7 Ups & 4 Downs From AEW Dynamite (Apr 21)

Allin faces Jungle Boy, Moxley and Kingston return, and Jericho plays it for laughs.

Darby Allin
AEW

How do you follow up on an episode that posted the second-highest viewership in your brand's history, surging to second in the night's cable originals rankings on the very first week without direct competition? By loading your card to the gills with nought but hot, story-driven singles matches.

Last night's AEW Dynamite had the potential to be one of the five best shows in the flagship's history. It didn't hit that level, unfortunately, but this was a good episode nonetheless, with two big title matches and significant developments on the roads to Blood and Guts and Double or Nothing.

Darby Allin defended his TNT Championship for the second consecutive week, looking to follow up on his Matt Hardy victory with another over Jungle Boy. Elsewhere, top-ranked Tay Conti stepped up to face Women's Champion Hikaru Shida.

The Pinnacle and Inner Circle weren't short of things to say ahead of Blood and Guts, Eddie Kingston and Jon Moxley returned for the first time in two weeks, and Ricky Starks opened up against Hangman Page.

Let's light the fuse on Dynamite's successes and failures, starting with the lows...


Downs...

4. Bus Stuff

Jon Moxley Eddie Kingston
AEW

Jon Moxley and Eddie Kingston are p*ss-funny.

Their camaraderie makes you want to hang out with them, even though you know it'll likely end in a bar fight. Last night, they were at it again, with Kingston clapping at Mox for throwing a baseball bat through The Elite's bus window before he'd moved out of the way, and Jon admonishing his buddy for trying to steal The Young Bucks' expensive Dior sneakers. They're a hoot.

Unfortunately, the rest of this segment was not.

The Elite cut snotty promos from their trailer before being distracted by a horn outside. When Kingston and Moxley rammed with their vehicle, they found the heels had disappeared.

Straight out of the Vince McMahon playbook, this was. The Elite pretty much vanished into thin air, the faces looked daft for giving them warning before charging, and the whole thing felt gimmicky. As funny as Kingston and Moxley's banter continues to be, it couldn't help the segment transcend its framework.


3. Don't Disrespect Sue

Penta El Zero Miedo
AEW

Penta El Zero Miedo vs. Trent? was a brisk, hard-hitting clash with bigger bombs than the opener, and looked like an apt singles comeback for Trent? following his recent return, though it was ultimately undone by an unnecessarily cluttered finish.

Alex Abrahantes is now more than just the Penta Says guy. He's a full-on manager for the Lucha Brother, and that works. Obnoxious in all the right ways, Alex has charisma, makes you want to slap him in the face, and generally plays his role well. Here, he was overused to the point of derailment.

Abrahantes intervened when Penta was in trouble, grabbing a microphone to tell Trent? he sucks, his friends sucks, and his mom, Sue, sucks. Literal "Your Mom!" jokes opened the window for Penta to prevail, with a microphone shot and Package Piledriver finishing the Best Friend.

Trent? looked silly for gawking at Alex while all this was going on. Penta, meanwhile, came across as a guy who needed his interviewer buddy's help to win. Weak stuff.


2. Inner Circle Comedy Fails To Land

Chris Jericho
AEW

There was plenty of good in The Inner Circle's latest pre-Blood and Guts address. Santana was excellent on the microphone, outclassing everyone else with rugged believability, and Chris Jericho, when he finally got serious, fulfilled the purpose of a wrestling promo: he promoted. That last minute or so helped make the rivalry with the Pinnacle feel even more important than it already does.

This was necessary after the attempt at opening with comedy. None of Jericho and Jake Hager's jokes landed, from the depreciating My J*rkoff Friend/Pineapple lines to the "show tune" that was only a couple of degrees away from the career-low "rooty, tooty, booty!" promo Le Champion once launched at The New Day. These parts only undermined a serious, heated blood feud, particularly after The Pinnacle's exemplary segment, and it's weird that Jericho took this route.

