6 Ups & 4 Downs From WWE Raw (23 Dec - Results & Review)

The New Day lose Kofi's Mom AND Dirty Dom, and McIntyre and Zayn continue their simmering rivalry

New Day
WWE

Welcome to Raw is Festivus!

Sorry, only one chance to make that joke, but it was worth it.

Asking fans to keep up the energy levels through a double taping is a tall order, and Monday’s episode suffered a bit due to being taped and due to a burned-out audience that needed some artificial sweetener to “come to life” at certain points during the program.

Overall, Raw did produce some decent moments, with Drew McIntyre and Sami Zayn bookending the show nicely, and the New Day having a stellar night, as they were shunned by both Dominik and Rey Mysterio and Kofi Kingston’s own mother.

Beyond that though, Raw was an uneven show, booking almost identical matches and finishes back-to-back, an inexcusable mistake. They finally got around to booking Chad Gable and his new stable against his old group, Alpha Academy, picking up a thread that should have been pulled on months ago. And the Women’s Intercontinental Championship tournament continued its record of underwhelming triple threats, putting all the pressure on the two semifinals to drive excitement for the new title.

It's difficult to hold these holiday season episodes to a high standard given the circumstances, but at the same time, WWE has been firing on all cylinders for a while now, so why shouldn’t they be expected to deliver when they have the benefit of a week to edit together the show?

Let’s get to it…


DOWNS…

4. A Useless Stable

Pure Fusion Collective
WWE

Mid-card heel stables are often by design incompetent and bumbling. They’re threat is their numbers, not how menacing they are.

Pure Fusion Collective, however, are saddled with a horrible name, a terrible won-loss record, a reputation for wrestling to deafening silence, and now evil genius idiocy.

Monday, the trio approached Raw GM Adam Pearce with Sonya Deville reminding everyone of how she had a worse role on the show as an assistant GM and tried to book herself into the Women’s Intercontinental Championship tournament to replace Kairi Sane… after the group injured her on camera last week.

Pearce rightly mocked them as being “our of [their] damn minds” before revealing he had tapped Sane’s fellow Damage CTRL teammate Iyo Sky for the spot. And just to make this a bit worse, Shayna Baszler pointed out that Sky was essentially being rewarded after losing her Women’s World Championship match clean at Saturday Night’s Main Event.

Heel stables that menace the midcard and lose a lot of matches are fine, but PFC is far from entertaining or “over” with the fans. Their appearance Monday felt more like a nuisance than anything else.


3. Another Lackluster Triple Threat

Natalya Iyo Sky Alba Fyre
WWE

Let’s get this out of the way immediately: Iyo Sky is incredible, and regardless of the “consolation prize” vibe of her losing a Women’s World Championship title match and immediately being inserted into the Women’s Intercontinental Championship tournament as an injury replacement, she’s value added.

But her triple threat match against Alba Fyre and Natalya was yet another soulless performance of moves happening in front of an audience in this tournament. Fyre, who barely gets TV time these days and has had just one televised non-tag match in the last 10 months, felt like she was just there, rather than maximizing her opportunity.

The action had a few sloppy moments, and the double Sharpshooter spot looked incredibly artificial. There also was an obvious mid-match edit, with the referee magically teleporting to the opposite side of the ring and Natalya appearing on the mat suddenly, so either there was a cut for time or there was a noticeable botch edited out.

Sky versus Lyra Valkyria should be an excellent semifinal match, but there’s no emotional investment in these triple threats, which could also funnel onto the new Women’s IC title if the semifinal matches don’t connect. If you want a title to mean something, then do something more than throw a bunch of wrestlers out there to do a flurry of moves and then pose with the new title making the “I want the belt” gesture.


2. Too Little, Far Too Late

WWE

Five months. That’s how long Chad Gable and the Creed Brothers have been aligned as a heel stable with jock energy to spare.

This should have been one of the easiest groups to book – a faction with amateur wrestling bona fides and Gable looking to put the comedy act of Alpha Academy behind him. They should have crushed the Alphas en route to becoming a solid force in the tag division, with Gable serving as a gatekeeper in the midcard.

Instead, the group feuded with – and lost to – the Wyatt Sicks before transitioning to a rivalry with the LWO that petered out last month. The group has been a huge disappointment, seemingly suffering from an identity crisis as they vacillate between track suits and business suits.

Now, it looks like Gable finally is going to feud with Otis, dispatching with Akira Tozawa Monday night in a nothing match that only served to create the staredown between the former tag champs and set up a match for next week that should have happened four months ago.

Short of an absolute commitment to book the group adequately at this point, it’s just impossible to get invested in American Made. There would need to be a good four-to-six weeks of consistent booking to convince cynics that WWE is serious about them.

