7 Ups & 2 Downs From AEW Dynamite (18 Jan - Review)

Bryan Danielson vs. Bandido, Top Flight vs. Young Bucks, and big heel turns highlight AEW Dynamite.

Kushida Darby Allin
AEW

Rest in peace Jamin Pugh, otherwise known as Jay Briscoe, who tragically passed away following a car accident in Laural, Delaware on Tuesday.

Wrestling remains in mourning - and will do for a long time. Just 38 years old at the time of his passing, Pugh was a 22-year veteran, a Ring Of Honor cornerstone, and one of the most decorated, influential, and important wrestlers of his generation. As the Briscoes, he and brother Mark deserve mentioning alongside the Midnight Express, Fantastics, and Rock 'N' Roll Express when discussing the greatest American tag teams of all time. In the singles realm, Jay was a giant, too, with his 2013 ROH World Title win over Kevin Steen standing as one of the most impactful moments in that company's storied history. As a personality, he was as real as it gets, his work burning with the kind of intensity and authenticity that cannot be taught, his promos equal parts hilarious and terrifying.

But more important than all of this, Pugh was a father, a husband, a brother, and a son. Our thoughts remain with those closest to him during this difficult time - as do those of the wrestling community as a whole.

Though he was never able to appear on company television, Pugh had been directly linked to AEW since March 2022, when Tony Khan's ROH takeover was announced. The situation hung heavy over Dynamite, as it should have, and while it feels surreal to break down a wrestling show under these circumstances, this was a great episode.

Let's talk about it.


Downs...

2. Ricky Starks vs. Jake Hager (And Assorted Shenanigans)

Ricky Starks Jake Hager
AEW

Ricky Starks vs. Jake Hager didn't overstay its welcome, running only a few minutes outwith the picture-in-picture ad break, and they got the obligatory hat spot out of the way. 'Absolute' entered a solid performance, too, though this six-minute clash was hampered by a sluggish Hager control portion and a post-match with one development too many.

Starks escaped through the crowd before Daniel Garcia and Sammy Guevara could jump him. Later, the Jericho Appreciation Society cut a promo confirming Starks and Action Andretti vs. Guevara and Jericho for next week. Rather than keeping it simple, AEW instead added a stipulation to Garcia and Andretti's Rampage match. If Danny wins, he partners Jericho, not Guevara - and will do so wearing new leather gear gifted by Guevara.

This feud is unfortunately going in the direction of many Jericho Appreciation Society feuds before it. Meandering, time-consuming steps are being taken that may leave Starks no stronger than when he started. Perhaps he should share experiences with Eddie Kingston.


1. Gunn Family Values

Billy Gunn MAx Caster
AEW

Colten and Austin Gunn are getting good heat as irritating midcard heels. Their presentation is working and they're positioned where they should be, though the ongoing storyline with The Acclaimed feels low-rent and beneath an AEW championship program.

The Gunns tried to stop Max Caster rapping about them by yelling over the top of his beat. In response, Caster got Austin's mic cut, spat rhymes on Hunter Biden and something that was entirely censored from the broadcast, before he, Anthony Bowens, and Daddy Ass stepped in the ring for a fight.

Except they didn't. Billy split it up, grabbed a microphone, and put the opposing sides in a Family Therapy segment for next week.

The Acclaimed going from the star-making Swerve In Our Glory feud and impossibly fun Jeff Jarrett/Jay Lethal run to this feels like two steps down. A middling slice of Sports Entertainment will be served next week en route to the title match, which will probably go down well enough.


Ups...

7. For Jay Briscoe

Matt Jackson Jay Briscoe armband
AEW

Before diving into matches and storylines, AEW did right by Jay Briscoe on Wednesday night.

Tributes to the departed 38-year-old included, but weren't limited to, wrestlers like The Young Bucks and Bryan Danielson adorning black armbands adorned with "JAY", Top Flight hitting a Doomsday Device-adjacent move similar to The Briscoes' signature, and a pre-show memorial graphic that sat alone before the credits.

