5 Ups & 4 Downs From AEW Dark (Sep 29)
Dissension in The Dark Order, Tay Conti, Nyla Rose, and more.
All Elite Wrestling switched things up with this week's episode of Dark, attempting to present the nine-match card as something more than the usual run of samey squash matches by incorporating several storylines. They have done this before, of course, and the format rarely lasts, though the twist was welcome. Consuming this typically dry show on a weekly basis gets tiresome.
That isn't to say there wasn't room for a handful of textbook Dark pseudo squashes, though. Last night had several, and their effectiveness was as varied as ever, particularly in the tag division.
Ricky Starks has been a complementary presence in the commentary booth lately and earned an eight-match run last night, replacing the guesting Shawn Spears after the opening bout. He did a good job as usual, though it helps that he has built-in chemistry with Taz and is generally one of AEW's slickest talkers, easing the transition.
It was a rough night for The Dark Order, who experienced misfortune in two separate tag matches. Elsewhere, SoCal Uncensored warmed up for tonight's Tag Team Title shot, while Nyla Rose, Tay Conti, Best Friends, and more worked showcase spots. Let's light the fuse...
Downs...
4. Best Friends vs. M'Badu & BSHP King
Best Friends completionists need only apply here. This wasn't a bad match, but it didn't bring anything new to the table either, with Trent and Chuck Taylor working their typical Dark bout.
Such matches are typically a little too long and lack the variety required to hook a more casual viewer. M'Badu looked power and explosive in defeat, entering a solid performance, but regular viewers have seen dozens of matches like this since Dark turned into Squash Match City. Skip.
3. Chaos Project vs. Brian Pillman Jr. & Griff Garrison
Preceded by a nonsensical promo in which Luther and Serpentico babbled about being born evil, or whatever, this match started with Chaos Project's smaller man launching his streamers at Pillman Jr. and Garrison, getting tangled up in them in the process. This led to him working the opening stages covered in paper, like a technicolour mummy.
There was little to sink your teeth into here. Chaos Project are trying to forge an identity but struggling to find their voice, despite the promo, and they aren't particularly engaging stylistically either.
Luther and Serp took the win via Doomsday Meteora.
2. Penelope Ford vs. Alex Gracia
Wrestling Penelope Ford may have been seen as something of a tryout for Alex Gracia, who wrestles out of Texas but has experience working in Mexico and Japan. If it was, it wasn't a particularly successful one, as Gracia was given little opportunity to show what she can do.
This was a mechanical squash with a few clunky moments. It looked like the wrestlers' timing was off by a few milliseconds on several occasions, so they struggled for cohesion. A shame, really, as moments like Ford snapping Gracia's throat up into the top rope looks great. The individual pieces just didn't come together.
Ford was in complete control throughout, eventually putting Gracia away with her Fisherman Suplex.
1. Gunn Club vs. Cezar Bononi & Shawn Dean
Former NXT wrestler Cezar Bononi debuted for Dark months after first appearing in an AEW crowd, having failed to make a lasting impression in WWE. It's rare that the talent themselves can be blamed for this, so deep is WWE's developmental pool, though she showed little here to suggest that he'd be an essential AEW pickup.
These Gunn Club matches exist to get Austin valuable experience, as he's still very green. They rarely break out of first gear, let alone second or third, and this was the case here as well, with Billy eventually scoring the win via Fame Asser.
Ups...
5. Nyla Rose vs. Rache Chanel
Rache Chanel hasn't looked great in longer squashes, so it's fortunate that AEW kept her bout with Nyla Rose relatively brief.
'The Native Beast' dropped a couple of big bombs early and appeared to have the match won. She pulled out of a pinfall at two, however, allowing Chanel a route back into the match, through which she landed a few hits of her own, including accidentally booting a camera. Her offensive spell lasted only a few seconds, however, as she was eventually flattened via Beast Bomb.
Simple, short, and one-sided enough to be effective, this was all it needed to be. Rose needs to crush people in this manner on a more regular basis.
4. SoCal Uncensored vs. Ray Rosas & Ryzin
Ostensibly a warm-up match for tonight's Tag Team Title match on Dynamite, it was cool to see AEW's first champions back in action here, as Frankie Kazarian and Scorpio Sky reunited to face Ryzin and the debuting Ray Rosas.
Sky's future lies in the singles ranks, as we've been told over the past few months. His next move was signposted by Shawn Spears' presence on commentary. Spears was scouting the SCU man after getting chased away by him following a win over Matt Sydal on Late Night Dynamite. The duo had a staredown after the bell, which may lead to 'The Chairman' getting involved tonight.
This ended up being a well-worked contest with flashes of life from the enhancement talents, building to Rosas taking the pin after eating a rising knee strike.
3. Tay Conti vs. Red Velvet
Tay Conti scored her first AEW singles victory over Red Velvet and looked good in doing so, showing flashes of potential in her showcase spot.
Conti is clearly very dedicated to this. There are incremental improvements in her work every time out, most notably in the striking department, where she appears to be living up to her climbs of diving into the Tomohiro Ishii vs. Katsuyori Shibata feud as research. She worked with pop and snap and of course, her martial arts experience gives her a unique stylistic flavour.
Anna Jay cheered her partner on from ringside, hitting the ring after Velvet had been submitted. This led to Brandi Rhodes chasing the duo off to seemingly established a tag bout - potentially for next week's Dark.
2. Jurassic Express vs. 5 & 10
5 & 10 are The Dark Order's lowest unit now that John Silver and Alex Reynolds have levelled up. The thing about this stable, though, is that they're all good-to-great wrestlers, as the wrestlers formerly known as Alan Angels and Preston Vance demonstrated here.
This was a fun, fast-paced, and exciting back-and-forth in the early stages, with Luchasaurus beefing his opponents around before Jungle Boy got the tag. The younger man took the heat for a while, building to the hot tag, and while the Order scored a good near-fall off a Powerslam and Frog Splash, 5 ended up taking the defeat.
Luchasaurus entered a strong performance here, continuing his recent run of great form.
1. John Silver & Colt Cabana vs. The Natural Nightmares
A clear highlight of the night inside the ring and out, this was all about furthering the tension between Colt Cabana and the rest of The Dark Order.
Colt keeps costing his stable victories. John Silver addressed this with Evil Uno backstage, with Uno urging Silver to trust his judgment, asserting that Cabana could become an integral part of their group. It all bled into the ring as Uno attempted to coach Cabana from ringside and John bossed him around. They were able to overcome their issues late on, taking control of the bout and seemingly edging towards victory, before miscommunication led to Colt screwing up a double team move and costing his side another win.
The right outcome, and The Dark Order got the "lack of chemistry" story over well. Dustin Rhodes deserves a nod, too: this was a strong, high-effort performance from the veteran, who even flew from the apron with a flipping Senton... on Dark!
Legend.