it’s a boy!
Kurt Angle announced on Raw this week that the big secret hanging over him was that he actually had an illegitimate son; with that son being none other than American Alpha’s Jason Jordan. Yeah…
Once the chorus of worldwide forehead slapping had finally finished reverberating around the globe, reality soon set in that WWE had once again wasted what could have well been fantastically intriguing booking with a nonsensical, unbelievable storyline.
But this is far from the first time that wrestling has taken a dive into the gene pool for storyline purposes. Join us as we crack open the classified cabinet of kayfabe and inspect the confidential family files of five illegitimate son angles.
5. Kurt Angle & Jason Jordan
Starting at the most recent, Kurt Angle revealed on the July 17th episode of Raw that Jason Jordan was (in storyline) his own son; a chip off the old block; the fruit of his proverbial lions. “WTF?” I hear you ask/exclaim/sigh? Well...here goes.
Based on Angle’s explanation, the connection between the two stems from an apparent relationship Angle had during his university days at Clarion; where Angle stated he had been going out with a girl who he supposedly impregnated before they split – unbeknownst to our Olympic Hero.
The unnamed girl eventually gave birth to a baby boy nine months later and Jason Jordan was born. Jordan was apparently put up for adoption after that and, years later, Jordan would eventually uncover the “truth” behind his existence using a private investigator. Oh it’s true; it’s damn true...or, in this case, completely false.
With Angle’s secret and impending announcement looming for weeks prior, fans were left salivating at the prospect of a Dixie Carter reveal that could spark some form of cross promotional war, with a nod to Kurt’s tenure in TNA. If that was too much of a stretch, many believed that WWE would simply opt to rekindle the Kurt/Steph romance angle from 2000, inevitably leading to a showdown between Angle and Steph’s husband, Triple H.
But alas. Here we are.
As one half the American Alpha tag team on NXT and later Smackdown Live, Jordan has long been compared to Angle, due to the obvious similarity in styles and the overall presentation of his character as a thoroughbred athlete with a strong amateur background; with the same being said for his tag partner, Chad Gable. With Angle’s announcement of Jordan being his “son” and his apparent move to Raw, question marks immediately loom above the status of American Alpha as an active team.
Wrestling is often at its best when the drama and acting is done from bell to bell; not outside of the squared circle. With Jordan being a natural in the ring and inexperienced in the theatrics outside of it, surely the best option would be to play to his strengths and focus on his in-ring skills and not place him in a doomed scenario that not only necessitates acting and conviction, but also requires a healthy dose of suspension of disbelief from the audience.
The angle itself does open up the opportunity to explore a revamped Team Angle scenario, with Kurt leading the charge of American Alpha on Raw. The recurring rumours of Shelton Benjamin re-signing also add an element of intrigue to this concept and, with Angle himself presumably wrestling a very limited number of dates, a refreshed Team Angle led by Benjamin, flanked by Alpha and propped up by Kurt as the mouthpiece could work wonders long-term.
Whether the storyline surpasses expectations and hits a home run remains to be seen, but based on the lukewarm reaction from the crowd in attendance at Raw, WWE will be facing an uphill battle with this one. Having said that, stranger things have happened in wrestling and the crowd’s love for Kurt could prove to be the deciding factor in whether the storyline gets over or dies horribly.
4. Andre The Giant & Big Show
When Paul Wight first debuted in WCW in 1995, the 7 foot tall, man-mountain was a long way from the colossal behemoth of the Big Show we know and love today.
WCW fans got their first glimpse of the as yet unnamed giant during a segment on the July 16th edition of WCW Main Event in 1995, when the mysterious towering individual confronted The Hulkster (mid-promo brother!) by throwing an oversized shirt in his face and simply saying “Remember this?” During the aftermath, Hogan would later quip “This is Andre’s”; laying the groundwork for the formal introduction of The Giant as Andre’s kayfabe son.
Known simply as The Giant, Paul Wight would appear in a number of cringe-worthy vignettes in the weeks that followed; aligning himself with Kevin Sullivan’s Dungeon of Doom stable of misfit freaks in their seemingly eternal battle against Hulkamania.
The Dungeon of Doom would go on to square off with the team of Hogan and friends (comprising of Randy Savage, Lex Luger and Sting) in War Games at the Fall Brawl event that year; with the caveat being that, if Hogan’s team were victorious, Hulk would get his hands on Kevin Sullivan, mano a mano in the cage. Before that could really happen, The Giant came to the aid of Sullivan; setting up Hogan vs The Giant at Halloween Havoc the following month in a poor and blatant rehash of WrestleMania 3.
One month later, Hogan would drop the title to The Giant in his debut match (on a technicality) and the “Son of Andre” gimmick would quietly be dropped after the fact.
3. Waldo Von Erich & Lance Von Erich
The Von Erich family will go down in history as one of the most beloved families in wrestling history; made all the more treasured by the wrestling community due to the tragedy that befell them.
From Fritz, Kevin and David to Kerry, Mike and Chris, the family will forever be etched in Texas folklore as the lifeblood of wrestling in the Dallas area. However, two such names that may not make that list are Waldo Von Erich and Lance Von Erich.
Waldo Von Erich was billed throughout the 60s and 70s as the brother of Fritz Von Erich. Despite no legitimate connection, the kayfabe “brothers” held the NWA American Tag Team Championships together, while Waldo also went on to challenge Bruno Sammartino for the WWWF Championship on a number of occasions before retiring in 1979.
