7 Ups & 2 Downs From AEW Dynamite (May 22 - Results & Review)
Darby Allin introduces an insane weapon on a silly but effective Double Or Nothing go-home episode.
Much discourse surfaced over the weekend about AEW Collision and, chiefly, why it actually exists.
Consider the match between Nick Wayne and Jack Cartwheel which, one delightfully unhinged bump on the part of the latter aside, was a bit of a piss-take. Last week's Collision was a barely glorified episode of Dark: Elevation. That show, hardly must-see, once functioned as a means of "building" wrestlers ahead of a key match on Dynamite. Collision has now supplanted that thin purpose. Had Wayne featured prominently on television, and wasn't one of the countless wrestlers that have no space through which to progress, there'd have been nothing wrong with a quick squash win - but he's barely on TV. That woefully predictable match was borderline insulting, reeking of last-minute homework. Who says Nick Wayne, who we don't care about enough to book consistently, can't beat World champion Swerve Strickland?
He just beat another guy we don't care about enough to book consistently - in two minutes!
Yes, there's some nice continuity to the Swerve Vs. Wayne subplot, a bit of thought, but the patterned booking is really showing its age five years in.
All of which is to state that this was AEW's last chance to hard-sell Double Or Nothing 2024.
It's already happening. Double Or Nothing has crept up on fans - is it this weekend already? - without much in the way of feeling. A great, well-built show is meant to feel like it's ages away. The expanded pay-per-view schedule is undermining the crucial sense of anticipation.
Did AEW disprove this creeping cynicism on Dynamite...?
Downs...
2. Chris Jericho Remains At Large
In three-way/Triple Threat matches, you'll often see a spot in which two of the wrestlers each apply a submission hold to the third.
What happens if they tap out? What happens if they tap out in a title match? Do the two wrestlers become co-champions? Three-way matches are fundamentally stupid; they've just been normalised.
Last night, AEW answered a question that shouldn't have been asked in the first place: both Katsuyori Shibata and HOOK made Bryan Keith tap out. The match was a lethargic exchange of suplexes and little more before this bad finish. Watching Shibata do bad TV wrestling miscommunication spots is a little soul-destroying.
Chris Jericho - who provided guest commentary here - is very often criticised by default these days. And rightly so: he hasn't earned his ever-present status in a long time and people want him to go away. Sometimes he's not actively atrocious, just profoundly over-exposed and slow in the ring. He was actively atrocious last night, Jesus Christ.
He said, in that disingenuous new cadence, that he loves being on TV. Isn't that the wrong way 'round? If he's doing an insincere playing dumb bit, shouldn't he be saying something along the lines of "Well, you know I don't like to steal focus from the young guys, but I was asked by the Young Bucks to come out and do commentary, and since I'm a pro..."
That way, the character would both make sense and it would feel as though the Young Bucks are actually interested in taking over the show beyond their own segments.
Jericho hopped on a live mic after the match to explain the finish, but was so caught up in getting his new bad bit over that he ran out of time. He had to "shut the hell up" as his music played as a cue to get him out of there.
Woeful look for the guy whose entire reason for hanging around is his level of experience.
1. Pure Weapons-Grade WrestleCrap
After Malakai Black defeated Kyle O'Reilly, red spooky lights flickered over the arena.
Then, Malakai was drenched with a ludicrous amount of terrible fake blood. On about every conceivable level you could possibly imagine, this was awful.
Right.
To unpack.
The blood was obviously fake, but if the insinuation was that it was real, Adam Copeland has either killed a human being or a collection of small animals. At an absolute minimum, he has stolen it from a hospital and indirectly killed more people by preventing them from a potentially life-saving transfusion.
If the blood was meant to be fake, and this was some "twisted" "mind game", then Black was horrified to be...mildly inconvenienced enough to take a post-match shower, which you'd hope he would have done regardless. Also: this was obviously a nod to Adam Copeland's days in the Brood. What is remotely intimidating about that?
"Gaze upon the horror of...me cosplaying as my old greenhorn self being unable to cut promos in a gimmick that prevented me from getting over".
Also: who put the blood up there?
Also: it didn't look remotely real. There were bits in it, like jam (or "jelly").
Goofy, fake, cringe-worthy - and this isn't the first time that Copeland's self-referential work has scanned as masturbatory.
Ups...
7. Women's Match Is Flawed, But Very Over
Up until the finish and post-match, at least, Toni Storm and Mariah May Vs. Saraya and Harley Cameron was a strong bit of business. Despite very generous chants of "This is awesome", it was only a decent-to-good match. Perhaps the extent to which it over-delivered explains the response.
