7 Ups & 2 Downs From AEW Dynamite (February 14 - Results & Review)

Heat, not love, was in the air on a very good Valentine's Day edition of Dynamite.

Jon Moxley Dax Harwood
AEW

Last week's Dynamite was great; a genuine return to form as opposed to the "restore the feeling" posturing that betrayed the show-don't-tell mantra.

More encouragingly still, the events were framed to matter, to linger. Tony Khan has been fairly accused of burning through story beats and pacing his shows in too rushed a manner. On Collision, through Adam Copeland and Eddie Kingston blasting the Young Bucks for what they did to Sting and his family last week, the transgression deepened, reverberating around the locker room. This effective device, a return to the detail-oriented peaks of AEW at its best, painted a picture of AEW as an interconnected and more believable entity, as opposed to a crammed warehouse of talent, few of whom are pushed at the level they should occupy.

This week's Dynamite promised to be very good. Jon Moxley and Dax Harwood were the two best TV wrestlers of 2022, and while a meeting two years later wasn't quite as appealing, the ceiling was high and the floor was a damn good match.

Adam Copeland Vs. Daniel Garcia seemed like something more than the usual AEW TV formula of top star narrowly defeats up-and-comer. Garcia has racked up the wins recently, and, at some point, Copeland and Christian Cage will join forces: would a shock Garcia win draw a bitter Copeland to the dark side?

The Young Bucks, in a squash Rampage win, teased a less ostentatious ring style. Did that continue against Top Flight, or would fans have to settle for a trademark whirlwind banger?

On a less good note, Tony Khan also booked a Texas Death Match (!) between Orange Cassidy and Matt Taven.

What?

Yes, the show emanated from Cedar Park, Texas - but Khan did a magnificent job of preserving the mystique of the stip in 2023. It felt like a gimmick with real aura to it, where so many - Hell In A Cell, ladder - have faded. Now, it's a subplot ahead of a midcard title match on PPV.

Did this latest Texas Death match live up to the legend...?


Downs...

2. A Bit Of A Waste

Samoa Joe Hangman Page
AEW

The segment booked to build the three-way World title match at Revolution was strange.

AEW advertised that fans would hear from Samoa Joe, Swerve Strickland and Hangman Page. It was implied that you'd hear from them separately, since you can't account for a promo train, which is premised on unexpected interruptions. Promo trains are contrived enough as it is: an advertised promo train is even worse. The content of the promo train was also uneven, which didn't help.

Samoa Joe's delivery was fantastic as he brushed off the idea of facing two wrestlers. They'll walk in, but limp out. While it probably wasn't a capital idea to bury three-way matches as "dumb" - which they sort of are in a sports-oriented league, since a champion need not be defeated to lose their title - he did so in a way that was funny, comparing it to how "bigger and dumber" everything is in Texas.

Swerve was the second carriage on the train, and said the sort of things he's been saying for a while now - he's put in the work, he's undeniably great etc. He needs a plot development to avoid these retreads, and this segment advanced nothing. The story has been told well, but it feels finished weeks ahead of Revolution.

Hangman entered the fray last, and while a dril reference was delightful to hear on a mainstream wrestling TV show, his motives didn't make a great deal of sense. He's meant to be scrambling to justify his actions, as his sense of morality slips, but this went too far.

Firstly, he said that Swerve didn't beat him and thus doesn't deserve a shot at the belt, even though Swerve was ranked #1 and he didn't best Swerve either. Secondly, Page said to Joe that the Revolution match should be wrestled by the two men who most value the World title. What?

That's all Swerve has talked about forever.

Page is one of the deepest thinkers of his era, but he has a tendency to over-think, and this might have been the case here.


1. More Of The Same

Wardlow Dynamite
AEW

On the rankings system generally, it can never be perfect.

It could only be perfect, were AEW to implement some sort of points-based league system in which every wrestler works the same amount of competitive fixtures, and that is not possible. Injuries are a huge factor, and running what would amount to a year-long G1 Climax would interfere with the need to space out big matches and build grudge programmes to sell pay-per-views.

