6 Ups & 6 Downs From AEW Dynamite (Jul 29)

Matt Cardona and Ariane debut on an uncharacteristically flat show.

Matt Cardona
AEW

AEW Dynamite's energy, atmosphere, and exuberance are its biggest selling points. This is typically a bright, colourful wrestling show teeming with life, where freedom of expression crushes sterility and "boring" doesn't exist, regardless of the show's quality.

This wasn't the case last night. A flat atmosphere permeated the worst episode of Dynamite in weeks, accentuating the lows and taking the shine off the highs. This made for an uncharacteristically laborious viewing experience despite the episode playing host to several newsworthy events, including two debuts, a Tag Team Title match, and a huge Inner Circle ten-man tag.

Jerich led his mob into battle against Best Friends, Orange Cassidy, and Jurassic Express, while The Dark Order's Stu Grayson and Evil Uno challenged Kenny Omega and Hangman Page. Elsewhere, indie standout Warhorse jumped up from the underground to face TNT Champion Cody, Jon Moxley teamed with Darby Allin to meet Brian Cage and Ricky Starks, and MJF delivered his "State of the Industry" address.

The Ups-to-Downs ratio in the title should tell you that this wasn't a bad show, though some elements of it definitely didn't work. Let's light the fuse...


Downs...

6. Abandon All Life

AEW wrestlers ringside
AEW

The main factor contributing to Dynamite's lifeless, Moon-like atmosphere was the crowd's reconfiguration. Fewer wrestlers than usual were gathered around ringside this week, with many confined to the bleachers and the heel side almost empty, and those who were there weren't at their most vocal. This detracted from the experience as a whole.

Every part of Dynamite felt lesser as a result. As we noted a few weeks ago, the noise generated by these people meant the show no longer felt like a true Empty Arena Era affair. Take it away and AEW is closer to NJPW's current blandness.

The caveat here, of course, is that having less people around assuages social distancing concerns. If this was AEW's motivation, fair play. These shows are reviewed on the quality of the show, however, not behind-the-scenes stuff, and Dynamite was a harder watch than usual.


5. Papers, Please

Brodie Lee Stu Grayson
AEW

There wasn't much to the Dark Order angle that followed Kenny Omega and Hangman Page vs. Evil Uno and Stu Grayson.

Mr. Brodie Lee took his furious Being the Elite character to television, shouting his minions down, launching papers in Uno's face, and grabbing Grayson by the throat. A short promo saw him infuriated by Hangman for laughing at what was going down before The Young Bucks descended from the bleachers. Lee's group, not the Elite, had the strength in numbers, so goobers surrounded the ring, swarmed the faces, and beat them down until FTR came out for the save, clocking Brodie with a beer cooler then forcing the Order to the ramp.

A semi-effective bridge to next week's mega-tag, sure, but an otherwise uninspired set piece. It would have come off a lot stronger had Lee's recent character development gone down on Dynamite, not BTE. Such is the issue with telling stories across multiple platforms: not everyone is going to watch everything. AEW needs to do a better job of filling in the gaps.


4. Welcome To The Impact Zone

Matt Cardona
AEW

It's impossible not to feel happy for Matt Cardona, who has always seemed like an earnestly good guy and a hard worker. Building organic popularity and momentum is no small feat, particularly in a system that oppresses creativity and freedom like WWE's, so he deserves all the props in the world for getting over before getting turn down in Vinceland. That his methods were so similar to those used by The Young Bucks in creating Being The Elite (and, by extension, AEW) bodes well for him here, making this more than a situation of Cody giving his old friend a job.

But again, these shows have to be judged on what happens on air - and this wasn't a good introduction.

Debuts are difficult in the Empty Arena Era and you'd ideally want Cardona to show up in a big building crammed with fans. That's impossible at the moment, so we can't criticise AEW for that, though this would have reeked of "what is such-and-such doing in the Impact Zone?!" regardless. Cardona just walked out to no fanfare, saved Cody from John Silver and Alex Reynolds, and posed. It was in and out in about a minute and left no lasting impression.

Cardona will likely do well in AEW, starting with next week's tag against Silver and Reynolds. Fingers crossed he successfully becomes the next AEW wrestler to overcome a less-than-stellar introduction.


3. Girl, Hi?!

Ariane Andrew AEW
AEW

A supplemental Down for the news that AEW's Deadly Draw tournament will go down on YouTube, not Dynamite. The women's division needs exposure - shunting them onto the internet, not national television, won't give them that.

The segment in which former WWE wrestler Cameron (now Ariane) was introduced was extremely weird. The Deadly Draw dictates that wrestlers will be paired with whoever draws the same coloured ball as them, so Ariane joins Nyla Rose. The former Funkadactyl walked in, declared this, dropped her catchphrase, and left, leaving Guerrero and Rose as perplexed as the viewer.

