7 Ups & 5 Downs From NJPW Wrestle Kingdom 17 (Review)

Kenny Omega & Will Ospreay steal the show, TAFKA Sasha Banks makes a bold new statement...sort of.

Mercedes Mone
NJPW

It is pointless and insincere to suggest that New Japan Pro Wrestling is just as hot across the wrestling world going into Wrestle Kingdom 17 as it was for Wrestle Kingdom 11, 12, 13, 14 or really any January 4th card that came before an ongoing global pandemic that's not yet over and remains acknowledged as such by the company itself.

But those ones between 2017-2019 specifically are notable for a reason - those were the editions headlined or co-headlined by Kenny Omega.

Breaking through as the company's joint top star following a legendary and plate-shifting headliner against Kazuchika Okada in 2017, Omega and Chris Jericho "changed the world" a year later, before 'The Best Bout Machine' bowed out of NJPW by looking at The Dome lights for Hiroshi Tanahashi in 2019 before the formation of All Elite Wrestling. Will Ospreay dutifully stepped in his place almost immediately, but the landscape was changing beyond The Elite giving their notices at the same time.

January 4th 2020's event was the last major stadium wrestling show before before the pandemic closed everything down, and up until January 4th 2023, fans were - at best - only to allowed to clap in support of the action in order to express their emotions.

The buzz on both sides of the Pacific was palpable - fans in Japan were finally going to be able to cheer again, on a card that theoretically gave them multiple opportunities to do so. Meanwhile, western fans were keen on the Omega/Ospreay generational bout, Kenny's return to NJPW in general, and something resembling the audio/visual experience that has been gone from New Japan for far, far too long.

Could the card - headlined not by Ospreay and Omega but the prestigious IWGP Championship bout between Jay White and Kazuchika Okada - meet or exceed these lofty expectations?


Downs...

5. The KOPW 2023 New Japan Ranbo

Great O-Khan
NJPW

A near-30 minute cluster was best summed up by El Phantasmo during Shingo Takagi’s entrance into the match late on.

As listless wars were waged on the outside, ELP briefly checked in with the English commentary team to joke about how nobody knew what was going on and how great it all was.

Neither statement was incorrect or entirely untrue, even if most of the match was mostly trash. The Ranbo was as big a load of b*llocks as usual, at times impossible to keep on top of and almost never coming close to feeling like something that actually mattered to the competitors. It was rubbish, and just occasionally charmingly so.

Toru Yano and The Great O-Khan made the final four by actively avoiding action, Sho did too and Takagi’s place was assured pretty much the second he arrived as the contest’s biggest star by orders of magnitude.

Those four will compete for the Provisional 2023 KOPW Championship at New Year Dash, though the typically knockabout booking didn’t exactly encourage anybody to follow them.


4. FTR (c) vs. Bishamon (Hirooki Goto & Yoshi-Hashi)

FTR Bishamon
NJPW

There had been a not-inconsiderable amount of buzz about this tag match some days before it was actually booked - when Aussie Open could possibly seal victory in the World Tag League, the possibility and promise of a rematch between the Royal Quest II main eventers seemed high.

It wasn’t to be, and further circumstances beyond this match’s control might have had something to do with its overall clunkiness.

Cash Wheeler had apparently endured multiple travel delays just to get to Tokyo, to such an extent that he was allegedly arriving as the show was about to go live. Less-than-ideal is an understatement then, but also the kindest description of this flawed final defence for the champions.

It was most succinctly defined by a Big Rig pinfall break-up by the challengers that didn’t register correctly or with the slick timing of a typical FTR offering. The match hobbled to its predictable outcome from there - Dax and Cash had to lose to complete the surrendering of all their gold and continue a losing streak - but the result subsequently felt much more of an obligation than a spirited sporting outcome.


3. Kairi (c) Vs Tam Nakano

Kairi Tam Nakano
NJPW

The first defence of the IWGP Women’s Championship was Wrestle Kingdom history before the bell even rang, and the prospective appearance of somebody else later on added drama in the slick, technical and tense early stages.

The two could only concentrate on each other for a scant few minutes after the feeling out process. A blade-sharp spear from Kairi cut through any kindness, and a Steiner Screwdriver around the five minute mark awakened a violence within the Champion that resulted in a stirring strike fight and InSane Elbow for the quick win.

Way, way shorter than it needed to be (and should have been), this promising outing seemingly only existed for another purpose, and that was fulfilled seconds after a frustratingly premature bell.


2. Mercedes Moné Arrives

Mercedes Mone
NJPW

Mercedes Moné’s debut was unfortunately mostly terrible.

A star on her level on a stage that big after a wait so long shouldn’t have coalesced to cultivate a moment that felt so awkward and small-time, but that was the case in what ended up being a difficult marriage of different presentation styles.

