7 Ups & 5 Downs From IMPACT Slammiversary 2023 (Review)

Three surprise returns and the ascendancy of Trinity highlight a mixed bag for IMPACT Wrestling.

Josh Alexander Alex Shelley
IMPACT Wrestling

Slammiversary 2023 was an unmitigated success story that will receive little-to-no major social media discussion because of the event's prefix: IMPACT Wrestling presents.

The brand, though having been revived and rebirthed by Scott D'Amore, is not without its haters and trolls, just like WWE is, just like AEW is, just like your favourite wrestling promotion is. It's a global issue, but one that particularly affects the success rate of IMPACT's content output.

Slammiversary, though, has had its identity restored across the six events put together by D'Amore. 2018 and 2019 were his first offerings, boasting immense cards with genuine must-see matches across both; Sami Callihan and Pentagon Jr's Hair vs. Mask match from the former being the most must-see. 2020 and 2021, meanwhile, relied heavily on the element of surprise amidst swathes of WWE releases. In 2022, IMPACT celebrated its 20th birthday, bringing back a horde of relics from the past, sans the RelliK.

As for 2023? There was a good-to-great championship match for each of IMPACT's six championships, the conclusion to a never-ending saga that, although mundane, brought with it a hero's welcome, a bitter feud between two pillars of IMPACT's past and present, a maniacal Ultimate X match, and the comeback of IMPACT's Ace.

Was it any good?

Let's find out...


Downs…

5. Production Problems, Obviously

Gia Miller Kenny King Sheldon Jean
IMPACT Wrestling

A minor Down, but a Down nonetheless, seeing as it's a recurring issue.

Despite being a promotion celebrating its 21st birthday, IMPACT pay-per-views are renowned for their minor production issues. On this occasion, it was a sound problem during Gia Miller's first backstage interview of the evening, as during her chat with new Digital Media Champion Kenny King, the sound of the microphone was booming through the audio bed, instantly deafening headphone users.

The live feed also missed several marquee moments during matches, most notably during the Ultimate X and four-team matches. Though given the frantic nature of such clashes, this can be easily forgiven.

Both details are far from a big deal, but as production is an aspect that IMPACT struggles to achieve flawlessly during live broadcasts, they're a must-mention.


4. A TV Match On A Pay-Per-View

Gisele Shaw Courtney Rush
IMPACT Wrestling

Gisele Shaw works a great character. As 'The Quintessential Diva', she possesses the traits necessary for a successful modernistic take on an archaic character. She's a good worker, too, and Savannah Evans and Jai Vidal accentuate Shaw's positive traits perfectly; she's a finished project you could say.

But the character doesn't work on a pay-per-view product.

Wrestling Jody Threat, Courtney Rush, and Jessicka on the Countdown to Slammiversary pre-show, the match was one you'd expect to find on a weekly IMPACT broadcast, Before The IMPACT even, but not a prototypical opener playing out in front of a 1,000+ audience. There was little meaning or impact behind certain spots of the match that didn't flow well at all. The Shaw-led group dominated large chunks of the contest before Threat and The Death Dollz suddenly triggered the hit-all-our-finishers skill in what is unfortunately an atypical trait of such matches. It was trivial and disappointing.


3. Too Long With Nothing To Show

Frankie Kazarian Eddie Edwards
IMPACT Wrestling

Eddie Edwards vs. Frankie Kazarian was fundamentally a solid pro wrestling match. The strikes were heavy, the slams were stiff, and the dives were potent, but clocking in just shy of 18 minutes, it was difficult to remain invested for the entire match.

It dragged on.

And on.

And on.

Outside of a fiery Eddie Edwards suicide dive, there was little in the way of excitement, as the match relied heavily on rest holds, walking-and-brawling, and ringside shouting matches involving their wives - Alisha Edwards and Traci Brooks, respectively - who added nothing of note to the bout, outside of an ineffective referee bump that saw Traci seemingly twist her arm while Spearing Alisha.

Eddie cracked Kazarian with a kendo stick into a Boston Knee Party for the win, but this finish wasn't the expected one, nor the justifiable one, for a bout billed as the rubber match. There'll be low interest in seeing a fourth match between the two if this is the quality of their pay-per-view work. It's fine for heels to cheat, but in this situation, it shouldn't have been the finish.


2. The '90s Called...

Joe Hendry Kenny King
IMPACT Wrestling

Joe Hendry has been genuinely incredible as IMPACT's Digital Media Champion. He took an inconsequential belt that had endured a lifespan of negligence and inferiority, and turned it into a worthwhile title that has since produced a glut of good-to-great defences. So, why did he drop it on a pay-per-view pre-show in a storyline that's focus has been Hendry mocking his opponent, Kenny King, by deeming him a stripper?