This was deeply basic stuff done really quite well. The babyfaces got the shine. The nefarious heels cheated to reverse the momentum, and maintained the heat throughout the commercial break. Saraya, who is too often ridiculed, should receive a degree of credit for elevating the basic structure. Just before the break, she ate a stiff strike from Mariah. She immediately fell to the canvas in a panic and summoned the ref. This was an effective ruse. She's a better worker than her reputation suggests. The match was also elevated by the sheer popularity of the Storm/May pairing.
Even when they didn't showcase the most fluent synchronisation on double teams, the fans didn't care. They just love the act. Cameron - who is one of the very few acts in wrestling who can believable perform as if slightly unbalanced - did her part to dial up the volume by going nuts on the apron. She was also game to take an overkill sequence during the closing stretch, but immediately before the finish itself, Toni and Mariah each planted forced kisses on Saraya and May respectively. This (worked) non-consensual stuff is ugly and it's frightening that so few people raise it as an issue.
After Storm and May won, Serena Deeb attacked them all from behind with a steel chair.
A sneak attack when Deeb was outnumbered three to one about sums up the utterly broken face/heel dynamic.
6. As Basic And Uninspiring As It Gets...But...
The IWGP World Title Eliminator match at Double Or Nothing underscores the core AEW problem. There are too many stars AEW feels the need to protect, and too many prospects Tony Khan attempts to book at once. A predictable match featuring two wrestlers who should be focused upon more ensues.
Jon Moxley Vs. Konosuke Takeshita will be awesome - they worked one of the best matches in Rampage history in late 2022 - but is it really necessary? Doesn't it feel like these two wrestlers just needed to be on the card in some capacity?
This segment really wasn't bad in and of itself, just uninspired and insulting in that customary US wrestling TV way. Hang on, guys...if Konosuke Takeshita was so dominant on Wednesday...that means...he might beat Jon Moxley on Sunday!
Yes, form is a very real sporting concept and it's not AEW's fault that WWE bastardised it with its lazy "momentum" trope, but AEW's television show is desperate for more promos, and it's not as if they don't have countless great talkers - Mox among them - on that bloated roster. Take defeated Matt Sydal in a squash (the one time a predictable lengthy back-and-forth would have justified itself...).
Afterwards, in an awesome spot, Take feigned to shake Sydal's hand. Take then yanked him, seamlessly, into a dead-lift German suplex. This was amazing. Sydal looked like Yoshihiko, Take is that strong. Mox made the save, laid Takeshita out, and said he'd see him on Sunday.
TL;DR - the most basic AEW go-home angle you'll ever see, but because Takeshita was involved, it looked incredible.
5. Death Triangle Are Back
The Bang Bang Gang called out PAC. PAC revealed that which he's teased for a while: a fully fit Death Triangle are back in action and will challenge for the Unified Trios titles at Double Or Nothing. Death Triangle got the better of the resulting brawl.
There was nothing more to the angle than that, but the crowd popped huge for the babyface trio's entrance and the angle, no matter how basic, was very over in the building.
4. Malakai Black Is Worth The Wait
Malakai Black rarely works singles matches, which is a pity: he is an awesome pro wrestler. You could make the argument that his brief interaction with Kenny Omega at Revolution '23 was among the best wrestling action witnessed all year, and it went about three minutes.
Here, he defeated Kyle O'Reilly in a great and very distinct match that, while sadly lacking in scorching heat for much of the duration, was the sort of spectacle that makes you grateful all over again for the existence of All Elite Wrestling. You simply will not find something this unusual on other mainstream wrestling shows.
A worked kickboxing match fused with pro wrestling dramatics, it was a delight. The various evasions and blocks were perfectly timed and only enhanced the moments of super-stiff connection. The strike counters into submission holds were also just sensational. The idea that neither wrestler could make even a minor timing error was executed masterfully. Suspension of disbelief was so easy to achieve.
In an awesome finish, Black feigned to strike O'Reilly with The End. With O'Reilly's guard down, Black struck the real thing for the win. Black's supernatural rubbish is especially frustrating when he is, evidently, levels above it. He is fantastic when staying in his lane as a strategic, unique pro wrestler whose mind games are far better suited in the context of wrestling action.
The wild contrast between the match and the post-match angle could not have made this more clear.
3. Main Event Segment Is Bananas
Bryan Danielson went over Satnam Singh (!) by DQ in a match that probably didn't reach unrealistic expectations of a triumphant, impossible over-delivery.
