7 Ups & 2 Downs From AEW Dynamite: Big Business (Results & Review)
Big Business - mostly - achieved the full spectrum of TV brilliance last night.
AEW was questioned about its approach to last night's Big Business TV special - and rightly so.
As ever, two different conversations unfolded amongst a fandom that is destined to fight forever as vocally as they chant those two words. Tony Khan hardly created some complex puzzle, offering only cryptic clues. Only a complete idiot would have failed to grasp that last night's show, which emanated from BO$$ton, Massachusetts, was the site of Mercedes Moné's debut in All Elite Wrestling. Nobody in their right mind could claim they didn't know that.
The real question was: did Khan do enough to build Moné's profile?
Khan opted for the glorified surprise pop, once again refusing to deviate from a tactic that he has done to death. Why not try something new? Or a proven formula that has worked historically, but Khan has mostly shied away from?
The idea is to get excited about something you're almost certain is happening. A series of well-produced teaser vignettes would have done the job. People enjoy luxuriating in the anticipation. That's the art of promotion.
The thing is, in not yelling to the world to that AEW had signed one of its biggest stars, AEW drew an unflattering comparison.
This was basically the First Dance, only nowhere near as fun. CM Punk's presence was all over AEW programming before he even appeared on it. Beyond the odd aside made by Serena Deeb on Collision, this wasn't the case with Mercedes. Also: Moné didn't leave wrestling for seven years, and as phenomenal as she is in the ring, the world wasn't waiting to hear her speak as they were Punk in Chicago. A repeat of her NJPW debut hardly seemed like a great idea.
The insinuation, to be really cynical, is that AEW didn't care as much about Moné's arrival as they did Punk's, which itself only worked because the event was so improbable. Surely, a Deeb open challenge fused with a series of vignettes was the way to go, if Khan was insistent to securing that "surprise" pop. The build to Big Business was neither nothing nor something.
Was it all worth it in the end...?
Downs...
2. Chris Jericho Continues To Drag It All Down
Chris Jericho, on last night's evidence, is as washed as Kevin Kelly's brain.
His match alongside HOOK, LionHOOK Vs. Gates of Agony, was not particularly good at all. Worked between three green, dynamic guys and one slowing veteran, the pacing was odd, disjointed. Jericho played face-in-peril. Nobody gave a f*ck. The story and atmosphere was doomed. In a looping structure that felt never-ending, HOOK kept getting knocked off the apron. It happened around three times. He looked like a geek for not even trying to get cut off in his fury by the ref. (He's better off studying '90s AJPW tape than teaming with Jericho).
The faces got back into it, but the comeback was all kinds of bad. Jericho only just managed to hit Bishop Kaun, who was out of position to take a missile dropkick. Just before the finish, Jercho took out Toa Liona with his apron dropkick. He got caught up in the ropes; another rough spot in yet another rough Chris Jericho match. He might get a pop if he went away for six months. Right now, he positively reeks of desperation. It's almost unbearable.
As AEW continues to feel rejuvenated, Jericho remains the skeevy, unwanted, vibe-destroying guest who won't get the hint.
1. That Didn't Feel Like A World Title Match
Sadly, Samoa Joe Vs. Wardlow was a nothing match with an anticlimactic finish. It wasn't actively bad. In fact, there was a certain intelligence to it. Wardlow doing a fake-out aerial to trick Joe into the nope spot was a creative sequence. It just never came together as an absorbing, big-feeling super heavyweight prize fight. There was no escalation of drama nor violence. Every time something cool happened, and momentarily jolted the crowd, Joe and Wardlow seemed to sell for an age. Since few are as invested as they were in Wardlow in 2022, and Joe feels increasingly like the dreaded "safe pair of hands", this all dragged.
Nobody was begging them to rise to their feet and continue the war - especially since the war felt nothing like, for example, the defiant urgency of Batista Vs. Undertaker. That was a hoss fight. This was a mediocre match made all the more glaring in its mundanity in the shadow of AEW's new super-roster. Quite good was never good enough in AEW. It is unacceptable now.
This was a poor decision by Tony Khan, which is strange. He's doing a magnificent job elsewhere. Wardlow and Joe simply have zero chemistry. Their TNT title programme was bang average as well. Joe won out of nowhere and very decisively with the Coquina clutch.
What next for Wardlow?
Wrestling is a harsh business. Not everybody can make it, and not for the first time, Wardlow didn't tear the roof off the arena when positioned in a key slot. He doesn't have the main event aura, credentials, or craftsmanship. The AEW x NJPW partnership is woefully lopsided. Could Wardlow do the G1? Are there enough great wrestlers in New Japan these days for that to be a true test of his mettle?
Or could he succeed in a company - WWE - that isn't quite as obsessed with match quality?
Ups...
