7 Ups & 6 Downs From Impact Wrestling Hard To Kill 2020

A history-making night as 'The Draw' meets his match.

Tessa Blanchard Impact Champion
Impact Wrestling

2019 saw four outstanding pay-per-views held by Impact Wrestling. They all came jam-packed with some amazing wrestling matches. However, none of them (maybe with the exception of Slammiversary) were quite as historic as their first of 2020, Hard To Kill. The name choice was certainly appropriate.

The 12 January event in Dallas, Texas marked the first time in history that a woman would main event the pay-per-view of a major wrestling promotion by challenging for the main championship of the company. Not only was it historic, but the story coming into the Sami Callihan vs. Tessa Blanchard showdown has had everyone watching fully invested from start to finish. Their match was just the icing on the cake.

That wasn't the only reason why it was such a successful pay-per-view, however. Michael Elgin and Eddie Edwards had a fantastic rematch of their encounter from this past Tuesday's episode of Impact, Taya Valkyrie continued on her staggering reign as the Knockouts Champion after a thrilling match with Jordynne Grace and ODB, and Willie Mack went into the World Tag Team Championships match alone, taking The North to the limit in the process.

If the company is looking to have an even better year in 2020, then they're certainly coming out all guns blazing. The landscape of Impact has been flipped on its head with the history-making title change. Let's get to it...


Downs...

6. Doctor's Orders

Full disclosure: this will be the most nitpicky Down to ever exist. But the ankle injury to Rich Swann that ruled him out of the World Tag Team Championships match needs to be discussed.

These Impact Plus/Twitch specials that Impact put on are usually decent events. However, it's perhaps a better idea to not have two of them a few days before a big pay-per-view because situations such as this can easily occur. Obviously no-one can foresee injuries happening, but it's surely something to be thinking about for the future.

'Chocolate Thunder' instead went into the match on his own, and as we'll discuss later on, the match quality didn't suffer in any way whatsoever.


5. Le Sigh...

Katie Forbes is entirely unbearable when she's onscreen. There's no denying it. Just look at the embedded GIF.

Every time she makes any sort of appearance, whether it's backstage or in front of the live audience, it feels as if she's just taking away from the wrestling itself. There's nothing wrong with characters - it's one of the things that makes professional wrestling as great as it is. However, whatever her persona is meant to be has got to be one of the worst things in Impact right now. Her whole 'can't keep her hands off Rob Van Dam' thing is excruciating to watch.

Even when she gets involved in RVD's matches, it's the exact same. It's a common sight for 'The Whole F'N Show' to go outside the ring during his matches just to get his hands on Forbes. Surprisingly, it hasn't actually cost him any matches thus far, but that doesn't make it any better. It's a complete nuisance having her around.


4. Stepping Up

Seeing as Brian Cage wasn't able to take part in his match with Rob Van Dam, Daga instead stepped up to the challenge of the former Impact World Champion. It had all the potential in the land to be a great match, had it gone on for longer than five minutes.

The match was nothing special in any way. A few kicks and dives, before the extreme icon connected with his corkscrew leg drop and a Five Star Frog Splash for an easy victory. It's like Daga didn't even bother putting in any effort - although, to be fair, he didn't know he'd be having the match. Still, it could've been wonderful, had it gone on for even a few additional minutes.

If we get a rematch between these two, then that will no doubt be an extraordinary encounter. As for now, their match gets a Down, sadly through no proper fault of their own. Just too short to get anything else.


3. Establishing The Wrong Stars

Coming into Hard To Kill, there were three matches on the card that featured names who fans could watch in the '90s - Rob Van Dam, who was booked to face Brian Cage, Ken Shamrock, who battled Madman Fulton, and Rhino, with 'The War Machine' going one on one with Moose. Unfortunately, two of those veterans were victorious in their matches, which isn't the route we should be going down.

While you could argue that RVD was the rightful winner in his match, well, matches (more on that later), there was absolutely no need for 'The World's Most Dangerous Man' to defeat Fulton. The former SAnitY member is still waiting for that big breakout moment in Impact, and this very much could've been that moment. Instead, he tapped out to Shamrock, although it was quite a nasty-looking submission in fairness to him. Thankfully, Moose defeated Rhino in their No Disqualifications Match so it wasn't all bad news.

Impact don't usually have this much of a problem when it comes to building up their younger stars. It's just a shame they also don't have an issue in putting over the already established faces. Maybe mix it up every now and then.


2. Farewell To The Machine

If the reports are to be believed, then former World Champion Brian Cage is heading for All Elite Wrestling. Assuming that is indeed the case, then Hard To Kill vs. Rob Van Dam may have been the final Impact Wrestling 'match' for 'The Machine'. Match is in inverted commas because, well, it just wasn't a match.

As Cage was making his entrance for the hotly-anticipated first time ever clash, he was grabbed from the crowd by RVD's other girlfriend, with Van Dam then unleashing an assault aided by both Katie Forbes and a steel chair. Cage appeared to suffer a busted mouth upon being struck with the steel, with a Van Terminator seemingly knocking him clean out. He was taken to the back, and that was that. No announcement made or anything.

