5 Ups & 3 Downs From WWE SmackDown (4 Oct - Results & Review)
AJ Styles returns; WWE's road to Bad Blood has dumpsters and ladders.
It didn't make the cut because it was a blink-and-you'll-miss-it teaser, but there's a solid chance that vignette on SmackDown was hype for Motor City Machine Guns duo Alex Shelley and Chris Sabin. If so (most online are 99.9% certain), then the ex-TNA tandem will add a ton to the blue brand's doubles division.
Reigning champs Tama Tonga and Tonga Loa will be watching. They ended the episode as champs following a typically spot-heavy ladder bout vs. The Street Profits and DIY. It was a wild ride, and the kind MCMG would love to be part of. Soon, gentlemen. Soon. First up, R-KO will presumably get the title nod.
Friday's SmackDown was akin to a two-hour Kickoff for Bad Blood. There were several hype packages, most of the biggest stars were absent, and WWE put on a flurry of entertaining enough attractions featuring those who didn't make the PLE cut. That's fair enough, but it would've been lovely to see Triple H bless Nashville with a bit more star power.
They did get the return of AJ Styles, in fairness. Keeping an eye on his developing worked health issues should be interesting.
Here's all the good and bad!
Downs...
3. Nothing For Roman Or Cody?!
There's a caveat to this moan.
WWE did complete the build towards their Bad Blood tag match before reaching Tennessee, but it would've been nice to have something from Roman Reigns or Cody Rhodes on the show. They were conspicuous by their twin absence despite being part of SmackDown's biggest match on the next PLE, and any show without the pair of them is going to feel less than.
That's just the way it is. It felt kinda weird that Cody didn't even drop by to cut a promo or take in the main event ladder bout. Literally anything would've been better than the awkward glances from fans about where exactly the two biggest babyfaces on Friday nights were. Maybe they did a Dennis Stamp and spat the dummy because they weren't booked.
People are pretty used to Roman taking days off, but Rhodes is a workhorse. Granted, Triple H doesn't need to necessarily cram every major star he can think off on broadcasts every single week, but...there were far too many big names missing from this one.
2. This Didn’t Help Either!
Yeah, see?
Even Kevin Owens and Randy Orton were posted missing from SmackDown. That bruised the lineup just a little too much, especially when R-KO has been a heavy presence in Cody's story and will probs be expected to work with Tama Tonga and Tonga Loa soon. Wouldn't they fancy watching the main event ladder match up close?!
Look, some will read this and think it's a disgruntled fan reaching for 'Downs'. It's understandable if things come across that way, but it's more fan disappointment than anything else. It sucks to tune into SmackDown and realise that Roman Reigns, Cody Rhodes, Kevin Owens and Randy Orton (all top stars) aren't even in the building.
WWE had a PLE to promote here, so you'd think at least one of those dudes would show up to feed into Bad Blood shenanigans or drop a hint at what's coming after Saturday's show. Nope. Suppose the silver lining is that other names got to shine, but the star power chasm was too vast.
1. Ye Olde Loser Before Winner Gimmick
One of WWE's most annoying tropes over the years has been tearing someone down before they're suddenly about to experience great success. That's the way Tiffany Stratton's loss to Naomi came across. It's irritating that Triple H chooses to continue this unwanted Vince McMahon tradition.
The match wasn't bad at all technically, and the best workers can overcome losses, but man - strap a rocket to Stratton already. There are some worrying signs with her character development right now. She should be a priority, yet doesn't come across as one, and Trips seemingly wants to portray her as someone content to get bullied by Nia Jax.
There's an upside to that which will be explored shortly.
It's impossible to give the Naomi vs. Stratton match result anything other than a 'Down' though. They worked hard, but this felt like an apology win to Naomi from creative for losing the chance to challenge for the Women's Title. Again, not cool when Tiffany is Money In The Bank holder.
Ups...
5. That Tiffany Tension
Behold the good side of Tiffy's work right now.
Bayley pointed out that she's a definite threat to Nia Jax, but so is Stratton 'cause she holds the key to rip Nia's title away in an instant: Money In The Bank. This isn't anything fans didn't know before, no. However, it's wise to keep hammering home that Tiffany has the means to slap Jax in the face.
