6 Ups And 6 Downs From WWE Hell In A Cell 2017

A dramatic, vicious cell match dazzles fans. And there was another one with Shane-O-Mac!

Kevin Owens Shane McMahon
WWE.com

WWE was poised to deliver a good PPV Sunday with a couple memorable moments. And while it did for the most part deliver, it also left something to be desired.

Hell in a Cell put forward a tremendous cell match that had high drama and emotion, the bitter hatred of a heated rivalry coming to a climax… and then there was a second cell match as the main event.

When the best match of the show is the opening bout, you run the risk of burning the crowd out or having them become increasingly restless. And the bout between the Usos and New Day set the bar so high that only the United States Championship contest came close to matching it.

The HIAC match between Kevin Owens and Shane McMahon was full of heart-pounding moments, and while some will contend that those breathtaking moments translate into an awesome match, they’re overvaluing it. A stunt-show full of high-impact bumps does not necessarily make for an awesome bout. KO and Shane-O-Mac had a good car-crash of a match, with a nice twist at the end, but it wasn’t the all-timer that the announcers will surely call it on Tuesday.

Overall, this wasn’t a bad PPV by any stretch, but back out the two midcard title matches and you have a subpar event. Still, it’s worth checking out if you have three hours to kill.

With that said, let’s find out what scaled the cell and what came crashing to Earth. Let’s get to it…


Downs...

6. Roode, Ziggler Get Death Slot

Dolph Ziggler Bobby Roode
WWE.com

You really can’t fault Bobby Roode or Dolph Ziggler for their match getting less than an enthusiastic response. After all, it came after Jinder Mahal sucked the oxygen out of the room by retaining his title, and it was the only match standing between fans and the Hell in a Cell main event.

Still, although this mini-feud does have a decent premise – Ziggler has been ticked about wrestlers getting attention and adoration for their flash rather than their substance – it hasn’t really gotten a lot of traction. Roode is a former NXT Champion, which means he hardly is all flash. And Ziggler’s entire persona is rooted in being a show-off – hell, his intro music says it all. While that might apply to his ringwork, he’s never been afraid to be flashy outside of it.

It’s really not fair. This should be a good feud, and it might be one. But it just felt flat Sunday night. The circumstances mentioned earlier might have hijacked it, but we’ve still gotta give it a grade, and as of right now, it felt like a negative. But this writer reserves the right to modify that going forward.


5. Cheap Finish

Natalya Charlotte Flair
WWE.com

Let’s get this straight: Natalya spent an entire match working over Charlotte Flair’s knee, only to give up and just bash her with a chair for the DQ?

Who booked this crap?

Seriously, what a waste of 10 minutes. This wasn’t as if Charlotte was locked in the Sharpshooter for an extended period multiple times and refused to give up, or as if she nearly beat Nattie a few times. The champ was largely in control for much of the match. She hit a moonsault to the floor for her first big move in a while, prompting Natalya to grab a chair.

It was a horribly disappointing ending to a match billed as the next chapter in a “storied” rivalry between the Harts and the Flairs. In reality, it’s a chapter best left unwritten… at least at this point.


4. Rusev Flounders Again

Rusev Randy Orton
WWE.com

Seriously, did Rusev make a pass at Stephanie McMahon or something?

The Bulgarian Brute is by all accounts a complete athlete. Far from being a typical foreign heel, Rusev is athletic in the ring, is competent on the mic and has meshed well with nearly every opponent he’s faced. And yet, he’s lost 70% of his televised matches this year and has lost all five PPV matches he’s had.

Granted, Randy Orton is one of the biggest names in WWE, but let’s face it: babyface Orton is bland and boring. Sure, fans cheer for him, but is anyone truly clamoring for a mega-face run for him in 2017? The most interesting Orton has been in recent memory is when he joined the Wyatt Family – and not because he turned on them as part of a “master plan” and won the WWE Championship.

Rusev could have used a big win Sunday night to give himself some momentum. Even a win with a little help from Aiden English would have worked. But losing clean to an RKO after losing at SummerSlam in mere seconds was just shoveling dirt on him.


3. Shane ‘Evel Knievel’ McMahon

shane mcmahon HIAC
WWE.com

We all knew when Shane McMahon was set to square off against Kevin Owens that it was going to result in a car crash, a series of stuntman-esque spots building to a big climax.

