5 Stars Who Returned To WWE After Suing Them

Some big names here including a husband and wife duo that came back post lawsuit.

The recent news about CM Punk having his lawyers send a 22 page letter to WWE about his royalties got us thinking about other wrestlers that have sued WWE. Punk didn't sue WWE yet. It was merely a long letter because he felt like he was owed money. If things get complicated then perhaps it will turn into a lawsuit, but for now everything is civil. There have been several big names that have sued WWE only to return. It's proof that Vince McMahon is a forgiving man in some cases. If anybody knows how crazy the wrestling business can be, it's Vince. Somebody might feel one way while they're on the road for years, then they get home for a year two, miss the WWE life and do what they can to come back home. It might happen for Punk too. You never know. It takes a lot for somebody to sue WWE. Anybody that sues them knows that McMahon's got high powered attorneys that can handle anything so it would tough to beat WWE. The courts really have a tough time dealing with it because WWE can always just say they're entertainment and that everything they do is for that reason. It also goes without saying that WWE is a very smart organization. It's why they're so successful. Here's a look at five superstars that ended up working for WWE in some capacity after they sued them.

5. "Superstar" Billy Graham

Superstar Billy Graham was known as one of the most muscular and charismatic wrestlers ever. He's also had a tumultuous relationship with WWE. He was also a WWWF Champion back in 1977 and held the title for nearly a year. During the steroid distribution trial that Vince McMahon and WWE went through in 1994, Graham ended up suing McMahon and Dr. George Zahorian for forcing him to take steroids in order for Graham to remain in a top spot. Keep in mind that Graham was active through the 1970s and into the early 1980s. This trial was in 1994. It seemed like a bit of a reach. His lawsuit failed big time. A big reason it failed is because he was using steroids for about a decade before he even got to WWE. That was obvious. Just look at the guy. When Graham got back in the good graces of WWE in the early 2000s, he told WWE Confidential in 2003 that he was just bitter about a lot of things and that he was an innovator of steroid use in WWE. Ten years after Graham sued WWE, he was inducted in their Hall of Fame in 2004.

4. Jerry "The King" Lawler

Jerry Lawler billed himself as "The King" of wrestling during his prime mostly in the Memphis, Tennessee area. He was a booker, promoter and top star from the 1970s and 1980s until he became a regular in WWE in the early 1990s. He was actually working in Memphis still while he was in WWE too. The reason Lawler sued WWE was because stared their own "King of Wrestling" type of gimmick with Harley Race in 1986. Race was a huge star working outside of WWE, so Vince McMahon figured it would be a good way to bring him into the company. Apparently Lawler didn't like it especially when WWE was in Tennessee and he ended up suing them. Here's how Lawler explained it: "I filed a lawsuit when they ran a show in Jackson, Tennessee. I sued Vince McMahon and the WWE for trademark infringement, claiming I was the king of wrestling in the state of Tennessee. And I actually won the case. I think Vince really respected that. It didn't make him mad. I think he got a kick out of it." There are no details about how much he sued WWE for and how much they paid him, but they still kept on using the king gimmick in WWE for a few years after that. Randy Savage was the heel Macho King too. Of course once Lawler showed up in WWE he had a natural feud with Bret Hart when he was the inaugural King of the Ring in 1993.

3. Sable

Sable was the most popular diva in WWE during her initial run in the company from 1996 to 1999. Initially she was brought in as a valet for Hunter Hearst Helmsley, but then they joined her husband at the time, Marc Mero, as his valet. As time went on, she started to show more skin and became very popular on her own. She was a ratings draw as well as somebody that male fans absolutely loved. In June of 1999, she initially sued WWE for $110 million although that number became much smaller. Here's what it said in the AP story about it: "Pro wrestling champion Sable is suing the World Wrestling Federation for $110 million, complaining it wanted her to participate in a lesbian storyline, expose her breasts on TV and appear in sexually degrading photos. The lawsuit, filed Thursday in federal court, charges that professional wrestling has become increasingly obscene, titillating, vulgar and unsafe." No details were released about the lawsuit although they settled in August of 1999. Apparently things weren't that bad because Sable was brought back to the company four years later. She returned to WWE for about a year from April 2003 to August 2004. Her return surprised a lot of people because it was so rare to see somebody brought back after they sued WWE, but there she was five years after her lawsuit. A few years after that she married Brock Lesnar, who she met during her return to the company, and the couple has two sons together.

2. The Ultimate Warrior

There were a number of legal battles between The Ultimate Warrior and WWE in the last twenty years. Most of the battles had to do with Warrior's name. They had legal issues because both sides felt that they owned the Warrior and Ultimate Warrior characters. From WWE's perspective, they created the gimmick. From Warrior's side of it, he's the one that was the Ultimate Warrior so he felt like he owned the rights to it. Warrior ended up winning and the courts said that Warrior was legally entitled to use the gimmick, costuming, face paint designs, and mannerisms of the "Warrior" character. He ended up legally changing his name to Warrior too. Warrior also sued WWE in 2006 after their DVD release titled The Self-Destruction of the Ultimate Warrior criticized him heavily to the point that they made fun of him for a lot of things that he did. Three years later the lawsuit was dismissed probably because WWE could argue it was just part of the show. The Ultimate Warrior returned to WWE in 2013 as part of the WWE 2K14 video game. He was also inducted into WWE's Hall of Fame in 2014. The next night he appeared on Raw and day after that he died of a heart attack. It's a sad story although it was nice to know that he had mended fences with WWE.

1. Brock Lesnar

The current WWE World Heavyweight Champion Brock Lesnar sued WWE in 2006 because they prevented him from working elsewhere. Lesnar quit the company in 2004 even though he had a long term contract and WWE felt like if he wasn't going to work for them then there was nobody else that would be allowed to employ him either. Lesnar's lawyers claimed that it wasn't fair. Here's how Lesnar's lawyers stated their case in 2006: "Lesnar now desires to work and earn a living in the only occupation for which he has been trained and which he knows, professional wrestling, and/or the occupation for which his physical gifts and training as an amateur wrestler make him particularly well suited, professional combat sports." WWE wasn't shy about taking shots at Lesnar. This is from their lawyer Jerry McDevitt: "He didn't have two nickels to rub together before he met the WWE. He's basically asking a judge to rewrite his settlement agreement. We don't think we've been dealt fairly by this man from day one." The lawsuit ended up getting dismissed in June of 2006. Lesnar was able to work elsewhere. After doing some wrestling and MMA in Japan, he went to UFC in February 2008, had a lot of success there and became one of their biggest draws ever. As we all know, Lesnar came back to WWE in 2012. Two years after his return, he ended The Undertaker's WrestleMania streak at 21 wins and he also beat John Cena for the WWE Title at SummerSlam.

In this post: 
Sable
 
Posted On: 
Contributor
Contributor

John wrote at WhatCulture from December 2013 to December 2015. It was fun, but it's over for now. Follow him on Twitter @johnreport. You can also send an email to mrjohncanton@gmail.com with any questions or comments as well.