6 Match Star Ratings For WWE Royal Rumble 2022
Royal Rumble 2022 was far from "Stupendous" in paving the road to WrestleMania 38...
The build to the 2022 Royal Rumble was either funny or upsetting, depending on the extent to which you're numb to the whole thing.
Almost every women's division act you've been asked to invest in on SmackDown over recent months has vanished, quit, or been released. There is a wrestler on the show capable of firing lightning from her hands, and she's still not considered worthy of promoting as an attraction. WWE would rather ring TNA than put a real-life sorceress on telly.
The men's match was a similarly star-bereft deal with no clear winner. Most predictions were informed by the "Depends on the f*ckery in the title matches" variable, and the build was limited to Rey Mysterio playing peekaboo with his large adult soon.
WWE couldn't bring themselves to present Brock Lesnar and Bobby Lashley as equals in what was a sobering development, not that jolly Brock Lesnar isn't amazing. Roman Reigns and Seth Rollins trading "shoot" insults in a hastily-arranged all-heel storyline was Paul Heyman at his absolute laziest.
Maryse was great value - better value than actual comedy film star Johnny Knoxville, whose stuff was Sami Zayn was just wretched. Jackass is funny. It's stupid, but it's funny. WWE couldn't even hit Sami in the c*ck with an oversized prop. They couldn't even do slapstick.
As for the show itself...?
6. Roman Reigns Vs. Seth "Freakin'" Rollins - Universal Championship Match
The show started on such an incredible note.
The second that the Shield's theme dropped, you couldn't help but melt into a wry, appreciative smile. It was more than a neat moment of nostalgia; Seth's attire choice made sense of and even enhanced a bad, hastily-thrown-together build. This word has been bastardised beyond recognition, but the moment was so cool and inspired that it went some way towards making people forget that the Shield have reformed multiple times since 2014.
The match itself pulled at this thread artfully too; Seth, who was on sensational 2015 form, worked the match as if he'd spent hours and hours drilling into Roman's psyche. The callbacks weren't mere fan service. Rollins unleashed the "Shield bomb", countered the Spear into a Pedigree and played the frantic aerial artist of 2012-2014 as a way of unsettling Roman, who was nowhere near the worker Seth was when the Shield were a breakthrough full-time unit. Roman was brilliant too in a match refreshing for its lack of methodical, we-tell-stories posturing; his 2.9 kick-outs sold the shock result with exquisite dramatic timing.
The match peaked before the finish, and the finish was bobbins.
It was as annoying as it was puzzling, looking at the full picture. Reigns went full heel, and later realigned with Paul Heyman, preserving their face/heel dynamic. So why have Brock Lesnar eliminate hometown star Randy Orton and last eliminate a returning babyface?
Getting disqualified for kicking too much ass isn't storytelling; it's an excuse to prolong a story for content's sake.
Star Rating: ★★★½
5. Women's Royal Rumble Match
An actively horrendous match for the vast majority of the duration, it also doubled as an indictment of WWE's progressive (if belated, arrogant and hypocritical) "Women's Revolution".
Beyond genuinely encouraging strides in parity and the distribution of TV time, it was only ever a vehicle for the Four Horsewomen - and one of them, Sasha Banks, was eliminated as if she was just another midcard act in a promotion teeming with them. Even if her elimination was pitched as build towards a Tag Team title pursuit with the returning Bayley, that's still well below her star aura. Her character work in reaction to Melina was fabulous. It wasn't rewarded.
This didn't register with the importance and prestige of a Rumble match, even the all too comedic modern evolution of the genre. Between the not exactly illustrious personnel and so many botches, it felt more like the WrestleMania X-Seven gimmick battle royal, only not as fun, not as knowing, and with staggered entrances. The spot-calling, the hesitation, the awkwardness: this was just woefully lacking in quality.
If that scans as harsh, it's only a slight exaggeration; much of the action was truly dismal, appallingly and glaringly sloppy. Tamina actively tried to save her opponents from elimination at various points. Is she that incompetent, or was that a rib?
Because this is WWE, both scenarios are likely. Sarah Logan returned, and, in another presumed rib, enjoyed an emotional moment with former Riott Squad stablemate Liv Morgan. They didn't team up and run through some tandem spots to charm their cult following. They were swiftly dumped by the Bella Twins. They looked so staggeringly stupid and feckless. The cruelty behind this sequence was notable even by WWE's cold standards.
Bianca Belair emerged from the debacle with a degree of credit, as one of the few performers to work a style that remotely resembled impactful. Elsewhere, this was just dire, and the finish was nothing if not fitting. There's a good reason why Ronda Rousey didn't look anything like she did in 2018, but there's no good reason why her elimination of Charlotte Flair was so strikingly anticlimactic.
Charlotte effectively no-sold it, as if it didn't even matter or even hurt.
Ronda's win will draw numbers and interest, and criticisms of less importance, but it didn't feel like an achievement.
Star Rating: ★
4. Becky Lynch Vs. Doudrop - RAW Women's Championship Match
Elements of certain matches were fantastic, or merely good, but on the whole, everything on the night was in some way flawed, too long or just unnecessary.
The one unqualified success on the entire Royal Rumble card - something that could legitimately be described as a really good and solid piece of business - was ruined because WWE almost incinerated an entire section of the audience by f*cking up the pyro which, incidentally, was one of the few things left they could actually do well.
The women didn't deserve this, but the company damn sure did.
