6 Ups And 8 Downs From WWE Elimination Chamber 2017

Bray Wyatt's coronation tops an otherwise pedestrian night for the blue brand.

bray wyatt wwe champ
WWE.com

After watching a big-deal PPV like the Royal Rumble, almost anything is going to pale in comparison. Throw in that just two weeks later is a brand-specific PPV and odds are you’re going to be underwhelmed.

That more or less describes Sunday’s Elimination Chamber PPV, a SmackDown-only event sold on a stacked chamber match with six of the brand’s biggest stars… and then a bunch of other matches. When half of the card is filled with women’s matches from a ridiculously limited roster, you know you’re scraping bottom.

Despite that, Sunday’s event was fine for what it was. But one thing it wasn’t was a major table-setter for WrestleMania XXXIII. Sure, we saw two title changes, but aside from a couple matches, SmackDown’s contributions to Mania remain largely a mystery (within storylines). That means that it’ll be up to regular episodes of SmackDown to lay out the blue brand’s matches for Orlando.

With a new world champion in Bray Wyatt, it will be interesting to see the dynamic between he and Royal Rumble winner Randy Orton, as the two Wyatt Family members appear to be on a collision course in seven weeks.

With that said, let’s find what survived the chamber and what was beaten and battered. Let’s get to it…


Downs...

8. True Filler

mojo rawley curt hawkins
WWE.com

On one hand, this is exactly the kind of match that should be a warmup act.

On the other hand, what does it say about WWE’s roster depth issues when Mojo Rawley versus Curt Hawkins is a PPV kickoff show match?

Hawkins and Rawley had what could best be described as a perfectly pedestrian and acceptable TV match before Elimination Chamber officially got underway, with Hawkins disrespecting Mojo’s buddy Rob Gronkowski on Twitter being the setup for this bout. There really isn’t much to say about the match, other than it happened, and Rawley took the victory.

This isn’t meant as a slight against the two wrestlers, but it’s just reflective of how thin the two main rosters are when this is deemed worthy of a PPV, even if it’s a kickoff show bout. Seriously, there’s no one else to put out there?


7. Carmella/Ellsworth Segments

Every once in a while, you have moments that make you groan louder and louder every time they arise. That was the case Sunday every time they cut to the skybox with Carmella and James Ellsworth.

Dasha Fuentes kept asking Carmella questions after each of the three women’s matches, and each time, Carmella gave short, insipid answers that didn’t say anything and didn’t advance anything. Ellsworth then just repeated it while the two ate popcorn. The “payoff” for these segments was Ellsworth kicking Dasha out of the skybox at the end.

Maybe this writer is missing something from SmackDown, but these “interviews” added nothing to the PPV and were beyond pointless. Just a waste of time.


6. Miz Tossed With Ease

john cena miz
WWE.com

For all the talk about how improved and how much of a career renaissance he has been having, the Miz got beat pretty easily Sunday night.

Miz was the last man out of the Elimination Chamber and quickly stole a pin on Dean Ambrose, then hit his version of Daniel Bryan’s Yes kicks and corner dropkicks on his opponents. But then, he quickly at an Attitude Adjustment from John Cena to end his night, just like that. To call it unceremonious would be an understatement, and it somewhat undermined all the talk about how Miz has improved in the past year.

The ease with which Cena dropped Miz also makes you wonder if WWE actually pulls the trigger a mixed tag feud involving the two (more on that later). Why would that even be a thing when you consider how easily Cena beat Miz? That was just a poor decision.


5. Pinfall Via Rollup

baron corbin
WWE.com

Inside a demonic structure where people get tossed into a chain-linked fence, backdropped onto a steel floor and thrown through plexiglass pods, you’d imagine it would take a Herculean effort to pin someone.

So when a dominant heel gets pinned via rollup, you have to be a bit more than shocked, right? Or maybe disappointed is the right word. Either way, it defied logic when Dean Ambrose simply rolled up a distracted Baron Corbin while he tried to coax Miz out of his pod. Sure, it set Baron up to demolish Ambrose and “get his heat back,” but it looked completely out of place to see guys being tossed into the chamber wall, slammed on the floor and powerbombed on the mat and still kick out, but Corbin couldn’t handle a rollup.

