6 Positives And 4 Negatives Heading Into WWE Survivor Series 2016
Major announcements, huge returns, as well as some dodgy booking on the road to Survivor Series...
With both the Raw and SmackDown go-home shows in the books, this Sunday’s Survivor Series is just about upon us.
It brings down the curtain on a fairly lengthy build, the seeds of which were sown way back at the start of October when Goldberg first appeared on ESPN’s SportsCenter teasing a potential return to the ring. The following week, SmackDown then set the wheels in motion for a series of elimination matches, challenging Raw to men’s, women’s and tag team showdowns. And after much ado, we now know those line-ups for the respective brands, and truth be told it makes for a fairly exciting card.
As ever, we’ve seen our fair share of ups and downs along the way, from questionable scripting to bombshell announcements—not to mention the returns of some megastar names.
This article reflects on all of that drama as we look back at six positives and four negatives heading into Survivor Series.
10. Negative — This "Fantasy Warfare" Malarkey
First off we’ll address the negatives, and in particular this "fantasy warfare" tagline that WWE has looked to shove down our throats at every available opportunity.
I get that it’s a tie-in to the WWE 2K17 video game. And I get that Goldberg’s unexpected return to a real-life ring does kind of fit the definition of fantastical. But it takes the biscuit a little when they’re trying to claim that the entire show is made of up dream matches.
Sure, the matches look exciting enough, but the idea of this SmackDown vs. Raw feud being a “fantasy” doesn’t really hold up since the Brand Split simply hasn’t been going long enough at this point. Just a few months back we were seeing these guys mixing it up on a regular basis. Take the Miz and Sami Zayn for example; they’ve met in singles action three times already this year, so their match this Sunday hardly falls into that "fantasy" category.
I could make more comparisons between guys like Dean Ambrose and Seth Rollins, or the Usos and the Club, but either way the point remains the same; it hasn’t been long enough to start calling these meetings “fantasy” matches, and to do so sounds slightly naïve, at best. At worst, it kind of insults our intelligence…
9. Negative — Infighting Between The Teams
There’s nothing wrong with a bit of uneasiness within the ranks heading into Survivor Series. In fact, it’s something we see just about every year, and for the most part it only adds to the excitement.
But this year we saw more than just the occasional squabble or one or two members refusing to get along. This time, the bickering was essentially encouraged by the management teams of each brand, turning this into some sort of weird, institutionalised infighting.
Usually the pre-match story sees one of the team captains looking to get their comrades to co-operate, or at least tolerate each other for long enough to get through a match. This time though, we saw Mick Foley and Stephanie McMahon forcing the members of their Raw team to tear each other apart just weeks before the show.
First we saw the Team Raw quintet face off in Fatal 5-Way action, and though admittedly the following week was slightly better, we still saw Team Raw guys facing other Team Raw guys right through the show.
In fairness, I suppose it’s a tricky situation because they have to fill a three-hour show somehow, and their roster’s much smaller than it used to be. Still, this kind of booking just felt like a fairly stupid way to prepare a team for Survivor Series.
8. Negative — State Of The Union Address
Following this past week’s showing of Raw, a State of the WWE Universe address was staged between the Raw and SmackDown authority figures. Except, rather than discussing the more pressing issue at hand—this Sunday’s Survivor Series showcase—they instead chose to argue over who loves their brand more, which show’s been utilising its talent better and something about Stephanie McMahon and socks…
Simply put, this show was a train wreck, and not necessarily in the entertaining way.
A seemingly jet-lagged Shane spent much of the debate giving perplexed looks as he watched the madness unfold, Foley embarked on lengthy tirades answering questions that nobody had even asked him, and Stephanie was forced on countless occasions to try and save the show by diverting the attention back to the Survivor Series pay-per-view.
Ultimately we didn’t really learn much, and it just made the on-screen management teams look bad. Usually I’m all for these unscripted, line-blurring post-shows such as Talking Smack, but this time it just didn’t quite click. Too many cooks? Not enough direction? Probably a bit of both, but either way it didn’t make for a good recipe at all.
7. Negative — Four-Hour Show
German-American architect Ludwig Mies van der Rohe is often cited as providing us with the famous aphorism, “less is more.” Unfortunately, this is a memo that clearly didn’t reach WWE headquarters, as they continue to steer closer to the “bigger is better” school of thought.
You may be wondering what an earth I’m on about, but this is a segue into the news that Survivor Series, like many other major WWE PPVs, is now going to be a four-hour extravaganza.
First it was only WrestleMania that was afforded the extra hour, before SummerSlam soon got in on the act. Now, it appears that each of the Big Four shows are going to keep us Brits up until the early hours...
Don’t get me wrong, I love that they’re doing their best to make Survivor Series a big deal again. But personally I feel like there are better ways of doing that then simply adding an extra hour to the run-time. Plus, given that we currently have more PPVs than months on the calendar, not to mention a marathon three hours of Raw to slog through every week, bumping Survivor Series to four hours is verging on overkill in my book.
6. Positive — Multiple Elimination Matches
That being said, the additional hour of airtime to fill does mean that we have a pretty stacked card to look forward to. And one of the most notable—and welcome—features of that card is the triple dose of traditional Survivor Series elimination matches that will be contested over the course of the evening.
In recent years, Survivor Series’ heritage has become something of an afterthought. Not since 2009 have we seen a show with more than two elimination matches, and many of those shows featured just one sole elimination bout.
This time around though, we’ll be seeing a healthy amount of elimination action, much like in the early days of the Survivor Series PPV. Also, these aren’t your usual hurriedly-assembling multi-man bouts; each one has had plenty of thought put into it, and each of the men’s, women’s and tag team matches includes the respective brand’s divisional champion.