A botched new finisher on Kairi after a handshake didn’t help, nor did an uncharacteristic but understandably nervy promo from the former ‘Boss’. But these are growing pains at worst, first night jitters at best, and everything in wrestling is recoverable.

Her new look was typically dynamic, the gimmick is fully-drawn and the eventual title fight with Kairi that this arrival served to promote will be a killer, but it was hard to shake the feeling that the whole thing was 2023’s first abject disappointment.


1. Karl Anderson (c) vs. Tama Tonga

Tama Tonga
NJPW

This was way, way better than it had any real right to be, but such low standards were set by Karl Anderson wilfully taking the p*ss out of the art of wrestling itself in knowingly bad matches.

Tonga was in fantastic condition, Anderson wasn't far behind, the the two worked a competent but completely unremarkable match (save for an unfortunately botched finish) that wouldn't have looked out of place on Raw if it had gone five minutes longer than the nine it was allotted.

But there was a feeling of celebration in the air in Tokyo - the idea that normalcy was around the corner and Wrestle Kingdom was a monument to that. For such bland flavourless action to command a spot felt as much about Anderson's unique status between WWE and NJPW as it was the epic conclusion to a storied tale.


Ups...

7. Yuji Nagata, Satoshi Kojima & Togi Makabe vs. Tatsumi Fujinami, Minoru Suzuki & Tiger Mask

Tatsumi Fujinami
NJPW

More than just a murderer’s row of past, present and future Jon Moxley opponents, the New Japan Da six-man headlining their Wrestle Kingdom pre-show was designed as one of several tributes to the legendary Antonio Inoki.

By the end, it had served its purpose in a way almost impossible not to love.

The NJPW founder was honoured in a hard-hitting brawl that suited the six just fine. Togi Makabe was in rare form ahead of him picking up a jarring and surprising win for his team, while Minoru Suzuki’s babyface energy was a joy following the heart-warming Suzuki-Gun split and his impending exit for some All Japan dates later this year.

Regardless of how the bell-to-bell was supposed to end, Suzuki, Tatsumi Fujinami and Tiger Mask got the last word anyway - they led the crowd for a rousing rendition of Inoki’s theme. Though tinged with sadness, there was something moving about the live audience finally getting to engage with the passing of the industry icon.


6. Catch 2/2 (TJP and Francesco Akira) (c) vs. LiYoh (Lio Rush & Yoh)

Catch 2/2
NJPW

Super Junior Tag League winners Lio Rush and Yoh only met each other in October and were rank outsiders to win the tournament itself late last year, but getting the privilege of opening Wrestle Kingdom proper against IWGP Junior Tag Team Champions TJP and Francesco Akira made their short union feel like an epic heroes journey.

Rush being violently bludgeoned on the ramp in the first seconds of the contest continued this story magnificently. It was a thriller from there, with the former WWE Cruiserweight Champion gutting his way back into a quality spotfest that twisted and turned with the flexibilities of its competitors before Rush’s sustained damage ultimately cost the underdogs.

TJP getting the win with an inside cradle, parked LiYoh’s Championship aspirations for now, but the commentators were at pains to say that their run may not be over, even if this first shot was.


5. Zack Sabre Jr. vs. Ren Narita

TMDK ZSJ
NJPW

New Japan Pro Wrestling didn’t really need another Championship in 2023, nor particularly one that bent or tweaked the rules of a traditional singles match. But if such a thing was deemed necessary, there were worse ways to launch it than with this minor classic between Wrestle Kingdom veteran Zack Sabre Jr and exhilarating future prospect Ren Narita.

And the shock of ZSJ’s new luminous blonde hairdo couldn’t compete with the shock to the system of the kicks and punches that followed the pair’s early grappling exchanges. Though not exactly fought with respect, there was a certain cohesion that eventually made way for a competitive cruelty that brought the match - and The Tokyo Dome - to life.

Tiring of the Brit’s arrogance, Narita burst fourth with soul-sapping kicks a watching Ketsoyouri Shibata would be proud of, before punching and chopping Zack to the ground to jumpstart a run of breathless submission and pinfall attempts.

After clambering out of the trap, Narita fell back into one. This was deep water, and he drowned, abruptly. In celebrating becoming the inaugural titleholder, ZSJ joined forces with Shane Haste and Mikey Nicholls to form a new version of TMDK in the post-match.


4. Keiji Muto, Hiroshi Tanahashi & Shota Umino vs. Los Ingobernables de Japon (Tetsuya Naito, Sanada & Bushi)

Shota Umino Keji Muto Hiroshi Tanahashi
NJPW

More fun than good, it was hard not to raise a smile when Keiji Muto insisted on starting the match instead of one of his younger partners, especially when one of those was the 46-year-old Hiroshi Tanahashi.

Such was the magic of the babyface trio cast against Los Ingobernables de Japon for the latest stop on Muto's farewell tour.