And while you’ll see some praise later on, that doesn’t mean we can’t be frustrated with the simple premise that a 47-year-old executive who had wrestled three matches in the past eight years went through all that punishment and still continued to fight on. Contrast that with two-time world champion Dolph Ziggler losing to a rollup with tights in the previous match or any other distraction finish we see week after week.

That simply is going to be a repeat complaint whenever McMahon wrestles. While he should be commended for his fearless attitude, it really suspends disbelief that he has given Undertaker, AJ Styles and now KO a run for their money. (No pun intended.)

If they operated from a position that Shane was outmatched and needed an equalizer of some sort to level the playing field, that would have worked better. But there’s an inherent belief in WWE that a McMahon is on equal footing with any talent.


2. Sucking Oxygen Out Of The Room

Jinder Mahal
WWE.com

Look, maybe the ratings and attendance figures back up keeping the WWE Championship around Jinder Mahal’s waist, but that certainly isn’t the case in this writer’s opinion.

The easiest comparison some might make with Jinder as champion is Honky Tonk Man in 1987-88, when he reigned for more than a year as a hated heel who held onto his title by hook or by crook, often with his manager interfering or by getting counted out or disqualified.

However, that’s where the comparisons end.

Honky sold out house shows as a headliner for B-shows. There isn’t any evidence that SmackDown is selling out with Jinder on top. In fact, plenty of photos have surfaced showing the exact opposite. Ratings have at best held steady since Mahal became champ.

When Mahal defends his title, the reaction doesn’t feel like fans are made that a vile heel escaped with the title; it feels like they can’t believe this career jobber is still champion.

Again, maybe there are good reasons out there to keep him as champion. And maybe the fact this writer is ticked off is part of the game – after all, wrestling is all about playing with fans’ emotions to get them invested in the product. But this feels more like a cruel joke than part of the show.


1. Burning Another Top Talent

Jinder Mahal Shinsuke Nakamura
WWE.com

Maybe more than just the frustration of Jinder Mahal retaining his WWE Championship once again is the fact that he did it for the second time at the expense of Shinsuke Nakamura.

In NXT, Nakamura was a phenom, a guy who took the brand by storm with his fast and flashy moves and unique persona. He was incredible to watch, and he was booked properly, as a dominant force who was all-but-impossible to best. You couldn’t help but think that there was no way that WWE could screw this up – as long as they followed a similar blueprint on the main roster.

And then they stuck him against Jinder Mahal at two straight PPVs, where he lost both matches. Compare that to Shinsuke’s first NXT match against Sami Zayn, where fans chanted, “Fight forever!” throughout it. Nakamura hit the ring with a dull thud when Mahal hit the Khallas, and fans just groaned.

Instead of making a new star that could captivate fans, a champ who could carry great matches with top talent, WWE made Nakamura just another guy. Somewhere, someone in the back was probably talking about Shinsuke paying his dues, or remarking at how him losing will help him “get over” in the long run.

Regardless of that idle speculation, it was a waste. If Nakamura wasn’t going to win the title, then they shouldn’t have put them into these matches to lose.


Ups...

6. Some Love For Greg Hamilton

Greg Hamilton
WWE.com

For fans of a certain age, no one will ever be able to top Howard Finkel. The iconic WWF/E ring announcer was the voice of a generation of youngsters who dreamed of hearing themselves announced as new champion.

But WWE has had a dearth of ring announcers in recent years, with the company turning to less-than-adequate, unmemorable barkers. While JoJo might be beautiful and have an incredible singing voice, it’s hard to imagine anyone envisioning walking down the ramp to her ring introductions.

But SmackDown ring announcer Greg Hamilton deserves a little credit. He seems to have gotten some of the best parts of the job down. His cadence in introducing wrestlers is great – listen to him run down AJ Styles’ intro. His inflection works really well too – listen to him introduce Shinsuke Nakamura. And he gets something right that JoJo constantly fails to do: knowing that that the fans today often repeat “one fall” as part of their audience participation routine, Hamilton actually waits for them to do their bit before continuing.

Sure, Hamilton is no Finkel, but hearing him Sunday night was a reminder that some ring announcers are better than others, and Greg is pretty good.


5. A Step Forward For Tye

AJ Styles Tye Dillinger
WWE.com

The easy, cynical view is that Tye Dillinger was inserted into the United States Championship match to provide an easy out for the writers to transition the title from AJ Styles to Baron Corbin without AJ losing.

