7 Ups & 4 Downs From WWE Elimination Chamber 2025
Cena. Rock. Cody. A stunning close to a solid show. Jade returns, Liv shines in women's chamber.
WOW.
It’s extremely difficult to adequately describe what happened at the conclusion of WWE Elimination Chamber on Saturday night without underselling the magnitude of the moment. Triple H and The Rock collectively promised a bold, disruptive, industry-changing event - and for once, the hype matched reality.
John Cena did the unthinkable, turning heel on Cody Rhodes and joining forces with The Rock after Cody refused to “sell his soul” and become the Final Boss’ champion. Cena, Rock, and rapper Travis Scott proceeded to obliterate Rhodes as the PLE closed out, leaving the Undisputed WWE Champion in a bloody heap and dramatically altering the landscape of the company.
Elimination Chamber itself as an event was a four-match show that unquestionably delivered with both of its signature matches and somewhat fumbled the two others. However, nothing on this show was actively bad – save for one announcer. Some of the negatives noted below are more of a feeling or personal view than something that will be universally panned. Your mileage might vary.
Saturday’s show also featured a huge return to kick off the women’s chamber match, with Jade Cargill showing up to get revenge on her attacker. And despite not emerging victorious, Liv Morgan had another really solid night in the ring, continuing her run of impressive performances.
But really, Elimination Chamber will forever be remembered for the final half-hour, and that moment will carry this show to the highest levels as time wears on.
Let’s get to it…
Downs…
4. Not The Best Vibe
Maybe this is a one-night feeling, but is anyone else less than excited for a Kevin Owens/Randy Orton blowoff match at WrestleMania 41?
Orton returned at Elimination Chamber to save Sami Zayn from any further injury after his unsanctioned match, as Owens had pulled up the mat on the floor and was threatening to deliver a package piledriver. Randy dropped Owens with an RKO and was about to put him on the IL with a punt when the officials intervened and KO scrambled out of the ring and up the aisle.
During the past few years, Orton has been extremely well-received by fans, a career resurgence that has belied nearly 15 years of malaise, a reputation for being “methodical” and extremely dry as a performer. Orton’s Legend Killer/Viper/Apex Predator persona was often bland, intense and ultimately uninteresting. His matches teetered on boring, albeit technically sound. But the last few years, he’s been nearly universally praised for his character work, becoming the most interesting and popular that he’s been in forever.
Again, it could just be a gut feeling from this one night, but a returning Orton out for revenge on Owens and looking intense and threatening to punt KO gave circa 2008-2018 vibes, and that is not meant as a compliment. If we’re getting “super serious and intense Randy,” then this could be a snoozer and a huge letdown from what fans could have had with Owens/Sami Zayn at WrestleMania.
For now, this will get a very mild “down” with the full knowledge that the view could change dramatically as the story unfolds.
3. A Janky Tag Match
Nostalgia and hometown pops will only get a match so far.
Trish Stratus embarked on her 25th-anniversary on tour Saturday night, teaming with WWE Women’s Champion Tiffany Stratton to take on Nia Jax and Candice LeRae in Trish’s hometown of Toronto. That alone kept fans invested and involved throughout much of the match, but the action itself just wasn’t that good.
Stratus looked like someone with a bit of ring rust – which is understandable – but the match just never really clicked. Stratton had a couple of nice power moves and sequences, but she certainly didn’t look like the women’s champion heading to WrestleMania to have the biggest match of her career against Charlotte Flair. Shockingly, the person who played their role the best and was most consistent? Jax.
At some point, there needs to be an evaluation and analysis of Tiffany to see if she’s actually regressing in the ring. She was long lauded (and rightly so) as a future main-eventer in the women’s division, but lately she’s felt like her relative inexperience (just over three years in the business) is catching up with her.
Maybe chalk it up to an off night and having to follow a really good women’s chamber match, but this was a bit of a letdown.
2. SHUT UP, MCAFEE!
Pat McAfee was not happy with the Canadian crowd booing the US National Anthem. #WWEChamber pic.twitter.com/pxz76iToV6
— PWUnlimited (@PWUnlimited) March 2, 2025
Much of what WWE served up on Saturday night at Elimination Chamber was a rousing success, but one thread throughout the evening that dragged the proceedings down was one-third of their announce desk.
Pat McAfee does have his moments here and there, but by and large, he’s borderline insufferable on commentary. Saturday was one of his more annoying performances. He could not get past the fact that the Canadian fans booed the American national anthem, something that wrestling fans have done forever – booing foreign anthems. Yes, there are some geopolitical factors at play these days, but McAfee came back to this point three times during the show.