Again, like the knockouts trios match, it wasn't a terrible bout. Hendry did some great beefer work and King played the cowardly heel role well, benefitting from Sheldon Jean running amok. The finer details are what stopped this from being an Up, though, as Kenny dressed Joe in a Chippendales bowtie, which Joe was fine with.

So why did he begin the mocking in the first place if there's nothing wrong with it?!

It was stupid. Plain stupid. Not fun stupid; Vince McMahon growing out a moustache stupid. So, naturally Kenny King won the match and the title - ending Hendry's stance as the current longest-reigning champion in IMPACT - with his feet on the ropes.

Joe's face told the entire story. It was a senseless piece of booking that did nobody any favours.


1. Oh, Canada

Eric Young Deaner Scott D'Amore
IMPACT Wrestling

Everything was working against the originally-planned Bully Ray and Maclin vs. Scott D'Amore and PCO match - and then the match itself sucked.

Turned into Ray and Deaner vs. D'Amore and Eric Young, the match was slow and plodding, stodgy almost, with the Ray and D'Amore interactions between sterile and lacking the fire expected of such an apparently heated feud. As for Deaner - a strange replacement who tried his best to make it make sense - he added nothing to the match. Eric Young was the bout's only redeeming asset.

Special guest enforcer Darren McCarty - again, strange - got involved, too, aiding Scott in driving Bully Ray through a table, because of course he did, but this only came after the assigned referee walked out mid-match(!).

That wasn't the worst part of it, though; that, instead, would be when Eric Young pinned Deaner for the win, in spite of neither man being a part of this eternal saga until the week of the feud-ender.

Scott D'Amore is a prodigious promoter and booker. He's rebuilt IMPACT Wrestling back from the ground up, reaffirming it as a real alternative to wrestling fans disinterested in WWE and AEW in the same vein as ECW did in the '90s while the WWF and WCW were waging war. A prodigious pro wrestler, he is not. Let's hope this is the last we see of him in that God-awful lycra.


Ups…

7. EastEnders Who?

Eric Young Scott D'Amore
IMPACT Wrestling

Eric Young returning 'from the dead' as Scott D'Amore's surprise partner was a great, great piece of bullsh*ttery.

It was ludicrous and further exemplified professional wrestling being a better soap opera than all this EastEnders malarkey.


6. FINALLY

Masha Slamovich Killer Kelly MK Ultra
IMPACT Wrestling

The Knockouts World Tag Team Championships were reintroduced at Bound For Glory 2020, but only now do the belts mean something - and it's down to The Coven and MK Ultra.

The quartet worked a lively match, the division's first since the belt's 2020 rebirth (or ever, if you weren't keen on the Sarita and Taylor Wilde unit in 2009), that focused heavily on re-establishing the division as one worth investing in. Wilde and KiLynn King were great at cutting the ring off, while Masha Slamovich and Killer Kelly gelled together throughout the match. When they ultimately toppled The Coven, it was evidently the right choice; the Windsor audience lapped it up.

Putting a weighted significance behind the Knockouts World Tag Team Championships has been overdue on IMPACT's list of priorities. The titles were brought back when the division was booming, but it quickly turned into a sour state of disarray with mish-mash teams battling it out in uninspired and lazily worked matches and angles. Here's hoping the style of The Coven vs. MK Ultra continues, at least through 21 October's Bound For Glory.


5. Ultimate X Thrives - Just

Jake Something Kevin Knight
IMPACT Wrestling

This wasn't the best Ultimate X match ever. Clunky, it was not, but it wasn't 100% clean. The X itself was dangling within minutes of the bout beginning, owing to the high-speed nature of the match, and one or two spots weren't executed without a blunder.

But, it was fun. Slick, delectable fun.

Straying from the layout of the previous two Slammiversarys' Ultimate X matches by switching high spots for constant cable-climbing, the match was bolstered, too, by a last-minute Jake Something addition. Jake allowed the match to flow differently from a traditional X Division match, Powerbombing fools over the ropes and using his large frame to swipe them down. This was obvious from the bell ringing; his Powerbombing of Kevin Knight onto the other entrants was the first big spot of the match.

KUSHIDA winning also went unexpected. His status in IMPACT has been on-and-off since he debuted in 2022, and even then, he's never been pushed as a legitimate championship contender. He'll be included in the contendership matches as a highlight reel of charisma and armbars, but rarely as a potential victor. That he now stands with a future X Division Championship match is proof of IMPACT's tendency to give everyone a bash. It's consistently worked and it'll continue to do so with a potential KUSHIDA vs. Lio Rush match in the future.


4. Proving Ground

Nick Aldis Alex Shelley
IMPACT Wrestling

Alex Shelley needed the Nick Aldis match. Hastily crowned World Champion at Against All Odds after only two months of Steve Maclin having served as the kingpin of IMPACT, Shelley faced doubts, being branded a transitional champion from the moment his fingers touched the belt.

Those claims are false.