Here's hoping for a heftier tone during next week's parley.


1. Interferences Everywhere

Luchasaurus Sting
AEW

The glut of interference and distraction spots on every episode of AEW Dynamite is undermining the company's reputation as the clean finish promotion.

It's good that AEW isn't booking a bunch of countouts and disqualifications, but three of last night's six matches had some kind of interference. In QT Marshall vs. Billy Gunn and Penta vs. Trent?, it led directly to the finish. This wasn't the case in Darby Allin vs. Jungle Boy, but Sting and Luchasaurus' involvement was still distracting, having a clear detrimental impact on an otherwise strong bout.

AEW's use of these spots now borders on overreliance. Few of them feel necessary and while these finishes are technically still "clean," the company is being a little too cute with how closely it skirts the line.


Ups...

7. Outgunned

QT Marshall Billy Gunn
AEW

There was a lot going on when cowardly QT Marshall wrestled Billy Gunn, but the whole package served its purpose and didn't overstay its welcome, hence why it's on the positive side of the ledger.

Gunn barrelled into QT and his Factory to start, then beat him up for the bulk of the match. Things turned around with Nick Comoroto struck Billy and drew Austin and Colten Gunn from the crowd. Having turned the corner through no work of his own, Marshall profited from an Anthony Ogogo body shot while the referee tended to the Factory's leader, who won via QT Cutter.

Comoroto looked like a beast when he absorbed Dustin Rhodes' wooden chair shot like it was nothing. That should be a singles match - and pronto.


6. Bidding War

Setting up a bidding war between managers for Jade Cargill's services makes the rookie feel like an even bigger deal than she already is, having made a flying start to life as a pro wrestler.

Cargill asserted that she doesn't need a manager because she's her own boss, and anyone who wants to be associated with her needs to make a hell of a deal. Vickie Guerrero and Matt Hardy both featured in the vignette, singing Cargill's praises, presenting Jade as a woman in the demand.

Good, simple stuff for the sought-after future star, and it'll be interesting to see if she lands with Hardy, Guerrero, or someone else entirely.


5. Christian Survives The Powerhouse

Christian Cage
AEW

You hire a guy like Christian Cage for matches like last night's, as the rejuvenated veteran put on an excellent defensive showing against Powerhouse Hobbs.

Hobbs was already a fun action fighter whose big boy power moves were amongst the most giffable in the company. Here, he put on a different kind of performance. Team Taz's Powerhouse was a clobbering menace, beating Cage up in a more methodical manner than usual, without shortcutting to launching him around the ring. For his part, Christian bumped and sold well. His first two AEW singles matches have shown that he remains elite in these aspects of the game, and he made Hobbs look like a beast while in control.

Cage was crafty, too, countering out of Town Business when Hobbs was too focused on mocking his signature pose. Experience proved the difference-maker as Christian snatched victory from the jaws of defeat with the Killswitch.

Afterwards, Christian and Ricky Starks stared each other down, forecasting a potentially delicious Double or Nothing match.


4. Page Cements His Ranking

Hangman Page Ricky Starks
AEW

While Hangman Page vs. Ricky Starks could have done with another five minutes and was likely curtailed by the sheer volume of important content on this show (or perhaps the nasty neck bump Starks took off a suplex), their opener was still hot.

The announcers continued to lean heavily on Page's status as the company's number one ranked wrestler, forecasting a World Title shot. He worked well with Starks, despite said neck bump, showing his strength with hoss spots including a lifted pumphandle off the mat. Later, Starks got nasty, hammer-throwing Hangman into the corner after throwing him against the second ropes, but a worked ankle injury hindered his offense. Ricky sold this like a pro, struggling all the way to the end.

Hangman trapped Starks in a bulldog choke that might not have finished him had Page not grabbed the hurt ankle as well, forcing 'Absolute' to tap. Afterwards, The Dark Order arrived to chase the swarming Team Taz away.