More likely, next week’s match is going to be a comedy affair with Otis either picking up the win or having to try to overcome Gable and both Creeds before finally succumbing, which will do nothing to make this jock heel stable feel like anything but a star-spangled New Judgment Day.


1. Déjà Vu

Wyatt Six Final Testament
WWE

Agents have an important role to play when it comes to laying out matches and a wrestling show in general. One of the things they theoretically help avert are situations where important spots are diminished or repeated throughout the show. If a big match calls for a wrestler to have his ankle pillmanized, then that same chair spot shouldn’t happen in a throwaway opening match.

Clearly, the agents missed the assignment for this week’s Raw, or they were worn out after a double taping, because two consecutive matches followed the same pattern: a chickensh** heel (Dominik Mysterio and The Miz) fought a superior opponent (Damian Priest and Dexter Lumis) but had backup appear at ringside (Judgment Day and Final Testament) whose leaders caused a disqualification, triggering a four-on-one beatdown until other babyfaces (War Raiders and Wyatt Sicks) appeared to make the save.

These were back-to-back matches, with only the Seth Rollins interview segment breaking them up. How does this get booked like this?

Also, Karrion Kross’ grand plan from last week was to send Miz out there to get his a** handed to him and then surround Lumis, as if he hasn’t watched a single minute of the Wyatts on Raw these past five months and how they magically appear at ringside. Come on.


UPS…

6. When You’ve Lost Dirty Dom…

Dirty Dom New Day
WWE

The New Day’s heel turn has been very carefully cultivated and curated thus far, but there have been some pretty good beats along the way – crowd sweetening notwithstanding.

Backstage, Kofi Kingston and Xavier Woods have gotten the cold shoulder from everyone, from production crew to locker room leader Rey Mysterio. Monday, it appeared as though they finally had found a kindred spirit in Dominik Mysterio, who clapped the “New Day rocks!” as he approached them.

However, Dirty Dom quickly changed his tune, commenting, “I didn’t like Big E, but that (the verbal beatdown earlier this month) was just crazy” as he walked off. Woods was quick to shoot back, “You look like a broke-ass Tom Selleck!”

Mysterio stroked his mustache and replied that Selleck wishes. When you’re getting put down and outshone by one of the most despicable wrestlers on the roster, you know you’ve hit the bottom – in the best sort of way. Great stuff here for a 30-second segment.


5. The One Saving Grace

Damian Priest Finn Bálor
WWE

Damian Priest continuing to feud with the Judgment Day – and more specifically Finn Balor – is the story that never ends in WWE right now, and it’s reaching the point of diminishing returns.

His match against Dominik Mysterio Monday night was another nothing bout that was less about the in-ring action and more about what it set up afterward: a six-man tag match with the War Raiders joining Priest against the Judgment Day next week. Fine, that’s at least a new wrinkle and follows Erik and Ivar taking the tag titles off Finn and JD McDonagh.

However, one cute bit saved this: Dominik told his cohorts when he went to make the match that he “had a plan” to beat Priest. During the match, Damian was dominating when he spotted a Santa at ringside and yanked the beard down to reveal McDonagh. Priest beat him up, then went to climb back into the ring before stopping and lifting the ring skirt, exposing Carlito. Another beating commenced.

Joe Tessitore nailed it when he said, “He knows their playbook!” That was such a true statement: Priest was part of Judgment Day since the beginning, so it only made sense that he knew all the tricks and short-circuited those plans. It showed a smart babyface thinking a couple of steps ahead in thwarting his rivals.

Regardless, a blowoff match to put the Balor/Priest feud to bed for good would be tremendous.


4. A Mother’s Love

New Day
WWE

Man, the New Day can’t catch a break, can they? First Dominik Mysterio scoffs at them, and then Kofi Kingston’s own mother shuns him.

Kofi and Xavier Woods came to ringside Monday (once again sans music, as they’re making fans wait to hear what New Day’s new entrance theme will be) to jaw with the announcers and once again argue with the fans about how they could have beat up Big E several weeks ago but instead just kicked him out of the group. Woods got off a great line here about how he and Kofi gave the fans “the best 10 years of your lives.”

That’s when Kingston railed against the fans for booing them after he flew his mother 20 hours (in a middle seat, no less) from Ghana to Boston to see him on Raw. Claiming that “she doesn’t deserve this,” Kofi jumped outside and offered her a hug… only for his mother to respond off-mic, “What’s wrong with you?” and refuse to embrace her son, instead leaving while Kingston stood there with arms outstretched.