And while that might be true, Sunday’s triple threat U.S. title match represented a step forward for Tye. Why? Because Hell in a Cell was only Dillinger’s second WWE PPV appearance (not counting kickoff shows) after the Royal Rumble. Dillinger has been on the main roster fulltime since April and hadn’t had a PPV match until Sunday. Mull that over.

So being in that match was a step forward. But then, we also got to see Tye hang with AJ and help elevate the match – which on paper might have been pretty dull with Styles trying to carry Corbin – into something pretty good. Tye even had a couple moments where he looked like he had a chance to walk out with the strap.

But in the end, the Perfect 10 was there for one purpose. But hopefully, the higher-ups saw Dillinger use his opportunity to put in a solid performance, and it won’t be nine months before his next PPV bout.


4. Something For Sami

Sami Zayn
WWE.com

A spot was reserved in the “downs” section to lament how Sami Zayn had been on the periphery of the Shane McMahon/Kevin Owens rivalry but was left off the PPV entirely. Thankfully, that item wasn’t written before the last five minutes of Hell in a Cell.

Zayn showed up at the end of the HIAC match between KO and McMahon, and he made a big impact. Sami pulled his former (and now current?) best friend Owens off the announce table seconds before Shane plummeted through it after jumping off the cell. Then, Zayn dragged KO’s carcass over to pin McMahon.

While that might constitute a heel turn – which would be a huge character swing for him – Sami looked conflicted as he walked off. Regardless, it still was a fairly big development for Zayn, a guy who has been given little to do in WWE for the past year other than reliably have great matches on the undercard.

As long as Sami isn’t bound for serving as Shane’s victim at the next PPV, this is at least something that looks better than doing nothing.


3. Two Of The Best

Usos New Day
WWE.com

There’s an old adage that when you pit two great players or teams against each other, they often up each other’s games, resulting in an even better contest. Think the Red Sox and Yankees in baseball.

So while pitting New Day against the Usos might not be on the level of 80s glory days tag team wrestling, they still are two of the best tag teams in WWE in recent memory. And matching the two teams up against each other has produced some excellent bouts this summer and fall. And Sunday’s Hell in a Cell match was no different.

We’ll discuss the match itself later, but let’s just give credit to the job these two teams have done to elevate tag team wrestling and captivate fans. They battled in only the third HIAC tag team match and made a PG PPV look brutal. And despite trading the SmackDown Tag Team Championships back and forth, they’ve made them something that should be a prize to capture.

Here’s hoping the next team to step up to face the Usos is game.


2. Heart In Your Throat

kevin owens shane mcmahon
WWE.com

As mentioned earlier, let’s set aside the gripe about Shane McMahon not being a wrestler and still going toe-to-toe with top talent.

The Hell in a Cell main event provided enough suspense toward the end that it felt like a horror movie, where you have your hands up to your face because you can barely watch. Of course, this is referring to the portion spent on top of the cell as Shane and Kevin Owens slammed each other on the roof of the structure.

Every time someone bumped onto the cell, you couldn’t help but remember Mankind breaking through the roof and plummeting to the ring below. Shane slammed and suplexed Owens, while KO hit a senton and pop-up powerbomb on the commissioner.

The match itself was little more than a series of elaborate stunts, and really shouldn’t be highly regarded, but at least there was a tangible storyline behind it and the elaborate stunts kept your attention.


1. Usos, New Day Reinvent The Wheel

uso new day
WWE.com

After 36 matches, you would be forgiven if you thought there wasn’t much new ground to break inside Hell in a Cell. After all, we’ve seen people tossed off the cell, slammed and speared through it, and beaten inside it with nearly ever weapon imaginable.

But the Usos and New Day managed to innovate several new moments Sunday night – and now, we’re not talking about using a trombone, cowbell and gong as weapons. The two teams wailed on each other with kendo sticks, speared each other into the cell, and imprisoned their opponents while inside a prison.

The match itself should be notable for the sheer volume of gruesome spots, as well as the creative ones employed. This match set the bar extremely high and, as Corey Graves put it, neither team should be disappointed – although the Usos certainly will have an easier time licking their wounds.


Contributor
Contributor

Scott is a former journalist and longtime wrestling fan who was smart enough to abandon WCW during the Monday Night Wars the same time as the Radicalz. He fondly remembers watching WrestleMania III, IV, V and VI and Saturday Night's Main Event, came back to wrestling during the Attitude Era, and has been a consumer of sports entertainment since then. He's written for WhatCulture since 2014, establishing the Ups and Downs articles for WWE Raw and WWE PPVs/PLEs and composing pieces on a variety of topics.