7 Ups & 4 Downs From NXT Halloween Havoc Part Two (Results & Review)

Creeds' last dance, hard-hitting NXT Championship match, and Dar as Scooby Doo. Buckle up!

WWE.com

NXT was always going to have a difficult road ahead of itself to top last week’s Halloween Havoc episode, even with three title matches and a possible farewell to a popular act.

But Tuesday’s show was still a good deal of fun. It helps with the bar being lowered (below WWE’s already lower standards) because NXT is more of a developmental brand than Raw or SmackDown. The program gave fans spirited title defenses, a surprise return and potential goodbye to the Creed Brothers, who returned from a successful Raw debut Monday night.

Being NXT, viewers had to expect some goofy Halloween season !*$%, and the show definitely provided a few of those moments, but it mostly worked and kept the really silly stuff to a few select segments involving Meta-Four and the wrestlers who always look like they’re ready for Halloween, Alba Fyre and Isla Dawn.

If you were new to NXT, there were probably a few moments where you got lost, but there also was some good content to hook you in. Call Halloween Havoc a success for staying true to what NXT is today and not straying too far off in either direction, right down to Noam Dar dressed as Scooby Doo.

Let’s get to it…


DOWNS…

4. King Creeper

Lexis King
WWE

Maybe his gimmick is supposed to give off “80s high school jock reject” vibes, but Lexis King was not exactly setting the world on fire during a brief backstage interview.

King gloated about always being pleased with himself and how his name (the new one he chose because he doesn’t want to be known as Brian Pillman Jr.) generated a lot of buzz. He tried suggesting he had done something that would get a lot of attention soon, but didn’t elaborate, then awkwardly hit on Mackenzie Mitchell and failed miserably.

The premise of the name change is at least better than previous moniker switches, but this character feels like a slate of attributes rather than an actual, fully formed character. Maybe that will change over time, but Tuesday just felt awkward.


3. Who Agents The Agents?

Tiffany Stratton Fallon Henley
WWE.com

Talk about déjà vu.

The Creed Brothers and Angel Garza and Humberto Carrillo had a personal grudge, so their “Tables, Ladders and Scares” match started on the floor, with the Creeds meeting them on the ramp. That made sense. The next match saw Tiffany Stratton jump Fallon Henley in the entranceway, rendering the match moot. OK.

But a few matches later, Thea Hail and Jacy Jayne jumped Chelsea Green and Piper Niven to kick off their women’s tag title match.

That’s three scheduled matches in the span of 90 minutes that started almost the same exact way. When the third happened, it felt like the agents didn’t talk to each other, or they were copying each other’s homework. It felt lazy and repetitive, and that shouldn’t be the first vibe you get from a match, simply because you’ve seen the same start twice earlier in the night.


2. Still Not Down With Gacy

Joe Gacy
WWE

It’s not fair to saddle Joe Gacy with all the blame for the groan-inducing stupidity that was the Schism during the past year-plus.

But with the demise of that group in recent weeks, it seemed like there was a real opportunity to reboot Gacy, who is a talented wrestler between the ropes when you can ignore the nonsensical promos.

And then Gacy spoke Tuesday night. Transcribing it would just waste minutes that couldn’t be returned, as would trying to understand and interpret the promo. Joe mused about the “unspeakable things” he did (like repackaging the Grizzled Young Veterans into the Dyad) and asked, “Am I the problem?” before declaring he isn’t asking for forgiveness.

It was just more nonsense with fewer spooky undertones, which is funny considering this promo took place on Halloween Havoc.


1. Maybe Frazer Should Slow Down

Dominik Mysterio Nathan Frazer
WWE.com

Nathan Frazer should be a can’t-miss superstar with his talent. And yet, somehow NXT decided to take an in-ring accident a couple of months ago and turn it into a new character trait where he sprints around everywhere at light-speed in a chaotic manner.

The result is a wrestler looking frantic in the ring rather than smooth and fast. It also forces Frazer’s opponents, like Dominik Mysterio on Tuesday, to keep up the insane pace, which opens the door for missteps. At one point, Frazer went for a middle rope moonsault into an inverted DDT, and they very nearly lost the thread because Nathan was flying at him at 100 kph.

