7 Things WWE Can Learn From NJPW
WWE should steal a lot more than talent from New Japan.
The fates of World Wrestling Entertainment and New Japan Pro Wrestling have intertwined in a way that nobody expected they would in 2016. After a groundbreaking 2014 New Japan stalled somewhat in 2015, but the sheer depth of the roster made for a plethora of exciting shows. As Wrestle Kingdom 10 approached, the future looked pretty darn good for NJPW.
The day after Wrestle Kingdom 10, everything changed. Four of NJPW's biggest stars handed their notices in; Shinsuke Nakamura, AJ Styles, Karl Anderson, and Doc Gallows were all gone in the blink of an eye. Rumours were rife that the quartet were on their way to WWE, and rumours were true.
After taking stock of the situation and dealing with the initial shock, New Japan went back to doing what it does best; putting on professional wrestling shows. New faces have stepped into the gap left by the departures, and arguably the future continues to grow in the resultant light for NJPW.
On the other side of the pond, WWE's product continues to thrill and irritate in equal measure. By looking over to Japan for more than just talent, WWE could possibly take a few pointers from New Japan Pro Wrestling on ways to maximise their roster and put out a more consistent product in the process.
Here are seven such ways...
7. A More Physical In-ring Style
Whilst I don't expect to see R-Truth and Fandango going at it like Tomoaki Honma and Tomohiro Ishii anytime soon, WWE could definitely benefit from allowing its talent to work a more physical style. This might seem like a risk in light of the mass of injuries WWE has experienced over the last year or so, but the positives of such a move are clear to see.
WWE's audience still wants to see the physical side of the product, and nothing heightens the anticipation in this regard more than the promise of a true war. It's also true that a couple of the maligned WWE chosen children, namely Roman Reigns and Sheamus, get a much more respectful reception when they work a more physical style.
Kevin Owens and Sami Zayn bring crowds to their feet whenever they are within punching distance of each other, and a lot of this has to do with the sense of reality that comes from their exchanges. By allowing their talent to lay the strikes in a little deeper, WWE could really benefit.
6. The Benefit Of Tournaments
Vince McMahon's disdain of tournaments is well-known, but the positives of running such things are clear for all to see. Already this year outside interest in WWE has been pricked somewhat by the announcement and beginning of the Global Cruiserweight Series, and last year's NXT Dusty Rhodes Tag Team Classic was a success on all levels.
New Japan's year pretty much revolves around tournaments. With authority figures not around to meddle in interests and the performers having little care in talk shows, these tournaments act as the sparks for rivalries to begin. Potential challengers to titles stake their claim by defeating the incumbents in tournaments, and matches that may be less interesting on paper are given fresh meaning.
Tournaments allow rivalries to begin organically, and they also do a great job of establishing in-ring talent in a similar way. Even by running one big tournament a year, WWE could see an up-swing in the quality of its storytelling.
5. How To Use The Veterans
One of the big gripes that many have had with WWE over the past few years is how much TV time has been taken up by guys whose best is quite clearly behind them. Big Show and Kane in particular seem to find themselves at the business end of the show more often than not, and whilst it is difficult begrudge the legends this time it simply isn't necessary.
NJPW consistently finds ways to utilise its veterans in positive ways. Sure, they might spend the majority of the year in multi-man tag matches early on the card, but the benefits are two-fold; one is that the live crowd gets to see true legends, and the second is that young workers get a chance to work up close with men who have been around the sport for a long, long time.
The company also isn't afraid to shine a little bit of spotlight on these veterans from time to time, as seen in the feud this year between Katsuyori Shibata and the endearingly-termed New Japan Dads (Tenzan, Kojima, and Nagata). Shibata has disrespected the legends at every turn, which he followed by backing himself up in the ring in defeating Tenzan and Kojima. His cockiness got the better of him against Nagata however, with Blue Justice picking up the win and the NEVER Openweight Championship in the process.
Far from weakening Shibata by having him lose to an older competitor, the loss is designed to light a fire under the bottom of Shibata and push him further up the card. It also has that double value of giving a major rub to whoever defeats Nagata for the championship.