There are times that a rollup is going to happen and we might as well accept it. It’s part of wrestling. But inside the Elimination Chamber, where people are getting slammed into every surface of the structure? Come on.


4. Won’t Commit To Heel Run

dolph ziggler apollo crews
WWE.com

It’s fair to say that Dolph Ziggler was stale as a character when he finally turned heel recently. He was long overdue for a change, and that’s what they delivered.

However, WWE has been hesitant to have the turn fire on all cylinders, opting to have Ziggler lose to Apollo Crews on SmackDown and then fall to Crews and Kalisto in a 2-on-1 handicap match at Elimination Chamber.

Yes, Ziggler jumped Kalisto beforehand and injured Apollo afterward, but if the goal was to revitalize Dolph, why only go halfway? Why not have him win the match by putting his feet on the ropes or pulling the tights?

It’s just a half-a$$ed way of doing things. Commit to the heel turn and have Ziggler look like a legit threat. Beating two babyfaces who aren’t doing anything of note would have been one way to accomplish that. Instead, we get a “two steps forward, one giant step back” approach.


3. Mute Otunga

becky lynch miz
WWE.com

This column constantly gives Byron Saxton grief for his lackluster announcing, but David Otunga might be worse.

Sunday, Otunga immediately showed how not-ready-for-primetime he was during the first match when he noted that Mickie James hadn’t been in WWE for seven years, so she must have a lot of ring-rust on her. He would repeat that claim multiple times during the match.

Let’s quickly unpack that: WWE has been openly acknowledging that wrestlers come to the company from other promotions and have achieved success all over the world. They might not reference the company by name (such as TNA), but they definitely will note that wrestlers have experience.

That’s what made Otunga’s repeated insistence that Mickie James was rusty such a moronic statement. It was so bad that the third time he said it, JBL jumped in and shut him down, noting that Mickie had been competing all over the world the past seven years, just not in WWE.

Stick to bodybuilding, David.


2. Truncated Tag Team Turmoil

usos american alpha
WWE.com

Sometimes, more is not necessarily better.

In a likely effort to give more tag teams a PPV slot and make the SmackDown Tag Team Championships look more competitive and desirable, (all) six tag team competed Sunday in a tag team turmoil match, which was five short, successive matches ending with American Alpha successfully defending their titles.

But while the matches meant that more tag teams got to showcase their talents, it prevented American Alpha from really standing out as the top duo. Instead of five mini-matches, they could have booked one 15-minute tag battle with the Usos or a triple threat tag match with an additional team and let Jason Jordan and Chad Gable pull fans in.

Instead, the tag champs showed up second-from-last and beat the Usos in a short bout with a rollup, then got pummeled by Jimmy and Jey before rallying against the Ascension to defend their titles. It felt more like a time-filler than a courageous title defense.


1. So This Is How It Begins…

nikki bella natalya
WWE.com

Please tell us this isn’t how we get the rumored mix tag match.

Fans have long assumed that John Cena would have a marquee match at WrestleMania XXXIII, possibly against the Undertaker. But recently, rumors have flowed that Cena would tag with real-life girlfriend Nikki Bella against the Miz and his wife Maryse. As crazy as it sounded, it looks like we got the first hint at it Sunday night.

During a backstage brawl between Nikki and Natalya, Nikki got knocked into Maryse, sending powder flying everyone and knocking Maryse over. Later, she did not accompany Miz to the ring, and JBL reminded everyone why she likely didn’t come out.

Kane and Chris Jericho once had a feud over spilled coffee. Edge and Booker T had a WrestleMania battle over a shampoo commercial. Somehow, this feud – if it comes to pass – would lower that bar.


Ups...

6. Women Lead Off Solidly

becky lynch mickie james
WWE.com

There was a time in the not-too-distant past that WWE would never have thought about putting a women’s match on first on a PPV. It just would’ve flown.

But Sunday, Mickie James and Becky Lynch led off Elimination Chamber with a solid bout that stayed relatively grounded and still worked really well. James worked over Becky’s arm for much of the match, but both women traded their signature spots, leading up to Mickie’s jumping DDT being countered into a Disarm-Her, which was countered into a rollup, which Lynch countered into a jackknife cover for the three count.

