7 Reasons WWE Payback PPV Has Died A Slow Death

Payback 2014 This Sunday's WWE Payback event takes place following a tumultuous month of May news for WWE. From the stock going down significantly causing Vince McMahon to lose approximately $350 million to the WWE Champion Daniel Bryan needed neck surgery, it's been full of bad news. It feels like the music of Bad News Barrett is going to start up any minute now or maybe an Undertaker like lightning bolt is going to strike down on WWE. The good thing about Payback is that June is a new month and Chicago is arguably the best city that WWE routinely visits. The crowd will certainly help things even if the build up to some of the matches has been pretty poor. While this isn't a piece that will predict what's going to happen, here is something you can take to the bank: There will be CM Punk chants all night long. That's what they do. Those chants are interesting not because he is coming back even if we want him to, but because WWE never acknowledges. When any other chants start up the announcers usually comment. They are trained to have selective hearing in WWE. There are plenty of reasons why Payback might be a good show, but there are also several reasons why the build to it has been lackluster at best and because of that it's the least anticipated PPV of the year so far. Here are seven of those reasons.

7. Another Torito Vs. Hornswoggle Match Is Insulting To Others On The Roster

It's fine to do a little person match like Torito vs. Hornswoggle once in a while, but when you do it nearly every week in some form it gets very tiresome. Last month at Extreme Rules they did a "WeeLC" aka TLC Match that Torito won clean. So why has it continued? Because Vince McMahon laughs at little people fighting each other? Apparently that's a good enough reason to keep it going. Chances are that most wrestlers in the match find Torito vs. Hornswoggle to be hilarious because last month at Extreme Rules apparently everybody was watching on the monitors backstage and laughing about it, so they are popular with the "boys" in WWE. However, when you look at the whole roster it's just another example of lazy booking. There are so many wrestlers that could benefit from the TV time that WWE chooses to give to this comedy feud that has absolutely run its course.

6. Very Predictable Matches For "New" Performers

Rusev will likely face off with Big E and Adam Rose will probably take on Jack Swagger. Neither match is officially announced as of yet, but they're both likely to happen. It's very unlikely that Rusev would lose to Big E. They actually have a lot of common in that both guys spent a couple years in NXT, they are both power wrestlers that really aren't that tall and each guys have recently had their name shortened too. Big E has fallen off so much as somebody that was the IC Champ to a guy that is not expected to get pushed any time even though he's still in his 20s. The Adam Rose/Jack Swagger feud was started because of Rose's issues with Zeb Colter, who didn't like that Rose was a foreigner. Swagger's a guy that loses a lot of matches yet WWE keeps throwing him out there because he's been a champion in WWE before. It's fine to have one match that is basically a squash on a PPV. When there are two or more it gets boring really fast.


5. None Of The Title Matches Feel Important

While it's nice to see at least three titles on the line (and maybe a fourth if the tag titles are there), champions like Barrett, Sheamus and Paige all won their titles recently so there is little expectation that they will lose. Maybe The Usos will lose to Rowan & Harper team, but that wouldn't be smart because The Usos are a popular team right now. A well booked midcard title feud can go a long way to building up interest in a show. Cesaro's a strong challenger because he has a lot of credibility following WrestleMania 30 and his match with Sheamus could be great. However, what if they don't get enough time? They deserve 15-20 minutes. If they get that it could be match of the night. Alicia Fox has really started to get noticed as a crazy heel diva. It's so rare to see WWE actually give character development to a diva that she's being praised simply for acting crazy. Rob Van Dam is coming in very flat and uninspired as a challenger. On the plus side, at least WWE actually remembered to book champions in PPV matches. It's better than what they did at WrestleMania.

4. Raw Has Been Below Average In May

Calling Raw "below average" this month is being generous. It's been a very cold period for WWE following the hot WrestleMania season, which really wasn't that until they figured out that Daniel Bryan needed to be pushed as the top guy and that was in March. It should have been in January. Sitting through a three hour episode of Raw is difficult because of all the useless segments they have. A lot of them may be building to PPV matches, but they are not being done in a productive way. Do we really care who is dancing with Fandango or who he is kissing? It might lead to a match at some point. Not at Payback, though. That time could go to somebody else that's a part of Payback that could benefit from it. When Raw is a hot show it usually means a PPV is going to be strong because everything is clicking on all cylinders. When it's bad that doesn't always mean that a PPV will be bad because PPVs are built on matches, but it does hurt the anticipation of the show. In the case of Payback, even if the in-ring action is good it's not going to resonate with fans because of how poor the month of May has been.

3. No WWE World Heavyweight Championship Match

This one is out of WWE's hands because Daniel Bryan got hurt, but it's a bad sign when a promo with the WWE Champion is what is being advertised. Are we really supposed to care if Bryan's wife Brie Bella is fired considering she's barely on the show, firing angles rarely last and nobody believes it anyway? Firing angles are a waste of time. Since they are likely going to prolong the storyline with Bryan, it's likely a situation where he's going to end up keeping the title and he'll be healthy enough to defend it by Money in the Bank on June 29. In other words, nothing is likely going to happen at Payback, which again hurts the quality of the show. People that bought WWE Network for PPVs are likely not thrilled that part of their money is going towards a promo that could just have easily taken place on Raw.

2. The Shield's Rematch With Evolution Doesn't Seem Necessary

The problem with The Shield's match against Evolution is that The Shield already beat them clean at Extreme Rules. They should not have had that as a finish if they were going to set up a No Holds Barred match at Payback. That tells me that maybe they didn't plan that far ahead. We know there were issues with Batista and questions about if he was going to stay until Payback, so that's why he got pinned at Extreme Rules. However, they're building to a match where they are likely to do the exact same finish with The Shield getting the win. This match could lead to something further with Roman Reigns further establishing himself as a top guy, which could set up a heel turn by the other two guys or maybe Sheamus ends up joining Evolution to keep things going with this rivalry. There are a lot of possibilities. In terms of match quality, it should be excellent. The problem is that a lot of people already saw it and may want something else. Instead, it's more of the same over and over again.

1. There Is Nothing That Feels Fresh

When the top two matches are rematches from the last PPV and Cena/Wyatt is going for a third straight PPV it doesn't come off as appealing to the fans. Not only that, but these are feuds that have already had clean finishes in those matches with the babyfaces win. Cena beat Wyatt clean at WrestleMania 30 and The Shield beat Evolution at Extreme Rules. A babyface win usually means an issue is resolved. Not here. It's nice that Cena wants to fight for the fans to prevent Bray Wyatt's influence from spreading, but when you hear those two guys talk there are more people cheering for Wyatt. It took Cena quite a while to get out there to save Jerry Lawler from a potential attack that maybe Wyatt is right in that Cena only cares about himself. That's about the only "new" development in this angle in the last two months, but it's not like Cena is going heel either. There just isn't a hook for this show. At least Money in the Bank will feel different and so will Hell in a Cell later in the year. Payback is essentially the same thing with stipulation matches for the major feuds while everything else just doesn't matter as much. Change the name all you want. Until you can make the show feel different in a positive way fans aren't going to be that interested in it. Here's hoping that June is a better month than May has been for WWE.

Contributor
Contributor

John wrote at WhatCulture from December 2013 to December 2015. It was fun, but it's over for now. Follow him on Twitter @johnreport. You can also send an email to mrjohncanton@gmail.com with any questions or comments as well.