The three brushed aside Tetsuya Naito, Sanada and Bushi in something that would have scanned as a bit of a demotion for Naito and Tanahashi had the whole thing not gone down in the intended nostalgic spirit - Muto had the energy of the "I'll f*ckin do it again" Goofy meme as 'The Ace' blocked his attempt to do a psychotic moonsault one last time, but Bushi was eventually fed to the faces to give Shota Umino a big Wrestle Kingdom win.


3. Taiji Ishimori (c) vs. El Desperado vs. Hiromu Takahashi vs. Master Wato

Hirmou Takahashi
NJPW

A glorious closing run of nearly-but-not-quite deathblows summed up the success of this four-way's tremendous structure.

Master Wato was the unfancied underdog here, but the layout put him over as somebody that may one day be a contender amongst his more experienced peers, even in heartbreaking defeat.

There was an unusually disciplined feel to proceedings for much of the early stages, but when Desperado, Takahashi and Ishimori fell like dominoes to a Wato dropkick on the ramp, everything gradually became a little more unhinged.

From there, the title could have gone anywhere but fans wanted it for Wato, and that was the point. Takahashi's latest stint with the belt should be his last - he's been in the Junior Heavyweight division for far too long - but this was extremely effective in


2. Will Ospreay (c) vs. Kenny Omega (with Don Callis)

Kenny Omega
NJPW

Every bit the epic it promised and then some, the Wrestle Kingdom semi-main made it incredibly difficult for actual headliners Jay White and Kazuchika Okada to follow 2023's first bona fide classic.

Will Ospreay and once-again IWGP United States Champion Kenny Omega had their own names and reputations to live up to, but did so in grandiose and bloody fashion across 35 absorbing minutes that simultaneously left everything in the ring and left plenty more for a potential sequel.

Omega used the build to attack the mental strength of Ospreay, and used the match itself to literally go for his head. First clattering him through a table - or more specifically clattering the table through him - Omega took the worst of what Ospreay had to offer before unlocking an evil, neck-dropping, V-Trigger-spamming God Mode barely visible since he last graced the Dome in 2019.

Ospreay's final fight back was game, but simply not enough - with sickening science, Omega had simply extracted too much from his younger rival. Snap dragons, turnbuckle DDTs et al generated instinct kickouts but spitting in Kenny's face earned a One Winged Angel and a painful loss.


1. Jay White (c) vs. Kazuchika Okada

Kazuchika Okada
NJPW

It just about got there.

That'd be the best way to praise a match that wasn't always great, without criticising one that really, genuinely had gripping moments.

Were these moments thanks to Kazuchika Okada's typical wizardry? Perhaps. Jay White played his crucial part too - 'Switchblade' remains as divisive as ever, but Okada is still a magician in this context and the fans inside the Tokyo Dome came unglued every time he dropped into the Rainmaker/Switchblade reversal sequence now synonymous with the pair.

Maybe that's the problem - the two have wrestled a lot over the years and plenty of times in a similar context, and the specialness that once defined their rivalry has long gone. The result was part of a final touching tribute to Antonio Inoki, and had to be, but at seven reigns and no obvious gripping next chapter, could the peak of 'The Rainmaker' feel too more a part of NJPW's rich past than its bright future?


 
Posted On: 
Contributor
Contributor

Michael is a writer, editor, podcaster and presenter for WhatCulture Wrestling, and has been with the organisation for 10 years. Alongside the production of daily written, audio and video content covering WWE and AEW, he also provides knowledge and insights on all aspects of the wrestling industry thanks to a passion for it dating back over 35 years. As one third of "The Dadley Boyz" Michael has contributed to the huge rise in popularity of the WhatCulture Wrestling Podcast and its accompanying YouTube channel, earning it top spot on the UK's wrestling podcast charts with over 10,000 episodes and 70,000,000 total downloads. He also co-hosts Benno & Hamflett, In Your House!, Podcast Horseman: The BoJack Horseman Podcast, and has guested on long-running Sunderland AFC podcast Wise Men Say. With WhatCulture, he has provided in-person coverage of some of the biggest pay-per-views and Premium Live Events in wrestling history, including WrestleMania, Survivor Series, All In & Double Or Nothing in destinations such as New York, New Jersey, Chicago, Dallas, Las Vegas, Philadelphia, London and Cardiff. He has also been featured as a wrestling analyst for the Tampa Bay Times, Fightful, POST Wrestling, GRAPPL, GCP, Poisonrana, 411Mania and Sports Guys Talking Wrestling. Michael's background in media stretches beyond wrestling coverage, with a degree in Journalism from the University Of Sunderland (2:1) and a series of published articles in music and culture magazines The Crack, Pilot as well as Sunderland AFC's premiere fanzine A Love Supreme. When not offering his voice up for daily wrestling podcasts, he can be found losing it every other Saturday at the Stadium Of Light, and at Cribs gigs nationwide.