5 Ups & 5 Downs For AEW Collision (Dec 2 - Results & Review)

Some excellent wrestling amidst some other more questionable calls.

AEW Collision Bryan Danielson Eddie Kingston
AEW

Another week, another AEW Collision in the books.

This was a strange ol' episode of Collision, for it featured some exceptional in-ring action yet also had several moments that left you scratching your head.

With the Continental Classic continuing to rumble on, the Blackpool Combat Club's Claudio Castagnoli squared off against House of Black's Brody King, Andrade El Idolo took on Daniel Garcia, and Bryan Danielson and Eddie Kingston were on main event duties. As expected due to the names involved, all three of those matches delivered and delivered big.

Elsewhere, Kiera Hogan and Abadon paired off in Collision's standard solo women's bout, Malakai Black and Buddy Matthews battled Christopher Daniels and Matt Sydal, the Iron Savages went up against the Kingdom, and there was an impromptu bout between El Hijo del Vikingo and Kip Sabian.

For the most part, it was away from the actual wrestling on display where this week's Collision faltered, with certain familiar issues raising their head yet again, making this a frustrating mixed bag of an episode; so much of it great, so much of it questionable.

With all of that in mind, then, Saturday night's alright for fighting...


Downs...

5. "One Of The Great Tag Teams"?

AEW Collision Matt Sydal Christopher Daniels
AEW

Clearly, part of Tony Schiavone's job is to make everything feel like as big of a deal as possible. Still, describing Christopher Daniels and Matt Sydal as "one of the great tag teams" is just absolutely ridiculous.

Both Daniels and Sydal are well travelled veterans with a ton of credit in the bank amongst savvy wrestling fans, but Schiavone's comments - made during the opening Claudio Castagnoli vs. Brody King match as Tony hyped what was coming up - were utterly insane.

Yes, this tandem had a brief run with the ROH Tag Team Titles as 2006 rolled into 2007, but this supposed all-timer of a team have only tagged together 24 times dating back to '06. And in an AEW TV context, Daniels and Sydal had only teamed up three previous times; three matches which all resulted in losses. Even if you look at modern-day Ring of Honor, this "great" pairing has been on the receiving end of defeats to the Righteous, the Gunns, the Kingdom, the Gates of Agony, Aussie Open, and El Hijo del Vikingo and Komander here in 2023.

Hyperbole is part of the job when it comes to professional wrestling, but Tony Schiavone bordered on the ludicrous with this one.


4. Why Even Bother...

AEW Collision Kiera Hogan Abadon
AEW

AEW Collision will usually feature just one sole women's match, which tends to run for eight minutes or so, three of which are spent in a picture-in-picture commercial break. In Collision's lifespan, the show has never featured more than one bout for the company's talented ladies, and only once - Kris Statlander vs. Britt Baker - has this Saturday offering been headlined by the AEW women.

The good news this week? That's that Abadon vs. Kiera Hogan thankfully didn't get a picture-in-picture break sandwiched in the middle of it. The bad news? Why, that's that this match got less than four minutes.

A four-minute match is fine if there was another women's match or two spread out across Collision. Unfortunately, this was it as far as the in-ring time for the AEW ladies this week. Yep, not even four minutes of ring time for the women's roster.

Having to write about the same issues each and every week for AEW Collision Ups & Downs is incredibly frustrating, but it's something that has to be called out. This problem isn't specifically a Collision one, of course, as the promotion's ladies receive the same treatment across all AEW programming; to the point, you have to ask yourself why Tony Khan even bothers with a women's division when he blatantly sees such little value in one.

As for Abadon vs. Hogan, it was about as good as you could hope for from a match that was only afforded three minutes and 41 seconds of TV time. Both ladies have plenty of upside, and this time out it was Abadon sealing the 1-2-3 after hitting the Black Dahlia, with post-match shenanigans lining Abadon up to face AEW TBS Champion Julia Hart.


3. That Joke Isn't Funny Anymore

AEW Collision Samoa Joe Roderick Strong The Kingdom
AEW

Roderick Strong is great. Mike Bennett and Matt Taven are great. The Iron Savages are a personal favourite of your writer's and have so much potential. That said, everything involving Strong and the Kingdom on this week's Collision just felt a little naff.

There's only so many times you can hear Roddy scream "Samoa", "Dasha", or "ass" before it becomes a little stale. And sadly, this whole schtick felt extremely stale on this latest Collision; not helped by the Iron Savages being put away in barely two minutes.

Whether it was the backstage interaction with Samoa Joe or the stuff with Boulder and Bronson, this is starting to feel somewhat played out for Strong and his buddies. Yes, the "Adam!" joke was funny the first few times around, but there needs to be something more by this point.

To borrow a line from The Smiths, that joke isn't funny anymore.

Having Adam Cole on the shelf clearly impacts whatever's going on with Strong, the Kingdom, and the wider story with MJF and Samoa Joe. And likewise, the ongoing Devil saga means that Roddy feels somewhat stuck in a holding pattern until that reveal is eventually made. Either way, AEW is at a very real risk of completely jumping the shark on what started as a funny 'bit'.


