5 Positives & 5 Negatives From WWE Royal Rumble 2016

The road to WrestleMania officially began last night.

The 2016 edition of the Royal Rumble is in the books and many fans left Orlando's Amway Center in a better mood than the fans that left Philadelphia's Wells Fargo Center after last year's show, or the Consol Energy Center in Pittsburgh in 2014. Triple H made history by not only winning the Royal Rumble for the second time, but by becoming a 14-time world champion, sitting just two reigns behind his idol Ric Flair. There were many other reasons for fans to leave the event excited and feeling satisfied, but that doesn't mean the show was without its flaws. Generally speaking, the 2016 Royal Rumble was a good start to the new calendar year and has laid the foundation for WrestleMania in Dallas, Texas. Fans now have an idea of what the card will be as several high profile matches began shaping up courtesy of Sunday night's PPV. The show was far from perfect and aside from the commentary, which at this point goes without saying is positively awful and almost unarguably the worst part of RAW and PPVs every month, there were several negative elements of the show. This article will take a look at 5 negatives that the Royal Rumble provided viewers as well as 5 positives that it left fans with...

Negative...

5. Sasha Kicking Becky Lynch

To start off the not-so-great moments of the 2016 Royal Rumble is the questionable booking surrounding Sasha's return. After Charlotte's post-match beatdown on Becky Lynch, the crowd was hot for Sasha Banks' return. The Boss slowly walked down the aisle staring at Charlotte, stopped just outside the apron and took off her hand rings, climbed into the ring, and then laid a kick to...Becky Lynch? Knowing how the segment ended, with Sasha out-smarting Ric Flair and stretching Charlotte in the Bank Statement, it made the brief heel spot seem a bit confusing. If the goal was for the crowd to cheer for Sasha, which the segment was clearly positioned to do, why risk softening the cheers for her by having Sasha kick Becky Lynch, a beaten down babyface who had just gone through a long, hard-fought match? Had Becky quietly rolled to the outside of the ring before Sasha's entrance, leaving the two former NXT Women's Champions to have the ring to themselves, the segment would've played much better with even more people supporting Sasha. As it was, it seemed like a quick and cheap swerve for swerve's sake. Fans were surprised and booed when Sasha attacked the babyface Lynch, especially when all signs pointed towards her coming after Charlotte, but then the fans had to quickly turn back to supporting Sasha, making it a quirky, confusing mess.

4. Ric Flair Kissing Becky Lynch

Speaking of a mess, the soon-to-be 67 year-old Ric Flair laid a kiss on the 28 year-old Becky Lynch during the middle of the Divas Championship match. WWE is often over-criticized for acts that may be seen as €œpolitically incorrect€ since playing on those topics is what professional wrestling does best and is part of the reason sports-entertainment has heels that fans are supposed to genuinely dislike. With that said, WWE has clearly gone the way of avoiding all things not deemed PC by society in 2016, so then why is male-on-female sexual assault permitted? Entertainment, including movies and other scripted shows, has all sorts of villains including murderers, rapists, thieves, bullies, criminals, violent individuals, etc. The fact is that heels do €˜dastardly€™ things, but the inconsistency in WWE is what is the problem here. WWE often works with blinders on, or at least in very narrow-minded ways and they clearly didn€™t see enough wrong with booking that spot where Flair kissed Becky against her will. How can this company still be so obtuse to let something like this through when, in a previous example, Daniel Bryan lost his job for mimicking violence on a show that mimics violence? Whether the company decides to lighten up a bit or keep the screws tightened with an overabundance of political correctness, they must be consistent; one man shouldn€™t be deciding who €œshouldn€™t€ get offended by €œwhat€ in 2016.

3. Alberto Del Rio vs. Kalisto

This match had potential, but due to some poor execution, failed to live up to it. Del Rio's never been in better shape in his entire career but his matches since returning to WWE have been hit-or-miss, with many being the latter. Kalisto was in his highest profile position since being called up to the main roster and, whether it was big-match jitters or just bad luck, the Lucha Dragon member seemed to have a couple of flubs in this match. To say nothing new, commentary didn't do this match any favors and the result saw Kalisto defeat Del Rio for the US Championship. This could mean that Alberto is set for bigger things heading into WrestleMania, which is probably the safe bet considering the lack of depth of the current roster, as well as the amount of money that WWE is likely paying Del Rio. Although the rumors of the $1.45 million dollars per year contract may have been just that, it is likely WWE is paying Del Rio a pretty penny for his services and would want to maximize their investment by booking him into bigger profile matches. He'll need to start delivering on a more consistent basis though to prove worthy of any contract he signed. In all fairness, it takes two to tango but their Royal Rumble dance just wasn't very good.