Page now advances to face Brian Cage next week. He has cemented his position at number one and it'd now take a minor disaster to dislodge him from that spot ahead of Double or Nothing.


3. Great, Period

The Pinnacle
AEW

Thank goodness for The Pinnacle, whose sitdown interview with Jim Ross landed exactly as intended.

MJF was characteristically great here, as Tully Blanchard indirectly gifted him a new Burberry Scarf, but it was cool to hear Wardlow speaking up as well. He's as well-spoken as they come and his delivery is on the money, so let's hope the big man starts verbally cutting fools down more often.

Saying he wasn't just great for 25 but great, period, Max was on fire. He's the one guy that Chris Jericho couldn't keep under his thumb, a mark for Jericho's spot rather than Jericho himself, and now, he only associates himself with top guys and winners, despite last week's "immortal" Inner Circle promo.

Serious, hefty, and full of conviction, this was exactly what it needed to be, and went a long way towards selling Blood and Guts. These guys are going to get nasty.


2. The Young & Hungry

Jungle Boy
AEW

Wacky outside interventions aside, Jungle Boy vs. Darby Allin was a good TNT Championship match to continue Allin's recent hot streak on top, with the Face of the Network proving himself quite the ratings-winner for AEW at the moment.

Given their youth, this is a match we'll likely see a dozen more times over the coming years, yet this was the first time they'd ever gone one-on-one in AEW. This speaks how adept the promotion is at protecting and preserving first-time matches. Rather than spamming these clashes to fill television time, AEW keeps hold of them, and they don't typically empty at the tank in the first match either. While Allin and Jungle Boy worked hard and generated excitement, they left plenty of ground for future bouts to cover.

Taking a more refined, technically, and clinical approach than many might have expected early on, Jungle Boy vs. Allin soon unravelled, with the champion stepping to an opponent capable of matching him hold-for-hold. Later, Darby returned the favour by working his way to the ropes from the Snare Trap, escaping the sub where so many have fallen.

Though Allin was fading late on, eye-gouging his way out of another Snare Trap saved his bacon. Jungle Boy couldn't kick out of the ensuing Last Supper.


1. Tay Conti Levels Up, Britt Baker Steps Up

Hikaru Shida Tay Conti
AEW

It's impossible to say enough good things about Tay Conti, whose rapid AEW rise is both a damning indictment of WWE's developmental system and testament to her own will and drive.

In a short space of time, the Brazilian has gone from underdeveloped WWE cast-off to one of the most improved wrestlers in the world. Her strikes pop and snap, she works her martial arts techniques into a pro wrestling framework seamlessly, and last night, she sold well too. Beaten down for prolonged periods, Conti took her licks like a potential champ as she delivered the best performance and match of her career.

Hikaru Shida has always been a great mechanic capable of elevating anyone she stands across the ring from. Here, she worked with increased nastiness, showing flashes of heeldom as she worked Conti over on the road to victory. This eventually came via Katana.

Props, too, to whoever laid the match and its perfectly dramatic closing stretch out. More than mindless signature move kickouts, those last-minute saves felt earned. They were the product of grit, fight, and heart. A struggle.

In defeat, Conti moves down from number one in the rankings, allowing Britt Baker to finally ascend. She accosted Shida after the bell - so there's your pay-per-view match.


Channel Manager
Channel Manager

Andy has been with WhatCulture for 10 years and is currently WhatCulture's Wrestling Channel Manager. A writer, presenter, and editor with 10+ years of experience in online media, he has been a sponge for all wrestling knowledge since playing an old Royal Rumble 1992 VHS to ruin in his childhood. Having previously worked for Bleacher Report, Andy specialises in short and long-form writing, video presenting, voiceover acting, and editing, all characterised by expert wrestling knowledge and commentary. Andy is as much a fan of 1985 Jim Crockett Promotions as he is present-day AEW and WWE - just don't make him choose between the two.