5 WWE Smackdown Draft Picks That Ruled (And 5 That Sucked)

The blue brand weren't ALWAYS short-changed, but when they were...

The wrestling world is still buzzing at the news that the draft split is returning, meaning exclusive rosters for Raw and Smackdown, with title belts set to be exclusive to particular shows and the probably introduction of a new, secondary World Title. This is all exciting stuff, as it marks the first time the brand extension has been in effect since August 2011.

The draft is scheduled to take place sometime in June/July, before Smackdown goes live (another business-changing proposition). Despite going live, Smackdown has some reason to be worried heading into the draft. After all, tape delay or no, WWE have always perceived it as being the 'B' show to Raw's 'A' show.

That's something that has been reflected in previous drafts, as Smackdown were routinely stripped of their top stars without fair compensation. it's a story that played out time and time again, as the blue brand fought an uphill battle against its red counterpart.

Of course, Smackdown wasn't always shafted. On the contrary, many draft picks ended up helping the show in big ways. But it was inconsistent and happened with far less frequency than the producers, writers and other talent of the show would have liked.

With the spotlight on Smackdown due to the announcement that it is soon to be airing live, coupled with the blockbuster news that a draft split will once again be in effect, let's take a look at 5 Smackdown draft picks that ruled and five that sucked.


5 That Ruled...

5. Chris Benoit (2005)

Chris Benoit 2005 Draft
WWE

Since returning from major neck surgery in the spring of 2002, The Rabid Wolverine had started out on Raw (despite being drafted to Smackdown), then moved to the blue brand with Eddie Guerrero a few months later, before moving back to Raw in February 2004 after winning the Royal Rumble and deciding to challenge World Heavyweight Champion Triple H instead of then-WWE Champion Brock Lesnar.

There was a lot of loopholin' going on here, folks.

Benoit was a standout on Raw for the first year or so he performed there, but he had dropped down the card somewhat by the time the spring of 2005 rolled around. He'd wrestled pretty much everyone of note, having great programmes opposite Edge, Triple H, Shawn Michaels, Chris Jericho and so on. It was obvious that it was time for a change of scenery once more.

The Canadian Crippler was the first choice draft pick in the 2005 draft (where one wrestler moved shows every week) and he immediately entered into a feud with United States Champion Orlando Jordan, winning the belt at SummerSlam. From there, he contested feuds with the likes of Booker T, JBL, Randy Orton, Finlay and Chavo Guerrero, all of which were somewhat fresh and rewarding, before fully embracing the 'grizzled veteran' role in matches opposite the Ken Kennedys and MVPs of the world.

Benoit was great for Smackdown, viewed back then very much as the 'wrestling show', as he could always be counted on to produce a great match and act as a mentor to the younger talent.


4. Jeff Hardy (2008)

WWE.com

The Charismatic Enigma returned to WWE in August 2006 after a near three-and-a-half year absence from the company. Jeff returned on Raw, where he had wrestled exclusively in the wake of the 2002 draft until his firing in April 2003. The talented star immediately set about capturing Johnny Nitro's Intercontinental Title.

Following his inevitable IC triumph and subsequent defeat, Jeff began tagging once more with brother Matt, before his burgeoning popularity and consistently high performance level convinced WWE management to book the Rainbow-Haired Warrior in a WWE Title programme with Randy Orton in early 2008.

He was unsuccessful in his quest, but would capture the 'big one' soon enough, once he was drafted over to Smackdown in the summer 2008 draft. Jeff was a top star on the blue show and had a great series of matches with Triple H and Edge, capturing the WWE Title in a triple threat match at Armageddon 2008.

Jeff was great for Smackdown as he was so over and was regularly having good matches against all comers. His feuds with Edge, CM Punk and, to a lesser extent, Matt Hardy in 2009 were all rewarding. Importantly, when it was time to leave he went out on top, as the most popular star on Smackdown in a red-hot feud with Punk.

He lost his final Smackdown (and final WWE) match to the Straight-Edge Superstar in the cage match main event of the August 28th, 2009 episode of the show.


3. Rey Mysterio (2009)

Rey Mysterio 619 Chris Jericho Smackdown 2009
WWE.com

Rey Mysterio is synonymous with Smackdown, having wrestled on the show for the majority of his WWE career.

From his WWE television debut in July of 2002 until he was drafted to Raw in June 2008, Rey was an ever-present on the blue show. He flourished there, tearing it up in the cruiserweight division and with the so-called 'Smackdown Six' before becoming a main eventer in 2006.

His brief scenery change in 2008 didn't really help him much, although he did win the Intercontinental Championship for the first time in his career (at WrestleMania XXV), making him a WWE Triple Crown winner in the process. The masked man went back 'home' in April 2009, which would lead to one of his best ever years inside the squared circle.

Rey was one of, if not the, best wrestler in the world throughout 2009. His lengthy feud with Chris Jericho, which saw superlative matches at Judgement Day, Extreme Rules, The Bash and Smackdown itself, was a joy to watch. His matches after that, against the likes of Dolph Ziggler and John Morrison, were also first-rate.