All in all, it’s a nice throwback to the set-up that made Survivor Series great in the first place, as opposed to squishing the elimination matches into the early stages of the show to make way for the more important world title clashes.
5. Positive — Cruiserweight Title Bombshell
One of the biggest announcements heading into this year’s Survivor Series was the news surrounding Brian Kendrick’s Cruiserweight Championship match with Kalisto. Not only is this an inter-promotional clash, and not only will the title be on the line, but the future of the entire Cruiserweight division will also hang in the balance.
If Kendrick wins, the Cruiserweights remain on Raw, whereas if Kalisto wins he’ll be bringing the boys with him to Tuesday nights. As far as game-changing stipulations go, they don’t get much bigger than that.
Of course, this news doesn’t simply benefit their Survivor Series match. As well as drastically raising the stakes for this Sunday, it could also be a big positive in the long-term. Many have already suggested that the Cruiserweights would be better off working on SmackDown, due to the brand’s smaller roster. Also, the fact that the new '205 Live' show will be broadcasting on Tuesdays suggests that logistically this move makes sense too.
Maybe I’m getting ahead of myself there—either way, in terms of Survivor Series alone, ramping up the risk like this will surely make this Sunday’s Cruiserweight Championship bout all the more exciting.
4. Positive — The Undertaker's Return To SmackDown
This one may not relate to Sunday’s show directly, but it’s a development that still played a fairly important part in the build-up to Survivor Series.
On SmackDown this week, the Undertaker made his scheduled return to WWE programming, in what was assumed to be a one-off appearance in celebration of the brand’s 900th episode. After suggestively claiming that WrestleMania “will no longer define” him, the Deadman gave Team SmackDown a unique pep talk, complete with what was basically a threat that if they didn’t beat Team Raw they’d have to answer to him.
Oh, and he also uttered the words "I'm back" which certainly makes it seem as though his return will be a rather more permanent deal. Add in the fact that during that pep talk he firmly nailed his colours to the SmackDown mast, and also reminded us that Survivor Series is where the Undertaker was born, and there’s bound to be rampant speculation about a potential Undertaker appearance at the PPV this weekend.
Still, regardless of whether or not he shows up on Sunday, this segment was nonetheless a definite highlight on the road to Survivor Series—and a potential appearance at the PPV would only be the icing on the cake.
3. Positive — Shane McMahon’s Involvement
Truth be told, I spent a fair old while deciding whether to not to list this is as a positive or a negative. In the end, I’ve decided to appease my inner-Attitude-Era-child and embrace the revelation that Shane O’Mac will once again step foot in a WWE ring, when he takes to the trenches as a part of Team SmackDown at Survivor Series.
I could certainly see how people would look upon this negatively. Not only is he a part-timer, he’s not even the biggest-drawing part-timer (cough, Undertaker, cough), while it also seems a little hypocritical of an authority figure to thrust himself into the spotlight given that SmackDown has been predicated on being the land of opportunity.
All that aside though, it was a major announcement that certainly popped the Glasgow crowd on SmackDown last week, and there’s a reason it was received so warmly. After all, this is a guy who risked it all at WrestleMania 32 to pull off one of the most ridiculous stunts in WWE history.
Plus, the fact that it’s a slightly questionable choice to make up the numbers on Team SmackDown does open up the possibility that it’s all a ruse, and that someone else will in fact be taking his place come Sunday. The aforementioned Deadman springs to mind, or even a certain Joe from Samoa…
2. Positive — The Toronto Crowd
This may be another slightly more subjective entry, but I do honestly believe that staging the PPV in Toronto can only be a good thing.
For starters, there’s an absolute ton of history between Canada and Survivor Series. I’m sure I don’t need to go into the gory details of that Montreal Screwjob from 1997…
As well as that though, this will be the first WWE PPV to take place in Toronto in more than a decade. Not since Unforgiven 2006 has the company returned to the Air Canada Centre, and prior to that there’ve only been three other Toronto PPVs, by my humble calculations; WrestleMania VI in 1990, WrestleMania X8 in 2002 and SummerSlam of 2004.
Obviously that sucks for Toronto that they’ve been so regularly shunned by WWE, but selfishly it may be a good thing for us neutrals. Cities, and indeed countries, that are starved of live events usually make up for it when a show does roll around—I guess I’m biased, but I’d say that the UK are a pretty great example of this in action.
It may be a little presumptive, but I’m banking on a hot crowd from Toronto this Sunday—and surely that can only be a good thing for the overall spectacle of the show?
1. Positive — Brock Lesnar Vs. Goldberg
Finally, we arrive at probably the biggest positive heading into this year’s Survivor Series—both figuratively and literally.
After weeks—arguably years—of anticipation, Brock Lesnar and Goldberg will once again do battle in a WWE ring when they take centre stage on Sunday evening. Given that this will be Goldberg’s first outing in a dozen years, and the fact that any Lesnar appearance is worth checking out, this match just about sells itself on name value alone.
On top of that though, WWE has managed to do an excellent job of building this feud into perhaps the most anticipated match of the entire year. Goldberg has been handled brilliantly since coming back into the fold, unbelievably more so than in his initial run, and it’s only made this feud feel all the more special.
For the in-ring segments, the backstage promos, as well as the promise of seeing one more spear or one more jackhammer, I personally can’t look beyond this one as the most noteworthy positive ahead of Survivor Series 2016.
If you disagree though, do let me know in the comments below, and feel free to sound off with your own suggestions regarding the ups and downs heading into this Sunday’s show.