2. Cameras Missing Spots

Something that's been happening over the past year or two that never used to happen in the previous 30 years of Kevin Dunn's WWE career is the camera operators missing spots. The biggest gaffe that the camera crew experienced at the 29th Royal Rumble surrounded New Day and Kofi Kingston's "second" elimination from the Royal Rumble Match. The New Day member did not disappoint in his annual eliminated-but-not-really attempt this year, which of course came with the help of his New Day comrades, specifically landing on Big E's shoulders. The spot was not the most original of Kofi's run, but it made sense and continued the tradition. That part Kevin Dunn's crew got just fine. It was what happened after that they missed. To start, after Big E caught Kofi on his shoulders, Kofi comically grabbed a soda from one of the fans outside the ring that the camera crew didn't cut to. Kingston remained outside the ring, on E's shoulders, for the next several minutes but the camera crew never felt it necessary to get a closer shot. Instead, they focused on the wide shot of all the match's participants, which can be explained away for a bit, but Kofi was out there for quite a while. Long enough to be able to take a fan's bucket of popcorn that he then ate as part of his mid-match snack, and again, no focus from the camera crew. But the most egregious spot that the camera operators missed was both Kofi's re-entering the Royal Rumble Match, followed apparently by his abrupt legitimate elimination. The camera went from a wide shot showing New Day still outside the ring, then a switch to Stardust entering at #14, then the camera switched back, not to the match, but instead on the League of Nations' attack on Roman Reigns over by the announce tables, outside the ring. Instead of quick cuts back into the ring, keeping the television audience abreast of the match's happenings, the cameras focused on the non-match-threatening action surrounding Reigns on the outside. When the view finally cut back to the ring, the New Day was no where to be seen and only a few minutes later did fans at home get a replay of Kofi's elimination, after the fact.

1. No Flashback Rumble Participants

The lack of flashback talents entering the 2016 Royal Rumble may have left some fans that left the Amway Arena in Orlando disappointed. Over the past several years, the 30-man battle royal has set expectations for fans to see a couple of superstars from the past, but that didn't happen Sunday night. Some of these surprise returns have allowed talents, once thought to be done inside a WWE ring, brought back for another run, such as Mr. Perfect in 2002. Others were able to use their Rumble spot as a legit return to full-time, going as far back as 1992 when Rick "The Model" Martel returned to WWF television after having not been seen since WrestleMania VII. Finally, there are often just fun, little "remember me?" moments like when The Godfather, Diamond Dallas Page, or Kevin Nash entered the Royal Rumble to a standing ovation. The match doesn't need to have a bunch of these spots but the 2016 Royal Rumble didn't see any. With all due respect to these two, did this year's match need Jack Swagger or Mark Henry, for example? Could a couple of non-standard superstars from the past have made better use of those positions? Click "next" below to read the positives...

Positives...

5. Use Of Surprise Rumble Participants

There were only arguably 3 entrants that were considered surprises. AJ Styles, Sami Zayn, and Triple H all delivered and were among the highlights of this year's Royal Rumble. AJ Styles made his much anticipated WWE debut, Sami Zayn made his presence felt by eliminating Kevin Owens and renewing their rivalry, and Triple H can add his name to the list of Royal Rumble winners (John Cena in 2008, Edge in 2010) that have won the match while entering as a surprise. WWE was very efficient in its use of surprises this year and it put even more emphasis on the unpredictability of the match while showcasing that the unknown entrants aren't always just for laughs.

4. Booking Heat

One of the things that has been missing in WWE's booking lately has been the element of heat. It's been relatively non-existent, but the company brought it back in the 2016 Royal Rumble Match. First, we saw the League of Nations gain an unfair advantage over Roman Reigns by taking him through the ropes, to the outside where Sheamus, Del Rio, and an already-eliminated Rusev took turns delivering multiple kicks to his head. Soon after, Mr. McMahon appeared and the trio then left Reigns laying, nearly needing a stretcher, after a running Rusev splash through the announce table. Later on in the same match, the Wyatt family, after every member but Bray had been eliminated by Brock Lesnar, cheated and attacked Lesnar despite 3/4 of the Wyatt Family being already eliminated. Brock weathered the storm at first but their strength in numbers eventually overpowered the Beast and together the Wyatt Family dumped one of the biggest fan-favorites over the top rope and onto the arena floor, eliminating Lesnar from the Rumble. Both spots were meant to build heat on the villainous groups of the League Of Nations and the Wyatt Family, respectively. While the former was relatively effective, the latter was no doubt a success as the Orlando crowd was very upset when Lesnar was eliminated. It also prevented Bray Wyatt from getting cheered in spots later on during the conclusion of the Rumble Match. Will the heat last? Will WWE continue to build heat as we move closer to WrestleMania? Who knows, but it was nice to see it return at the Rumble and it's mind-boggling that this basic, fundamental element of professional wrestling has been missing for so long.

