7 Reasons Why WWE Hell In A Cell 2017 Floundered

If you've gone through all the trouble of constructing the Cell, you should use the thing!

224 HIAC 10082017mm 7214  C159e793a6776370528910274a1ddda9
WWE

It looked like the roster of SmackDown Live were fighting an uphill battle at Hell In A Cell. Many fans weren't exactly hyped for the event, and who could blame them? The outcome of the WWE Championship match was obvious, a man who isn't even a professional wrestler was competing in the main event, and for a PPV named Hell In A Cell, there were very few matches that were actually contested in the confines of the Devil's Playground.

And yet, the show was better than expected. The tag match between the Usos and The New Day was as good as a Cell match could possibly be, Tye Dillinger finally escaped the dreaded preshow spot, and Sami Zayn aiding Kevin Owens to victory over Shane McMahon has the potential to send huge shockwaves throughout the land of Smackdown Live.

But just because Hell In A Cell was satisfying enough to watch, that doesn't mean the WWE didn't make some very bad choices last night. Careers have been tarnished through bad booking, titles were made to feel redundant, and the Cell spent more time in the rafters than it did around the ring.

7. The Tag Titles Flip-Flopped Yet Again

Jimmy Jey Uso Hell In A Cell
WWE.com

It seems like Hot Potato is Vince McMahon's favourite game. Much like the Raw Women's Championship before it, the Smackdown Live Tag Team titles have bounced around more times than is really necessary.

At HIAC, the Usos became champs once again, and while they are deserving of the belts, it doesn't do the titles any good to be passed around four times in as many months. Contrary to the belief of Vince McMahon, a championship actually needs to be defended successfully from time to time to add any sort of prestige to it. Champions should been seen as near impossible to defeat, and shouldn't lose their titles whenever we flip to the next page on the calander.

The New Day now have a contractual rematch for the straps, but in order to move forward with the division, they need to lose, and Jimmy and Jey need to find new competition.


6. Dolph Ziggler Lost

Bobby Roode Dolph Ziggler
WWE.com

There were two men on this card that needed a big win to keep themselves relevant. One of those men was Dolph Ziggler. Making his way to the ring with no entrance music was genius; his character is all about excelling in the ring, and mocking those who have to rely on a flashy entrance to get the crowd pumped. But once again, 'The Showoff' lost.

We're meant to believe that Ziggler is one of the best competitors on the roster, that he doesn't need to be good on the mic, and he doesn't need the WWE Universe behind him. But when he can't back up his claims with a win over Bobby Roode, or anyone with a crowd-pleasing entrance for that matter, how are the fans meant to take him seriously?

A win here would have cemented Ziggler's new persona, and carried him nicely into a rubber match with Roode, or a new feud entirely. As it was Bobby's first pay-per-view match, he could have easily taken a loss and bounced back. All this match did was bring Ziggler's momentum to a screeching halt.


5. Rusev Lost

Rusev Randy Orton
WWE.com

The other competitor in need of a major win last night was Rusev. The man has all the in-ring talent in the world, and is pretty good on the mic too, yet he can't pick up that one victory he needs to propel him into the main event scene.

The feud between Rusev and Randy Orton hasn't been interesting in the slightest, but at the very least, Orton could have put the 'Bulgarian Brute' over in this match, as Rusev is in dire need of winning a feud before he becomes a complete joke. As a multiple World Champion, 'The Viper' would have been the perfect man to lose to Rusev, as it would make the Bulgarian look like a legitimate contender for either the United States title or the WWE Championship.

The big question is: where does Rusev go from here? My guess is he'll be lost in the shuffle once more.


4. Natalya's DQ

Charlotte Flair
WWE.com

Quite possibly the worst booking decision of the night. About ten minutes into a good, technical match, Natalya sought to get herself disqualified by attacking Charlotte Flair with a steel chair outside the ring.

This would have made a lot more sense if the match had been built around Natalya's growing frustration at not being able to pick up the win. The bout hadn't been going for a particularly long time, and Natalya had barely gone for the win at all; she spent most of the match wearing down Charlotte's leg for what we assumed was to set up the Sharpshooter later on.

Natalya did lock in her finisher briefly earlier in the fight, but there wasn't any reason to think that she wouldn't be able to wrap up Charlotte's legs again, and get the submission victory.

The planning of this match was wrong; Charlotte should've spent longer in the Sharpshooter without tapping to justify Natalya's actions, or Natalya should have won cleanly to help cement her as the top competitor in the Smackdown Live women's division.


3. The WWE Championship Match Wasn't Inside The Cell

Jinder Mahal Shinsuke Nakamura
WWE.com

You know things haven't been planned out properly when your World Champion defends his title in a throw-away match in the middle of the card. Jinder Mahal and Shinsuke Nakamura have battled twice now over the WWE Championship, and the crowds have sat on their hands the whole way through.

There aren't many people that would enjoy seeing Jinder have the final match of the night, so it can be seen as a wise move by the WWE to not put him on last. However, there is no excuse good enough for not putting the World Champion in a Hell In A Cell match when the whole event is based around the Steel Structure.

Having the WWE title defended in a regular match made it feel like the strap isn't worthy of being fought for in one of the most dangerous stipulations possible. By not lowering the Cell, they've ironically lowered the standing of one the most prestigious prizes in wrestling.


2. The Women's Championship Match Wasn't Inside The Cell

Natalya Charlotte Flair
WWE.com

Despite proving last year that women can compete just as well as the men can inside the Steel Structure, a Hell In A Cell Women's match was noticeably absent from the card this time around.

Charlotte Flair and Sasha Banks made history in 2016 as the first ladies to ever battle inside the Cell. They put on a fantastic match that would go on to define the idea that the women in WWE are every bit as able as their male counterparts. Furthermore, WWE decided to have the Women's Championship match as their main event of the night.

What HIAC 2017 has shown us is that the women's division has slipped dramatically now that the initial buzz around it has died down. The only women's match on the card, the bout between Natalya and Charlotte Flair had all the potential to steal the show, but battling in the middle of the event with no stipulation made it seem lacklustre. What's more, ending the fight by DQ cheapened the match. The WWE needs to make the division more exciting, but it's not possible when it feels like they can't be bothered to try and top the show they put on last year.


1. Shane McMahon Was In The Main Event

kevin owens shane mcmahon
WWE.com

Kevin Owens and Shane McMahon put on a decent match; there was a lot of action, Owens played the heel role like he was born into it (big thumbs up for taunting the O'Mac children), and the high impact spots on the top of the Cell were nail-biting to say the least.

Vince McMahon sees his son as a big deal, and getting the opportunity to fight against Shane should be seen as an honour. But when all is said and done, Shane is a 48 year old businessman, not a professional wrestler. The Smackdown Live brand is meant to be about providing hardworking sports entertainers with the opportunities to succeed, but this match showed us that being a dedicated wrestler isn't the only way to get the best spot on the card. Sometimes, all you need is the right surname.

The main event slot should be reserved for either the World Championship match, or the best potential fight on the card. No one really wants to end the night on a Jinder Mahal bout, but finishing with the tag match between the Usos and The New Day would have sent the crowd home very happy indeed.


Contributor
Contributor

I'm technically an adult but no one in their right mind would ever call me a man. Freelance writer interested in wrestling, television, film, literature, and video games.