Afterwards, AEW taped a special 'Jay Briscoe Celebration of Life' show under the ROH banner. These column inches won't be used to spoil an episode crammed with Ring Of Honor alumni set to air on Honor Club, for free, in the near future.

It has since emerged that AEW was prevented from running a full-on tribute by network Warner Bros. Discovery.

Again, rest in peace Jamin Pugh. His loss will be felt forever.


6. MJF Is An *sshole

The eventual Konosuke Takeshita vs. MJF match is going to rule.

A quick, snappy retort following last week's divisive in-ringer came in the form of a backstage interview with Renee Paquette last night. Takeshita loved wrestling his hero, Bryan Danielson, on Dynamite, but addressed MJF in Japanese. Firing up for a few sentences, he was grilled for a translation by Paquette.

"MJF is an *sshole," the former KO-D Openweight Champion said, demonstrating great comic timing.

Soon, Takeshita is going to have to beat one of the big names he is paired up with for great matches every other week. Expect the MJF jabs to continue through that.


5. Jay Lethal vs. Orange Cassidy

Jay Lethal Orange Cassidy
AEW

Your mileage may vary on Jay Lethal vs. Orange Cassidy for many reasons, including:-

1. It was largely built around comedy.

2. Said comedy took place at ringside - and largely cannibalised the match itself.

But while the position was suboptimal (a more fitting opener would've been Top Flight vs. The Young Bucks - this set a jarring tone), Lethal vs. Cassidy was fun, light-hearted pantomime. Sonjay Dutt, Satnam Singh, and Jeff Jarrett were banned from interfering, so they hit ringside and turfed planted fans out of their front-row seats. An usher-cosplaying Danhausen attempted to eject them. Best Friends then shuffled along the front row, sitting near the heels, stirring the pot.

The match played out between this. Cassidy and Lethal entered typically strong performances, even when the focus wasn't entirely on them, culminating in the Orange Punch for another successful All-Atlantic Championship defence.

Cassidy tried to goad Dutt into getting himself fired with the soft kicks after the bell. Cooler heads prevailed, the heels bailed, and the feud continues.

Again, this would have been better positioned elsewhere - and the constant cutaways may have been too much for some. But subjectively, this fit the tone of Best Friends vs. their goober heel rivals so far.


4. Toni Storm vs. Willow Nightingale (And Listening To The Audience)

Saraya Toni Storm
AEW

Pivoting away from existing plans and going with the audience has been a hallmark of AEW's existence thus far - and it continued with Saraya and Toni Storm last night.

Audiences have been souring on Saraya since her cathartic Grand Slam debut. This is down to her character and content as established in the Britt Baker feud, throughout which Britt came off as a heroic, homegrown figure protecting her turf from a WWE interloper. And if it wasn't already the case, last week's jeers cemented the need for a turn.

So that's what we got. Eyebrows were raised when Storm was booked opposite insuppressible heroine Willow Nightingale, the most babyface babyface to ever babyface. And though the bout start in typical face vs. face fashion, Toni quickly pivoted, slapping Willow down and getting nasty. For the finish, Saraya distracted the referee, allowing Storm to roll Nightingale up with a handful of tights. A beatdown followed, with Ruby Soho making the save.

On watched Hikaru Shida, whose own heel turn has been teased since Saraya spurned her in favour of Toni. AEW subverted this by flipping the other wrestlers instead.


3. Kushida vs. Darby Allin

Darby Allin Kushida
AEW

It could have used a little more heat, a little more intensity, Darby Allin vs. Kushida, but the end result was still a strong technique-first match - and a story well-told.

Debuting for AEW, Kushida was accompanied by the LA Dojo's Kevin Knight and DKC while Sting cornered Allin. Throughout, the match reminded you of how many levels there are to Darby's game. While the flashy, daredevil spots understandably grab the headlines, he is a diverse, well-rounded wrestler with no holes in his game. He proved that once again by matching Kushida on the deck, though his arm and shoulder were pulled, gnawed, and stretched at throughout.