Yes, the crowd sweetener was obvious here, but getting dissed by your own mother has to be a huge blow that will carry over into future weeks. The goal right now clearly is to condition the fans to boo the New Day, showing that everyone – including Dominik, and even Kofi’s mother – is against them.

Here’s hoping there are real, thunderous boos raining down soon enough.


3. Making Promises

Seth Rollins
WWE

Setting aside Seth Rollins calling his match against CM Punk in two weeks as “the biggest fight in our industry” right now, the Visionary did deliver some strong promises in advance of their 6 January match.

In a sit-down interview, Rollins called Punk a hypocrite for trashing WWE after he left when he actually needed it to be relevant. He ranted about Punk and Roman Reigns being hand-in-hand at Survivor Series and how that scene made him want to throw his remote through the television. His goal in this upcoming match is to make everyone see the hypocrisy and to excise Punk like a cancer.

And that’s where the promise came in. Punk and Rollins have stepped up the physical confrontations, with one more face-to-face coming next week. But Monday night, Seth promised that fans would see a side of him that no one had seen before, a more violent and raw side when he fights Punk.

The reality is that Rollins has now made a promise that this is going to be a PLE-quality match, perhaps even WrestleMania-worthy, as everyone had invested a lot of energy and capital into it. Rollins deserves the benefit of the doubt here, hence the positive marks as they ramp up the hype. But if it fails to deliver on the night, the fall-off will be spectacular.


2. No Fireworks, But A Great Sell

New Bloodline
WWE

Sami Zayn versus Drew McIntyre at Saturday Night’s Main Event was a solid opening match, trim and efficient, a no-wasted-motion bout.

Their rematch Monday night on Raw was the opposite, a slowed-down, more grounded match that focused on Sami’s tremendous selling and comebacks, leading up to Zayn loading up for a Helluva Kick but being unable to pull the trigger due to his injured back. That allowed McIntyre to nail a Claymore for the win and remain undefeated against Sami.

As a typical WWE main event, this was certainly a different pace, as they avoided a lot of the bells and whistles and stuck to a steady drumbeat of Drew torturing Sami’s back, including a back suplex on the apron. That might have been the biggest spot of the match, save for the dueling tilt-o-whirls (a McIntyre backbreaker, and a Zayn DDT).

Afterward, Jey Uso ran down for the save again, only for the Bloodline to arrive and lay both Jey and Sami out, as Drew casually left the ring. All of this was in service of the Tribal Combat match for the Raw on Netflix debut in two weeks, which should be a big turning point in the latest Bloodline saga.

While not Earth-shattering, the new Bloodline continuing its assault of everyone in Roman Reigns’ absence should factor into the OTC’s character arc soon – his team can’t keep taking bullets for him without being acknowledged.


1. Buried Nuggets

Drew McIntyre Sami Zayn
WWE

Drew McIntyre opened Raw Monday night, complaining about his injuries from Hell in a Cell, the personal tragedy he endured when he went home to Scotland, and the lack of sympathy from fans and fellow wrestlers in the aftermath.

The show-opening talk segment felt a lot like a retread of stuff Drew and Sami Zayn have said before about each other, but buried within this promo were a couple of nuggets that should yield fruit as things move forward.

McIntyre sniping at the myth of his colleagues as “one big happy family” was a great way to further isolate himself, but he left a bit of a mystery when he said that only one person called him while he was home recovering. Who is that person, and how will they factor into the story in the coming weeks and months?

Zayn pointed out Drew’s hypocrisy by connecting how McIntyre has had to work through personal strife to the fans, who also have had to deal with tragedy and still show up for their job. It was a great connection that brought the crowd into the moment and made them part of the scene, relating to them and not just talking past them.

It’s also worth noting that McIntyre continued his war of words against CM Punk and Roman Reigns as “the real villains” in WWE. That language echoes what Seth Rollins would say later, adding another thread to bind those two together down the line. Eventually, fans are going to choose Punk and/or Roman over Rollins, and he’s going to snap like Drew did. McIntyre’s rant Monday night laid some of the foundational arguments that Seth could use himself. Time will tell if that comes to fruition or if they get there via other means.


 
Posted On: 
Contributor
Contributor

Scott is a former journalist and longtime wrestling fan who was smart enough to abandon WCW during the Monday Night Wars the same time as the Radicalz. He fondly remembers watching WrestleMania III, IV, V and VI and Saturday Night's Main Event, came back to wrestling during the Attitude Era, and has been a consumer of sports entertainment since then. He's written for WhatCulture since 2014, establishing the Ups and Downs articles for WWE Raw and WWE PPVs/PLEs and composing pieces on a variety of topics.