Following a 60-day suspension for violation of the Wellness Policy, Mysterio slotted right back in at the top of the card in feuds with Batista, The Undertaker and CM Punk. Despite needing major knee surgery and continually putting it off and working through the pain, Rey was the most consistent wrestler on any of WWE's shows and produced thrilling matches with stunning regularity.


2. Triple H (2008)

WWE.com

Since the initial brand split in March of 2002, Triple H had been exclusive to Raw. More than that, he was actively against going to Smackdown, being built up as the most important star of the year during his reign of terror from the summer of '02 to around the spring/summer of 2005. The 'B' show was beneath him.

He was the man who was just given the brand new, Raw-exclusive World Heavyweight Title, simply because he was the biggest star and the best wrestler in the world. He'd done everything, and beaten everyone on WWE's 'A' show. It had been obvious for years that new surroundings might benefit the somewhat stale performer.

And so it came to be in June 2008, when The Game (along with Mr. Kennedy) was the last star to be drafted after Edge won a Raw/Smackdown/ECW tri-branded battle royal to secure two draft picks. He didn't look exactly happy about it, but it wound up being a good short-term career move for him as well as being a genuine boon for the blue brand.

The Cerebral Assassin had some stellar feuds and matches with Edge and Jeff Hardy, and even managed to get a good match out of The Great Khali (at SummerSlam). He was working good, long matches with fresh opponents and putting new guys over. His autumn dispute and Survivor Series match with the ill-fated Vladimir Kozlov was a bit rotten, but he can hardly be blamed for that debacle.

Sadly, Trips switched back to Raw in April 2009, where he had yet more matches with the likes of John Cena and Randy Orton, guys he'd already faced (and beat) many times before, before reforming the tired DX for one last barrel-scraping run.


1. CM Punk (2009)

CM Punk 2009 Smackdown World Heavyweight Champion
WWE.com

It's amazing to think, considering how his WWE career turned out, but there were a lot of people resistant to CM Punk getting the call-up from developmental. It was only due to the championing of Paul Heyman that the Second City Saint was given a spot on the re-branded ECW.

After a good run on the 'C' show, Punk's career was given a boost when he was drafted over to Raw on the 23rd, 2008 draft. The Money in the Bank winner wasted no time making an impact, successfully cashing-in his guaranteed WWE Title shot on Edge the following week and becoming World Heavyweight Champion for the first time.

His run was something of a flop, unfortunately. Feuds and matches with Batista and JBL sought only to undermine him and he lost the title at Unforgiven in September, despite not being involved in the match (he was attacked by Legacy beforehand and replaced by eventual winner Chris Jericho).

It was obvious that, while on the flagship, Punk would be taking a backseat to the likes of Randy Orton, Batista and John Cena. With his switch to Smackdown in 2009, his fortunes changed for the better. His cash-in on and subsequent feud with Jeff Hardy over the summer was great, with Punk really shining on the mic and doing his part in high pressure pay-per-view main events.

He looked like a proper star, until some off-hand comments landed him in the doghouse and saw him stripped of the World Heavyweight Title in the autumn. He would slide down the card momentarily but recovered with the excellent Straight Edge Society, eventually clawing his way back up the card.

Regardless of his role, Punk was a bright spot on any Smackdown show on which he performed.

Click "next" below for those that sucked...


5 That Sucked...

5. Triple H (2004)

Triple H World Heavyweight Champion Royal Rumble 2004
WWE.com

What a total farce this whole thing was.

Remember what I said earlier about Triple H being considered the most important star in the company, gifted a World Title and generally treated as being above everyone apart from those he chose to put over? Well the 2004 WWE Draft pretty much confirmed those sentiments.

The Game was drafted during the lottery style drawing, causing him to do a spit-take and for a panicked Eric Bischoff to complain personally to Vince McMahon that it wasn't fair. He needed Trips on Raw, you see. The show would die without his presence! The Bisch was so against losing his biggest asset that he struck a deal with SmackDown general manager Kurt Angle get him back on his show.

Bischoff traded Raw's Booker T and both Dudley Boys in order to reacquire the services of the King of Kings. Not only did it show how little WWE valued the talents of the three veterans, but also how much they valued Smackdown compared to Raw. Bad business all around that did nothing but massage HHH's ego and make the blue brand look second-rate.


4. Muhammad Hassan & Khosrow Daivari

Muhammad Hass Drafted To Smackdown 2005
WWE.com

Okay, so there was nothing that Muhammad Hassan and Daivari could have done on Smackdown, given the circumstances, but this goes down as one of the most pointless draft picks ever, in hindsight. Daivari and Hassan were drafted from Raw to Smackdown on the June 23rd, 2005 episode of the show, with Hassan picking up a quick win over Big Show on the night.