The Detroiter took Aldis to the limit in a well-paced main event. From the off, Alex Shelley was established as the babyface-in-peril, being easily manhandled by a Nick Aldis driven by determination. Aldis was the perfect heel challenger for Shelley to establish him as a credible champion, drawing incredible heat for his desperation and will to wear Shelley down, who answered by honing on a weakness, targeting Aldis' leg.

This didn't play into the finish at all, which is what pushes it lower down on the Ups ranking, but the finish was sweet nonetheless. Aldis' foolhardy desire to win overcame him as his plan to use the World Championship belt backfired before he walked into a match-winning Shellshock, cementing Alex Shelley not as a transitional champion, but as the champion of IMPACT.

Both Shelley and Aldis came off great in victory and loss, respectively, with the former now having Josh Alexander to look ahead to in what will be a true test of Alex Shelley's capabilities as IMPACT World Champion. Win, lose, or draw, the legitimacy of his reign depends on it.


3. Work Or Shoot, Rush Rules

Lio Rush
IMPACT Wrestling

The health status of Chris Sabin remains uncertain, but his 80-second scrap with Lio Rush over Sabin's X Division Championship did its job regardless.

Hammering Sabin's head with a kick mid-entrance and javelling himself at the defending champion with a brute of a suicide dive led to the intervention of medical staff, who refused to let Sabin wrestle. This, naturally, raised concerns of a legitimate injury until Chris Sabin got into the ring. It was here that Rush was established as the X Division's foremost threatening practitioner, again caving in Sabin's head with a kick before flattening him with two Frog Splashes. Rush's Frog Splash is a beast to take, too, as he puts all his weight across his stomach as he descends upon the victim.

Lio Rush now stands as a menace in a division that has been craving one since Josh Alexander - playing the same role as a babyface - ascended to the World Championship picture in 2021. Rush has this uniqueness to him that is often lost in modern wrestlers, in that everything he does is done to make you cheer for him or boo him. He doesn't do the anti-hero babyface or cool heel schtick; he's either the loveliest chap you know or the most despicable d*ck.

Again, the legitimate health status of Chris Sabin remains unknown, but work or shoot, this positioned Lio Rush perfectly as a potential X Division Ace.


2. Subculture Are Stars

Mark Andrews Brian Myers
IMPACT Wrestling

Or at least they will be.

Strapping up Mark Andrews and Flash Morgan Webster was the right decision. The pair are simply fun to watch, carry themselves like superstars, and have oodles of potential and chemistry together. Passing on the chance to sign them and have them head up a division that IMPACT has excelled in crafting, would be foolish.

They toppled Ace Austin and Chris Bey in a berserk four-way that fluctuated in pacing throughout - and not in a bad way. Matching two gifted acrobatic pairings with the throwback hoss style of Moose and Brian Myers, and whatever the hell you'd call the style of Rich Swann and Sami Callihan, allowed for a diverse match as for every Mark Andrews somersault dive, Moose and Myers had a pair of Powerbombs to keep you off your feet.

The closing sequence, in which The Rascalz cost The ABC the titles, was great, too, as it gets the belts off Austin and Bey without a loss of direction for them. The feud doesn't need the titles. Although The Rascalz and The ABC would complement the titles, and vice versa, the wrestling itself will be enough. Placing the belts instead on Subculture, an act clearly destined for greatness in the right place, was the right move and IMPACT's doubles division now resembles its mid-noughties peak.


1. The Definition Of A Division

Deonna Purrazzo Trinity
IMPACT Wrestling

Trinity was always an underrated gem in WWE. Athletic, charismatic, and bodacious, her work was exciting on the down-low as she was in a division with a horde of similar talent who WWE perceived as being better investments.

In IMPACT Wrestling, Trinity is the investment.

Vs. Deonna Purrazzo, her world-class attributes were underlined. Purrazzo was the killer and Trinity was her prey. The essence in which Deonna wrestled was akin to the way she fought opponents when she first came into IMPACT, wearing them down before going for her big hitters so that when she hit them and/or applied a submission, the match was done.

But Trinity evaded a Fujiwara armbar and kicked out of a ring apron Queen's Gambit. It illustrated Deonna's vehement intention to retain the title wondrously. So much so, that when she submitted, there was a legitimate gasp.

Trinity's ascendancy to win the Knockouts World Championship was the expected result from the moment the match graphic did the rounds on social media. The expected result can often be the best result in pro wrestling, and this proves it. Trinity is a generational star in IMPACT. Never before has a talent of her star power and magnitude left their previous employer in the way that she did and come into the Anthem-helmed group as a bigger star.

How apropos, too, that her last singles championship challenge came against Charlotte Flair, as Trinity is now the Queen of the knockouts division.


Contributor
Contributor

Can be found raving about the latest IMPACT Wrestling signing, the Saints Row franchise, and King Shark in The Suicide Squad.