6 Ups & 7 Downs From WWE WrestleMania 37 - Night 2

Roman reigns supreme; Ripley has crowning moment; Fiend cheats death, jobs to RKO.

Roman Reigns Jey Uso WrestleMania 37
WWE.com

Well, that was certainly a definitive way to close out a WrestleMania.

Stomping (or chairing) your opponents into submission and then pinning their lifeless corpses has to be a the top of the list of ways to establish your dominance over a roster, and we should just take a moment to bow to the greatness that is Roman Reigns.

And kudos to the other guys in the match, Daniel Bryan and Edge, who together put on a show-saving performance in the main event of Sunday night’s WrestleMania 37. Up to that point, Mania’s second night wasn’t bad, but it wasn’t terribly memorable either.

It was tough to get the bad taste of the opener between Randy Orton and The Fiend out of our collective mouths, as WWE took a horrific feud and just saw it through with a terrible match to start the show. We won’t spoil it, but it involved black goo.

Throw in a subpar women’s tag title match and a lackluster Intercontinental Championship match and the undercard wasn’t cutting it. We did get some good performances in the United States Championship match and the rivalry between Kevin Owens and Sami Zayn. But the Raw Women’s Championship and Universal Championship matches really pumped up the show’s stock.

Still, WWE managed to botch simple stuff, showing that the problem isn’t the talent, it’s the dopes writing this stuff. Maybe clean house there, and don’t axe the wrestlers.

Let’s get to it…


Downs…

7. Questionable Booking Decision

Nia Jax Shayna Baszler
WWE.com

With Rhea Ripley winning the Raw Women’s Championship on Sunday, it’s clear WWE is positioning her as the next big star on the red brand, so it would make sense to have opponents lined up for her.

If that’s the case, then why did Nia Jax & Shayna Baszler retain the WWE Women’s Tag Team Championship on Sunday night? It would have worked well to have them lose the titles to Natalya & Tamina, then turn their attention to their single’s pursuits, and the Raw title – and Ripley.

Also, the women’s tag “division” has been a joke for months, so putting the titles on someone different would have at least given the chance to reset things a bit and maybe change things up.

But we didn’t get that, so now if Baszler or Jax go for Rhea’s title, it would mean that the tag titles would be sidelined for a while. Not exactly what you should be going for here.


6. How Do You Blow That?

Rob Van Dam Riddle The Great Khali
WWE

WWE has all but ruined Riddle on the main roster by turning him into a goofy caricature of a stoner, making dumb jokes and being generally annoying to everyone around him.

But on Sunday, they paired him up with a Hall-of-Famer who could have actually delivered a really perfect, symbiotic moment: the Great Khali. Well, he was there initially, but it was Rob Van Dam showing up that really made you think that this was going to be the meeting of the minds.

Here was RVD, the original WWE stoner character, alongside the 2021 version in Riddle, and the best they could think of was to have Van Dam act as Khali’s translator, and then have Riddle do Mr. Monday Night’s “RVD” shtick.

Good Lord, these writers had how long to come up with that dud?


5. Cole’s Verbal Flaws Continue

Michael Cole Samoa Joe WWE WrestleMania 37
WWE

Saturday night’s SmackDown Women’s Championship match went off without a hitch, save for “the Voice of WWE” Michael Cole horribly flubbing the finish, calling that Sasha Banks had kicked out of Bianca Belair’s KOD, when she in fact stayed down for the 3 count. Cole was rightly raked over the, *ahem* coals on the internet for it.

On Sunday, however, Cole continued to dazzle us with his verbal miscues. During the opening match, Randy Orton threw the Fiend into the giant Jack in the box at ringside, which Cole called a “box-like structure.” He later called Sami Zayn’s Michinoku Driver a “Blue Thunder Bomb,” which looks very different. (Corey Graves corrected him to “save” him from internet embarrassment.)

You’d think after 20-plus years, they would have found someone else who can call matches and get storylines across without flubs like these, but we get what we deserve, apparently.


4. Read The Room

Bella Twins
WWE

Memo to WWE: No one likes or cares about the Bella Twins. They’re not icons or legendary performers, no matter how much you build them up or fake honors you bestow upon them.

So when Nikki and Brie Bella came out to shut up Bayley (who was killing it by insulting Titus O’Neil, Hulk Hogan and Michael Cole), the fans rightly booed the entire beatdown from the Bellas. In the writers’ room, they probably envisioned this segment as a big welcome back moment for the Bellas, silencing the loudmouth Bayley. But the fans crapped on that decision – as they should have.