The unfortunate flawed reality of a system that is best approached as means of maintaining narrative discipline revealed itself when Wardlow won a squash match. It was a decent enough fatality, but will at some point propel Wardlow up the rankings when he didn't exactly beat anybody worth beating. Away from that logic gap, it felt like an obligation, an excuse to get Wardlow on the show - to remind fans that he's still in the mix as a top player.

He doesn't feel like one, though, and that's fundamentally more important than points, data and numbers.


Ups...

7. The Only Women's Match (Again) Is Solid Enough

Willow Nightingale Skye Blue
AEW

Willow Nightingale Vs. Skye Blue was solid.

Enough.

The basic thrust of the match saw Blue carve out strategic opportunities to neutralise Willow's size advantage to gain momentum - in one example, by grabbing her from the top turnbuckle and smashing her with a powerbomb - to come agonisingly close to victory. This story beat, sadly, was acted with liberal NXT face. The fans were somewhat into it, but were louder elsewhere on the night.

It's Wednesday, you know what that means...

Skye came so close in fact that Stokely Hathaway embraced the idea of helping Willow in order to gain the trust of Kris Statlander: after Blue hit Code Blue on Willow, another move that wasn't 100% convincing, Stokely dashed from the commentary table to the apron and distracted the referee, allowing Willow to kick-out of the visual win and win herself with the Doctor Bomb.

The idea of Stokely, Willow and Stat earnestly becoming friends is the sort of charming and wholesome development at which AEW excels.


6. Toni Storm Does It Again

Timeless Toni Storm
AEW

This week's Toni Storm segment was both intentionally funny and perversely funny, depending on your disposition.

Toni was a riot narrating her new short feature 'Wet Ink' which, as expected, was the reveal of a cover-up to mask the matching tattoo she once had inked alongside Deonna Purrazzo. She built the idea that Deonna was her naive "young girl" to climax with the fantastic line "she bit the t*t that feeds".

It was then revealed, maybe, that Storm has covered up the old tat with a dagger effect stabbing through it. If this is real, going to the hassle of altering one's body so that we go to the back! for a 10 second Deonna reaction shot is insane.

A 10 second reaction to a lifelong decision!

Even if it's a temporary gimmick, at least pretend that it's real, and sell it with the gravity it should warrant. As under-sold as this plot development was, it was still a creative beat in the best women's story AEW has told in absolutely forever, and Toni is now consistently funny enough every single week that her Timeless character no longer feels like a sports entertainment imposition.

It's funnier than sports entertainment.


5. An Intriguing Match All-Round

Daniel Garcia Adam Copeland
AEW

Adam Copeland Vs. Daniel Garcia was trending towards excellent when Christian Cage, at the ideal time, dispatched the Patriarchy to the ring to put an end to it in a rare no-contest. This was very clever booking.

The fans were deprived of a beautiful slow-burn match just as they were getting into it, siphoning the heat towards Christian Cage. That device can still work, if the results are mostly clean elsewhere. Garcia was protected. He held the advantage over Copeland for much of the match, with his direct strategy of tripping up and attacking the leg of his taller opponent so that, as Taz pointed out, he was the same size on the mat. Also, the ambiguity was notable.

The match was assembled beautifully and gripping as a result. The leg work linked to a subtle and well-crafted spot in which Copeland couldn't support it when attempting the spear, allowing Garcia to instinctively kick him and jam him with a jack knife pin. This was class: a proper "Is he done for here?" moment, expertly timed.

Copeland meanwhile did not win. He heeled it up to funny effect during the commercial break, but that might have been because it wasn't canon, and he felt like having fun at the expense of a crowd who simply didn't like him. Situational stuff, or a hint towards his imminent direction?

He didn't win here, and while it was implied he would have - he had the Grindhouse locked in before the match was called off - it's still notable. He took a Con-chair-to. This could pave Garcia's road to Revolution. That, in turn, could drive a bitterness on the part of Copeland.