Becky Lynch gave a lot to Doudrop in what was a professional and well-judged star performance. In a match like this, the objective is to elevate the challenger in prominence. She did. It's not as easy as simply doling out a certain ratio of offence; Lynch sold the threat with a strong range of facial expressions, and Doudrop carried her part with almost too much enthusiasm at various, alarming points. The structure of the match wasn't particularly ambitious - it was a simple story that must be told - but measured against the wretched WWE curve, it flattered both performers, featured spots that might have drawn gasps in more ideal circumstances, and concluded with a rare, clean result, via a modified finish designed to convey the idea that a last resort was needed to put over a threat of this scope. The avalanche Manhandle Slam spot was the exact sort of easy finish that WWE tends to not to do, and was earned here.
The atmosphere was nonexistent, and the pace was such that it mightn't have fared much better with a more enthusiastic, less endangered crowd.
But they grafted, and Lynch as Champion at least sold that she was under duress.
Somebody else didn't.
Star Rating: ★★¾
3. Brock Lesnar Vs. Bobby Lashley - WWE Championship Match
It would be better if WWE simply decided to be bad immediately, all the time, with no hope to the contrary.
Even to this day, after years of bitter and bland disappointment - the infamous 2015 Royal Rumble was seven years ago, and that was hardly the day everything started to go wrong - this promotion is still capable of creating the illusion of something good before WWEing it.
Much of Brock Lesnar Vs. Bobby Lashley was awesome; a true glimpse into the sheer spectacle that any other company would have the decency to promote. They exchanged German suplexes early. They exchanged terrifying German suplexes early; after Lashley almost dumped Lesnar right on his head, Lesnar nearly killed him right back in response. Even if the first was botched, sh*t still ruled; gnarly head drops are awesome, and even if inadvertently, this played into the super-athlete pissing contest at the core of the conflict. After learning his lesson, Lashley did everything possible to not land on his neck, and while the over-corrections were obvious and not significantly less dangerous - his elbows and shoulders took a pounding - the nasty spills looked all the better for how unclean they looked.
Weirdly, the prolonged Hurt Lock sequence lacked suspense. It's unclear why - WWE has done a tremendous job of getting it over - but elsewhere, the action was so big-time that even a clichéd barricade spot worked in this context.
The other clichés however dragged the match down to "f*ck this" territory; the ref bump was horrendous carny facilitation, Brock's visual pin made it impossible to think that Lashley won't end up doing some nothing midcard fare in the summer, and the Roman interference spot and Paul Heyman's betrayal just added sports entertainment overtones to super-rare big fight drama.
The finish also all but ruined the men's Rumble match, too...
Star Rating: ★★★½
2. Edge & Beth Phoenix Vs. The Miz & Maryse
A quasi-WrestleMania midcard attraction that wasn't remotely bad - if anything, it over-delivered - it didn't remotely belong on an overlong Royal Rumble card that had already dragged and lost the crowd.
All four performers in the end generated a response worthy of the spectacle, but when the show had already done so little to build towards WrestleMania with any sort of intrigue, it felt especially frivolous. The expected structure unfolded early. Maryse was terrified of Beth Phoenix and took refuge on her husband's c*ck on the outside before cheating to hand her husband the advantage - upon which he capitalised with a slow run-through of his Yes! kick sequence.
When that structure was subverted and the story riffed on the TV build, the drama spiked. The brick came into play deep into the match, informing a suspenseful near-fall, but the biggest pop was reserved for a genuinely impressive athletic feat and narrative twist: the petrified Maryse grew in confidence and struck Edge with a hurricanrana. This was a doubly incredulous spot, and earned the sizeable pop for its audacity.
At the finish, Edge and Beth overcame the heel chicanery and blasted them with a stereo Glam Slam. It wasn't perfectly in sync - nor was much of the offence exchanged between Phoenix and Maryse - but it was a fun enough if slightly out-of-context crowdpleaser all the same.
Star Rating: ★★★
1. Men's Royal Rumble Match
A great Royal Rumble match is synonymous with thrilling spots; suspenseful near-eliminations; dream match stare-downs; layered storytelling that builds or advances midcard WrestleMania attractions; an out-of-nowhere fun nostalgic cameo; a final four teeming with anxiety; a notable Iron Man performance booked to highlight a breakthrough act; a monster elimination spree; at least two credible potential winners worth tracking throughout what is a long, demanding runtime.
The 2022 men's Royal Rumble match offered literally none of this.
Riddle and Randy Orton didn't tease dissent. AJ Styles, through his elimination by Madcap Moss, was hardly built as a potential opponent for Edge at WrestleMania. Nor, through his elimination by Shane McMahon, was Kevin Owens. Everything was so casual, aimless. They'll worry about that sort of thing later.
Before the celebrities generated the expected pop and the real stars entered the match late, this truly was a whole load of absolutely nothing notable only for the "TNA!" chants that received the AJ Styles Vs. Bobby Roode meet-in-the-middle.
Johnny Knoxville, professional stunt comedian, basically did the Daniel Puder bit. There was no creativity to capitalise on the publicity with an attention-grabbing GIF worth circulating on social media. Recklessness, yes, but no creativity. Even the few strong moments were damning of the entire company. Bad Bunny impressed again, so much so that - and this isn't that hyperbolic - he's better at this than 80% of the NXT 2.0 roster.
The match was structured with zero love nor forward-thinking. It was simply a procession of just-there midcard acts, entering the ring suspiciously close together, trading eliminations. WWE telegraphed the winner via the result of the WWE Title match, and what's worse, they didn't bother dispatching anybody from RAW to the commentary booth. They only needed Michael Cole and Pat McAfee to put over Brock Lesnar at the finish.
The finish itself was unceremonious in the extreme. Drew McIntyre was thrown out so quickly that it felt like WWE was actively trying to tell you that the events of 2020 didn't matter. Should you let that one "play out"?
On the evidence of this mundane sea of damned souls just doing things, arbitrarily, the only thing that's played out is this wrestling promotion.
Star Rating: ★★