2. FTR Look Like Total Losers

AEW Collision FTR House of Black
AEW

Dax Harwood and Cash Wheeler are the greatest tag team in the industry. However, AEW Collision made FTR look like total losers.

After Malakai Black and Buddy Matthews had handily defeated "one of the great tag teams" in Christopher Daniels and Matt Sydal, FTR's music hits as Dax and Cash made their way to the ring to confront the House of Black duo.

Firstly, FTR looked foolish for letting their guard down after Malakai proclaimed how House of Black have had Harwood and Wheeler's back in recent times. Secondly, the totally fresh FTR then proceeded to get the absolute piss knocked out of them by a duo who'd just wrestled for nearly ten minutes. Thirdly, Black's words about FTR having no friends in the AEW locker room rang true, as not a single person could be bothered to come out and help out FTR once a beating was put on them.


1. No Stakes Filler

AEW Collision El Hijo del Vikingo Kip Sabian
AEW

El Hijo del Vikingo is obviously one of the most athletic, impressive high-flyers in the world, and Kip Sabian is another personal favourite of your writer. And while their match on Collision was absolutely fine, it just felt a little lazy from Tony Khan.

Some have questioned Khan for how he has too much of a penchant for putting on matches just for the sake of putting on matches, with no storyline, no emotional investment, and no reason for an audience to care bar for the fact that, yes, the wrestling on display is good-to-great. With the Continental Classic, that in itself allows for contests to take place without any heated rivalries or prolonged stories at play; instead, what would be cold match-ups are justified under the banner of a tournament and the will to win said tourney.

On this week's AEW Collision, Claudio Castagnoli vs. Brody King, Abadon vs. Keira Hogan, Andrade El Idolo vs. Daniel Garcia, the Kingdom vs. Iron Savages, House of Black vs. Christopher Daniels & Matt Sydal, and Bryan Danielson vs. Eddie Kingston were all largely bouts that had no personal stakes to them and weren't part of some brewing rivalry. And that's fine, particularly when three of those contests took place as part of the Continental Classic.

With that in mind, though, did we really need the addition of a no stakes match between El Hijo del Vikingo and Kip Sabian? No, not at all. This served solely as filler designed to pop the crowd with a few high spots and also eat up one of Collision's picture-in-picture breaks.

To the surprise of nobody, Vikingo got the win after hitting his 630, but could this eight minutes of bell time have been used better elsewhere? Absolutely. Hey, maybe we could've got a second women's match or Kiera Hogan and Abadon could've got more than four minutes?


Ups...

5. Pre-Titles Promos

AEW Collision Bryan Danielson
AEW

As is always the case, whenever AEW Collision starts by utilising pre-titles promos, it'll receive a customary Up from your writer.

This week, it was Brody King, Claudio Castagnoli, CJ Perry and Andrade El Idolo, Daniel Garcia, Bryan Danielson, and Eddie Kingston firing barbs and setting the table for what was to come.

So simple, but so, so effective.


4. A Perfect Opener

AEW Collision Claudio Castagnoli Brody King
AEW

Claudio Castagnoli is a freak specimen who mixes power with silky smooth technique. Brody King is low-key one of the most impressive talents in all of AEW. Opening up AEW Collision here, these two big strong boys put on a belting bout.

In most cases, an opening match should hook you in, setting the stall for what is hopefully a great show. In Castagnoli vs. King, that was absolutely the case.

This was a contest that was just a whole bunch of fun, with both men bringing different variations of the power game to the fore. Where Claudio is concerned, there's forever a Rolls-Royce sheen to that power, whereas for Brody he's just a wrecking ball of dominance when he gets going.

Strikes were the order of the day, and that always makes for a good time when that involves either of Claudio Castagnoli or Brody King. And this time, it would be the House of Black man who'd eventually emerge victorious, putting Castagnoli away in just under 13 minutes after hitting the - mildly cast-assisted - burning lariat.

As ever, it's also worth noting that Claudio has the most stunning, jaw-dropping uppercuts in the game. Seriously, just a complete work of art.


3. More Great Wrestling Action

AEW Collision Andrade El Idolo Daniel Garcia
AEW

Much like Claudio Castagnoli vs. Brody King made for some great professional wrestling, so too did Andrade El Idolo vs. Daniel Garcia.

Andrade vs. Garcia exemplifies so much of what is good about AEW. As in, great in-ring action. These two tore it up in Continental Classic competition, with El Idolo scoring the win after landing his hammerlock DDT to get the 1-2-3.

Daddy Magic provided his usual frenetic energy on commentary, imploring Garcia not to do that dance, as this all plays into furthering the dissention between these former JAS fellas. Considering how some viewed Red Death as an outside bet to win the entire Continental Classic, it's a little surprising to see him sitting on zero points after two matches, but the larger story here is about establishing the New Yorker as more of a serious wrestler than a sports entertainer. Even if he can't quite get the W over names like Andrade and Claudio, he's still showing that he can hang with two such exceptional workers.