Elements of it were very well done. Sometimes matches look better for how uglier they are, and Satnam's standing suplex looked very ugly (but devastating). Danielson took two bumps, one on his hip and another on his legs, because the drop was that steep. As Taz expertly called it, it was as if Danielson had fallen off a building. Danielson is a pro wrestling genius, and as such, he constantly built the action around the immense size difference between himself and his opponent. He didn't merely fight from underneath; at every turn, he made himself look even smaller.
The visual was fantastic, particularly when he sat on Satnam's shoulders to deliver the hammer-and-anvil elbows. He was practically in the rafters. He did this again at the finish. He looked as though he was straining every tendon in his arms by reaching out desperately to apply the hold. He was predictably brilliant at maximising what little Satnam can do. He ate an almighty overhand chop when he was one second away from connecting with the Busaiku knee, creating the electrifying, necessary movement.
The match threatened to fall apart when Sonjay Dutt tried to clear the table for a plunder spot, but it immediately collapsed. In a neat bit of improvisation, Satnam instead used the apron for his chokeslam.
The Elite stormed the ring to beat up Danielson in the post-match. Paying off the show-long storyline, Tony Khan drove the "banned" Darby Allin into the arena. Darby warded off the Elite - in a deranged, utterly fantastic idea - with a flamethrower.
Hard not to get pumped up for Double Or Nothing with such an outrageously badass visual like that.
2. Super Resourceful Opening Segment
The opening match was very good without - consciously - ever striving for greatness. Roderick Strong and Trent went over Will Ospreay and Orange Cassidy when Strong pinned Orange with End of Heartache.
The sensible idea was to both provide a glimpse into what Will Ospreay and Roderick Strong can achieve together and attend to the thread of Orange Cassidy's reaction to Trent's betrayal. In a match not too unlike a Four Pillars tag, in how it was structured at least, Orange Cassidy was so driven by vengeance that he was compelled to attack Trent every time he ran the ropes and saw him standing there. This was a hailstorm of activity perfectly slotted in the opener.
The chaotic atmosphere and relentless activity helped focus the attention and put the phone away. The rate of incident here was propelled by pure Dynamite energy, and it also helped to preserve the Ospreay/Strong dynamic. Just when they'd worked an excellent struggle and motioned to go all out, the Kingdom, for example, would interfere and Ospreay would flatten them with a sensational dive on the outside. Then, after what is becoming one of his trademark absences, Wardlow flatted Ospreay immediately after Will had reversed the momentum.
Similarly, when Strong thought he had Orange beat, Don Callis, furthering the linked subplot, unexpectedly jumped up from the commentary desk and helped the man he's trying to corrupt by placing his foot on the ropes.
A deft spree of action tying multiple threads together, this was a crazed series of story beats and action set-pieces. The rhythm of it was fantastic. It never felt like numbing booking overkill.
A slap to the face, a pinball machine of an opening segment.
1. Swerve Strickland's Best Night Since Full Gear '23
Swerve Strickland, after getting his ass kicked relentlessly over the past few weeks, enjoyed his best night yet as AEW World champion.
He entered nothing short of a babyface tour de force of a performance, one so relentlessly great that it was reminiscent of Jon Moxley in 2020, even Steve Austin in 1998. Before making his entrance, the Young Bucks stumbled upon him. He asked the "turds" what was up before, with pure contempt, asking them to hit his music. That interaction didn't happen by accident. Then, in a very refreshing and well overdue break from the usual 50/50 back-and-forth predictable TV match formula, Swerve - who was vulnerable to the occasional creative counter - quite handily and viciously defeated Nick Wayne. This didn't strain for epic; instead, Swerve kicked his head in with a series of spectacular and well-linked moves, including a backdrop suplex on the apron that led to a Swerve Stomp launched from the apron.
After Swerve won with the House Call, the Patriarchy swarmed the ring, threatening yet another beat-down angle. Instead, Swerve got the better of Killshot. This panicked Christian Cage, who retreated up the ramp. Killshot rose from the dead, but in a superb bit of blocking, Swerve, the effortlessly precise gunslinger in the western, took him out with a no-look Last Call before confronting Christian. This next bit was tremendous - peak, detail-oriented AEW.
Cage, much like had when running away from Adam Copeland in the not too recent past, carjacked some poor guy and tried to drive away from the arena. He was cut off by a returning Prince Nana, dragged out of his car, and then almost brained with a Con-chair-to.
Following this total blast of an angle, you'll have to wait (and pay) to see the heel receive his comeuppance.
Mostly excellent go-home material all night long.