5 Ups & 8 Downs From AEW Dark (Aug 25)

AEW's B-show struggles in an overlong, botchy episode.

Vickie Guerrero Nyla Rose
AEW

It's important to temper criticism of AEW Dark every once in a while. In the Empty Arena Era, getting wrestlers that aren't guaranteed a Dynamite spot every other week as many reps as possible has become the web series' primary function. It's about building experience so that when they are needed for TNT, they're ready, which explains the match cram. Watching from start to finish every week is reserved for the hardest of the hardcore, with cherry-picking easy on YouTube.

But it's still a product put out by AEW for public consumption, making it fair game for said criticism - particularly when the concept is stretched as thin as it was this week.

Dark presented 13 matches across close to two hours, making this the longest episode since launch. That means extreme repetition. You know the drill by now, but this was the same cast of characters working roughly the same matches they have all the time, and while some performers stood out, this episode was a slog.

Highlighted performers include Lance Archer, Shawn Spears, Ricky Starks, Nyla Rose, and Jake Hager, while Veda Scott returned to the announce booth, joining Taz and Tony Schiavone.

Let's light the fuse.


Downs...

8. The Initiative vs. Serpentico & Luther

Serpentico Luther
AEW

The law of diminishing returns was in play here as The Initiative slumped to their latest defeat, falling to the revived Luther/Serpentico alliance when Peter Avalon accidentally smashed Brandon Cutler with a book, with the heels hitting their Powerbomb/Meteora combination for the win.

The work here was solid enough, though it's hard to get invested in Avalon and Cutler when they have a near-identical match every week. They work with fire for a while, lose control, and have Leva Bates interfere on their behalf, often provoking a distraction. This typically leads to them losing, as was the case here. Variety is needed if Dark fans are to stay interested in their ongoing quest for win number one.


7. Gunn Club vs. Franke Stone & Baron Black

Gunn Club
AEW

A filmed house show match. That's what this was and while such things aren't new on Dark, Gunn Club vs. Stone and Black offered little to compensate for the lax pace.

Stone stood out on last week's show but less so here. His and Black's isolation work on Austin was solid, though Billy's hot tag was lethargic and the finish didn't click either, as Austin hit his modified hip toss following a wishy-washy exchange of strikes. The younger Gunn needs these reps more than most others. He's almost a total rookie, so the missing pieces can be excused, though Gunn Club's tags aren't bringing much to the table right now.


6. Jake Hager vs. Marko Stunt

Jake Hager
AEW

Marko Stunt is a phenomenal squash match victim whose murder by Lance Archer's hand was one of the most memorable television matches of the year. Jake Hager, unfortunately, is sloth-like in his execution, leading to a largely unconvincing shellacking of the Jurassic Express man.

Where Archer was fierce, Hager was going through the motions. This has been the story of his AEW run thus far. He fizzed with life in his electric debut and the enhancement bouts preceding his AEW Title match, but disappointed against Dustin Rhodes, Jon Moxley, and Cody, barely slipping out of second gear. Here, he adopted a similar approach en route to beating Stunt.

Jungle Boy and Luchasaurus couldn't run Hager offer before he dealt further damage after the bell. Here's hoping the teased match with Luchausaurus works better.


5. Shawn Spears vs. Jessy Sorensen

shawn Spears
AEW

Shawn Spears is suffering from the same problem as The Initiative: these matches aren't bad, but it's the same thing every week. He beat Jessy Sorensen after levelling-up halfway through the match then nailed him with the loaded glove after the bell. That's all the analysis this thing warrants; you've seen it five or six times before.

It feels as though AEW is keeping Spears in a holding pattern while figuring out what to do with him going forward. Perhaps there's already a plan in place, though this repetition isn't doing anything to push him forward.


4. Penelope Ford vs. Heather Monroe

Penelope Ford Heather Monroe
AEW

Penelope Ford is one of 2020's most improved wrestlers and usually brings something entertaining to the table, no matter her opposition, though opponent Heather Monroe dealt her a poor hand last night. A confused, mistimed opening sequence, largely on the fault of the loser, dragged this down early on, and while there were flashes of character here and there (Ford kissing Kip Sabian through the ropes with Monroe in a submission), it didn't hit.

A straightforward victory for Ford, though Monroe was overmatched in every sense of the word.


3. Best Friends vs. Demetri Jackson & Storm Thomas

Best Friends
AEW

Solid action, as Best Friends defeated newcomers Storm Thomas and Demetri Jackson to open the show, though the layout made little sense.

Best Friends are gearing up for a Tag Team Title contendership gauntlet match on Dynamite. Giving them a win ahead of that was a smart move, but they are second only to FTR in the rankings and will enter the gauntlet in a privileged position as a result of this. Also, they competed for the belts a few weeks ago. They're one of the top teams in the company, and yet they swung momentum back and forth with a couple of jobbers, who enjoyed an even share of the offense.

That shouldn't be the case. There should be tiers. AEW's rankings system exists to create these, so it's frustrating when the framework is ignored.