In that regard, this match was yet another example of just how great an in-ring talent Garcia is. Holds, transitions, strikes, and plenty more were on display as the former ROH Pure Champion went toe-to-toe with one of the smoothest wrestlers on the planet. And on that front, Andrade was once again on fine form as he brought his customary crispness to everything that he does between the ropes.

This was more great pro wrestling in a tournament designed to showcase great pro wrestling. Lovely stuff.


2. Some Solid Backstage Progression

While one can question why Ethan Page has only been featured three times on AEW programming since his hometown battle with MJF on the third ever episode of Collision back in June - all three of those matches being losses, all three being doomed to AEW Rampage, and two of them being battle royals - it was at least great to see All Ego resurface on AEW TV here.

Page was featured in a backstage promo, bigging up his more recent ROH appearances and boldly throwing down the challenge to Kenny Omega for a match next week in Montreal. As always with the former North man, he brought his usual charisma to this challenge, and hopefully this is the start of more TV time for Page. Then again, this could just be a case of Tony Khan bringing the Canadian out for another Canada show, just to revert to type and banish Ethan to ROH once Montreal is out of the way...

Elsewhere, seeing Willie Mack on AEW TV was similarly a blast. Mack has long been one of the most underrated men in the game, and we now know he'll be going up against Wardlow next week. Then there was the interaction between Miro and CJ Perry, with the Bulgarian promising to stay away from Perry's new client, Andrade El Idolo; a promise that clearly won't last all that long.

Whereas the in-ring focus for AEW women's division was again incredibly frustrating on Collision, there was at least some promo time for "Timeless" Toni Storm and, later, Skye Blue. With these two gearing up to do battle over the AEW Women's Championship, Blue cut what could well be her best promo so far. As ever, of course, "Timeless" Toni was great at doing her "Timeless" Toni schtick - even if AEW needs to be extremely careful not to, like Roddy Strong, jump the shark with Storm's curent persona.

Shane Taylor was another to get some time in the spotlight, as he and Lee Moriarty confronted Keith Lee backstage. While some may quibble at AEW TV time being taken up by ROH content, the now-confirmed Taylor vs. Lee match at ROH Final Battle later this month is something that's been a long time - too long, to be honest - in the making.


1. An Excellent Main Event

AEW Collision Bryan Danielson Eddie Kingston
AEW

Where this week's AEW Collision was concerned, it was very much three for three when it comes to the Continental Classic.

While Claudio vs. King was a meshing of elegant, precise power and monstrous brute force, and Andrade vs. Garcia was more a sleek exchange of holds and a classic chess match, Bryan Danielson vs. Eddie Kingston closed out Collision with a lovely, snug war between two of the most popular performers in the company.

As is often the case with this duo, plentiful chops were the order of the day, with some of those strikes being absolutely deafening. Then there was a particularly gnarly-looking back suplex on the outside from Kingston to the American Dragon, as both men clearly felt the impact of that.

Adding to the sense of drama was the fact that Eddie had come up short against Brody King on last week's Collision, meaning the Mad King was desperate not to face a second straight Continental Classic loss, especially with his ROH Championship and NJPW Strong Openweight Championship on the line. As such, it didn't take long for Kingston to target Danielson's orbital injury as he attempted to take advantage of the bullseye painted on Bryan's face.

However, despite Eddie's best efforts, it would be Bryan Danielson who emerged victorious here, getting the pinfall win after hitting a Busaiku Knee, in turn getting the Blackpool Combat Man off the mark in the Continental Classic and cementing him as the early favourite to win the tournament.

As usual, there has to be additional props to Nigel McGuinness, who once again did a fantastic job of mocking Bryan at every turn, even shouting advice to Kingston at times, as we continue to dream of Danielson vs. McGuinness at All In next August.


Senior Writer
Senior Writer

Once described as the Swiss Army Knife of WhatCulture, Andrew can usually be found writing, editing, or presenting on a wide range of topics. As a lifelong wrestling fan, horror obsessive, and comic book nerd, he's been covering those topics professionally as far back as 2010. In addition to his current WhatCulture role of Senior Content Producer and Presenter, Andrew previously spent nearly a decade as Online Editor and Lead Writer for the world's longest-running genre publication, Starburst Magazine, and his work has also been featured on BBC, TechRadar, Tom's Guide, WhatToWatch, Sportkskeeda, and various other outlets, in addition to being a Rotten Tomatoes-approved film critic. Between his main day job, his role as lead panel host of Wales Comic Con, and his gig as a pre-match host for Wrexham AFC games, Andrew has also carried out a hugely varied amount of interviews, from the likes of Robert Englund and Eli Roth to Kevin Smith and the Russo Brothers, to Kevin Conroy and Frank Miller, to Bret Hart and Sting, to Mickey Thomas, Joey Jones, Phil Parkinson, and Brian Flynn, to many, many more. Where his beloved Wrexham AFC is concerned, Andrew is a long-standing season ticket holder and an FSA Award-winner for his time co-hosting the Fearless in Devotion podcast.