7. A Few Quick Notes
In a good production touch, AEW Dynamite: Big Business began with an external shot of the TD Garden in Boston. It's a small thing, but presenting the show as emanating from a big, historic venue in a famous metropolis made AEW feel big time. Then, an extravagantly priced Mercedes-Benz rolled into the arena. AEW made the occasion and the star feel enormous.
Also, while the match itself failed to deliver, it was another clever touch to build Joe Vs. Wardlow with a video package. Adam Cole, in "story time", narrated Wardlow's character arc in a pre-tape. The idea was to set the match apart as a big deal, a gift on free television, something potentially momentous.
Ultimately, the spectacle and drama of the match was not enhanced - but AEW should absolutely do more in this vein the next time a World title match is booked on TV.
6. Super Effective Main Event
Riho Vs. Willow Nightingale was a blast: a heated, exciting, dramatic TV match. It was a great, proper TV match too.
It didn't strain for epic, it didn't go long for the sake of it. It was punchy, lean, brimming with the trademark AEW energy. The dynamic was simple, logical, wholly engaging. Riho was slippery and evasive; when Willow finally hit her moving her target, her strikes were backed by missile power. Her pounce looked evil. There was one terrifying moment, in which Willow landed on her head when taking a northern lights suplex, but it added to the drama.
The momentum shifted at a dizzying rate that inched the fans towards the end of their seat. In a great sequence constructed as the match sprinted towards its conclusion, after the pounce, Willow missed with a cannonball to the floor. Riho took advantage with a double foot stomp.
As both women recovered and slowly moved towards the ring, Riho - who literally every single time catches an awe-struck crowd unaware with this move - blasted Willow with a dragon suplex. In a beautiful display of counter wrestling, one that again was faithful to the dynamic, Willow reversed a jack knife pin, seamlessly, into a dead-lift Doctor Bomb. Willow scored the win, after which she was attacked by Julia Hart and Skye Blue and subsequently saved by Mercedes Moné.
A cynical thought, but did Tony Khan need to hire Jennifer Pepperman at great expense, just to do the imminent rivals team together first trope?
Probably not - but Moné's glowing star signing aura will undoubtedly transcend the familiar pattern.
5. Another Great Night For Will Ospreay
Will Ospreay cut a shockingly great promo.
He's been selectively very good at them in the right environment for some time - his demand of Shota Umino to save NJPW in November of last year was incredible - but in the context of US TV, he was unproven - until last night.
He again presented himself as a humble figure delighted to be there - he was thrilled by the new "Bruv!" chant aimed in his direction - and spoke confidently. He also planted the story beat of his match with Bryan Danielson at Dynasty. His tone developed into something menacing. After the fireworks of his two awesome exhibition matches against Konosuke Takeshita and Kyle Fletcher, he brought up Bryan Danielson's thoughts about his very controversial use of the Tiger Driver '91 against Kenny Omega at Forbidden Door '23.
Was it worth it?
Yes, Ospreay said, and at Dynasty, "It's your life or mine - and I don't plan on dying".
Killer soundbite, terrifying promise. The tension surrounding Danielson taking that move, with his history of head issues, will be harrowing. With this superb promo, Ospreay Vs. Danielson is no longer a mere back-and-forth "dream match". Will has injected the match with an unbearable level of emotion before the bell even rings.
4. Very, Very Good Match...
Darby Allin is at once generally received as an excellent pro wrestler and underrated. You could make an argument that he is the best or at the very least most valuable wrestler on the planet. They used to say that if Sean Waltman couldn't get a good match out of you, you were hopeless. Mick Foley meanwhile turned prospects into headliners with his selflessness and craft.
Darby is an incredible combination of those two attributes (to which he isn't even limited).
His last match for a while, one really would hope, anyway, was used as a means of reheating Jay White. It very much succeeded. The wrestling was excellent. Jay White is equipped with one of the most wicked chops in the business, and Darby's selling is as powerful as his bumping. In the early stages, the thought process behind the matchmaking manifested itself beautifully. Darby, after taking a trademark demented bump over the steps and onto his coccyx, fought back into it (as ever, with his expert grasp of pacing, it felt earned). He went for the stunner. Jay, in several heart-stopping moments, almost countered into the Blade Runner. This prolonged reversal sequence never felt choreographed. It was peak New Japan tier on a night where Jay felt like the best version of himself again.
At the finish, Darby missed a frightening apron Coffin drop. The way in which he just clipped it made the whole crowd wince. After a very good count-out tease, Jay put Darby away with the Blade Runner.
Very, very good match.
Unreal post-match angle...
3. ...GREAT Post-Match Angle
Bullet Club Gold is showing their true colors tonight!
Watch #AEWDynamite #AEWBigBusiness LIVE on TBS!@JayWhiteNZ | @theaustingunn | @coltengunn | @RealBillyGunn | @Bowens_Official | @PlatinumMax pic.twitter.com/UrtBzF468C
— All Elite Wrestling (@AEW) March 14, 2024
In the post-match, Jay, who has teased a babyface turn, extended his hand to Darby.