When you consider the way Ortiz and Santana left the company with a hero's farewell, it's a massive shame that Brian Cage didn't receive the same sort of goodbye. It makes Rob Van Dam look strong in the meantime, but he's Rob Van Dam for crying out loud - he doesn't need anything to help get him over. Cage did some amazing things during his time in Impact, so it would've made sense for him to get a grander final moment.

Keep in mind, this may not actually be his final appearance for the company, but with the way things went down here and the rumours that are swirling around, it's a fair judgement to be making.


1. Stodgy Opener

Ken Shamrock vs. Madman Fulton wasn't the worst match of all time, but it's not the sort of bout you'd expect to open an Impact pay-per-view. Typically, the first match of these shows is a more fast-paced bout, such as the Ultimate X Match from Homecoming or the multi-man X division matches from Rebellion and Slammiversary.

Instead, we were treated to roughly ten minutes of what was essentially an MMA fight with a few wrestling moves interspersed throughout. Shamrock used such an abundance of mixed martial arts manoeuvres that Fulton seemingly forgot who he was, as he started going for takedowns and such. Eventually, he did find himself, chokeslamming Shamrock into the mat, but he would also soon find himself trapped in a kimura lock. What was unique about this submission is that Shamrock also had Fulton's other arm trapped, meaning he had to submit using his head. Never see that these days.

Other than that creative submission, this just wasn't anything too special. Yes, one of the competitors in the match was 55 years old, but Ken was able to put in a decent match with Moose. As stated, it wasn't a bad performance from either man, just a little slow to get things kicked off on a high. On a side note, Madman Fulton's shoulder reportedly came out of its socket during the submission. If there's any truth to that, then best wishes to him.


Ups...

7. Good Things

ODB Impact Wrestling
Impact Wrestling

There's nothing else to really note on this, but ODB noted in a backstage interview with Gabby Loren that her food truck will be back up and running by spring of this year.

Some truly excellent news for the former four-time Knockouts Champion!


6. Spear Vs. Spear

Moose vs. Rhino was most likely going to be a fine enough match either way. However, the added stipulation of it being turned into a No Disqualifications Match made it far better than it probably would've been. Almost immediately, 'Mr Impact Wrestling' hit the No Jackhammer Needed spear, setting the tone for the level of brutality we could expect to see from them.

Things only picked up from that point forward. Moose took the brunt of it, being powerbombed through a table at ringside and then being superplexed onto a pile of steel chairs. Despite being manhandled, Moose was on top form here, dressed as 'Macho Man' Randy Savage (for whatever reason), which meant he had to perform a diving elbow drop. After yanking the referee in front of him that saw both he and the ref Gored through a table, Moose sealed the win with a low blow and a second No Jackhammer Needed for the three count.

It wasn't beautiful in terms of being a technical masterpiece, but in the eyes of a hardcore wrestling match, it was brilliant. It didn't have to rely too much on big spots, and the ones that did happen weren't over the top, which is always good. The ending with Moose grabbing the referee so he didn't take the full brunt of the Gore was a genius move on Moose's behalf, albeit not a fair one. That's Moose for you though.


5. Trey's Revenge

After weeks of torment by Ace Austin towards his mother, Trey finally got the chance to gain some retribution over 'The One True Ace' in their X Division Championship, and he did exactly that. Right off the bat, the match was fought like an actual fight, with Trey taking Ace to the mat, and pounding away with punch after punch after punch.

It wasn't the sort of match you'd expect to see from the X division, as it featured a lot more ground and pound as opposed to high-flying moves. There was, of course, still some moves that took to the air, as Ace connected with a truly spectacular Fosbury Flop, one of the moves he's perfected (or aced, if you'll pardon the pun). Sadly, Trey's mother was still one of the main focuses during the match, but that didn't necessarily take anything away from the match.

Trey came exceptionally close to capturing the championship, but Austin still found a way to pick up the win thanks to The Fold, and would continue the comments towards Mrs. Miguel post-match. With a fight between champion and challenger having to be broken up by referees and fellow wrestlers following the bell, it's clear that the issues between these two will be rolling on for the foreseeable future.

If Trey's mother remains at the forefront of the rivalry, then an honorary Down for that part alone. Otherwise though, a highly enjoyable X Division Championship. Not as spot-heavy as some other bouts from the division that we've seen in recent times, but an exciting encounter nonetheless.


4. Rematch Delivers

When Eddie Edwards and Michael Elgin opted not to wait until Hard To Kill by having their match on last week's episode of Impact, there was a slight bit of doubt that their actual pay-per-view match wouldn't have the same sort of hype around it. Coming away from the match though, we can all agree that possibility was false. It was just as good, if not better, than the original match.

It didn't take long for things to take a turn when 'Big Mike' pulled back the ring mats to unveil the concrete floor, something which he later used to deliver a pulverising apron-assisted neckbreaker. As was the case with their first bout, Edwards showed just how much strength he has inside him, as he hoisted Elgin off the mat on several occasions, most notably when he suplexed both him and the Canadian powerhouse over the top rope and down to ringside.