It's hardly the most inspiring debut for a wrestler who has been out of the business for four years now, and rarely set the world alight during her time in WWE. Like anyone else, Ariane deserves a chance, though this was a sucky intro.


2. A Poor Hikaru Shida Match

Diamante Hikaru Shida
AEW

How do you have a poor match with Hikaru Shida? The Japanese star has been the leading in-ring light of AEW's inconsistent women's division since its inception. She has a proven track record of making lesser wrestlers look better, helping them to matches above their average rate of delivery, yet she and Diamante contrived to produce one of the stodgiest, most dysfunctional women's matches of recent times.

The frustrating thing about this is that Diamante is good too - they just underdelivered. Badly. This was a clash of sloppy, awkward exchanges, including a dreadful roll-around brawl that saw them tumbling around as if they were drunkenly trying to negotiate a pub floor. There was more later on, with a misplaced sunset flip planting part of Shida's body on the ropes, preventing the pin.

Jim Ross did a good job of covering for the sloppiness on commentary, suggesting Shida, like Cody, was distracted by something else. Still, this was below average.


1. The Amateurish Match In Dynamite History

AEW wrestlers
AEW

The opening bout pitting The Inner Circle against Best Friends and friends was one of the most poorly-executed since AEW's inception. Its existence made sense, as everybody on the babyface side has some kind of beef with Jericho and his gang of goons, but the execution was slow, plodding, disjointed, and did very, very little to raise excitement levels, with even the high spots failing to register more than the slightest spike in adrenaline.

Jungle Boy hurricanrana-ing Santana off the apron was a nice moment, as was the Best Friends mega-hug. Still, it felt like the wrestlers were going through the motions. Rather than delivering an explosion, all-action cloudburst, they were just running through spots, and rarely eye-catching ones. Just a mess with zero structure, little story beyond the Luchasaurus/Jake Hager teases, and a straight-up garbage finish.

Matt Hardy's theme music hit while Sammy Guevara was readying himself on the top rope. This led to Hardy, a babyface, interfering and shoving Guevara down, allowing Luchasaurus to take the pinfall. That Sammy did that incredibly tedious thing of freezing when the music hit made it even worse.

Such a harmful thing to open your show with. May it never happen again.


Ups...

6. FTR Do The Deal

FTR contract signing
AEW

FTR's official AEW contract signing was an average segment, though one that had too much effectively subtle story stuff to consider anything but an Up.

This was FTR kayfabe inking their deals after previous claiming that they were working on a handshake agreement with Tony Khan. They had a couple of legal representatives with them and brought Arn Anderson in, because who knows more about tag team wrestling than 'The Enforcer'? Their clauses and conditions included a 10-second rule on double-team, use of a tag rope, and a guaranteed Tag Team Appreciation Night hosted by them on 12 August, which Anderson clarified was legal.

Hangman Page walked in with a bottle of whiskey and doled it out as the ink was drying. Arn pouring his measure into Cash Wheeler's glass was a nice touch, as was Page giving himself a full glass while FTR only got a finger or two.

In successfully building the established FTR/Page dynamic and hinting towards the Four Horsemen revival with Arn's presence, this worked.


5. A Solid But Unspectacular Title Defence

Hangman Page Kenny Omega
AEW

Hangman Page and Kenny Omega vs. Evil Uno and Stu Grayson was a lower-tier defence for the babyface tandem. That isn't to say it was outright bad (or even average), as the Elite tandem is remarkably consistent between the ropes, though it's hard to call it anything above "pretty good" in this diminished atmosphere.

New Dark Order recruit Anna Jay, who was accompanied out of the ring by the group weeks ago, joined Brodie Lee and Colt Cabana by the commentary desk. They watched on as Uno and Grayson entered a solid performance against the champions. The Dark Order felt more subdued than usual, working the faces over for a prolonged period, though the entire match came to life in a storm of offense late on. This broke the heels' control (shame on the producers for missing what looked like an incredible Grayson dive over the post, by the way) and Page and Omega took the W soon after, nailing the V-Trigger/Buckshot combo.

That there were no clear 'Cleaner' teases from Kenny is disappointing, though the tricky relationship between him and Page was played up well early on.


4. Tryhards Die Hard

Ricky Starks Brian Cage
AEW

Taz cut a good promo on Brian Cage's behalf last night, including a little jab at Jim Cornette, who recently criticised the ex-ECW man for standing in the foreground while 'The Machine' lurked behind. You know that Taz cut a good promo, though. It's what he does every week.

So how about Ricky Starks?