He also kept running his mouth at inopportune moments, none worse than right after Cody Rhodes told The Rock what he could do with his “sell your soul” offer. McAfee started yelling about Cody’s profanity, Travis Scott lighting up a blunt, and generally just bellowing over the crowd reaction. It was obnoxious, and it wouldn’t be surprising if WWE mutes that in future reproductions of the moment.
WWE clearly loves the guy, and he’s quite obviously a fan of wrestling, but the value added is nil for many fans.
1. Where’s The Blood?
Given what happened at the close of the show, there’s a very simple, plausible answer to that question, but it still needs to be asked…
Why would you book an unsanctioned match between lifelong friends/rivals Kevin Owens and Sami Zayn and not have any blood? The announcers made a big show of talking about the referee wearing gloves from the outset because of the likelihood that one of them would get busted open. Then they broke out a barbed wire-wrapped chair, with KO driven face-first into it… and nary a drop.
One could make the argument that they booked no blood in the unsanctioned match to make Cody Rhodes bleeding later resonate more, but if that’s the case, maybe don’t book barbed wire spots into the Owens/Zayn battle. Throw in a few more car crash spots or brawling in the crowd to up the brutality without the expectation of someone being busted open.
Don’t book something with the promise that it’s going to be one of the most brutal matches ever and then just have a really good plunder match. It’s a bit of a letdown that undercut the hard work both men put in during the match.
Ups…
7. Liv Morgan: Elimination Chamber MVP
A year ago, Liv Morgan was a solid role player on the women’s roster, a “good hand” who could add depth, serve as a challenger of the month, and take a good s**t-kicking when necessary.
Fast-forward to Saturday night, and Morgan was hands-down the MVP of the women’s Elimination Chamber match. Liv did not win the match, but she stood out from the jump, cowering when she thought Jade Cargill was coming to attack her, and then gleefully gloating at Bianca Belair when Naomi became the victim. Her taunting of Belair was fantastic, especially because then she immediately had to contend with Bianca.
Throughout the bout, Morgan found herself in the middle of everything, battling Bianca and taking a whipping – literally – atop the pod. The finishing moment with Belair, Morgan, and Alexa Bliss was fantastic stuff, and Liv was integral to those sequences.
Even though she walked out of the chamber unsuccessful, give Liv her flowers, and don’t sleep on her. She’s firing on all cylinders right now.
6. Jade Wastes No Time
The big, unspoken mystery heading into the women’s Elimination Chamber match was whether Jade Cargill would loom large over everyone. The references had picked up in recent weeks, and Bianca Belair and Naomi had zeroed in on Liv Morgan and Raquel Rodriguez as the attackers.
WWE decided not to make fans wait even one minute, with Cargill’s music hitting at the bell and the former tag champ stalked to the ring while Liv whimpered. Jade faked a swing at Morgan before veering right at an unsuspecting Naomi, leveling and battering her about the chamber. Cargill brutally slammed her into the pods before slamming the chamber door on Naomi’s midsection as she tried to crawl out.
All the while, Bianca sat in her pod and sobbed, overcome with emotion at everything breaking down. She was so distraught that it took her a solid two minutes to get back into the match after her pod opened.
Fantastic angle with an immediate payoff that then allowed the women’s chamber match to carry on unabated. And there of course is still the open question about whether Naomi is indeed the sole mastermind behind Jade’s injury, or if someone else played a role.
5. Praise For Unsanctioned Match
Despite leveling criticism earlier for the unsanctioned match between Kevin Owens and Sami Zayn, it would be a huge disservice to dismiss that effort without calling attention to the positives.
Sami was absolutely fantastic at playing the wounded hero, coming into the battle at less than 100% but still giving everything he had, timing his comebacks extremely well, and measuring his fire just right. Owens exuded every sinister quality imaginable, retrieving weapons and not hesitating to use everything at his disposal to maim his former best friend.
Zayn ate a lot of crap during this battle: shoved off the top rope through a double stack of tables on the floor, a brainbuster through a chair, a fisherman’s buster through a table, and two apron powerbombs. Owens endured the aforementioned barbed wire chair, two back suplexes through tables, and a half-and-half suplex onto a chair.
The violence was measured well overall. Had this not been billed as a major blowoff match as the culmination of a 20-year friendship/feud, it would have been more highly regarded. But to be clear, this was a good match – it just wasn’t the earth-shattering, call-your-friends feud-buster that was promised.
4. Women’s Chamber Delivers
In addition to praising Liv Morgan, hats off to all seven women (including Jade Cargill) who were part of the women’s Elimination Chamber match on Saturday night.