After a strike exchange and a casual German suplex off the top rope, Eddie reversed an Elgin Bomb with a surprise rollup to not only defeat 'Big Mike', but to also retain his Call Your Shot trophy. Just like their TV match, this was a perfect example of two wrestlers with different styles of wrestling coming together to produce a superb match that didn't rely on a great story to sell itself.

Now, Eddie can (presumably) move forward with his Impact career to focus on creating the perfect moment to cash in that title opportunity. He still has a bit of unfinished business with X Division Champion Ace Austin. Find someone who wouldn't want to see those two face off again.


3. Proving Himself

With Rich Swann unable to compete at Hard To Kill, what would happen to the World Tag Team Championships match that saw he and Willie Mack challenging The North? Mack went in it alone. On paper, that was perhaps a risky move from the challengers, seeing as it was just a few days ago when Mack stated he wasn't feeling at 100% following a knee injury he had suffered in the Tag Team Open.

You would never have been able to tell the man was injured though. 'Chocolate Thunder' put in the performance of a lifetime here, desperate to win the tag titles for himself and Rich Swann. While the numbers game did take its toll, there was nothing putting Mack down. Ethan Page (who wrestled the match ill, by the way) and Josh Alexander used frequent tags to weaken Willie, but they got their comeuppance in the form of Mack giving 'The Walking Weapon' a Canadian Destroyer from atop the shoulders of 'All Ego'. Madness.

That in itself was a truly memorable moment, but Mack's fighting spirit made the match that extra bit special so that no-one will be forgetting it any time soon. The Canadian duo went on to retain their titles, though even Page and Alexander can't take anything away from him. Just down to Mack's tenacity during the Handicap Match, he and Swann surely deserve another shot at the straps once the latter has been cleared.

If the two on one situation was this good, then how good will the full two on two scenario be?


2. Who Stops Taya?

Taya Valkyrie has lasted over a year as the Knockouts Champion, making her the longest-reigning champion in company history. It's a mighty impressive fact, and what's even more impressive is that she actually retained her title against both Jordynne Grace and ODB during the pay-per-view. Many fans, your writer included, were under the impression the reign of 'Wera Loca' would be coming to an end.

When the match was actually in progress, it was impossible to figure out who would be winning, seeing as each competitor got in their share of the offence. ODB laid out Grace with a thunderous fallaway slam on the ramp, while 'Thicc Mama Pump' took to the skies with a suicide dive into the champion. While the challengers laid it all on the line, Taya did her best to stay out of harm's way, but not so much so that there was ever any possibility she would lose her title.

The ending of the match played into Taya's character extremely well. Grace planted ODB on her neck with the Grace Driver, but after John E. Bravo distracted both Grace and the referee, Taya was able to take the pin for herself while Bravo held onto Jordynne's foot. It's exactly the type of thing we'd normally expect from Valkyrie as the Knockouts Champion. She hasn't exactly been known as being someone who wins matches by following the traditional wrestling rulebook.

As a result of her retaining the title, the question now comes up about who'll be the one to actually end her run with the championship. Tenille Dashwood? Madison Rayne for one final run? Tessa Blanchard? She's one for making history - how about the first ever World Champion vs. Knockouts Champion title vs. title match?


1. History Made, Again

Tessa Blanchard is the new Impact Wrestling World Champion. She's gone and made history once again, and she did it in style.

Her main event with Sami Callihan very nearly ended then and there when 'The Draw' hit a piledriver right off the bat, with 'The Undeniable One' very nearly being pinned for the three count. From there, Callihan did everything in his power to kee Tessa down, but she stayed true to her moniker by rising up every single time. She got powerbombed through a table, poked in the eye, and had her knee viciously assaulted by Sami, but she still got back to her feet time and time again.

Tessa connected with a Magnum on the ring apron later on which, while being nice to look at, made no sense as it didn't benefit her at all - it did more damage to her knee, she landed back first on the ring apron (which is, of course, the hardest part of the ring™), and Sami fell to the floor, so the referee began his ten count. For such a story-fuelled match, had that been the actual ending, there undoubtedly would've been an uproar.

After some nefarious shenanigans involving the championship belt, a pair of brass knuckles, and a kick below the belt, Blanchard escaped the pin following another piledriver, drilling 'The Callihan Death Machine' into the mat with a Canadian Destroyer and the Buzzsaw DDT to officially make history as she becomes the first woman in history to win a World Championship of a major wrestling organisation usually contested for by men.

For moments like this, let's put aside all of the recent Tessa controversies. For now, we're just speaking about Tessa Blanchard the wrestler, not Tessa Blanchard the person. This is a huge deal, and will hopefully bring a lot more eyes to the Impact product. It can only go up from here with Tessa at the forefront. A true history-making performer.


Contributor
Contributor

Can be found raving about the latest IMPACT Wrestling signing, the Saints Row franchise, and King Shark in The Suicide Squad.