Another downfall of this “speed kills” character trait is that when he needs to slow down to build drama and tension in the match, it suddenly looks like he’s moving through a tar pit. His climb to the top when Mysterio pushed him to the floor seemed to take hours by comparison after seeing him sprint to the top just moments earlier.

Just let Frazer wrestle as himself instead of trying to give him some goofy trait that isn’t going to make him – or the company – any money.


UPS…

7. Halloween Silliness

Meta-Four Scooby Doo
WWE.com

What can you really say about Meta-Four’s hijinks and Alba Fyre and Isla Dawn’s spooky spells they cast on NXT Tuesday night?

NXT itself is the land of silliness. Goofy gimmicks, nonsensical storylines and C-level humor have reigned supreme in the developmental brand for a while now, and that was only magnified with Halloween Havoc giving a bigger excuse for the absurd.

Factor in the superstars involved in the goofiest segments, and it makes perfect sense. Meta-Four is a comedy stable that was dressing up in costume in September, so why wouldn’t they do the same for Halloween? They played it perfectly, dressing as Mystery Inc. (Scooby Doo and company) while searching a “haunted mansion” for Dar’s Heritage Cup. The end result was equally silly, with Akira Tozawa stealing the cup simply to secure a championship match next week.

Fyre and Dawn have been nearly invisible on the main roster, so seeing them do anything on television is a positive, but leaning into the spooky side for Halloween worked well, as did tying them back to the “cursed” WWE Women’s Tag Team Championship.

Confining the truly ridiculous stuff to those characters – it’s not like Bron Breakker, Ilja Dragunov or the Creed Brothers were in costumes – allowed fans to compartmentalize the wacky and enjoy the overall show better.


6. Stratton Loses Her Cool

Tiffany Stratton Fallon Henley
WWE.com

Normally, baiting and switching on a match would be a big no-no, but when it makes sense in context, it can get a pass.

Tiffany Stratton was furious last week when Fallon Henley dressed up as her and did a pretty spot-on impression of the former NXT Women’s Champion. So Tuesday night, when the impersonation was brought up again, Stratton blew up and stormed off.

She stormed right down the entrance ramp and attacked Henley as she made her way to the ring, battering Fallon before putting her in a ringpost Figure Four, ala Bret “Hitman” Hart. It was later reported that Henley wasn’t cleared to compete and the match was off.

Stratton has always had to overcome the typecasting and belief that she’s not serious, despite how gifted she already is in the ring. Having her lose her composure and beat up an opponent for a perceived slight was a good way to remind fans that she has a vicious side and isn’t just pink sparkles and “toodles.”

They won’t get away with doing this a bunch, and it wasn’t some great character development, but on a packed show, this shortcut worked just as well as having a seven-minute back-and-forth match.


5. Angels And Devils

Chase U Chelsea Green
WWE.com

Poor Andre Chase wants nothing more than to be successful while doing things the right way. Unfortunately for him, those two goals do not always align.

Chase saw this firsthand at Halloween Havoc when Jacy Jayne and Thea Hail came oh-so-close to dethroning Chelsea Green and Piper Niven and taking their WWE Tag Team Championship. Chase U was rolling, with Jacy (of all people) getting the hot tag and running wild.

Still, she tried reverting to her old ways and attempted to use Andre’s tag title, only for Professor Chase to stop her. That distraction led to Green hitting Jayne with the Unpretty-Her for the win.

The entire Jacy storyline has been confusing at times, as fans are seemingly meant to take her as a heel trying to worm her way into Chase U to corrupt it – and Thea. But she’s helped boost Hail’s confidence, and Duke Hudson and Chase won the NXT Tag Team Championship last week, and Jacy and Thea came close to winning the women’s tag titles.

So how should fans receive all of this? These recent developments seem to suggest that Chase could be tempted by Jacy and unscrupulous ways… especially if they yield results, and the honorable way doesn’t work. That’s enough to merit an “up” here.


4. Lola Vice Breaks Out

Kelani Jordan Lola Vice
WWE.com

Sometimes, viewers have to remind themselves that match quality from contest to contest might vary greatly due to experience levels, especially in what technically is a developmental brand.

NXT boasts some extremely talented wrestlers who actually have a fair amount of in-ring experience, some prodigies, and then some really green superstars who are learning to ply their trade on television for the first time.