Maybe if fan-favourite Molly Holly had come out and battled Bayley, fans would have been more accepting of it. At least Bayley got off a nice dig to Nikki: “John Cena’s not here tonight.”


3. A Misfire

Apollo Crews
WWE

Apollo Crews’ recent rebirth as Nigerian royalty has been strange, but considering how listless his WWE career has been, we’re more than willing to give that a pass.

But his Intercontinental Championship match against Big E was disappointing, to say the least. Crews and E battled in a Nigerian Drum Fight, which really was just a no-DQ/hardcore match with drums and a gong at ringside. The match came about after Big E defeated Apollo multiple times in IC title bouts, but regardless, it had promise.

Instead, just as the match seemed to be hitting its stride, Crews missed a frog splash through a table, and E hit a Big Ending, only for Dabba-Kato to resurface in a Sgt. Pepper knockoff outfit and hit E with an Asiatic Spike. He then dragged Apollo on top of E to capture IC gold.

The entire thing just felt off and never really clicked. Throw in the out-of-the-blue interference from Dabba-Kato and the fact that a drum was never used (or heard) during a Nigerian Drum Fight, and you have what can best (and most politely) be described as a misfire.


2. Women’s Tag Match Fizzles

Shayna Baszler Natalya
WWE.com

No one was really expecting much from the WWE Women’s Tag Team Championship match between Nia Jax & Shayna Baszler and Natalya & Tamina, and it’s clear why.

All four women worked hard, but no amount of forced effort could make up for Nia and Tamina stumbling around the ring. It’s hard to believe that they have 16 combined years of main roster experience. Nattie and Baszler did an admirable job, but everything was hinging on the Samoan showdown, so we had to endure that.

At the very least, this was probably the least bad option of the tag teams from Saturday’s tag team turmoil match to have a passable match against Jax & Baszler. The only other option would have been the Riott Squad, and they wouldn’t have been believable against the champs.


1. What The Hell Was That?

Alexa Bliss The Fiend
WWE.com

So after an attempted homicide, a mystic resurrection, and months of fireballs and black goo, Randy Orton and The Fiend finally met in the ring again… and they had a regular wrestling match.

With all the various stipulations flying around the WrestleMania card, you would have thought that this would have been a Firefly Funhouse match, or some weird contest. But aside from red lights, Orton and Fiend just wrestled a normal match with typical moves.

But just when you thought it wasn’t strange enough, Alexa Bliss appeared on top of the Jack in the Box decked out like some dark queen – and proceeded to “bleed” black goo from the crown. This somehow distracted Fiend, who then turned around into an RKO… for the pin.

After six months of this supernatural stuff, Orton and Fiend had a regular wrestling match – mixed with a bleeding Queen Bliss – and then Fiend, who came back from the dead, jobbed to an RKO.

Oh, and then Fiend just disappeared from the ring. And the crowd rightly booed. Hopefully, this is an unceremonious ending to a horrendous feud. If not, we need to find a way to Old Yeller this rivalry for good.


Ups…

6. Karma Is A B****

Titus O'Neil Hulk Hogan
WWE.com

Few in professional wrestling have been more cockroach-like than Hulk Hogan, an industry icon who has existed at the top of the mountain for decades. However, he also has committed several transgressions outside the ring that has sullied whatever good name he had.

Hogan emerged from a wrestling purgatory a few years ago and resumed his role as a WWE legend, to diminishing returns. For WrestleMania 37, WWE decided to trot him out as a co-host of the event alongside Titus O’Neil. But the 25,000 fans in attendance on Sunday weren’t willing to just blindly cheer the Hulkster because it was what was expected.

Fans booed Hogan every time he talked. At first, you might not have been sure, but the crowd made it clear as they cheered every utterance from Titus and then booed Hulk louder each time.

So a slow clap for the fans, who wasted no time in being snarky in the best possible way.


5. KO, Zayn Do What They Do

Kevin Owens Sami Zayn
WWE.com

Sometimes, all you have to do to have a really good wrestling match is just take two talented individuals and let them go at each other.

In the case of Sami Zayn and Kevin Owens, the two longtime best friends tore into each other, battling nonstop with everything in their respective arsenals. Zayn hit KO with a suplex on the apron, a Michinoku Driver, a Blue Thunder Bomb, a brainbuster and two exploder suplexes into the corner. But Owens hit his frog splash, super fisherman’s buster, and then countered a second Helluva kick with a pair of superkicks before putting Sami away with a Stunner.

While it wasn’t a lengthy classic, Zayn and Owens crammed as much as they could into it, and KO hit a Stunner on Logan Paul as a bonus, so everyone wins.