Some of Nia's dirty looks through all of this were spectacular. WWE might be fudging Stratton's win/loss record for reasons only known to themselves, but things between her and Jax are reaching boiling point. They've got a good dynamic together, although it's fair to say Tiffany could do with shouting back a little more.
Bayley's promo presented her as someone who wants to defend the traditions of female wrestling against Nia's bullying, and gave a wink towards Stratton cashing in MITB at Bad Blood on whomever wins. Segments that achieve multiple things in one go = good.
4. The Dumpster Gimmick Does Heavy Lifting
Michin and Chelsea Green have worked super-hard to make something of their mini-feud. Unfortunately, WWE didn't really meet them halfway before Friday's 'Dumpster Match' suddenly popped into view. Creative should count their blessings that both women were right up for it, and that they've got someone who excels in comedy spots like Green.
She's happy to clown herself for everyone's entertainment. What a woman.
The 'Dumpster' bout was a fine midcard sideshow that ticked the box on laughs and drama. Michin looked good here, but it remains to be seen whether or not Triple H will continue pushing her or if she'll be able to properly connect with the audience. Being brutally honest, she hasn't thus far; not without someone like Bayley by her side.
This match definitely deserves an 'up' for effort and entertainment, right enough. Chelsea's agonised facials proved to be a highlight, and there was enough from Piper Niven around ringside to keep things interesting. Michin fought back against the numbers to score the win and keep her busy.
3. AJ Styles Returns
SmackDown opened with a smiling AJ Styles return.
It's legit awesome to see AJ back on WWE TV for the first time in a minute. He teased a retirement storyline over the summer, and it looks like that's set to continue through the latter months of 2024. Why not? There's plenty left in the tale, and it gives Styles some purpose on shows beyond 'stalwart veteran who wrestles good'.
Nashville's wrestling faithful were delighted to see AJ kick off the night. Being interrupted by a young buck (steady) like Carmelo Hayes will only keep wheels spinning on Styles' growing frustrations with how things are going in his career too. That moment was also in-character for a sh*t disturber like Hayes.
Some on social media seem upset that country music singer HARDY was flown in to do his thing and welcome Styles back. For the life of him, this writer isn't sure why. If anything, giving AJ that sort of entrance only made his comeback even more special. Everything about this worked.
2. A Stoppage That WORKED!
Remarkably, so did a referee stoppage.
You certainly don't get to say that very often, eh?! Praising a match stoppage can be hard to justify, but there's a bigger story at play. Namely, AJ's body giving up on him when he still needs it to function as it did before. Commentary talking about Styles' TNA days must be part of this narrative too. Good. It should be.
Hmm, maybe AJ needs a surprise TNA run to get him going again? That'd be tasty if Triple H can work if out with the folks down at Impact. Back on WWE's side, the match between Styles and Carmelo Hayes was fine before Charles Robinson triggered the story-based finish. There's loads of potential for more to come between these two.
Here's hoping WWE don't have LA Knight and AJ Styles team up though. That wouldn't fit either man's character, and it'd spit right in the face of a heated rivalry they worked earlier in the year. Keep 'em separate, and keep deep diving on AJ's physical struggles after decades of toil.
1. Enjoyable Main Event Carnage
Everyone knew what they were in for when WWE announced this three-way ladder match pitting The Bloodline vs. DIY vs. The Street Profits. It proved to be a fun ride through some familiar spots. To harp on that point, this was nothing you haven't seen a million times over, but sometimes you just need to kick back and watch some stunts.
This was a fine way to put a bow on DIY and the Profits challenging Tama Tonga and Tonga Loa.
It's also sweet to see Tama and Loa retain, 'cause it would've been silly to take the belts from them right now. That'll be a useful title switch once Roman Reigns starts chipping into Solo Sikoa's armour and tearing down his own self-styled version of a group Roman created from scratch. Keep it in your back pocket, Hunter.
The three-way ladder match deservedly headlined this week's show. Whilst it would've been nice to have some bigger stars on hand, all six of these guys delivered what was asked of them without hesitation. Nobody froze in a featured spot. Not even Tonga Loa (no matter what X says to the contrary!).
What did you think of this week's WWE SmackDown? For more like this, check out 10 DUMB WWE Face Turns (We Didn't Want To Admit Were GENIUS!) and 10 Times You Didn't Realise Wrestlers Were Saying 'Goodbye'!