7 Ups & 6 Downs From WWE WrestleMania XX

The Beginning Of The End.

WWE Network

Before the hole in his soul consumed him whole, there was a fondness for nostalgia and numerical neatness than Vince McMahon clung to when it came to the 'Show Of Shows'.

WrestleMania I's Madison Square Garden locale was an integral part of its success. McMahon wanted to present his product as the centre of the wrestling universe and picked the 'World's Most Famous Arena' to serve that exact purpose. His wounded ego was briefly healed by the pageantry of WrestleMania X's return "home". He didn't need Hulk Hogan - he had the hallowed halls of MSG hosting his New Generation.

WrestleMania XX's "Where It All Begins...Again" slogan was an inch-perfect tagline marketed by an organisation desperate to burst from the shackles of their long-dormant second boom. Millionaire McMahon was the king of his world and took the jewel in his crown back to its place of origin one final time.

His empire had grown enough that he'd be costing himself gate receipts to ever bother with it as a WrestleMania venue in the future, though he could do with a few more moments to erase one particularly dark chapter...

(Want more WrestleMania Ups & Downs? We got 'em: I, 2, III, IV, V, VI, VII, VIII, IX, X, XI, XII, 13, XIV, XV, 2000, X-Seven, X8, XIX)


Downs...

6. Fatal Bore Way

WWE

The trouble with trying to summon emotion where there blatantly isn't any to mine is how obvious it looks to those attempting to invest in it.

For that reason, it's pointless to try and contextualise any sense of tension between the sad squads in this card-filler. By 2004, almost every WrestleMania was designed to be every bit the 'Showcase Of The Immortals' it was marketed as, full of thrills, spills and personal grudges finally settled on the 'Grandest Stage'. This never proves true, but the heavy-handed narrative results in matches outside of that remit looking all the more exposed as a result.

Defending Champions Rob Van Dam and Booker T were too good for this sh*t (as too, broadly speaking, were The Dudley Boyz), but the contest at least gave La Resistance, Garrison Cade and Mark Jindrak 7:58 to tell their grandchildren about. Good for them. Dud for us.


5. Playdays

WWE

Illustrating where WWE's sexual politics were in 2004, this 'Playboy Evening Gown' match between Stacy Keibler, Miss Jackie, Torrie Wilson and Sable was booked based on jealousy the Raw divas harboured for their Smackdown counterparts when they were chosen to pose naked that year.

The four stepped out of their gowns before the contest began (despite protests from Miss Jackie that were rebuffed by her own partner), and the four set about exposing as much of themselves as possible without replicating the publication.

Stacey's corner choke and some rolling pinfall attempts proffered the boypoppers until Torrie scored the win for her team with a pinning hold that obnoxiously exposed as much of Jackie's underwear as the wrestlers could get away with. In another sign of the times, photographers stationed ringside raced forward to catch every last glimpse of the protracted pin.


4. Cruiserweight Closed

WWE.com

Ultimo Dragon stumbling as he made his entrance foreshadowed the humbling and hurried exhibition of Cruiserweight action planned for the biggest night of the year. Arguably worse than getting shunted into a battle royal, the challengers had to suffer the ignominy of several insultingly short matches just to be part of the 11:31 sh*t show.

In a segment of the show shorter than most promos Triple H has ever cut on Raw, Dragon pinned Shannon Moore, Jamie Noble submitted Ultimo Dragon, Noble pinned Sho Funaki, Nunzio was counted out, Billy Kidman pinned Noble, Rey Mysterio pinned Kidman, Akio was green misted out of sight, Mysterio pinned Tajiri and Chavo Guerrero (the Champion going in) pinned Mysterio cheaply to retain his title.

Yes, everybody got their sh*t in, but that's a pretty fitting description of how everybody looked as a result.


3. Badbye

WWE.com

Brock Lesnar and Bill Goldberg's big b*stard battle was - until they partially retconned it years later - one of the most preposterous WrestleMania encounters of all time. Ignoring the tension fans would be forced to wait over a decade for, the surprising news that both men were set to definitely leave the company after the event left the New York crowd ice cold towards each man.

That Big Bill only had one date left on his contract had already made the build-up challenging. Stone Cold Steve Austin was inserted as a placeholder for the former WCW World Champion, but Lesnar's disinterest didn't emerge until the night itself following revelations that weekend that he was leaving WWE to give the National Football League a try.