3. Triple H Winning

It's hard to imagine that in 2016, Triple H winning the Royal Rumble and with it, his 14th World Championship didn't elicit a crapfest reaction like the last two Royal Rumbles did. With WWE wanting to showcase the biggest WrestleMania of all time, it also shouldn't be that surprising to see a McMahon in the main event. With that being said, it was the right call given the limited number of options. Triple H and the Authority have been the company's top heel for the better part of the past 3 years. We haven't seen Triple H lace up the boots since his victory over Sting and the crowd, despite many fans knowing it was coming, still popped for The Game. In addition to the obligatory entrance pop, the crowd was still rooting for him several minutes into the match. Though the company was smart to position the pendulum to swing back towards the other direction by having Ambrose, not Reigns, as the final participant with HHH. The most controversial aspect of H winning the Rumble is his role in the main event of WrestleMania, assumed to be vs. Roman, as it will once again be giving a spot, and a massive pay day, to a part-timer (at least when it comes to in-ring work) and a McMahon. But with all the injuries that have been sustained the past few months to stop stars like Seth Rollins, John Cena, Randy Orton, Daniel Bryan, it really limited the options for what WWE can book for a WrestleMania main event and get away with. Compared to the endings of the last two Royal Rumbles, this choice was one that fans accepted and, for that, was a good call.

2. Kevin Owens' Night

What a night Kevin Owens had. To start, he had a 20+ minute brutal Last Man Standing match with Dean Ambrose and took a dangerous bump to the outside crashing through a table for the finish. That's quite a feat for the 250+ pounder, but his night didn't end there. He draws number 18 in the Royal Rumble Match and, selling the signs of wear and tear from the show-opener, proceeds to enter the fray and immediately goes after the WWE's newest member of the roster, AJ Styles. The two exchanged right hands for several seconds before Owens gained the upper hand and, much to the chagrin of the Orlando crowd, eliminated The Phenomenal One. Not to be outdone, Sami Zayn then joins the Rumble just two participants later at number 20, and in one of the hotter moments of the match, the two real-life best friends found themselves stealing the spotlight in a WWE Royal Rumble Match. What a moment for those two young men to share and it was well deserved, and well done as the crowd supported Zayn when he tossed his on-screen rival over the top rope and onto the floor, officially ending Kevin Owens' long night. Despite losing both of the matches he was in, Owens was made to look like a star and now has two potential future opponents of which WWE fans seem to be anticipating with great excitement.

1. AJ Styles

Well, many fans knew it was coming but that didn't temper their reaction. Like Triple H at number 30, the Orlando crowd had a pretty good idea that AJ Styles would be making an appearance in the Royal Rumble. Giving Styles the #3 spot insured his introduction in front of an energetic crowd, and gave him a chance to shine not only against the reigning WWE Champion, in which he more than held his own, but it also allowed The Phenomenal One an opportunity to be the feature Rumble participant for the next half hour. Oh and that theme song? Sounded pretty cool and definitely presented AJ as a star. As unrealistic as it may have been considering Vince McMahon's booking style of talents made famous elsewhere, many fans had hoped for AJ victory to win the Royal Rumble like Ric Flair did from the number 3 spot in 1992, the last time the title was on the line in this match. Although things didn't work out the same way for Styles in the 2016 Royal Rumble, the company gave him an opportunity and Styles more than delivered, generating the biggest reaction of the night.

Contributor
Contributor

A former stuntman for Paramount Pictures, Matt enjoys sports, water skiing, driving fast, the beach, professional wrestling, technology, and scotch. At the same time, whenever possible. Having attended many famous (and infamous) shows including WrestleMania XV, In Your House: Mind Games, and the 1995 King of the Ring, Matt has been a lifelong professional sports and wrestling fan. Matt's been mentioned in numerous wrestling podcasts including the Steve Austin Show: Unleashed, Talk Is Jericho, and Something To Wrestle With Bruce Prichard. As a former countywide performer, Matt has been referred to as Mr. 300 for his amazing accomplishments in the world of amateur bowling. He is also the only man on record to have pitched back-to-back no hitters in the Veterans Stadium Wiffle Ball League of 2003.