He then cocked it, beat Darby down, and threatened to Pillmanise his ankle. Darby was saved when the Acclaimed rushed the ring. This was an inspired, deft twist. The heat angle overlapped with the well overdue Bang Bang Scissors Gang split, and it was framed, brilliantly, as a real you-can't-do-that transgression. Darby is about to climb Mount Everest. He obviously needs his ankle in order to do that. Jay hit Billy Gunn with a chair. Bullet Club Gold cleared the Acclaimed out of the ring.
Then, just as the injury angle was framed as an unconscionable no-no of an act, White did it - he Pillmanised Darby's ankle with a chair and bat combination. This was powerful if very, very risky. There's a not insignificant chance that Jay can never actually capitalise on this heat - but if he can, Jesus Christ. Jay White Vs. Darby Allin II could be monumental in its heft.
The very best episodic TV shows aren't merely glorified pay-per-views. The idea is to promote great action and enhance the emotion of the bigger destination matches. AEW Big Business achieved the match, angle and promo trifecta in excellent fashion last night.
2. On The Night, AEW Nailed It
Mercedes Moné shows her appreciation for her hometown crowd in Bo$$ton!
Watch #AEWDynamite #AEWBigBusiness LIVE on TBS!@MercedesVarnado pic.twitter.com/WwMXtm9gkA
— All Elite Wrestling (@AEW) March 14, 2024
After arriving in the arena in what presumably was a very expensive car, Mercedes Moné kicked off the show.
She looked incredible, as ever - a massive star with an A-list aesthetic. Her new theme 'CEO', with an in-built chant, is a total ear-worm. Singing along with it is irresistible. The song beckons everybody to chant along with it; before she even enters the ring, she has received a booming ovation and conjured a rocking atmosphere.
This was a tremendous debut. In a nice moment, she was allowed to simply speak from the heart, tell a digest version of her backstory, and thank the fans for staying with her throughout her journey in wrestling - which of course began in that very area. She expressed a desire to wrestle virtually everybody, and by mimicking the rhythm of a certain catchphrase, may well have teased a match with Dr. Britt Baker down the line.
She was composed, sincere, humble (without betraying that magic star aura). Really, as simple and direct as it was, it was perfect - a complete 180 from her flat introduction for New Japan last year.
She ended the promo with a pose as the chants were echoed back to her at a deafening volume once again. Moné received the superstar treatment and presented herself as a superstar in a strong indication that, after five unacceptable years, the women's division might actually become something.
1. The Elite Are Named That For A Reason
Has Kazuchika Okada gotten into Eddie Kingston's head?
Watch #AEWDynamite #AEWBigBusiness LIVE on TBS!#EddieKingston | @YoungBucks | @rainmakerXokada pic.twitter.com/gAz1DMBSG2
— All Elite Wrestling (@AEW) March 14, 2024
The Elite continue to be the best new stable in All Elite Wrestling.
Ahead of their second trios match, in an interview, Kazuchika Okada tormented poor Alex Marvez by making him sing 'Happy Birthday' to Matthew Jackson, in an entertaining bit that depicted Okada as a nasty ar*ehole of a bully. In the ring, Okada, in a great subversion of his full-time debut, tagged out. Where he easily smashed three jobbers on Collision, Okada wanted no part of Eddie Kingston - until he had been weakened. Eddie fought his way back into it, caving Okada's chest in whenever he found the space to throw his sledgehammer of an arm around, but he was mostly - methodically! - controlled by the Young Bucks, who continue to reorient their ring work in a more patient, traditional direction.
They really want to become the best heels they can in this run. By slowing it down, and honing in on that obnoxious demeanour, they're succeeding - but there's a bit more to it.
They're adopting the facade of proper businessmen. Their bodies are insured, as they've mentioned, for several million dollars. The new Young Bucks pick their spots, and it's not just a means of making the high spots mean more as the closing stretch breaks down. They don't get their sh*t in, even if it's just to annoy you. They've gone corporate. In a fantastic meta bit, they're wrestling like they would if they'd "sold out" to WWE. That frisson of the finish is in full effect, still. The crowd exploded when, a nanosecond after hitting Matthew Jackson with a Canadian destroyer, Penta was smashed in the temple with a superkick by Nicholas.
Okada is perfect in this role, which is such an inspired idea. His facials are exceptional. His attitude is dripping with an aloof arrogance. He is incredible at depicting himself as the final boss. In one excellent glimpse of that, he held onto the rope as Penta tried to execute the turnbuckle backstabber. He don't just eat any old move in a simplistic melee of trios movez match. He's a much, much smarter operator than that. He too picks his spots, as he did at the finish: setting up a Continental title challenge next week, he struck Eddie Kingston with the match-winning Rainmaker after Eddie had been blasted with a low blow.
Another excellent night for the best unit in AEW right now.