This provided the core of the story. Kushida was constantly working to soften Allin's limb up for his Hoverboard Lock. The high spots came later on, escalating when Kushida caught Darby on the outside, doing so as the TNT Champion dived from the top rope. Later, the in-ring Hoverboard Lock had the LA Dojo so convinced of the outcome, they handed Sting a towel to throw in on his partner's behalf.

Struggling out of the final Hoverboard, Allin prevailed via Last Supper, besting Kushida by the slimmest of margins. The Japanese star was quick to remind Darby of this, even as he shook his hand.


2. Top Flight vs. Young Bucks

Darius Martin
AEW

Top Flight felt like they were being positioned similarly to Konosuke Takeshita heading into last night's match, in that AEW were building them up in defeat, booking them to have great matches against great teams they would ultimately lose to.

The people in that position have to win one of those matches to stay over. Dante and Darius Martin did that here, defeating The Young Bucks in Dynamite's biggest shock - and AEW's grandest upset in a while. That it didn't feel like it could happen so soon meant that it registered strongly as a legitimate surprise.

A great bit of business across the board, here. Not only did Darius and Dante go over well, but the action was as red-hot and cutting-edge as you'd expect. A contest to determine which set of brothers had the superior cohesion and agility played out before Dante was worked over for a long heat segment, leading to a great hot tag from Darius, who has returned from injury looking better than ever. The Doomsday Nosedive produced a great near-fall that kept the move protected when a desperate Nick dived in to break it up. Later, Top Flight proved themselves better and more cohesive on the night, with a ducked BTE Trigger leading to a rolled-through pic for the upset.

2023 is shaping up to be a big year for the Martin brothers. Besting the Bucks will not be their only big win by the time it is done.


1. Bryan Danielson vs. Bandido

Bryan Danielson Bandido
AEW

Bryan Danielson and Bandido could have told a simple in-ring story of superior high-flyer vs. superior mat wrestler and it would have still been excellent. The level of detail each puts into their work guarantees that even with a skeletal framework, they'd have had the best match on the show.

That the duo ended up giving the audience so much more than that is testament, then, to the time and effort they put into their work. Bandido vs. Danielson was more than three-dimensional. This wasn't a battle of speed and technique, but speed, technique, raw-boned power, strikes, spirit, strategy, and smarts, incorporating almost every physical pro wrestling genre in one dramatic package.

Danielson's attempts at grounding Bandido were thwarted not just athletically, but with strength - and mutual demonstrations of incredible core strength. Bandido did fly, but only in spurts. Cutoffs followed each attempt at building steam. He and Danielson wrestled unique, innovative counter sequences, seemingly coming out of each other's pockets at times, building one of the year's best matches so far.

But perhaps their biggest triumph was generating doubt about the outcome. Danielson's MJF program means that he was never losing tonight. He and Bandido, however, had the audience gasping for a late-match 21 Plex near fall, highlighting their storytelling prowess. Bryan was never losing here, but for a fleeting second, it felt like he was.

'The American Dragon's' win came via Busaiku Knee Kick. Next week's labour is Brian Cage, a wrestler on the upswing in AEW, and a fitting roadblock ahead of Revolution.


Channel Manager
Channel Manager

Andy has been with WhatCulture for 10 years and is currently WhatCulture's Wrestling Channel Manager. A writer, presenter, and editor with 10+ years of experience in online media, he has been a sponge for all wrestling knowledge since playing an old Royal Rumble 1992 VHS to ruin in his childhood. Having previously worked for Bleacher Report, Andy specialises in short and long-form writing, video presenting, voiceover acting, and editing, all characterised by expert wrestling knowledge and commentary. Andy is as much a fan of 1985 Jim Crockett Promotions as he is present-day AEW and WWE - just don't make him choose between the two.