4. Stick To Your Guns When It Comes To Pushes
For reasons I will never truly understand, WWE is frustratingly inconsistent when it comes to pushes. How many times over the years has it seemed like Dolph Ziggler was finally getting the faith the WWE Universe has clamoured for him, only for it to come to nought? The worrying trend in WWE is for a superstar to get a big push, only for it to be followed by a year or so spent in purgatory (see Rusev, Barrett, Sheamus, Neville et al).
NJPW however seems to have the confidence to back itself when it decides to put a rocket behind an individual. When Kazuchika Okada returned from his stint in TNA, his stock and confidence could not have been particularly high. After a year spent regaining his self-belief, he shocked the world by defeating Hiroshi Tanahashi for the IWGP Heavyweight Championship.
The title change came out of nowhere, and many called it a 'suicidal' move by the booking team. Rather than give in to these calls they stood by Okada, and he now finds himself as the biggest star in the company.
In many ways the same applies for AJ Styles and his recent run in the company. The audience reacted with disinterest when he defeated Okada for the same title, only for him to win them over completely less than six months later. If you decide to give someone a push, trust yourself and the talent.
3. Make Championships Matter
Before anyone points it out, I'm not talking about the NEVER Openweight Six-Man titles. Those belts are supposed to be hot potatoes, quite obviously.
One of the great things about New Japan Pro Wrestling (and most wrestling outside of WWE and TNA actually) is how important championships seem to be. Whilst an individual certainly doesn't need a championship belt to be important, it is vital that those holding the belts treat them as such.
New Japan counts title defences and counts champions, instantly giving the viewer a feeling of the history behind each belt. Challengers have to step up too. Whilst a number of championship matches come out of a challenger beating a champion in a non-title environment, this isn't done in a 'Oh my god! [insert name here] has pinned the [insert title] champion!'. No, the general feeling is always one of 'yeah, and I'll do that again if you put the belt on the line'. It matters.
Wrestling is still a performance art where individuals and teams are fighting in an attempt to win these trophies. They must be treated with respect.
2. Don't Force Moments
Every year, WrestleMania comes along with the grandeur expected of the biggest night in sports entertainment. Every wrestler strives to have their very own 'WrestleMania Moment', a moment on the big stage that will stay with them throughout their career. The problem with this is that more often than not they seem to be forced, and a moment for the sake of a moment is barely a moment at all.
Moments can only take on the resonance they are supposed to if allowed to build organically and explode as such. It was nice seeing Zack Ryder push The Miz off the top of the ladder and claim the Intercontinental Championship, but it was clear that it was diluted. It was short term, a quick feel-good moment with no legs whatsoever.
If we use the most obvious example from NJPW in recent years, when Kazuchika Okada defeated Hiroshi Tanahashi in the main event of Wrestle Kingdom 10 and finally became the ace of New Japan, it was a huge moment for all involved. Everyone and their dog saw it coming, but it was supposed to happen, and it felt huge for being allowed to build to that point.
1. How To Create New Stars
WrestleMania 32 was marketed around four big matches, one of which was the Women's Championship triple threat between Charlotte, Sasha Banks, and Becky Lynch. If we take that out of the equation, four of the six men involved in the other three matches performed at WrestleManias over 10 years ago.
This is not a new trend, and most of the recent WrestleMania events have been dominated by superstars of the past. WWE has seemed reluctant to get behind fresher stars despite having plenty of opportunities to do so along the way, and the product has suffered because of it.
Over the years New Japan has shown a keen awareness that time eventually catches up with all, and has realised the importance of building new stars to take the places of each passing generation. When Hiroshi Tanahashi, Shinsuke Nakamura, and Katsuyori Shibata came up together, they were clearly earmarked for great things and all (Shibata to a lesser degree) delivered. Sure, that can be put down the talent on display there, but they were given time to develop and built up properly in the process.
With Nakamura, Styles, Gallows, and Anderson all leaving at the same time. it is this that gives New Japan fans the most hope for the future. The holes left by these gentlemen are already starting to fill, with Tetsuya Naito finally delivering on his potential and wrestlers such as EVIl, SANADA, Shibata, Tomohiro Ishii, and Kenny Omega in particular stepping up to the plate.
This is perhaps the biggest lesson that WWE can learn from New Japan, and one that will guarantee a bright future for the largest professional wrestling company in the world.