The Cedar Park crowd may prove to be an aberration, but a message was sent in Texas at least: people have extended latitude to Copeland's Jack Reacher is happy to be here shtick, but it's not exactly Rated R.


4. The Young Bucks Match Is Good...

Darius Martin Matthew Jackson
AEW

The Young Bucks are among the most thoughtful and intelligent acts in pro wrestling history. You don't read the review of this show and this show itself does not even exist were that not true.

In the second consecutive great week for an act that feels all the way back, at last, Matthew and Nicholas Jackson defeated Top Flight in a very good TV match. It wasn't quite "vintage" Young Bucks, by design or otherwise. The last third was very exciting and improbably dramatic, given that the Bucks were hardly going to lose ahead of Revolution, but they are flirting with an almost methodical approach to the heat segment. It suits the development of their new characters.

Before the pace and action exploded, they did a very effective job of generating support on behalf of their opponents. They again wrestled in the white suits they wore during the attack on Darby Allin and Sting and his family. This is a great visual - the blood, now developing a browned tinge, is a reminder of a deeply-felt transgression - but the material limits their movement somewhat. It is impossible for the Bucks to work a match that is anything less than exciting, but they don't fizz about the ring in quite the same way. They wore restrictive gear in a match in which they also restricted their own movement.

That stated, the Bucks are simply so fantastic at crafting a match to suit the strengths of their opponents that this almost couldn't help itself but resemble a "banger" at times.

In a great sequence, Matthew almost lost when Dante used his brother as a platform to spike him with an awesome-looking DDT. In a great bit of heel work, Matthew hit Darius in the balls just as the match was approaching a breathless crescendo. In the most important of ways, this was better than a great match in and of itself. It will take some getting used to, but it is now the job of the Young Bucks to deprive the fans of exhilarating action. This was beautiful character development. Match quality is less of a concern at this stage of the arc.

It's all about drawing the heat and making you beg for the comeuppance, and they did that brilliantly in the post-match...


3. ...The Post-Match Is Even Better

Young Bucks Tony Schiavone
AEW

The Young Bucks doing trad pro wrestling is both surreal and funny. Of course they're great at it.

Tony Schiavone conducted a post-match interview with them. Matthew pointed out that he has heard Schiavone clutching his pearls over their antics at the commentary table. He's upset about it, but not as much as his hothead brother, who shoulder barged Tony to the canvas.

(One small complaint: AEW has done this once too often. This should be something more awful and beyond the pale than even attacking Sting and his family. Wardlow, using the exact same physical movement it should be added, did this to Schiavone just a few months ago.)

Seemingly apologetic, the Bucks motioned to lift Schiavone off the canvas. In a blinding and super-creative bit of physical storytelling, they seamlessly threatened to strike Schiavone with the EVP Trigger. The set-up looks identical. It is this level of thought that separates the Bucks from virtually everybody else - the level of thought that indicates they are back, dialled-in, thinking about and feeling their work all over again.

Sadly, this didn't quite generate the intended "F*ck off, you can't do that" reaction. Darby Allin made the save, and eventually made the match official - after berating the Bucks for what they did last week and for overlooking him back in 2019 in favour of Brandon Cutler. Darby has a mixed record of using real-life history in his promos, and can veer into dreaded worked-shoot territory, but his alluding to Cody Rhodes here was brilliant, since you're not meant to hear that name anymore, much less in such glowing terms. Darby thanked God that AEW used to have one EVP who knew what he was doing, and his name isn't Kenny Omega.

This storyline is superb and is highlighting the best AEW PPV build in well over a year.


2. Strong Opener Is Right

Jon Moxley Dax Harwood
AEW

You see chop battles premised on the idea of machismo every week. You see a match with loosely the same fighting spirit-informed structure as Jon Moxley Vs. Dax Harwood most weeks. The difference, the key that allowed the Dynamite opener to soar, was in its stubbornness.

Awful non-consensual kissing spot aside.