The discerning Madison Square Garden faithful flatly refused to engage in their contest as a result. The disdain was mutual; neither Brock or Bill had much interest in causing themselves or each other any damage as they prepared for their respective next steps. Post-match Stone Cold Stunners to both from 'The Rattlesnake' were the crowd's only placation.


2. Fatal Bore Way 2

WWE

The trouble with trying to summon emotion where there blatantly isn't any to mine is how obvious it looks to those attempting to invest in it.

For that reason, it's pointless to try and contextualise any sense of tension between the sad squads in this card-filler. By 2004, almost every WrestleMania was designed to be every bit the 'Showcase Of The Immortals' it was marketed as, full of thrills, spills and personal grudges finally settled on the 'Grandest Stage'. This never proves true, but the heavy-handed narrative results in matches outside of that remit looking all the more exposed as a result.

Defending Champions Rikishi & Scotty 2 Hotty were too good for this sh*t (as too, broadly speaking, were The APA), but the contest at least gave The World's Greatest Tag Team and The Basham Brothers 6:08 to tell their grandchildren about. Good for them. Dud for us.

What? If copying and pasting with blatant indifference to the wrestlers is deemed acceptable for WWE, it'll do here too.


1. The Lasting Image

WWE

Very little needs repeating about the saddest, darkest lows that followed the immeasurable highs of WrestleMania XX for Chris Benoit and Eddie Guerrero.

The journeymen wrestlers that had made it to pro wrestling's pinnacle had experienced many of the hardest yards together. They may have been holding up titles they were booked to win by an organisation dictating their futures, but the physical belts were acknowledgements beyond anything ever thought possible for the pair - they marked very real achievements for the performers so often considered too small, too bland and too generic to make it in an industry defined by WWE's output.

Capturing every emotional beat, Jim Ross lamented on their incredible sacrifices on the way up as streamers and tears flowed freely. Within three years, he'd be instructed to never mention the moment again.


Ups...

7. The Showstopper, The Headliner, The Main Event

WWE Network

Subjectively sh*t-canned but objectively outstanding, the WrestleMania XX headliner is less a world class war and yet another cogent discussion on the ethics of art vs artist. It's glib to parrot indifferent message boards and call it a "shame" considering the abhorrent final actions of match-winner and pay-per-view MVP Benoit, but the sheer glory of it all was vital to the hair-trigger tension in the bout.

Rivals on screen ever since 'HBK's heroic comeback, Triple H and Shawn Michaels were in reality the establishment a fan favourite like Benoit was all-too-used to running into. Headlong too, evidently.

Switch him out, (or switch his actions off, if you can) and there's to be found a truly magnificent Mania main. Discretion, quite plainly, is advised.


6. The Champ Is Here

WWE.com

Ahead of closing the majority of shows for the next decade, John Cena opened his first WrestleMania with the confidence of a man who wouldn't be jerking the curtain much longer.

'The Champ' claimed his first singles title after clocking The Big Show with a chain-wrapped fist and jaw-dropping FU, but the win felt transformative rather than ill-gotten. Long before audiences divided up between those in neon t-shirts and those paying for tickets to indulge their hatred, 'The Doctor Of Thuganomics' was both throw-back rapper and contemporary anti-hero.

In 2008, the Madison Square Garden faithful went nuts for his return before catching themselves. Here, they were caught up in his every move.


5. As The World Turns

WWE Network

Despite suspect acting, the romance angle between Chris Jericho and Trish Stratus in early-2004 had turned 'Y2J' babyface thanks to the transcendent popularity of the the biggest star in the Women's division.

Beginning life as a skit between heel chums Jericho and Christian, the relationship was formed after the cocky Canadians made a $1 bet that they could sleep with Trish or Lita respectively before the other. The former awkwardly admitted he had started to fall for Stratus after the details of the wager were eventually divulged.

Christian triggered his former friend by attacking both lovebirds, but it set the stage for an understated 'Show Of Shows' gem and a low key 'Grandest Stage' shocker. At the tail-end of the contest, Stratus inadvertently clocked Jericho in the face to gift Christian the win, but she brutally revealed a ruse.

Bitter at the bet from the very beginning, she viciously snapped with wild slaps, allowing Christian to floor him with an Unprettier. The two passionately kissed to the bewilderment of Jericho and the Madison Square Garden crowd, cementing their new relationship. It was sh*t hot sh*thousery.


