6 Reasons WWE Network Lost Record Subscribers This Summer

Are fans turning elsewhere due to WWE's decision-making?

Wwe Network Logo
WWE.com

WWE revealed during their Q2 earnings report that the WWE Network's subscription count has fallen from a record high 1.94 million to 1.63 million. The 1.94 number was released around WrestleMania 33 time, which makes sense due to the big push for new customers (and returning casual fans) to watch WWE's biggest annual show.

In the months since, that number has dropped, which is worrying when SummerSlam is just over the horizon. Could it be that people just aren't taken with the 'Biggest Party of the Summer' any longer, or is this representative of a wider issue? Have key decisions made since 'Mania caused fans to turn off and seek their wrestling fix elsewhere?

These are all questions that must be asked, because it's not good when The Wrestling Observer are also reporting record cancellations for WWE's on-demand service. Exactly what is causing this drop-off will be the source of intense discussion in WWE's board room.

Big Vince isn't gonna' be happy...


6. Other Interests Being Worthy Of Fan Money

Netflix Logo
Netflix

One immediate problem crops up when examining fan interest in the WWE Network over a sustained period. Whilst big events like WrestleMania and the Royal Rumble advertise cards sometimes months in advance, other shows prefer to rely on commitment before anything is announced. This forces people to flat out hope things will be worthwhile.

That's a risky way to do business, especially with so many other entertainment streams fighting for customer attention. Investing in other hobbies becomes more enticing when you know what you're going to get for your money. Even Netflix doesn't approach things this way; sign-up to that service and the consistent quality is flaunted long before things are added to your watch list.

Customers may already watch Raw, SmackDown, and perhaps even NXT or 205 Live, but beyond that there's probably no desire for more. It's a strange strategy to expect people to sign up for something when they may end up being disappointed by the eventual card on offer and come to realise that the quality isn't much higher than regular TV.

On that note...


5. Post-WrestleMania Pay-Per-Views Have Often Felt Throwaway

Rusev John Cena Battleground Flag Match
WWE.com

Aside from a few notable matches, what would people really miss by skipping pay-per-views like Payback, Backlash, Extreme Rules, Money In The Bank, Great Balls Of Fire, and Battleground? As soon as these shows are over, they're pretty much old news. Remember when each pay-per-view card felt unique and special?

Those days are over, replaced by a series of events that feel uniform and throwaway. Given five minutes, even those fans who dip their toes in and out of the WWE product would be able to name the major matches from WrestleMania 33 when pressed. It's hard to see the same thing happening if you plucked Backlash out of the ether and asked the same thing.

There's nothing truly essential on these pay-per-views. They're often enjoyable for the most part, yes, but rarely do they last long in the memory. By the time Raw rolls around 24 hours later (or SmackDown 48 hours later if it was a blue brand show), pay-per-views seem obsolete, almost like they've blurred together.


4. Absence Of Proven Draws On The Full-Time Roster

The Undertaker WrestleMania 33 Bye Bye
www.wwe.com

It's hard to accurately ascertain who is a guaranteed draw in WWE today. The rules have changed in that regard thanks to the Network. No longer can we simply analyse the roster to see who draws buyrates on top and who doesn't. Times have moved on, but there's still something to be said for star power.

Established names like The Undertaker and Triple H have been missed this summer. You can add Brock Lesnar to that list; even though Brock continues to be Universal Champion, he rarely appears on Raw and is treated as being above many others on the regular crew. That's a problem, and it's choking the ability of others to be taken seriously by fans.

Those casual fans who took the plunge and checked out 'Mania? They're gone, partly because the complete absence of names they recognise like Undertaker and Triple H on subsequent pay-per-views has killed their interest. To a lapsed fan from the '90s, a match like Roman Reigns vs. Braun Strowman from Payback just won't cut it.


3. There's Too Much Product Across The Board

raw smackdown live
WWE.com

Although it's hardly an issue exclusive to the summer of 2017, the fact remains that WWE's blinding amount of content is almost suffocating at this point. Three hours of Raw on Monday, two for SmackDown on Tuesday followed by another hour for 205 Live immediately afterwards and a further hour for NXT on Wednesday. It's all too much.

Even before taking into account all the extra product like Main Event, the Raw Pre-Show, Talking Smack (only just cancelled as a weekly), This Week In WWE, and the countless bombardment of YouTube content, WWE are expecting people to watch a minimum of seven hours per week just to keep up with everything that's going on. That's insane.

It does seem strange to complain about 'too much wrestling', but consider this: could you imagine being tasked with watching seven hours of your favourite TV show each week then hitting up YouTube for more? There should only be further content when there's a demand for it, not just because WWE feel like it.

Less, in this instance, would be more.


2. Jinder Mahal As WWE Champion

jinder mahal
WWE.com

Harking back to an earlier point about star power, casual fans who returned for WrestleMania 33 likely didn't even see Jinder Mahal on the card at all. Tucked away in a Kickoff show Battle Royal, the current WWE Champion is now someone WWE expect those jaded people to accept as worthy of a title dubbed wrestling's most prestigious.

Jinder's rise has been rapid and a consequence of WWE's clear wishes to plunder the Indian market, but it has felt low-rent compared to champions of the past. Nobody can claim Mahal hasn't worked hard to whip his body into shape, but that alone doesn't automatically make him championship material.

The played out wealthy foreigner with a disdain for America gimmick feels positively archaic in 2017, especially next to forward-thinking champions in other companies like NJPW's Kazuchika Okada. WWE titleholders do need to have character, but plucking someone previously cast as an also-ran and expecting fans to embrace it overnight is foolish.


1. Fans Are Drifting Towards Alternatives

Kenny Omega Okada
NJPW

WWE's product becomes more and more uniform the more it is analysed. Perhaps that's unfair; superhero movies, to use another pop culture example, also follow the same format, so it's tricky to blame WWE for sticking to what they know. That rigid template may have led to wrestling fans seeking something new though.

By running shows in North America and taking steps to make their own NJPW World on-demand service more accessible to English-speaking customers, New Japan Pro Wrestling are making strides in the Western world more than ever before. At last, wrestling fans who have grown bored of WWE's inflexible product have an alternative.

NJPW World's customer base has grown in 2017, so perhaps some of those cancelling the Network have defected from WWE. It's possible, because New Japan put on an exciting brand of in-ring focused wrestling and names like Kenny Omega have created significant online buzz.

WWE can't hide behind Vince McMahon's ancient claims that the company are 'Sports Entertainment, not pro wrestling' forever, especially not when their three-year old Network still hasn't hit the lofty 2 million subscriber mark and is in fact shedding customers.

-

Why else do you think the WWE Network subscriber count has dropped off this Summer? Let us know down in the comments section below!


In this post: 
WWE Network
 
Posted On: 
Contributor

Lifelong wrestling, video game, music and sports obsessive who has been writing about his passions since childhood. Jamie started writing for WhatCulture in 2013, and has contributed thousands of articles and YouTube videos since then. He cut his teeth penning published pieces for top UK and European wrestling read Fighting Spirit Magazine (FSM), and also has extensive experience working within the wrestling biz as a manager and commentator for promotions like ICW on WWE Network and WCPW/Defiant since 2010. Further, Jamie also hosted the old Ministry Of Slam podcast, and has interviewed everyone from Steve Austin and Shawn Michaels to Bret Hart and Trish Stratus.