That theme underpinned the entire match: neither man wanted to show an ounce of vulnerability or weakness. They at times couldn't mask how much damage they had endured - Dax's delayed, jelly-legged selling was excellent in particular - but refused to give in throughout. Neither man wrestled with an iota of intelligence until the finish required a semblance of strategy; instead, they became awful versions of themselves to prove their masculinity over the other. It was idiotic in the best, most deliberately way possible. They were too stupidly proud, and as the classic Jackass song goes, if you're gonna be dumb, you've gotta be tough.

And the shots in this match, Jesus Christ. They were indeed tough.

In this hard-hitting era of pro wrestling, you'll read variations of "they beat the sh*t" out of each other" most weeks - but they truly beat the sh*t out of each other. The match ruled. Attentional tone, gruesome physicality, loopy body language: it was gnarly, but also incredibly dramatic. It felt destined to go to a draw, since so many sequences were skilfully arranged to make it seem as though as neither man could be separated. The double count-out tease, done to near-death since it was popularised by resurgence-era New Japan, took on real meaning all over again here. On TV, AEW attempts the one wrestler goes over, the other gets over match constantly. This was one of the better versions: Dax simply never wins singles matches, and here, he almost took the winningest singles wrestler to his absolute limit.

In the post-match, Mox held onto the match-winning bulldog choke a little too long, drawing out Cash Wheeler. Claudio Castagnoli returned fire, setting up a very appealing tag match next week.


1. Wild Main Event Over-Delivers

Bloody Orange Cassidy
AEW

While this easily could and should have been held under some sort of Cedar Park Street Fight gimmick, to preserve the mystique of Texas Death, Orange Cassidy Vs. Matt Taven ruled.

It was also rushed. TV time constraints meant that the lack of selling during the climactic thumbtack spots were egregious. Still, while it could have done with a few more minutes, it was a cracking ultra-violent blast all the same.

Orange Cassidy executed a great tweak on Kenny Omega's spot at Full Gear '19 by leap-frogging over the barricade - with his hands in his pockets. This spot sparked a lively brawl through the crowd and led to the first big plunder action set-piece. It didn't go well. The table just sort of collapsed when Taven attempted to drive Orange through it with an elbow drop. In a superb bit of improvisation, Taven grabbed it, propped it up against the entrance ramp, and smashed Orange through it with a suplex. The match started to rock from that moment forward.

Taven killed Orange all the way down the ramp with his underrated strike game (everything about Taven is underrated) before outwitting Cassidy with his creative attack patterns. Orange regained the advantage when he dodged a Taven plancha through another table. He took a terrifying header of a bump. Taven's lunacy was as impressive as his quick thinking earlier.

In a cute and creative moment typical of the Best Friends, Orange retrieved a Valentine's Day gift box from under the ring addressed to him from Chuck Taylor. Thumbtacks, not chocolates, were contained within.

This incited the rushed finishing sequence, but it was so demented and blood-soaked that it hardly mattered. Taven took a spiked DDT on the things!

Orange won with the Beach Break on the tacks and some chairs following interference from Mike Bennett (thwarted by Trent). Until last night, the story of Orange Cassidy battling through fatigue felt like a deeply uninspired retread of his arc last year.

This was much more like it.


Contributor
Contributor

Michael Sidgwick (Creative Writing BA Hons) is an editor, writer and podcaster for WhatCulture Wrestling. With over a decade of experience in wrestling analysis, Michael was published in the influential UK institution that was Power Slam magazine, and specialises in providing insights into All Elite Wrestling - so much so that he wrote a book about the subject. You can order Becoming All Elite: The Rise Of AEW on Amazon. Possessing a deep knowledge also of WWE, WCW, ECW and New Japan Pro Wrestling, Michael’s work has been publicly praised by AEW World Champions Kenny Omega and MJF, and Undisputed WWE Champion Cody Rhodes. When he isn’t putting your finger on why things are the way they are in the endlessly fascinating world of professional wrestling, Michael wraps his own around a hand grinder to explore the world of specialty coffee. Follow Michael on X (formerly known as Twitter) @MSidgwick for more!