7 Times Wrestling Should Have Called An Audible

Rip up the godd*mn script, again.

Taker Strowman
WWE.com

On Monday's episode of WWE RAW, the Undertaker interrupted Braun Strowman's would-be show-closing promo.

It was a scene drenched in irony. Strowman was mooted as potential opponent for Undertaker at WrestleMania 32. That baffling peak Vince McMahon suggestion was waved away by both 'Taker and fans alike - and yet, just one year later, fans were deeply moved by the tease. They chanted "Holy sh*t!" in unison, desperate for the legend and the monster to wage war. At this rate, it wouldn't be a surprise if Elias Samson emerges as the man to retire Undertaker at WrestleMania 34. Wrestling is insane like that.

Unfortunately, Strowman answered the silent gesture by sort of meekly exiting the ring. Fans groaned. It was another platform on which to cover Roman Reigns in glory - and yet, if 'Taker was permitted to utilise his veteran presence, he could have called an audible, had Strowman get the better of their impromptu exchange, and created scope for Reigns to rescue him. The scene would not have deviated from the tone of the Reigns/'Taker torch-passing rivalry. If anything, it would have logically followed up on the positioning of both men, and given 'Taker a further reason to reassert his dominance.

That's a Strowman argument (sorry). Unfortunately, the heavily scripted nature of WWE in this modern era means the possibility of this happening was remote. It wasn't the only occasion on which a veteran star with the nous and power to exercise his power should have done just that.

7. Triple H - WWE WrestleMania XXV

Triple H Randy Orton WrestleMania XXV
WWE.com

Forget that Triple H and Randy Orton had to follow Undertaker and Shawn Michaels at the Reliant Stadium. That excuse is touted by Trips as the reason his match died a death, even in the face of evidence to the contrary. John Cena, The Big Show and Edge Triple Threat followed immediately afterwards, and that match generated a decent reaction, under the circumstances.

No, Triple H's successful WWE Championship defence was played out amid library silence because the book was written the wrong 'way round. He and Orton had annihilated one another in an escalating procession of over-the-top angles in the build-up. A more or less straight singles match, which Triple H had green-lighted as creative overlord, was a complete anti-climax.

Triple H was already owner-elect by 2009. He had the power to alter the match as it was in progress - and he was never shy about professing his supposed wrestling acumen. He should have sensed that the crowd had already been punted into a permanent state of tedium, brought forward the ref bump, and smashed Orton to pieces in a rousing display of destruction. He could have even blindly punted the referee, knocking him out for a second time, reinforcing his Cerebral Assassin persona in a classic babyface turnabout-is-fair-play trope while ripping up the prearranged, methodical structure.

Their match was an interesting experiment, on reflection - a somewhat inventive method of subverting Orton's callousness - but it was ultimately too clever - or too stupid - for its own good.


6. Steve Austin - WWF WrestleMania X-Seven

Austin McMahon WM17
WWE.com

Lost in the criticism of Stone Cold Steve Austin's business-destroying heel turn at WrestleMania X-Seven was the perfect execution of it.

Austin, soaked in claret, looked psychopathic as he destroyed The Rock with a steel chair. Vince McMahon, who engineered the turn, looked almost reluctant as he surveyed the creation of his new monster. The Mr. McMahon character existed to put Austin over, and he never did it with as much beautiful subtlety as he did here. Rock kicked out of everything, but it didn't once border on the ridiculous.

That said, the sheer brilliance of the performance just underscored the objective fact that it was never going to work. If that platform didn't allow Austin the chance to alter his perception in the eyes of the audience, nothing was going to.

The entire angle was pitched perfectly - but the problem is that it should never have happened in the first place. Austin's popularity was on the wane, but fans were unwilling to accept the turn. Besides which, The Rock was bound for Hollywood for a lengthy stint.

Austin is on record as singling out this moment as the biggest regret of his career. If he could retroactively change one part of it, he would go back and deliver a Stone Cold Stunner to McMahon following their notorious handshake. It would have retconned the entire development, but it would have at least been in keeping with his "don't trust anybody" mantra - and prolonged, even if briefly, the company's biggest ever boom period.


5. Hulk Hogan - WWF WrestleMania X8

Hogan Rock
WWE

It seems ridiculous to include this seminal improvisational performance on this list, but wrestling fans are nothing if not greedy.

Steve Austin exercised his prescience by refusing to work with Hogan at WrestleMania X8. He knew that he could not hide from the storm of nostalgia that was Hogan's return to the Show of Shows - nor Hogan's peerless politicking. It was an astute decision; Rock was booed out of the building when Hogan, in the opening exchanges, threw him across the ring and flexed his muscles. He wasn't wearing the red and yellow, but he might as well have been; in under a minute, he was the Real American of old. As he soaked up the cheers, he turned to the hard camera in delight. He had won them over. The camera panned back to Rock. As composed as any performer that came before him, an involuntary reflex highlighted his disdain. His right eye twitched. He had been rattled.

Hogan then mimicked Rock's just bring it appeal. The Rock called an audible and did just that, with a knowing nod, effortlessly gauging the shifting landscape and playing pseudo heel for the rest of the match. It was a masterclass of body language, improvisation and unadulterated natural talent.

At the close of the match, Kevin Nash and Scott Hall bum rushed the ring to turn on a repenting Hogan - another audible - before Rock helped him clear house. Hogan capped off his face turn by cupping his hand to his ear and working the crowd. As Hogan and Rock left the ring, Rock's "If you smell" theme played over the PA - but how much better would the moment have been, had "Real American" blared over the speakers?


4. The Undertaker - WWE WrestleMania XXX

Brock Lesnar Undertaker WrestleMania XXX
WWE.com

The decision to end The Undertaker's Streak at WrestleMania XXX was a strange one.