4. Five Stars

WWE.com

There's so much to love about Evolution Vs The Rock & Sock Connection that a mere 'Up' understates its sheer Sports Entertainment supremacy.

Built around the fabulous tension between Randy Orton and Mick Foley, it's left to the supporting players to steal the show. 'The Great One' and 'The Nature Boy' contest a dream match on their own terms, aping poses and bouncing around like buffoons for the joy of popping each other and sending the Madison Square Garden crowd loopy.

Surrounded by stars, Batista looks like one for the first time in his career, not least with two bonafide legends selling for him. Randy's victory kept his story with the 'Hardcore Legend' ticking over to the following month's powerful Backlash payoff too - even from an administrative point of view this clash was an unqualified success.


3. Hair Today...

WWE.com

A slightly disappointing scrap considering the combatants, the Women's Title between Victoria and Molly Holly was overshadowed by the head-shaving stipulation that befell the challenger following her loss.

Later confirming that she had volunteered herself as the unfortunate victim of the clippers simply to ensure a place on the already-stacked WrestleMania 20 card, she wisely reasoned that in hailing from Madison Square Garden and celebrating the previous two decades for the company, the show would be fondly remembered and oft-replayed.

Whilst not quite accurate on either count for reasons out of her control, the match was at least given some profile, and thankfully lasted three times the length of the aforementioned Evening Gown tag team match earlier in the night.


2. Booting Off

WWE.com

Eddie Guerrero and Kurt Angle's excellent technical war was confined to history by virtue of the event itself rarely getting a spotlight from WWE, but their 'Show Of Shows' Championship clash was the best of an outstanding series that stretched through much of 2004.

Guerrero's "Lie, Cheat & Steal" mantra was unbelievably over - for all Eddie worked to outwork 'The Wrestling Machine', it ultimately came down to underhanded tactics to leave Madison Square Garden with his title in tact.

This was 'Latino Heat's WrestleMania zenith. Not only would he fail to meet expectations against Rey Mysterio one year later, but he'd also never produce a love letter to everything that made him such a special performer as he did on this night.


1. Deadman Rising

WWE

As will become clear in potentially contentious future editions of this very article, your writer is neither fan nor mark for The Undertaker. It was however impossible not to be rapt in the pageantry of his return to the gimmick that had made him a megastar. Or, at least, a variation of it.

Undertaker - the truest version of the persona - was on his way back, and he was just a few years away from unleashing the most unlikely streak of bangers in company history. As per f*cking usual, he had a Kane to despatch of first.

'The Deadman's virtual squash victory over his brother neatly tied up their months-long angle, briefly reintroduced Paul Bearer for some early-1990s authenticity, and upgraded the former mortician's aesthetic to take in elements of the American Bad *ss fans had become familiar (if not friendly) with since 2000.


Contributor
Contributor

Michael is a writer, editor, podcaster and presenter for WhatCulture Wrestling, and has been with the organisation for 10 years. Alongside the production of daily written, audio and video content covering WWE and AEW, he also provides knowledge and insights on all aspects of the wrestling industry thanks to a passion for it dating back over 35 years. As one third of "The Dadley Boyz" Michael has contributed to the huge rise in popularity of the WhatCulture Wrestling Podcast and its accompanying YouTube channel, earning it top spot on the UK's wrestling podcast charts with over 10,000 episodes and 70,000,000 total downloads. He also co-hosts Benno & Hamflett, In Your House!, Podcast Horseman: The BoJack Horseman Podcast, and has guested on long-running Sunderland AFC podcast Wise Men Say. With WhatCulture, he has provided in-person coverage of some of the biggest pay-per-views and Premium Live Events in wrestling history, including WrestleMania, Survivor Series, All In & Double Or Nothing in destinations such as New York, New Jersey, Chicago, Dallas, Las Vegas, Philadelphia, London and Cardiff. He has also been featured as a wrestling analyst for the Tampa Bay Times, Fightful, POST Wrestling, GRAPPL, GCP, Poisonrana, 411Mania and Sports Guys Talking Wrestling. Michael's background in media stretches beyond wrestling coverage, with a degree in Journalism from the University Of Sunderland (2:1) and a series of published articles in music and culture magazines The Crack, Pilot as well as Sunderland AFC's premiere fanzine A Love Supreme. When not offering his voice up for daily wrestling podcasts, he can be found losing it every other Saturday at the Stadium Of Light, and at Cribs gigs nationwide.