2. Nyla Rose vs. KiLynn King

Nyla Rose KiLynn King
AEW

It feels like the Nyla Rose/Vickie Guerrero alliance was forgotten about as soon as the latter debuted as 'The Native Beast's' manager, with Rose not working a single Dynamite match since then. Last night was only her second bout with Guerrero by her side, period, and it was married by shoddy execution against an enhancement talent whose performances have varied greatly since she was brought into the rotation.

One great-looking Samoan Drop aside, this wasn't particularly convincing. The finish was the most egregious part, with Vickie shoving King from the top rope, allowing Nyla to hit her Beast Bomb. This might get heat in an attended arena, but Rose has a two-minute handicap win over King and Kenzie Paige to her name already. Why would she need the interference here?


1. Mel vs. Red Velvet

Mel Red Velvet
AEW

This squash was worked in molasses. It was a sleepy, unengaging monster vs. jobber match that started with Mel barely walking Red Velvet down in the corner, eating some token offense, running through her own basic moveset, before taking the win.

The right layout, though it wasn't well-performed. Mel is slow. She attempts to project dominance but is never imposing or fearsome, no matter the opponent. Running through somebody as small as Velvet should be an easy layup but while the former Nightmare Collective bruiser got the ball through the hoop eventually, it took several attempts.


Ups...

5. Santana & Oritz vs. The Metro Brothers

Santana AEW
AEW

The Metro Brothers have worked a couple of guest spots in NXT over the past few years, though they've largely struggled to break out on the independent circuit between those, working primarily in the southern states. Here, Chris and JC were effective victims for Santana and Ortiz to run through.

The Inner Circle men are at their best when they get nasty. They didn't straight-up smash the Metros but they were solid throughout, cruising past them with minimal fuss en route to a quick, elevatory victory.


4. Franke Kazarian vs. Kip Sabian

Kip Sabian
AEW

A very solid match, here. That's what Frankie Kazarian gives you. He's an excellent veteran wrestler who understands his role and usually does more than enough to make things interesting on Dark, where he has slotted into a regular role as SoCal Uncensored slip out of the spotlight.

This was above Kip Sabian's usual output, though he is improving. The character is coming together nicely, with 'Superbad' presented as Penelope Ford's secondary, not the other way around, and he worked well here. He came within a hair of winning after heading to the top rope following a Ford interference through he fell in the end, eating Kazarian's modified DDT finisher.


3. Sonny Kiss & Joey Janela vs. The Hybrid 2

Jack Evans Sonny Kiss
AEW

Dark's main event was essentially a series of fun, exciting spots that weren't always stitched together well, leaving a few pedestrian moments between them. This prevents us from slapping a particularly strong recommendation on it, though fun, exciting spots were more than welcome on a show like this, where genuine adrenaline sparks were few and far between.

It was interesting to see Jack Evans and Angelico pick up the win here as one would usually expect them to fall to the younger tandem. Nonetheless, it was earned. Janela was neutralised by the end, preventing him from intervening as Evans wrapped Kiss up, scoring the pinfall.


2. Ricky Starks vs. Shawn Dean

Ricky Starks
AEW

Few AEW wrestlers are as much fun to watch as Ricky Starks at the moment, whose good run continued with a solid squash win over Shawn Dean.

Starks' mastery of the little things in professional wrestling prevents tedium from creeping into this familiar format. Charisma aside, he's not the kind of wrestler who always catches the eye immediately because the things he does well are fundamental, not supplementary. He's great at selling, laying a match out, and imposing his cocky character on his ring work, and while he can dazzle when he needs to, he typically spaces those spots out, only breaking them out every now and then.

A smart strategy that prevents burnout and overexposure, with this a nice victory ahead of his inevitable clash with Darby Allin.


1. Lance Archer vs. D3

Lance Archer jobber
AEW

Lance Archer is the Dark benchmark.

He's the guy everyone else who wrestles on this show every week should be looking to as an example. Like them, he essentially works the same style of match each time out, beating jobbers with very little resistance. What separates 'The Murderhawk Monster' from Shawn Spears and The Initiative, however, is his ability to switch things up, tweaking his layout just enough to maintain effectiveness and prevent extreme repetition from kicking in, as he did against D3.

This one saw Lance get fired up after screaming at D3 to hit him, pull out of a pinfall after a Chokeslam at two, gouge the eyes, and thwart a doomed comeback to win via Blackout and EBD Claw. Good stuff.


Channel Manager
Channel Manager

Andy has been with WhatCulture for 10 years and is currently WhatCulture's Wrestling Channel Manager. A writer, presenter, and editor with 10+ years of experience in online media, he has been a sponge for all wrestling knowledge since playing an old Royal Rumble 1992 VHS to ruin in his childhood. Having previously worked for Bleacher Report, Andy specialises in short and long-form writing, video presenting, voiceover acting, and editing, all characterised by expert wrestling knowledge and commentary. Andy is as much a fan of 1985 Jim Crockett Promotions as he is present-day AEW and WWE - just don't make him choose between the two.