Becky’s victory was more of an escape given that Mickie was on offense much of the match, but that worked pretty well. And James showed she should help elevate the quality of the SmackDown women’s division going forward.


5. Ziggler Takes Shortcuts

dolph ziggler apollo crews
WWE.com

Put the match aside for a minute, and look at what happened before and after.

Dolph Zigger solidified his much-needed heel turn Sunday by taking out Kalisto before his 2-on-1 handicap match, then afterward proceeded to attack both the luchador and Apollo Crews. Dolph took it a step further when he grabbed a steel chair and Pillmanized Crews’ ankle twice. Destroying an opponent’s ankle like that is something that is missing from heels these days – you don’t really see it all too often – and it instantly gave Ziggler more of a hardened edge.

Sure, the conniving heel bit didn’t work entirely beforehand, with Kalisto recovering and factoring into the finish of the match, but in this aspect, Dolph played his part well.


4. Naomi Gets Her Moment

naomi women's
WWE.com

We can quibble over whether it was the right time to switch the title, or whether the right challenger won the strap, but all of that should take a backseat to Naomi winning her first championship in WWE.

The former Funkadactyl suffered through years of sidetracks since her NXT days, from being the aforementioned backup dancer to Brodus Clay, to getting injured just as she was on the cusp of a title chase. Naomi had been on the outskirts of the title picture for a long time, but Sunday night, she found her way in, defeating Alexa Bliss in a somewhat disjointed match.

And it looks like just in time: If she manages to hold onto the SmackDown Women’s Championship for the next seven weeks, she’ll defend it at WrestleMania XXXIII in her hometown of Orlando, Fla.


3. Harper Holds His Own

luke harper randy orton
WWE.com

The outcome of the Randy Orton/Luke Harper match never really was in doubt, but the outstanding question centered on how much of a fight Harper would put up before falling to the 2017 Royal Rumble winner.

The answer apparently was “a hell of a big fight.” Harper brought all of his offense to the match, hitting Orton with superkicks, a sit-out powerbomb, slingshot senton and a few other moves. Orton, to his credit, made Harper look good even in defeat, with the two men kneeling and trading bombs late in the match, complete with fans chanting “Boo!/Yay!”

The announcers called it Harper’s coming-out party, a standout performance, and indeed it could be – provided the writers don’t drop the ball with him. It would be nice to see them follow up Harper’s strong performance.


2. Chamber Match Delivers

dean ambrose aj styles
WWE.com

Hats off to the six men who competed in Sunday’s Elimination Chamber match, as it certainly delivered as promised. The wrestlers put on an action-packed bout that saw the crowning of a new world champion, which is a pretty good cap to the PPV.

The first three men in the match, John Cena, AJ Styles (who started the match) and Dean Ambrose had a great segment, as the first 10 minutes were rapid-fire action. Things continued with Bray Wyatt and Baron Corbin joining the fray and didn’t really let up until the end (though things did slow down as it wore on). It was a pretty good match that saw some interesting exchanges between the wrestlers.

As a one-match show, Elimination Chamber delivered because the chamber match itself worked well.


1. Wyatt’s Crowning Achievement

bray wyatt wwe champion
WWE.com

A first world title win typically should be a special moment. How it’s done can make it that much more significant.

In Bray Wyatt’s case, his first world title victory came inside the Elimination Chamber Sunday, with the Eater of Worlds pinning both John Cena and AJ Styles. That’s quite the achievement. Wyatt did so cleanly, which made his victory even more impressive. It also was payback in a sense, considering how Cena decidedly won their feud a few years ago.

Wyatt might very well only be holding the title for a few weeks, given that he’s currently set to face Randy Orton at Mania, but his win Sunday still was impressive.


Contributor
Contributor

Scott is a former journalist and longtime wrestling fan who was smart enough to abandon WCW during the Monday Night Wars the same time as the Radicalz. He fondly remembers watching WrestleMania III, IV, V and VI and Saturday Night's Main Event, came back to wrestling during the Attitude Era, and has been a consumer of sports entertainment since then. He's written for WhatCulture since 2014, establishing the Ups and Downs articles for WWE Raw and WWE PPVs/PLEs and composing pieces on a variety of topics.