Hassan was on a hell of a roll, defeating pretty much everyone on Raw since the turn of the year and mixing it up with top stars like Hulk Hogan, Shawn Michaels, Steve Austin and Batista. WWE clearly had big plans for him on Smackdown, too, which is why he went over Show and then began to feud with The Undertaker.

Unfortunately, the infamous 'terrorist' angle - during which men in ski masks attacked and garrotted 'Taker before carrying out Daivari as a martyr - was aired the same day as the very real 7/7 London bombings. The angle was in poor taste, but the timing was catastrophic.

According to UPN, WWE had went too far and they pressured the company to keep Hassan off of their network. WWE had no real choice but not write him off of TV until the storm blew over, so they had The Deadman obliterate him at the Great American Bash pay-per-view, a Last Ride through the stage acting as his WWE swan song.

There were supposedly huge plans for Hassan post-Undertaker feud, with one rumour having him beat Batista for the World Heavyweight Title (thus becoming the youngest WWE World champion in history). Alas, it was not to be, with Hassan now acting as a mere footnote in WWE history, and one of the poorest draft picks ever.


3. D-Von Dudley (2002)

Reverend D Von
WWE.com

The initial WWE draft in 2002 promised to shake things up, with champions and top stars becoming the exclusive property of one show. One of the teases for the draft was 'what would happen if (insert tag team here) split up?'. Would the Hardys go there seperate ways? Was it curtains for the team of Billy and Chuck?

Those two teams survived the draft intacts, but the APA and the Dudleys weren't so lucky: Bradshaw and Bubba were drafted to Raw while Ron Simmons and D-Von were put on Smackdown. Amazingly, D-Von was a proper draft pick, chosen specifically by Vince McMahon, as opposed to in the online portion of the draft. He was the No. 8 pick.

D-Von began to 'testify' for real on the blue show, as he became the villainous 'Reverend D-Von', crooked church man and 'spiritual adviser' to Mr. McMahon. The gimmick was a dud, running its course within a matter of weeks. It was clear that D-Von would struggle as a singles performer after years tagging with Bubba.

This period is notable for the debut of 'Deacon' Batista, who briefly acted as the muscle and tag partner of the rev. Following Batista's switch to Raw, D-Von began tagging with Ron Simmons, another wrestler who had struggled to do much of anything following the brand split. The thrown-together team didn't last long, either.

Come November, some eight months after the split, D-Von found his way back on Raw, once again as a member of the Dudley Boys tag team. The decision to split them, and push D-Von as a singles star (which also saw him score a rare win over Triple H), was a head-scratcher.


2. Ric Flair (2007)

Ric Flair MVP Vengeance 2007
WWE.com

It was obvious in the summer of 2007 that Ric Flair was very much in the winter of his career. Also, having been exclusively on Raw - where he was once general manager - since 2002, it was time for him to move on and try his hand at something else. He needed new challenges, new opponents and new storylines and so he was transferred to Smackdown in June

Flair has a few matches on Smackdown television against the likes of MVP, Finlay and Carlito, before he was 'injured' by The Great Khali and written out of storylines. So soon? Turns out, Flair was not happy with the way his character had been handled and had actually handed in his notice to WWE officials shortly after switching brands.

In Flair's mind, despite winding down as a full-time in-ring performer, he deserved better than his lot. The Nature Boy had a meeting with Vince McMahon on September 20th, which did not go well (Flair had the gall to bring his lawyers with him and the two clashed over his on-screen portrayal).

Flair would return eventually, of course, in November, but he wasn't back to being a quote-unquote 'Smackdown Superstar'. Indeed, Slick Ric began the storyline where he needed to keep winning matches, thus he be forced to retire, matches that took place on Raw, Smackdown and ECW.

Further to that, Flair continued to wrestle on Raw house shows and feuded with Raw's Ken Kennedy, further disassociating himself from the blue brand.


1. John Cena (2011)

John Cena Miz 2011 WWE Draft
WWE.com

Similar to the Triple H situation of 2004, this was a pointless exercise done to massage the ego of a top star.

Cena, who had wrestled on Smackdown from his debut in June of 2002 until he was drafted to Raw in June 2005, was drafted back to Smackdown in 2011 as the first daft pick of the night. A monumental pick, no? The biggest star in the business going back to the 'B' show. Boy, how he could help them out. Think of all the fres...

Okay, sorry. Couldn't go on there. As anyone familiar with this particular draft knows, Cena was a Smackdown roster member for the length of the Raw draft broadcast. Following the main event, in which team Raw beat team Smackdown, Big Match John was drafted back to Raw, becoming the first performer to change shows and then back again in one night.

And why? To create a little bit of buzz? To add another 'accolade' to Cena's ridiculous CV? The whole thing was pointless, a waste of two draft picks that could have helped further shape the identities of the shows.

Considering how guys like Daniel Bryan, Kofi Kingston and Sheamus were drafted via the bogus 'online' draft, it's inexcusable that two draft picks would be used just to put Cena over as a big deal.


Contributor
Contributor

Student of film. Former professional wrestler. Supporter of Newcastle United. Don't cry for me, I'm already dead...