It was met with widespread dissent because short of crowning them as champion in an age in which titles have been noticeably devalued, it marked the last instantaneous star-making tool WWE had at their disposal. But to play Devil's advocate, what if Mr. Kennedy was chosen to break The Streak in the mid to late 2000s? If his (non-Kurt Angle) TNA matches are any indication, he simply wasn't destined to improve beyond the performer he was at his not inconsiderable - but not exactly incendiary - WWE peak.

Kennedy was so well thought of by McMahon at one point that the thought might even have crossed his mind. Perhaps his subsequent downfall - and the more widespread dearth of new megastars - caused him to nix any plans of having an upstart talent break the Streak, if that was ever the plan.

Irrespective of whether the decision to have established part-time mercenary Brock Lesnar break the Streak was correct in itself, an audible should have been called when it became apparent that the 'Taker had been knocked silly. It was no way for him to go out. The whole thing was as depressing as it was shocking.


3. Somebody, Anybody - WWE Royal Rumble 2014

Rey Mysterio 2014
WWE.com

Poor Rey Mysterio. At Royal Rumble 2014, he was caught in the backdraft of the nuclear heat with which the Pittsburgh natives received the strong-headed anti-consumer relations exercise that was the Rumble match itself.

WWE knew what it was doing - to an extent. Vince McMahon did not entertain the notion of installing unanimous crowd favourite Daniel Bryan into it because he knew it would undermine Batista's win - but fans remained hopeful that WWE were playing the long game in a storyline they weren't prepared to reset as WWE had done.

Hopes were dashed when Rey Mysterio entered the fray at the number 30 slot. It was a senseless decision on a night full of them. Surely, the slot should have gone to a heel, if only to inject them with a short-term dose of heat. Instead, Mysterio was thrown to the wolves. Somebody, anybody should have called an audible and grabbed the nearest heel jobber to hand. As Tyler Breeze later learned to his cost, there would have been plenty left in the arena. Nobody is allowed to go home until the show is finished.

Mysterio's star was on the wane, but he never recovered. He was "not Daniel Bryan" for the brief remainder of his WWE career. It's no wonder he was so desperate to get out of there, but he had the last laugh. Nobody has been able to replicate his magic. It takes more than a mask.


2. Hulk Hogan - WCW Nitro July 6, 1998

hogan goldberg
WWE.com

Hulk Hogan's WCW main event presence was literally mandated. Creative control was written into his contract, and he exercised the clause whenever he didn't fancy lying on his back - which is ironic, given that years later we learned his favoured sexual position.

The most egregious - and business-decimating - example of his rampant ego torpedoed the storyline with which WCW had established ratings dominance over the beleaguered (but still financially healthy, contrary to revisionist history) WWF. At Starrcade 1997, Hogan decided he didn't fancy capping off an eighteen-month storyline arc and, supposedly dismayed at the shape in which Sting arrived at Washington D.C.'s MCI Center, orchestrated an impromptu finish in which he cleanly and quickly pinned Sting - he instructed Nick Patrick to forego the prearranged slow count, and then flailed in his Scorpion Death Lock after the restart. He purposefully didn't tap; instead, he sort of made Patrick feel awkward enough to just pretend that he did following a protracted staring contest.

Hogan was at his most selfless when he put Goldberg over at the Georgia Dome on free television, when in fact he should have repeated his old trick. WCW lost millions in potential pay-per-view revenue over the short-sighted desperation ratings grab. Had Hogan screwed Goldberg, the near-riot would have been worth it. The heat could have been siphoned into a redemptive and lucrative PPV climax.

It's not as if the company itself was high on clean finishes.


1. Kurt Angle - WWE SmackDown November 4, 2004

Kurt Angle in late 2004 fought Tough Enough hopeful Daniel Puder in a shoot match on SmackDown. The lowly status of his nobody opponent is why the segment made it to air; nobody counted on the extent to which MMA enthusiast Puder could hold his own. Angle wrestled him to the mat, but Puder caught him with a Kimura lock.

It was at this point Angle should have told Puder to relinquish the hold. His pride obscured common sense and his instincts to protect the business. He chose to remain locked into it, which rendered the aftermath ironic. Angle's reputation naturally took a hit - Puder was hardly a name in MMA circles - but the pain he endured was considerable. Many would not have been able to stand it.

In the end, the referee did call an audible - but by then, the damage to Angle's aura had been done. The quickness with which the referee counted the three, when Angle somehow rolled Puder onto his back, was transparent - as was the fact that Puder's shoulders weren't entirely pinned to the mat. The damage was temporary, at least; his incredible 2005, in which he wrestled one of the best matches in company history opposite Shawn Michaels at WrestleMania 21, cleansed him. Still, it remains an unenviable blot on his legitimate credentials as a hard man.

Good job he once bested Brock Lesnar in a backstage p*ssing contest.


Contributor
Contributor

Michael Sidgwick (Creative Writing BA Hons) is an editor, writer and podcaster for WhatCulture Wrestling. With over a decade of experience in wrestling analysis, Michael was published in the influential UK institution that was Power Slam magazine, and specialises in providing insights into All Elite Wrestling - so much so that he wrote a book about the subject. You can order Becoming All Elite: The Rise Of AEW on Amazon. Possessing a deep knowledge also of WWE, WCW, ECW and New Japan Pro Wrestling, Michael’s work has been publicly praised by AEW World Champions Kenny Omega and MJF, and Undisputed WWE Champion Cody Rhodes. When he isn’t putting your finger on why things are the way they are in the endlessly fascinating world of professional wrestling, Michael wraps his own around a hand grinder to explore the world of specialty coffee. Follow Michael on X (formerly known as Twitter) @MSidgwick for more!