'Absolute' did a good job on the stick too. He apologised to Cage when he said nobody was better than him, calling himself young, handsome, successful, and everything your baby momma hoped you were. He's got something different. Criticising Darby Allin for wrestling like a crash test dummy, Starks said that when you go against him, Cage, and Taz, tryhards die hard - and he was digging two graves last night.

Another sign that Starks is going to be a star here. He is a very good pro-wrestler across the board, from his ring work to his promos, and viewers should bank on him succeeding.


3. Warhorse Steps Up

Cody Warhorse
AEW

Warhorse did a good job of stepping up from the grimy independents to national television last night. This could have gone either way, as his is a heavily-gimmicked act that benefits immensely from a rabid indie crowd, though the man behind the metal is more than good enough to pull through between the ropes as well. At its core, the gimmick is pure '80 and therefore right up Cody's street and while it often overshadows his actual wrestling (which is a shame), Warhorse and 'The American Nightmare' delivered a good TNT Championship match.

This continued the theme of Cody showing increased frustration in his inability to finish opponents quickly, leading to Arn Anderson calming him down. Warhorse worked well with counters, targeting Cody's arm, though the champ worked into a control period during the commercial. The urgency was amplified on the return as Warhose upped the pace. He hit a double-stomp to Cody's back from the apron and scored a near-fall off a top rope elbow drop, though he was eventually submitted via Figure Four.

Cody's earlier leg work paid off in a smartly-worked match that will hopefully do for Warhorse what Eddie Kingston's standout showing did for him last week.


2. Brothers In Destruction

Darby Allin Jon Moxley
AEW

Darby Allin and Jon Moxley's Texas Tornado tag with Brian Cage and Ricky Starks came exactly as advertised. This was a wild, unruly arena-floor brawl rife with plunder and worked at a brisk pace, making it easily one of the most fun things on the card.

That the bout didn't even slow down when Dynamite went picture-in-picture speaks to the chaos, though an early miscommunication on a Cage/Starks double-team undermined this somewhat. It wasn't a derailment, though. The rest of the bout breathed life into an otherwise flat episode, with lots of fast exchanges and inventive spots, including a Coffin Drop/Paradigm Shift combo on Cage before Darby brought the skateboard into play.

A sick finish sequence saw Allin olly the board (which had thumbtacks glued to the bottom) onto Starks' back, scoring the pin. Ricky's flesh was torn and bloody. His partner was helpless to help him, too, as Moxley had his problem arm trapped in a crippling submission on the outside.

The post-match yielded next week's Allin vs. Moxley title fight, which goes down next week and should be loads of fun. They have history, an odd mutual respect, and good chemistry, so it ought to deliver.


1. State Of The Industry

MJF State of the Industry
AEW

Easily the best thing on Dynamite (and the only thing we could earnestly call "great") was MJF's State of the Industry promo, which we probably should have seen coming. 'The Salt of the Earth' dropping fire on the microphone is as big a sure thing as anything else in AEW.

MJF gimmicked the hell out of this, coming out with assistants, a Burberry podium, and the Goldberg entrance. It was like a presidential campaign speech throughout. "We deserve better," was his mantra, and while the promo relied on easy clichés early on, it got better and better as it went on.

Dropping the #MJF2020 and #NotMyChampion hashtags, MJF claimed it was time for a change, stating a certain individual was afraid up being upstaged by the top-ranked guy in the company. The idea of someone being on top of the card because of where they came from is old hat, brother, so he turned his sights onto Jon Moxley, who, decidedly, isn't his champion.

Gymnastics, flop-flopping, and flying were attempts at making "wrestlers" believe they are good at their job, and negative effects of "Dictator Jon's" reign. MJF accused his new foe of cosplaying Steve Austin, being an overhyped ratings draw, and somebody squandering opportunities for the new guard by representing the old guard on top. So, with his talent outweighing Moxley's tenure, MJF is coming for him at All Out.

Top-notch delivery as always, and the gimmick was totally on-point. An excellent way to drag MJF out of the holding pattern he'd been in, shunt him towards the main event scene, and take one step closer to establishing him as the heel in AEW.


Channel Manager
Channel Manager

Andy has been with WhatCulture for 10 years and is currently WhatCulture's Wrestling Channel Manager. A writer, presenter, and editor with 10+ years of experience in online media, he has been a sponge for all wrestling knowledge since playing an old Royal Rumble 1992 VHS to ruin in his childhood. Having previously worked for Bleacher Report, Andy specialises in short and long-form writing, video presenting, voiceover acting, and editing, all characterised by expert wrestling knowledge and commentary. Andy is as much a fan of 1985 Jim Crockett Promotions as he is present-day AEW and WWE - just don't make him choose between the two.