Following the death of David Von Erich in 1984, Fritz felt he needed another member of the Von Erich clan to help prop up business in World Class Championship Wrestling. However, it would take almost another year for these plans to come to fruition. When Mike Von Erich contracted toxic shock syndrome following a shoulder injury suffered on a trip to Isreal, Fritz decided the time was right to unveil the newest Von Erich to the world.
As such, Fritz opted for local wrestler, Ricky Vaughan, and quickly repackaged him as Lance Von Erich. To counteract his estrangement from Fritz and co in World Class, Lance was billed as the son of Waldo and, just like that, Fritz had himself another member of the Von Erich family on the books.
Lance debuted in October of ‘85 and was initially quite successful; however, many fans came to know or suspect that he wasn’t a real member of the Von Erich family, partly due to the fact he had wrestled previously in the Dallas area as Ricky Vaughan. WCCW attempted to cover for this fact by stating that he had wrestled under an alias in order to attain success on his own, independent from the Von Erich name.
Lance would actually go on to attain a great deal of success in World Class, holding a variety of championships and even challenging Ric Flair for the NWA World’s Heavyweight Championship. After various stints tagging with the Von Erich boys, Lance would also find success tagging with Dingo Warrior, who would eventually become the Ultimate Warrior in WWF.
Ultimately, Lance Von Erich would leave World Class after a dispute over booking and pay; allegedly refusing to put over Nord the Barbarian (aka The Berzerker in WWF). Fritz would respond by breaking kayfabe and publicly denouncing Lance as a Von Erich on television; revealing his Lance’s true identity and prohibiting him from ever using the Von Erich name again.
As a result, Lance was blackballed from WCCW, thus putting an end to the angle and simultaneously delivering a fatal blow to Lance’s from which it never truly recovered.
2. Eddie Guerrero & Dominick
When Eddie Guerrero and Rey Mysterio began feuding in 2005, the matches that occurred as a result were pure in-ring gold. Not so golden was the storyline that surrounded them; developing from a simple case of tag team jealousy into full-blown soap opera dramatics.
Despite being Tag Team Champions at the time, Rey and Eddie wrestled one-on-one in the opening bout of WrestleMania 21 in a fantastic, fast-paced encounter. Guerrero came up short in the match, setting the wheels in motion for the feud that followed and sowing the seeds for an impending heel turn for "Latino Heat".
Eddie and Rey would lose the Tag Titles to MNM (John Morrison and Joey Mercury) soon after due to Guerrero abandoning his partner mid-match. Guerrero's betrayal would be accentuated momentarily in the post-match, delivering a vicious beating to his former partner to solidifying the full heel turn. So far, so good…
Shortly thereafter, however, Guerrero would begin threatening his former ally, claiming to have a dark secret involving Rey Rey’s familia - specifically his son, Dominick. It eventually came out that Eddie was Dominick’s father, having left him at birth to Rey and his wife as they were having trouble starting a family.
The angle would reach its climax at SummerSlam ‘05 in a - sigh - “Custody of Dominick” Ladder Match, with the custody papers high above the ring. Yes, this legitimately happened. Luckily for Rey, he won the match and retained legal custody of son. Órale vato!
While this storyline was far-fetched to begin with, long-time fans of Mysterio will recall his latter WCW days where he performed without a mask and the fact that Dominick strongly resembled Rey and looked the spitting image of his dad did nothing to help validate the believability of the angle.
On the plus side, the storyline did give birth to the brilliant “I’m Your Papi” shirt worn by Guerrero throughout the feud, which has gone on to become a cult favourite in years since.
1. Vince McMahon & Hornswoggle
Perhaps the most well remembered storyline between a father and apparent son has to be the the ill-fated “Vince’s Son” angle from 2007.
Following the aborted “Who Killed Vince?” storyline earlier that year – which had to be immediately abandoned after the real-life double-murder suicide involving Chris Benoit and his family – McMahon and co. wanted a replacement “whodunit” angle to run with on Raw.
The solution came in the form of the illegitimate son storyline, whereby it was revealed that Vince McMahon had a mystery off-spring with a claim to Vince’s fortune. The storyline itself would eventually culminate in Hornswoggle being revealed as Vince’s dirty little secret and the entire angle would quickly degenerate into a comedic tool for WWE's resident D-Generate, Triple H, who would humiliate the boss at every turn.
John “Bradshaw” Layfield would eventually intervene with evidence of his own, disproving the McMahon connection and revealing that Hornswoggle was in fact the son of Finlay and NOT Vince McMahon after all; thus making the entire storyline completely pointless. What’s even more frustrating is that the original “illegitimate son” storyline was apparently part of an overall masterpiece, interwoven into the “Who killed Vince?” plot prior to the Benoit incident.
It’s since been claimed that Linda McMahon was originally tapped as the culprit behind Vince’s demise and would go to kayfabe jail for the apparent murder of her husband following the limousine explosion. It would then come to light that McMahon (in his will) had left the company to his illegitimate son – to be revealed as Mr Kennedy – who would then run roughshod over the WWE.
Mr Kennedy would then enter into a feud with Triple H, culminating in a battle for control of the company at WrestleMania. Kennedy would lose the bout, Triple H and Stephanie would regain the company in the name of the McMahon family and normality would be restored. All in all, an angle that's unquestionably a million percent better than Hornswoggle being Vince’s son.
Worse still, the plan was apparently to still have Kennedy as the illegitimate son in the condensed version of the overall angle following the Benoit tragedy; however, Kennedy himself got busted for steroid use a month before the reveal, leading to him being dropped from the angle and putting to rest the snake bitten storyline once and for all.