The women’s Breakout Tournament finals Tuesday featured two new but promising superstars, Kelani Jordan and Lola Vice, who executed a fast-paced, energetic match featuring some quick, powerful strikes, aerial displays and one big distraction that allowed Vice to pick up the win and earn a contract to face an NXT champion.

While the action was mostly good, it also felt like two women who had rehearsed their dance steps 100 times and went through them with precision, but without soul. They worked their way through the match with very few hitches, but it didn’t feel like a struggle between two women trying to win a tournament. It felt like two women trying to hit all their spots as cleanly as possible.

However, remembering that neither woman has more than 50 matches to their name yet, one must applaud the effort and recognize that both women could have bright futures ahead of them, and this was a positive step forward.


3. Melo, Dragunov Go To War

Carmelo Hayes Ilja Dragunov
WWE.com

Setting aside the conclusion, Carmelo Hayes and Ilja Dragunov had a bone-rattling NXT Championship match to close out Halloween Havoc, playing a game that combined Simon Says and “Can You Top This?”.

The two traded kicks and German suplexes to open the match, then pasted each other with clotheslines and counters to their signature spots. Hayes had an answer to the Constantine Special, but not the H-Bomb, which Ilja used to drive Carmelo through the announce desk. He managed hit a Codebreaker, only to eat another H-Bomb for a close two count.

Given the ad break and the finish, it never was going to equal their previous matches overall, but Hayes and Dragunov packed about as much dynamite into that match as they could, and it showed.

The ending though, with Trick Williams coming out and providing a distraction to Hayes, and then the odd staredown between Trick and Melo, was an interesting cliffhanger… which was then derailed by Baron Corbin attacking Ilja backstage. Because Corbin.


2. Von To The Rescue

Von Wagner Bron Breakker
WWE.com

The bond between Von Wagner and Mr. Stone took a long time to develop, but it’s clear that the manager and wrestler are a unit, and that relationship was on full display Tuesday night.

Stone sought to defend Von’s honor against Bron Breakker after Bron had caved in Wagner’s head with the ring steps a couple of months ago, putting him out of action. The result was never in doubt, but Stone managed to sneak in a flash pin attempt moments before Breakker cut him in half with a spear.

The aftermath might be a bit divisive though. Bron looked to repeat the punishment to Stone when Von emerged from the back with his head bandaged. He brawled with Breakker briefly and chokeslammed him on the steel steps before security separated them.

Wagner not coming out for the match and only emerging at the last minute was obviously for dramatic flair, but one could ask why he didn’t just provide the backup or even prevent the match from taking place if he cared about his friend Mr. Stone.

But that also can be overthinking things too much. Von got a great reaction and has never been in a position to be cheered like this before. There needed to a buildup for Wagner’s return, and it came at the most opportune time, leading to his challenge for next week. Cliché, yes, but that doesn’t automatically make it a negative.


1. Creeds Win Wild Plunder Brawl

Creed Brothers Angel Garza Humberto Carrillo
WWE.com

Just 24 hours removed from winning a highly technical, athletic match against Alpha Academy in their Raw debut, the Creed Brothers returned home to face Angel Garza and Humberto Carrillo in a very different kind of contest.

The brothers tangled with the cousins in a “Tables, Ladders and Scares” match that saw more than a half-dozen tables get shattered into splinters, ladders bent and chairs swung wildly. Julius Creed got slammed off the top rope onto a ladder, cutting and bruising his back, then ate a powerbomb through another ladder later. Brutus Creed was put through a table with a Gory Bomb/neckbreaker combo.

But the Creeds showed the same resilience that has put them on a fast-track to the main roster, overwhelming Garza and Carrillo before dropping Humberto with a Brutus Ball through two tables to pick up the victory.

If this was their NXT swansong, the Creeds went out in one of the wildest ways possible, earning numerous “Holy s***” chants and leaving no doubt that they are an NXT success story.


Contributor
Contributor

Scott is a former journalist and longtime wrestling fan who was smart enough to abandon WCW during the Monday Night Wars the same time as the Radicalz. He fondly remembers watching WrestleMania III, IV, V and VI and Saturday Night's Main Event, came back to wrestling during the Attitude Era, and has been a consumer of sports entertainment since then. He's written for WhatCulture since 2014, establishing the Ups and Downs articles for WWE Raw and WWE PPVs/PLEs and composing pieces on a variety of topics.