4. Sheamus Finally Wins One

Sheamus Riddle
WWE.com

If you were to label one wrestler on Raw as the underrated MVP, it would have to be Sheamus.

For the past few months the Celtic Warrior has repeatedly had really good matches with a variety of opponents. He has been able to bring out the best in Drew McIntyre, Bobby Lashley and Riddle, but he seemed to be the odd man out. His friendship and feud with McIntyre was excellent, and honestly, it could have worked as a WrestleMania match, but he was on the short end of the stick.

So it was somewhat fitting that the Celtic Warrior got a shot at the United States Championship and delivered a banger of a match against Riddle… and managed to wrestle the title away from the Original Bro. The match had everything you could have asked for, including a jaw-dropping finish, with Riddle going for a quebrada and Sheamus Brogue Kicking him in the upside-down face.

Congrats to Sheamus, and here’s hoping that he gets a good and proper run with the strap. If he just continues what he’s been doing and wrecking opponents, it could be a good reign.


3. Ripley Has Her Crowning Moment

Rhea Ripley
WWE

Last year should have been a career-defining moment for Rhea Ripley. She was slated to defend her NXT Women’s Championship at WrestleMania 36 in front of 80,000 fans. Then the pandemic hit, and Charlotte Flair beat Ripley in an empty Performance Center for the title.

But on Sunday, Ripley got her redemption, fighting Asuka for the Raw Women’s Championship and defeating the Empress in a solid title bout. The match pitted Asuka’s speed and varied offense against Rhea’s brute strength, which proved to be too much for the champ. Asuka pulled out all the stops, hitting a DDT off the apron to the floor and repeatedly going for submission moves.

Ripley countered with power moves, like deadlifting and powerbombing Asuka to break up armbar attempts. In the end, Rhea dodged a kick and nailed Riptide for the win, earning the title and getting her moment in the spotlight.

As with Bianca Belair Saturday night, you hope WWE is ready to push her properly and make sure they don’t screw up this star-making turn.


2. A Successful Return To ‘Normal’

WrestleMania 37 singer
WWE.com

For two nights at least, things felt almost normal for the first time in more than a year. After going through an empty Performance Center, to NXT trainees filling in as the PC audience, to the ThunderDome, it’s been a wild ride for WWE.

This weekend’s WrestleMania might have been operating at about 1/3 capacity, but seeing and hearing the crowd react to entrances and matches reminded you what’s been missing from the industry we love. (Of course, there’s still the knee-jerk cringing when you see people in close quarters, some of whom weren’t masked.)

Real fans chanting “Yes!” to Daniel Bryan’s entrance, singing along to Sami Zayn’s theme music, audibly anticipating Kevin Owens’ Stunner to Logan Paul, screaming loudly for Edge, and booing the Fiend’s disappearance illustrated the difference between the ThunderDome shows we’ve endured for the past several months and the real McCoy.

It’s probably going to be a while before we see this on a regular basis – although you have to imagine WWE is considering whether they could pull off a live crowd at least for PPVs given the energy the crowd fed to the wrestlers – so hopefully everyone enjoyed it.

And hopefully there were no negative consequences from the large gathering of fans.


1. Sticking With The Tribal Chief

Roman Reigns celebration
WWE.com

While a good case could be made for any of the three men in the Universal Championship match, it’s hard to argue with WWE for continuing to ride the horse that is Roman Reigns.

Edge, Daniel Bryan and Reigns (and Jey Uso) had a solid, action-packed triple threat main event on Sunday night, and at various points it looked like any one of them could and would walk out of WrestleMania 37 with the title. But when Edge snapped near the end and hit a conchairto on Bryan, it looked like we were heading toward a rarity, with both Royal Rumble winners capturing the gold.

But Jey interfered, saving Roman, who then speared and blasted Edge with a conchairto of his own, then dragged the Rated-R Superstar’s lifeless corpse on top of Bryan for the double pin.

Some might say it demeaned both Bryan and Edge, but seriously, who can touch Reigns right now? The only way he was going to lose this match was if one of the other wrestlers pinned the other guy (the one not named Roman Reigns), and really, if that’s the case, they might as well just keep the title where it is right now.


Contributor
Contributor

Scott is a former journalist and longtime wrestling fan who was smart enough to abandon WCW during the Monday Night Wars the same time as the Radicalz. He fondly remembers watching WrestleMania III, IV, V and VI and Saturday Night's Main Event, came back to wrestling during the Attitude Era, and has been a consumer of sports entertainment since then. He's written for WhatCulture since 2014, establishing the Ups and Downs articles for WWE Raw and WWE PPVs/PLEs and composing pieces on a variety of topics.