The women’s chamber match was brilliantly constructed, with Cargill taking out Naomi as the (presumed) attacker who put her on the shelf months ago. That freed things up for the remaining five women to get down to business. Bianca Belair sold being distraught at her tag team partner being wiped out but soldiered on with a shot at WrestleMania on the line. Roxanne Perez and Bayley renewed hostilities, with Bayley being overly focused on the NXT superstar, leading to her getting pinned.
Perez looked like she fit in on the main roster right out of the gate, while Bliss also looked good here, easing back into the mix and having a good showing rather than being put in a difficult spot in her third match back.
Better yet, the match featured some really well-timed finisher counters and a tremendous combo that saw Perez evade an Oblivion, Belair shrug Roxanne off an attempted Pop Rox into a Morgan Codebreaker, which immediately was followed by a Twisted Bliss to eliminate Perez.
As with all 40-minute chamber matches, there were some down spots in the first third, but when this got going, it was crisp and fun, and all of it felt like it meant something rather than just being MOVEZ. Solid opener.
3. Men’s EC Gets Rising Drama Correct
The men’s Elimination Chamber was a great source of speculation and wish-casting heading into Saturday. Who would win and challenge Cody Rhodes for the Undisputed WWE Championship? Each possible outcome brought its own storyline and baggage (in a good way).
But some potential winners presented more interesting matchups with the American Nightmare. For example, a Damian Priest/Rhodes match wasn’t going to set the world on fire. And Logan Paul would not be someone that could close out a night of WrestleMania.
That’s why seeing the final three of John Cena, CM Punk, and Seth Rollins was so heartening. Each of them had a strong case to make for challenging Cody at 'Mania, and each of them would bring an interesting story to the table. Punk and Cena’s rich history also made for compelling action, a mini-match to remind longtime fans of what they hopefully will get to see in extended format at some point this year.
Action-wise, the match was solid through and through. Cena was the biggest question mark, and his involvement was measured perfectly, being present for big moments and showing flashes of his old self without having to carry the match. Rollins, McIntyre, and Punk really did a great job threading the entire match and keeping things moving. There weren’t any dead spots, and it all gelled nicely.
The finish served as a nice bit of foreshadowing for what came afterward, which works even better on a rewatch, but still functioned well in the moment.
2. Cody’s Soul Is Not For Sale
?????????#WWEChamber pic.twitter.com/uurvIFN5AQ
— WWE (@WWE) March 2, 2025
Lost in the shuffle of the main event segment and John Cena’s shocking heel turn was the solidification of Cody Rhodes as the ultimate babyface, the Cena of our time.
In the lead-up to Elimination Chamber, the focus was entirely on whether Rhodes would give in to The Rock’s demand to sell his soul to the Final Boss and become his champion. The offer came with all the trappings of fame and fortune, as an incredible video package earlier in the night laid out Rock’s power and influence.
But in the span of about a minute, Cody shot all of that down, telling Rock that he gave his soul to wrestling and the fans a long time ago, and the Great One could “go f**k yourself”.
Just like that, Rhodes stood up to the ultimate power broker in WWE and the entertainment world at large and resisted temptation, and did so in a strong, defiant manner. The pop from the fans for that rejection was only exceeded by what came next with Cena.
What this means is that Cody will be the virtuous hero who stands up to the corrupt authority figure and jaded former hero, ending all speculation and clearly charting his path. If he goes out on his shield, so be it, but it was great to see that even cynical wrestling fans will still side with a force of good.
1. The Heel Turn Heard ‘Round The World
Fans have longed for John Cena to turn heel for nearly 20 years. They finally got their wish Saturday night in the midst of a farewell tour where most fans have accepted Cena as a perennial babyface.
In a moment that will long be regarded as a generational “where were you when…” moment, Cena turned heel when he picked up The Rock’s throat slash cue and kicked Cody Rhodes low, then proceeded to pummel him into a bloody mess. Rock whipped Rhodes with the custom weight belt reading “Cody’s Soul” and the date that Dusty Rhodes passed away, all as payback for Cody saying he wouldn’t sell his soul to the Final Boss.
But it’s Cena’s turn to the Dark Side that will have the entire wrestling world talking for weeks to come. Why did he do it? What did The Rock offer him? How far will Cena go as a villain?
The moment itself was a tremendous piece of business. Cena won the men’s Elimination Chamber by submitting CM Punk immediately after Seth Rollins interfered and stomped Punk on the chamber floor, essentially capitalizing on someone cheating. That set off some small alarm bells right there, painting Cena as desperate to win (Michael Cole even used that word to describe John) and go on to WrestleMania.
Then, after embracing Cody and acknowledging that they would face each other for the title at 'Mania, Cena would take his cues from The Rock, who made the offer one last time to make Rhodes’ dreams come true.
Without a doubt, one of the biggest moments in wrestling history, a proverbial ace up WWE’s sleeve that you never thought they’d ever play.